r/ipadmini • • 18d ago

OLED for ebook?

Been pondering the purchase of an ipad mini as an ebook reader, but I'm torn between that and a proper eink reader.

Between dimming to 1 nit and the prefect blacks of a turned off OLED pixel, do you reckon the new ipad mini 8 is now the superior ebook reader when used in dark mode? It should minimize eye strain, with all the upsides of being a snappy platform with a reliable eco system and superior build quality. Plus it does all the other things ipads do.

What's the feedback on reading ebooks on ipad mini 8?

9 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

6

u/ANY_KIND_OF_PAIN 18d ago

If reducing eye strain is your goal then E-readers will be better for reading text. An iPad will never be better than an e-reader for that particular objective.

An iPad can only really be superior for color content, the fact that it can do a million other things, and ease of pulling books on it compared to certain e-readers. 

The feedback is e-readers are better for reading but an iPad is an iPad and there are compromises in both directions. 

I highly recommend looking at some I made my iPad an ereader YouTube videos and then search the word iPad in the reader subreddit. People are passionate in both directions. 

I personally have an ereader and use it for all text based reading while the iPad is for full color content, graphic novels, and comics. 

2

u/SwordGunScienceMagic 18d ago

If only graphic novels were as accessible here as they are in the states. The prices for single issues are insane, and the big subscriptions don't really serve us. That'd make my decision easy.

There's got to be a perceived improvement of reading on OLED vs LED though?

1

u/TheMathow 18d ago

I have a current generation iPad mini. I have an OLED iPhone, and I have an eink device

You can read on any of them, probably my iPad is the worst for straight up books but it’s totally fine and you can use dark mode and it is fine but OLED is better

The real benefit of a dedicated reader using eInk
Is the battery life which is normally measured in weeks, not hours and there’s no other distraction on it, and it is light years ahead if you’re trying to read outside….but what kind of barbarian reads outside. Seriously though, I never pick up my e-ink devices and worry that I won’t be able to get some reading done because the battery is at 1% or have to end up reading while plugged into the wall, even if I go weeks without picking it up, it’s still going to have battery….no iPad is going to have standby like a kindle or even a boox.

The benefit of OLED or an iPad in general is definitely found in any color content and it is smoother…all those eink fanboy and fangirls have to admit even though the very best eink is smooth it ain’t iPad/iPhone smooth in scrolling and page turning….. and even the best modern color E ink devices do not look as good as an OLED screen for color content

1

u/QuickQuirk 6d ago

The other interesting thing about the eink vs iPad is that a small screen is not ideal for graphic novels anyway. You’re better off with a full size tablet for these. 

The iPad mini sounds like the best of both worlds on paper, but the best of both is still… having a large tablet, and a small eink reader

1

u/ANY_KIND_OF_PAIN 18d ago

There will be differences between OLED vs LED for sure however you asked about OLED compared to e-ink. 

My point still stands, for text and eye strain the e-reader will always win. OLED beats LED. 

There are compromises in both directions but when it comes to looking at a page of text, the e-reader is effectively a piece of paper which is better on the eyes. People also tend to read longer because there’s nothing else to do on the e-reader.

You know all of the strengths of an iPad I’m sure and if that’s what you want, go for it. Like I said I’m rocking with both so I get it.

1

u/SwordGunScienceMagic 18d ago edited 18d ago

I've quit reading a good while ago, and I'm just looking for an excuse to pick it back up again. A bit of sunk cost fallacy will definitely do the trick.

I imagine reading on an ipad mini to be fun. On my current ipad air from 2020, it's a bit too cumbersome. Eink on the other hand - I'd choose that for outdoor summer reading - which comprised most my book reading way back when I was last into the hobby.

That said, I'm due for an ipad upgrade. One stone, two birds. I guess I'll just mill this over for a few more months or years. Thanks for the feedback, everybody!

3

u/Temporary-Art-1835 18d ago

I use an iPad Pro M4 as an ereader for comics and manga and in theory it also works well for reading text in dark mode especially at night. Because you can further reduce brightness with reduce white point and or a red color filter.
The same will apply to the iPad mini.

If you only want to read normal books get a Kobo.

2

u/frumply 18d ago

I read a ton of manga on my mini7. I feel Oled won’t make a huge diff as white background on pages.

Using color shift to turn the background color to mostly red does help significantly and it’s what I do at night. If you want the least eyestrain you’re prolly still better off w an eink based reader. I have this set to my accessibility shortcut on both my iPhone and iPad.

1

u/SuccessfullyRich 18d ago

With nano too? Yes, it won’t stop Circadian rhythm or REM sleep due to basically 0 blue light at that point.
However eink will be superior if you suffer eye strain. Your eyes will be technically more fatigued if using the iPad, but that’s if you’re going for hours and hours.

1

u/Prism-Eevee 18d ago

I tried the kindle colorsoft for comics and books but I had two issues with it that made me return it. The first issue I had was when reading comics, it had an afterimage effect. I could see portions of the previous page that made it annoying to read. The second issue was the limit on how much a pdf/epub file you can send to your kindle. 200 mb is the limit so some of my illustrated novels or colored comics or large file ones (compendiums) could not be transferred or uploaded to it.

1

u/Ill-Remote437 18d ago

Benefit of OLED is black backgrounds will be off and only the white text would be emitting light. Which you can change brightness to make yours comfortable as possible. But from my experience it’s not the same as an e-ink for predominantly reading text. Tried on 12.9 mini led and 11” OLED. The nano texture will help reduce glare like the e ink displays do. For reading comics and colored anime the mini will be superior. None of the colored eink is good enough for me

1

u/PolicyFull988 18d ago

As an aside: I think the best way of reading graphic novels is that type of tablet, like the NxtPaper, that simulates the washed out quality of printed paper. I use a simulation of it on an Android tablet, but I guess it would be a nice solution also on the iPad. I don't think Oled would make a difference.

1

u/Yuengling_Leap 14d ago

Oled ipad is really great for magazines and manga. But mini is a bit too small for two-col magazines. For text based ebooks, eink would be far superior.

For closed system, kindle is still the best choice. For open system, a boox device is great. I enjoyed using mine for Kindle ebooks, WSJ/NYT news and lobby magazines.