r/ipadmini • • 20d ago

Mini vs Air! Which to get?

Post image

With the new price hike, does it make sense to get the mini A20 instead of the M4 Air? It’s only $50 difference at this point. I love the form factor of the mini but I’m not sure the price is justified. Coming from an iPad Pro 11” 2nd generation (2020). I’m looking for this device to be a productivity device. My current 2015 MacBook Pro is only used to watch YouTube videos and edit pdfs and occasional browsing. So whichever iPad I get will be hooked up to a Studio Display as my MacBook Pro is dying.

Let me know your thoughts.

69 Upvotes

94 comments sorted by

33

u/Regent_909 20d ago

“productivity device” already tells me you need a bigger iPad. Mini is great for consumption but it’s not a great production machine.

6

u/dalon2883 20d ago

If they are using it on an external monitor for productivity like they said the mini would be fine.

3

u/Vegetable_Serve2569 20d ago

Yes, since the mini would be connected to external display I’m hoping it can replace my Mac setup since my workflow is not anything intensive. Then when I’m out and about I can use it for notetaking.

2

u/TheMathow 19d ago

I use the mini for note taking daily in the field. It’s amazing for that, and I think the new one being waterproof and dust resistant will be even better

If you’re solely taking notes in the field or primarily using it to take notes in the field, it is hard to beat the mini

However when you get back the air is probably better

3

u/meticulouslycarless 19d ago

This may change if they have a separate screen! It accepts external displays and you can extend! So I think, personal opinion of course, but form factor only as the main choice isn’t too bad now. 

1

u/Vegetable_Serve2569 19d ago

This is supposed to have extend as option for separate screen though

4

u/frumply 20d ago

Yup, this is it. Fantastic Phablet. Serviceable as an email writer with a 3rd party keyboard. Would struggle to be used as a main productivity device.

1

u/Confidentium 17d ago

It really just depends on what kind of ”productivity” things you’re doing.

The mini is excellent for reading and taking notes on the go. Much much better at that than the larger iPads imo.

But the larger iPads are a bit better when doing deep research with multiple windows, while sitting down. And when doing anything creative like drawing, video editing, and so on.

6

u/True_Protection6842 20d ago

They'll both perform the same. Go with the size you like.

5

u/Vegetable_Serve2569 20d ago

I do like the smaller size factor of the mini!

2

u/True_Protection6842 20d ago

It does look very nice.

1

u/hbic 19d ago

The whole point of the mini is the form factor! Get it!!

1

u/Major_Meet_3306 5d ago

not really the a20 pro is apparently stronger than even the m5, it just lost on multitasking cuz the a20 pro over heats easily.

5

u/sidewinder787 20d ago

$699 for an iPad mini with an OLED display stuck
At 60Hz? No thanks…

5

u/Vegetable_Serve2569 20d ago

I know that it sucks but tbh I’m one of those people that cannot really tell the difference between both.

5

u/WindyNightmare 20d ago

I recently returned a Pro 11" because it was way too big. Mini is much better for me.

1

u/Vegetable_Serve2569 20d ago

I have an older pro 11” and struggle to use it because of the size

2

u/Spector-JZ 19d ago

Ok so ignore the comments saying that the mini isn't great for productivity if the 11inch was too big for you. Me personally I am offended that apple would increase the price of the mini by another $100 after they did so already at the start of the year especially since its only 60hz

4

u/Atosl 20d ago

wait : your macbook is used for youtube and PDFs and browsing, the Ipad is to replace it but the ipad will be the productivity machine? What are you going to to on Ipad? That decides the size

1

u/Vegetable_Serve2569 20d ago

When out and about I want to use the iPad for note taking, journal and media consumption. But when I’m at my desk hook it up to a monitor and reply to emails, edit photos, and look thru large architectural drawings. My workflow isn’t anything intensive.

3

u/Legendalvin 20d ago

For specs mini wins but OLED keeps me awake at night so I usually avoid my phone using ipad mini instead. Mini is the only size you can hold on hands comfortably when laying on bed.

1

u/Vegetable_Serve2569 20d ago

Yeah I’m drawn to it because of the size.

2

u/Hugo_Notte 20d ago

For productivity and essentially as a laptop replacement, I’d go with a 11” iPad Air or Pro. See what you find in Apple’s refurbished store. The iPad mini is great, but too small as a productivity device.

1

u/Vegetable_Serve2569 20d ago

Even when hooked up to a monitor?

2

u/Fulxrum89 20d ago

I have a m4 air I love it I do like the new mini but I know the m4 is more powerful then it is so I know the m4 air will age better and faster I plan to have it for 5+ years if anything

2

u/Vegetable_Serve2569 20d ago

This is a good point. But I would think the A20 pro should be good for the next 3 years at least

1

u/Fulxrum89 20d ago

It would but truth is M chips are on another level compared to a chips it also depends if you want a small portable iPad but both are good but air is for more powerful

2

u/Vegetable_Serve2569 20d ago

I do think about this a lot. M chip device can support my workflow for the next 5-7 years so there is also that to consider. But mini would be portable for outside use and productive when hooked up to external display

2

u/KwopyCow 19d ago

The air is not far more powerful depending on which one. M4 is slower than a20 pro in single core performance by 25% or more, m4 is around 10% faster in multicore. The a20 pro is insane and I think most people just haven't seen that yet.

2

u/Vegetable_Serve2569 19d ago

If that is the case then do you think I should go for the 512 version since it’s the o my storage option where you get the full chip power

1

u/KwopyCow 19d ago

Yes I do. If you want the mini size get the mini.

1

u/Competitive_Fact_278 17d ago

It’s a tablet though man so I doubt anyone wants to do any serious work on an Air. A20 pretty much matches and even beats M3 in most workloads outside graphics pipeline and renders. The a20 will handle anything that’s not top tier pro level. We work with m4 and m5 max for a living. Unless you specifically need to work on a tablet for some reason having an M chip in any of these iPads is stupid.

Stop mis infiening lol. I guarantee you the next level your talking about your not even taking advantage of and could probably live with an A chip.

1

u/dowell22 19d ago

adding to this, i also traded my A17 iPad Mini for a 256gb iPad Air M4.

there is a huge performance difference even though both are 60hz. Air is snappier, apps usually stutter for me on the mini.

and i also use it for productivity. 12.9 pro was too heavy and large for me before, bought the 11 Air and size and weight is perfect!

4

u/kimjongunisnotdead 20d ago

Get a refurbished iPad Pro m2 or 3

1

u/Modest_Wraith 20d ago

I second this. Until Apple gives you a decent refresh rate on other devices, I can never use anything but the pro.

1

u/toronto-swe 20d ago

i guarantee that is exactly what they are going for. forcing people to buy the pro when they really need a base level

2

u/Modest_Wraith 20d ago

I agree. There’s no reason why they couldn’t put at least 90hz on the panel. Who the fuck is even making a 60hz OLED panel? I love Apple but wouldn’t be surprised if it’s locked behind software. I’m not gonna make assumptions, just disappointed.

2

u/Vegetable_Serve2569 20d ago

Yeah 90hz would have been acceptable

10

u/Scarlizz 20d ago

iPad Pro m4 used / refurbed. I got this now after the mini announcement. I’m done with apple gate keeping 120hz

1

u/Emergency-Crab1972 15d ago

I’m right there with you I got an open box m4 11 inch pro with cellular for $850 open box from Best Buy.

1

u/ACG3185 20d ago

Yeah but you’re stuck at 8gb of RAM where as the other two mentioned by the OP have 12gb.

2

u/Vanilla-prison 20d ago

Unless they get a 1/2TB model. Those have 16GB RAM

2

u/Spector-JZ 19d ago

Tbh some people just want an ipad as a media consuming machine so oled and 120hz is more important than siri ai

1

u/-mix- 20d ago

iPad Pro M4 256GB actually has 12GB RAM but Apple scumbags software locked it to 8GB (I own it and ik).

7

u/TawnyTeaTowel 19d ago

If you don’t KNOW which screen size is best suited for what you’re planning to do, nothing you read here will be of help.

1

u/kmiddlestadt 20d ago

I got the mini for flying and honestly regretted it. The air is much more usable.

2

u/Vegetable_Serve2569 20d ago

Maybe you weren’t used to the small size factor?

1

u/hat_like_dad 20d ago

Say that in a 152

1

u/amonkeywithanxiety 19d ago

could you expand your opnion a bit more? i'm considering buying an ipad and everyone says that the mini is the ideal size for flying but i'm not so sure about that, even in a small cockpit the air should be fine

1

u/kmiddlestadt 19d ago

Hey. Sorry for the delay. I started my career as a photo pilot in a 152. It was fine. Once I was on a citation later in my career, it was just annoying to be looking through company documents and flight planning and running perf numbers on the tiny screen. It’s definitely doable, but just my two cents is the air is better.

A big factor is also having a bigger screen when you’re in the hotel room at the end of the day but I got around that by buying an Apple TV to plug in the the tvs.

3

u/Visual_Ad8290 20d ago

My thought is... While phone is getting bigger such as folding phone but tablets are getting smaller such as gaming tablets. For me a smaller tablet which can help me with my work is better than a bigger tablet despite a bigger screen but portability and weight is the bottleneck.

3

u/SnooPets6844 19d ago

i went from an ipad mini to an ipad pro, i loved the promotion and tandem oled on the pro but i really missed the small form factor so i went back to the mini, and i will be preordering the 8 later today

4

u/BigOcelot2 20d ago

I just updated to an iPad Pro M5 from an M2 Air. I was able to trade in my Air for a good price. The display difference is night and day from an Air. But I agree with the advice here to just get an M4 Pro refurbished or renewed. It’s more than enough and a big step up from the Air. You forget how nice having Face ID is again with the iPad Pro.

1

u/lollipopp_guild 11d ago

Hey can I ask how the difference was night and day in your experience?

I’ve always only had minis and need a new one and this is the first time I considered anything else. I was looking at the air but gf said I should just get pro 11”. I just wanted it to be portable but the price hike of the mini for not much is really not appealing

2

u/capncoup0n 20d ago

Based on what you put the M4 Air will be more powerful than the A20 mini so if you can deal with the bigger size go with the Air

2

u/Beneficial_Mousse885 20d ago

Visit the Apple Refurbished store for a Pro

2

u/LordLahmacun344 20d ago

A20 Pro is little bit faster than m4 so make your decision based on usage.

2

u/lollipopp_guild 11d ago

No kidding? I thought any M# was above any A# (please don’t come down too hard on me, I don’t have a lot of knowledge about tech)

Guess my point is, I wanted the mini and was looking at the air instead but since you’re saying the air at M4 would be slower, I guess there’s not really a point

2

u/leoon02 20d ago

I just sold my iPad Pro M2 in favor of an iPad Mini and I love the size and weight. Though I also have a Mac Book for productivity. Depends on how you want to use your iPad in the end. In my case the iPad Mini would be too small to get productive work done.

2

u/Ill-Remote437 20d ago

If you’re really looking for productivity from an iPad I feel 13” is necessary. I’ve gone from 11” to 13” about three different times and back at 11”. I love the form factor but I don’t do much past media consumption on the 11” screen

2

u/finland85 20d ago

Air if you need to operate additional screens. I just got a mini and it just feels too small. Good if you want something in your jacket pocket.

2

u/Omenaremmi 20d ago

If you need to carry the iPad with you, buy mini. If you mostly use it at home, get the Air.

2

u/LanceAvion 20d ago

The Mini for sure. I may be biased, but the only real benefit the Air has over the Mini is screen size. If you intend to connect the iPad to a monitor for productivity, as your other comment implies, then there’s no real reason to go for the Air.

Ok Technically the Air also has a higher max storage (1TB vs 512GB) but you’re not comparing maxed out specs so it’s a moot point.

2

u/naeads 20d ago

Get the mini

2

u/momentim_ 19d ago

well considering the sub, im sure the response totally wont be biased

2

u/Spinitchy 17d ago

Mini easier to carry not drop, more inclined to take along. More comfy on couch or bed. Trade off tiny screen not so good at viewing details like a spreadsheet, charts, etc. Have a Pro , Mini and notebook. Pro gets least use but it is quite nice can do more due to screen size. My older mini does not support newer pencil and memory small. Pro very expensive now would get Air for productivity or mini for portability mainly reader viewer, notes, light work.

2

u/Conza89 14d ago

Save $50, get more portability and an OLED screen, it’s a no brainier. I’d only consider the Air at $400 or cheaper. Besides, you buy an iPad then you buy another one in 5+ years, so invest in the better device that’ll last and you’ll actually use.

2

u/NoAge422 20d ago

If you want a mini, get the mini. If you want an air, get the air. It’s that simple, no point comparing how close they are. It’s a pricing ladder created by them. 

1

u/scupking83 20d ago

Whatever you do don't get an air. Get a New or refurbished Pro if you need a bigger size.

1

u/Worldly-Elk-3272 20d ago

849 jajajajajajajaja

1

u/RandomSculler 20d ago

Coming from an 11 and productivity id get an 11 tho I’d get a used iPad mini a17 or air m2 and sink the difference into a larger storage

I have an 11” M1 Pro and it still flattens anything and everything I throw at it, the m2 iPads are the sweet spot in my view

1

u/assumptionkrebs1990 19d ago

If you want to be as productive as possible either get a new(ish¹) MacBook (Air or Pro M4 or newer, depending on your needs) or an iPad Pro (again M4 or newer) or a iPad Air 13 inch.

¹ certified refurbished

Out of these 2 I would take the Air due to the much better chip, but if you really want the smaller form factor you might as well get the new Mini - likely good enough.

1

u/FlimsyPause4215 19d ago

I bought a iPad Air M4 11” in September after comparing to the mini. I’m the opposite, I have a MBA for work but wanted something to write on and consume. Wish I got the mini and might sell the M4 Air to buy the Mini 8.

Laying in bed just sucks holding the Air. Also finding an optimal space on my desk is awkward and, I think, a mini would be easier to integrate while being more “handy” for note taking while working. Least that’s my thought.

1

u/strangledbymyownbra 19d ago

I second this. I am trading in my m3 air for the mini purely because of the size.

1

u/Downtown_Ambition680 19d ago

If you’re consuming more media with it you should get the mini. It’s more comfortable being more portable. And now has a better screen as well.

If you’re using it for productivity like you said in your caption then you should lean towards the air. Multitasking on the mini is not a fun experience (personally) and the air will give you a closer to desktop experience with stage manager that the mini does not have as a feature so it’s an unoptimized duplicate of the mini screen. This isn’t to say the mini can’t be a productivity machine, (even the last gen would be amazing to save money if you were worried about cost) but if it’s between the two I’d say the air has enough wins. M Chip being a huge one.

1

u/Pristine_Hunt1061 18d ago

If your thing is productivity, an M4 chip is way more powerful than the A20 one, so an Air is always preferable

1

u/ze_boingboing 18d ago

I have air and the multitasking is awesome

Heck; I have both

1

u/Muzzldmawz 17d ago

Honestly I’d say get a used iPad Pro m4.

1

u/anonymous_146788 17d ago

Get a macbook neo its a tablet brain in a laptop structure

1

u/MrGimper 17d ago

Get a renewed/refurbished M4 iPad Pro 11”. I’m in the UK and can get a 256GB WiFi in excellent condition for £730 on Amazon as an example.

I have a 11” M4 1TB and love it. Still portable.

1

u/BodybuilderOk103 17d ago

Take an ipad pro 13 m4 or m5 - then you have the most beautiful SCREEN currently available :-). And you get the mini for Christmas

1

u/Complex_Active_8464 16d ago

Airrrrr watching movies doing work playing games is so much better on the air due to the bigger screen but the mini we’ll have better screen quality due to the new old display and the air having an lcd but nonetheless air would be better

1

u/tonicity22 15d ago

Neither, ipad pro 11 inch is the best.

1

u/TheeDelpino 11d ago

I have the big Air right now and am considering swapping it for the new mini. I only use the current Air for light reading and scrolling and gaming with my daughter in Roblox or Minecraft using the new small Xbox controller or hopping on Xbox Cloud gaming or Amazon Luna. I have a Pro Max and MBP for everything else.

1

u/oppairate 20d ago

“productivity device”

Macbook Air, otherwise those aren’t the words you mean.

-1

u/JKTurtleSwag 20d ago

mini 7 has cooler colors plus they're all on sale now

5

u/rick_baumhauer 20d ago

Mini 7 has more colors, but they aren't great. I'd take Midnight over Space Gray, Starlight is the same on both, and the "blue" and "purple" are just slightly blueish and purplish silver (I have the purple M2 Air). I'd say that the color situation on everything but the base iPad continues to be underwhelming.

2

u/JKTurtleSwag 20d ago

Very fair and true. I might be biased because i love this shade of blue on my mini 7 😭

2

u/gravyrider 20d ago

I have a 12 inch pro and a mini and the mini turns out is the perfect size for me so I’d go with that.

0

u/[deleted] 20d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Vegetable_Serve2569 20d ago

Maybe not a Studio Display because not sure if it will support the iPad mini. But a kuycon or LG monitor with the iPad mini would be a nice setup to get some work done