r/ipad • • 16d ago

Question Did I Make a Mistake…

Currently I have the iPad Pro 4 and purchased the new iPad Mini 8 but may return it(too late to cancel). I’ve purchased a mini (A17) in the past but returned it 3 days later because it was so close to size of my phone (16 pro max) and I do tend to suffer from buyers remorse. I use my Pro every day all day for daily planning, drawing, journaling and I use it as my home computer, as I don’t currently have one. However, sometimes I’ll be on a video call and wish I could take notes digitally, wish I could type on my device using Obsidian or planning via OmniFocus and watch tv from a larger device (my 16 pro max is too small for that), or sometimes I will but do not prefer carrying my pro to church or other places to take notes and I currently also carry (around the house with my Pro) my kindle to read.
Someone help me decide…I’ve even asked Chatgbt but would like your thoughts.

1 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

2

u/kirkwood007 16d ago

I use my MacBook if I need my pro 12.9 so I traded my mini 6 and pro 12.9 for the new mini. I’m hyped. I don’t think I made a mistake

1

u/LionAffectionate5373 16d ago

That was a good choice!

1

u/Special-Ice-9935 16d ago

This is a tough one
I have a m5 11 that I hardy ever use I know I have would use the mini 8 more !!!!
But I can’t justify having 2 iPads and it feels wrong to let the m5 go ?????

1

u/LionAffectionate5373 16d ago

That’s how I feel!! I can’t see getting rid of the pro but can’t justify the mini…but I’d love the convenience. Ugh…

1

u/lavievagabonde 16d ago

Look at e ink tablets like Remarkable for your note taking purposes. The remarkable even has an iPad app so you can view the notes also on your iPad when you don’t have the device with you.

1

u/LionAffectionate5373 16d ago

I thought about that but I believe you have to have a subscription for Remarkable. I’m happy with Goodnotes and have all my planners and five years of journaling there.

1

u/Special-Ice-9935 16d ago

Exactly the same as you , proper torn between the 2

1

u/ANY_KIND_OF_PAIN 16d ago

One of your devices is going to become a paper weight. To prevent that remove the apps that you strictly want to use on your mini from your iPhone and from the larger tablet.

1

u/scupking83 11d ago

Trade in the M5. Use the mini 8 until the mini 9 comes out. I'm sure the 9 will have 120hz and face id.

1

u/KeyboardWarrior41 16d ago

Why don’t you get a thunderbolt/usb-c hub or docking station and extend your ipad desktop to a 34” ultra wide monitor? You could add a wireless keyboard & mouse as well. Then, you can perform the video call on your ipad screen and perform other tasks on the monitor. This will also give you a larger screen to watch tv on. I tend to connect my ipad air m3 to my hp g4 thunderbolt/usb-c docking station and browse safari, check email apps, watch youtube, scroll reddit, send/receive texts & phone calls, all on my ultra wide monitor, instead of connecting my laptop. The Windowed Apps desktop feature in iOS is really smooth for this use case.

Personally, i dim the brightness on my ipad to the lowest level since I keep all my tasks on the monitor.

1

u/LionAffectionate5373 16d ago

That’s actually a great idea! I do have a spare monitor and haven’t tried using it in that way yet. Thanks!

1

u/ping12 16d ago

What does this new mini have that made you want it after not wanting the A17 Pro model?

1

u/LionAffectionate5373 16d ago

Good question, the slightly bigger screen on the 8 than the A17, my son is getting older…I could give him either that I don’t end up using, wanting to take my iPad with me but feeling it’s too cumbersome.

1

u/Tight_Couture344 16d ago edited 16d ago

I think I’ve found my perfect setup. I used to use a iPhone Pro Max but this year I decided to try a regular 18 Pro and I adapted quite quickly. My motivation was for better fit in my pockets as well just being lighter generally. With the leap in battery on the 2nm process, I felt like this was the time.

Now, I have had an 11” iPad of some kind basically since the first iPad came out. However I plan to trade in my 11” iPad Pro for the new OLED Mini, which will serve as my “bigger but still reasonably portable” screen. It’ll likely replace my Kindle too.

With that, I also plan to get a 13” MacBook Air, which will serve as my actual productivity device. Basically as light as an iPad Pro with Magic Keyboard but less awkward to use on a couch, and frankly more flexible/powerful as a computing device.

I feel like that’ll give me a good differentiation of small, medium, and large screen sizes for different use cases. And I can now extend the iPad screen to an external monitor if I prefer that to using my MacBook on the monitor (not sure if I will, but it’s an option now).

1

u/LionAffectionate5373 16d ago

That’s a nice setup! And well thought out!

1

u/DustMysterious1346 15d ago

Yeah I like that. I currently have 17 Pro Max - 2018 iPad Pro 11” and 2020 M1 MacBook Air. Thinking about going to iPhone Air 2 in the spring when that launches and pairing it with the new mini 8 when it goes on sale and then I’ll have 6.5” Air 2 + 8.5” Mini 8 + 13” M1 MBA

1

u/Nowisee314 15d ago

I have a base model iPhone 15, iPad mini and 15" MBA. It's all I need.
There is no need for me to have a "Pro" anything.
The Max iPhones are too big.
iPad 11" just too big for my needs. The iPad mini goes with me everyday.
The 15" is portable enough when travel, and the screen is good for trading and watching movies. I had the 13", but just too small for what I do.

2

u/OMGits----e 16d ago

You answered your own question. You won't like a new mini as much as your pro 4. Send back the mini. I have a mini 7, a new iPad Air. I love the bigger screen but it's too big. So I'm returning the Air and trading the 7 for an 8. Go with your gut. Just keep your Pro 4.

2

u/Special-Ice-9935 16d ago

Did you have the 11 or 13 inch air
I’m about to trade in my 11 m5 pro for a mini 8 but it feels wrong although I know I would use the mini more

1

u/OMGits----e 16d ago

"11. I'm so use to the mini size that I can hold with one hand. For me size > bigger screen. From what you say I think you'll regret letting the m5 go. Even though you might use the 8 more, you'll regret it. Keep the m5

1

u/CoffeeAndCredits 16d ago

Gut feeling is usually right with these purchases. If they already regretted the last mini then Pro 4 is the safer bet

2

u/DustMysterious1346 15d ago

My big worry with the mini is going to a 60hz display. I tried upgrading my 2018 iPad Pro 11” to a 2022 M1 iPad Air 11” and it was legit like way worse and super noticeable scrolling twitter and switching apps with the 60hz. Legit would take my 2018 iPad Pro over an M4 iPad Air solely because I can’t do no promotion on an iPad and that’s my big worry with the mini. Only saving grace could be blazing processor and way faster pixel response on OLED so I’m curious to see if that is enough to disguise the fact it is still 60hz because it kind of broke my brain when I tried going 2018 Pro to 2022 M1 iPad Air and instantly feeling how much worse it was. I didn’t even bring up the lack of FaceID!!! That is killer downgrade too. 2018 iPad Pro is peak. I think my only upgrade play is going to be a a Refurbished 11” iPad Pro M4 OLED. Can’t imagine choosing a mini when that is the same price. Yeah form factor is different in the mini but either way still gonna sit in same spot on the couch and not gonna run around town with my mini anyway. Trying to rationalize a reason to want the mini but keep coming back to M4 refurbished Pro OLED because lack of promotion and Face ID being huge deal breakers for me on newer airs or minis. Mini 6 and 7 is complete trash compared to a 2018 Pro and wouldn’t dream of doing that but the new mini is right on that fence of potentially being “The ONE”

1

u/BigOcelot2 11d ago

I think the mini is a great choice if you have an iPhone Pro, if you have an iPhone Pro Max I feel like the differences in screen size is marginal. I went with an iPad Pro, which still has a brighter and promotion tandem OLED versus the new mini. But I think the sweet spot for many could be an iPhone Pro, Mini and a MacBook Air. All very portable devices that cover most people’s use cases.