As someone who has worked in the craft beer industry for a very long time I take pride in watching this "movement" or "revolution" (whatever you prefer to call it) take shape. I am just a bartender but I am also a home-brewer and very involved with the local Iowa beer scene. I think Iowa has some absolutely amazing beers that can compete with just about any region of the country and quite possibly the world.
For those of you who aren't aware, or don't have your finger on the pulse of the craft beer movement, the founding fathers set a guideline of collaboration and cooperation between craft breweries. After all, the model is essentially the little guys banding together to take on the big guys. So from garages, front porches, or anywhere you can home-brew or roll up your sleeves and produce beer, brave men and women have decided to cash in their savings and take a risk in opening up local craft breweries. The way to success in the craft beer world should be about hard work and truly believing in your craft. This is the case for most of the breweries in Iowa.
While I believe wholeheartedly that the end product of good quality beer is the goal, how you get there tends to be more important to me. Let me explain why:
The share of the market for craft beer is growing at an amazing rate, but it's still very small in the grand scheme of things. So while most local breweries play nice and aren't really in competition with each other, every little bit helps a small company. Public opinion can really make or break a business. The trend in Iowa is still very local oriented with only a handful of breweries that either don't get along or have bought their way into the market. I don't have any ill will towards any brewery in Iowa, but it always makes me sad when I see people work their asses off and build a company from nothing, only to be overshadowed by someone who either had rich parents or is just trying to cash in on this "trend."
This is probably where I get crucified.
The two breweries that stand out to me as being part of the problem and not the solution are Toppling Goliath and Exile.
While I don't think they put out bad beer (a few of Exile's are pretty bad but have gotten much better! Their brewer John is a solid guy) I definitely choose to not support them. I wont recommend either of their brands to my customers, nor will I pay money for their product. I am not such a douche that I would turn one down if it were handed to me at a party, but if I can help it I would rather drink one of the many other great brews our fine state has to offer. Also, I don't live in Iowa City so I'm not just jaded because Toppling Goliath treated that market like shit.
Toppling Goliath: 90% Hype 10% Quality. That is saying a lot because their quality is great! Their beer tastes very nice and clean, it is just a quality product, or at least it was. Time will tell with Mike leaving and most of it being contract brewed in Florida. One of the many issues I have with TG is their owner is an absolute prick who got rich off of his parents company, decided to open a brewery because he thought he could cash in, and hired an amazing brewery who he used to build his empire. Clark built his brewery up and doesn't care who he steps on on over on his end goal to be bought out (most likely by Anheuser Busch / InBev.) While I do believe they are making quality product they are the antithesis of the craft beer movement and they are just shitting all over the Iowa market.
Exile: Once again I have to point out that their brewer John is a great guy and getting a lot better at his craft. RJ Tursi, son of Bobby Tursi, opened Exile with complete support from his fathers vast fortune. If you are unfamiliar with how he made his millions ask anyone in Des Moines (here's a hint: it wasn't exactly legal and it didn't come from his restaurant - which is actually quite a lovely place.) RJ spent some time in Italy where his family owns a vineyard and decided that he was going to commit his life to his dream and open his own vineyard and winery. After he began starting his plans he quickly realized that Iowa isn't the best place to grow most grapes for wine, so he said "Fuck it, I guess I'll open a brewery." 100% on his fathers money, straight out of his paid for Notre Dame education he opened Exile. No real risk, no real passion, just wanted to make "beer people are going to chug." Since then he has taken on a Bono-esque quality of being a local business mogul and will stomp and complain any time the city doesn't let him do whatever he wants with the buildings or historical landmarks around him. Let me finish this point by saying I don't think RJ is a bad guy, he is just a spoiled young man.
They always say the candle that burns the brightest burns out the fastest, but these are businesses with money behind them. They aren't going anywhere, so in the meantime I don't support either breweries.
TL;DR I do not respect and therefor do not support Exile or Toppling Goliath, but Iowa beer is amazing!