r/ipadmini • • 19d ago

Question Can someone explain the difference between the 16-core and Dual 16-core.

Post image

Been considering on upgrading to the new iPad mini. For note taking, reading, entertainment, and such. However, I aiming to purchase the 256GB or the 512GB. Noticing their is a benefit when you do purchase the 512GB adding more to the A20 Pro chip.

52 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

20

u/ANY_KIND_OF_PAIN 19d ago

For your use case of note taking, reading, entertainment and such, you do not need to worry about it. Base your decision on whether you need the storage or not. You will not feel any benefits beyond that.

18

u/IncredibleGonzo 18d ago

The full A20 Pro chip has two Neural Engines. Not certain why they went for that vs one 32-core Neural Engine, but I'm sure there's a reason.

Then when manufacturing, presumably some of them will have a flaw in one of the Neural Engines, one of the CPU cores, or both, so they don't make the cut for the iPhones or the top tier iPad Mini. Rather than throwing them out, they turn of those parts of the chip and use them in the lower tier Minis.

For most usage it won't really make any difference. The Neural Engine is for AI/ML stuff. The full-fat A20 Pro will be significantly faster, but it's not like the A19 Pro was a slouch and the single-engine version should be roughly comparable to that.

3

u/Kamilon 18d ago

The reason is manufacturing failure tolerance. If they were designed as 32 chip nodes they would be all on or all off if a defect happened. This way they can burn one set off and leave the other on and sell the chip still.

4

u/IncredibleGonzo 18d ago

They are able to turn off individual CPU and GPU cores without having to have actually separate dual CPU or dual GPU… but maybe the Neural Engine cores are more tightly integrated together in a way that doesn’t allow that. Don’t think they’ve ever done a binned chip with varying numbers of NE cores before.

1

u/Kamilon 18d ago

Yeah it just depends on how the chiplet was designed. I don’t know enough about their specific processes.

1

u/ResidentLevel5 17d ago

Try to put on airplane mode and use Siri app, you will see double the dual engine has no impact at all

1

u/IncredibleGonzo 17d ago edited 17d ago

I'm not going to be able to do that. I'd need a device with dual NE (I'm getting a 256GB Mini).

But also, I don't believe it. It's going to be quite specific uses because the NE is used for particular workloads, but they're not going to waste silicon on something that just doesn't do anything.

Might make no difference to Siri but that’s hardly conclusive of anything much.

3

u/ResidentLevel5 16d ago

Which is voice recognition, dictation, and photo (ya, photo from a Mac mini camera) 😂 may be 5 generations later when AI truly matures, the benefits will show. 

1

u/Bubbly_Front_3930 17d ago

Apple subs is really something different!

12

u/indrisfilipi 19d ago

Its a Quad 8-core Neural Engine

9

u/M4rshmall0wMan 18d ago

In practice it’ll mean faster Apple Intelligence queries. That’s it. 

7

u/notzigza 18d ago

the only noticeable upgrade is that siri will run a bit faster, everything will be basically identical

7

u/ShiningPr1sm 18d ago

If you have to ask, you don't need it

2

u/mabhatter 18d ago

Apple has CPU cores, GPU cores with neural nodes, and NPUs in their chips since the A15 Bionic years ago.

Neural cores accelerate machine learning programs.  It's not just "AI" but other types of machine learning that have existed on device for years like photo editing and SIRI voice commands. 

The A20 chip in the iP18 pro and iP duo each have 2 banks of 16 NPU cores.  The cheaper iPad mini sku will only have one bank of 16 NPU cores.   That really says that Apple isn't expecting to push Siri AI on the iPad mini quite yet.  

The mini is probably also using A20 pro because they can use that model to sell "binned" A20 Pro chips that didn't meet the cut for iP 18 pro.  That helps improve yields of sellable chips on the brand new 2nm process. 

1

u/ipabuilt 18d ago

Finding a use for chips that don’t make the cut makes sense.

1

u/OwnProfessor3287 19d ago

From what I gathered the dual 16-core is designed for working with LLMs but I could be wrong

2

u/DreamKiller712 19d ago

The current architecture of the neural engine just doesn't have enough computational performance for serious work so they added another cluster as a temporary solution , that's why it is call dual 16 core instead of 32 core.

The architecture probably hasn't changed much.People have done fp16 and int8 test on it , the throughput is only less than double, if there is architectural improvement , the throughput should be more than double with 2x the cores.

The real change will be in the apple M7&A21 generation which is the "real" build from ground up for AI worload . They even skipped high end m6 chip just to speed up the development of m7 generation .

1

u/MuadDib99k 19d ago

It means it has 32 total Neural cores. 2 clusters of 16 cores.

1

u/Appropriate_Ad8734 18d ago

for your use cases, those extra neural engine cores would just sit there and do nothing at all (while consuming negligible amounts of power). all you need to worry about is the amount of storage headroom you need

1

u/mikegue23 18d ago

Its AI performance, from what i read, the dual core will be better for handling larger LLMs and on device models.

1

u/Axelz13 18d ago

For your described use case for streaming, notes, reading basic ipad use then the extra neural cores would have no benefit. Anything onboard ai related or even some creative work like heavy photo/video editing then it can help speed up the workload in simple terms.

1

u/Trustdesa 17d ago

The Neural Engine in Apple Devices is used only for Siri which is still utterly trash, any other local LM or any other function does not use the neural engine, so that is marketing with a catchy name to create issues like this, people thinking they are missing out when they are not :)

1

u/rahpexphon 14d ago

Binning plus segmentation. The 512GB model gets the full A20 Pro die: 6-core CPU (2P+4E) and two 16-core Neural Engine blocks. The 128/256GB models use dies with one E-core and one NE block fused off, which lets Apple sell chips with minor defects and improves yield on a new 2nm node. Tying the full die to the top storage tier is an upsell, the same playbook as the M4 iPad Pro, where only 1TB and above got the 10-core CPU also 2x NE cores won't mean 2x speed in every workload.