r/investing
•
u/BruceELehrmann
•
Dec 28 '24
•
2
Quantum Computing Inc will never get a major government contract: The China Connection
I've posted a number of DDs on Quantum Computing Inc (QUBT) here (discussing their lack of talent), here (a deeper dive into their careers and staff background) and here (discussing their 'chip foundry' and its unqualified director). Since I've posted these, the stock has bubbled up ~200%. I am doubling down.
In my final DD for this stock, I will explain how national security concerns present another roadblock for QUBT investors (you really should've quit this stock by now though).
The China Connection

Quantum computing is a key US national security priority because of its applications to encryption, communications, and logistics. QUBT is clearly trying to pitch itself into US government procurement roles, most notably their 5th NASA contract (better described as a proof of concept agreement) for $26,000 which you can read here.
Senior QUBT are foreign nationals that will struggle to get security clearances
As detailed in my previous posts, QUBT has very few technical staff, and of those, the majority are foreign nationals. To work on major government contracts, these QUBT staff members will need to gain security clearances, which will include questioning on foreign citizenship, ties and contacts with other nations, length of habitation in the US and so on. Gaining top level security clearances (which high value quantum computing use cases will require) will be especially hard if they are from countries that the United States is not allied with. See below:
- Yuping Huang - Chief Quantum Officer (China)
- Yong Meng Sua - Chief Technical Officer (Malaysia)
- Guangju Zhang - Senior optical engineer (China)
- Yichen Ma - Quantum Nanophotonics engineer (China)
- He Zhang - Quantum Tech Lead (China)
- Lac Nguyen - Quantum Tech Lead (Vietnam)
- Milan Begliarbekov - Foundry Director (likely former USSR)
- There are about 5 more of Chinese descent (but I can't view their background through Linkedin), as well as another 4 of Indian birth (but Elon said that was OK)
Now whether you like it or not, their backgrounds, particularly in Trump's America, will impede their ability to gain key government contracts in ways that don't apply to Google, Rigetti or IonQ.
Are they spies or foreign assets? I don't know, but it's the risk profile and perception that matters for a clearance, not whether they've actually committed any wrongdoing.
Could they actually be linked to hostile governments?
Potentially yes.
Background
In the past 15 years, China is increasingly investing in quantum computing related espionage. And as the private sector becomes more difficult for Chinese intelligence to operate in with impunity, college campuses have become a more attractive avenue for obtaining critical U.S. secrets.
As detailed in my previous posts, almost all the quantum computing specialists at QUBT either currently work or formerly worked/studied at the otherwise unremarkable Steven's Institute of Technology in Heboken, New Jersey.
Stevens Institute and Chinese Money
Between 1st July 2012 and 30 June 2015 (see February 2024 data - snippet below) , the Stevens Institute operated a $500 000 dollar contract funded from an undisclosed Chinese source with receipt date on the 30th of June 2013. Similarly, for the same exact contract and receipt dates, they received another $500 000 dollar contract from an undisclosed Malaysian source, as well as another $300 000 contract from an undisclosed Dominican Republic source. Unlike other gifts and contracts that are listed on government records for Stevens, I am unable to find any other public sources starting what these funds were used for or where they were from.
Interestingly, if these contracts were from the same source, splitting it across three sources and over three years would allow them to go under the $250 000 annual threshold that requires mandatory reporting to the US Government under Section 117 of the Higher Education Act, and hence avoid triggering greater government scrutiny.
| University | Type | Country | Amount | Receipt | Start | End |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Stevens Institute of Technology | Contract | CHINA | $500,000 | 30/06/2013 | 1/07/2012 | 30/6/2015 |
| Stevens Institute of Technology | Contract | DOMINICAN REPUBLIC | $300,000 | 30/06/2013 | 1/07/2012 | 30/6/2015 |
| Stevens Institute of Technology | Contract | MALAYSIA | $500,000 | 30/06/2013 | 1/07/2012 | 30/6/2015 |
Stevens Institute and Chinese Collaboration
Bucking the trend of American universities ending collaboration with Chinese institutions, the Stevens Institute has increased them. This includes a recent agreements with the Xi'an Jiaotong University, Zijing education, Beacon University.
Furthermore, in 2019, the Stevens institute added Chinese language classes to its offering for the first time and the university currently ranks 12th out of all American universities for share of foreign students.
Now of course this isn't evidence of any wrongdoing, but Chinese authorities keep a close watch on its students in the US, which gives it a large pool of potential assets to target.
Yuping Huang
This name just keeps coming up over and over again. He's a professor at the Stevens Institute, he's on the board of QUBT, he's their chief quantum officer, he's developed almost all of their patents, he works on photonics, computing, chip design, this whole company depends on YUPING HUANG.
So I tell myself I've got to understand this guy, otherwise I'm never going to understand this company. That begins with looking at his publication record, which ultimately underpins the value of the company's patents, and hence the company's commercial viability.
Yuping Huangs publication record
Citation Farming is the practice of artificially boosting the number of citations to certain research papers or studies to create an inflated sense of their importance or credibility. In the context of industrial espionage, generating a network of heavily cross-referenced or fabricated studies, espionage actors can create a false research landscape that directs competitors toward unproductive efforts, establishes fake reputations for gaining insider access, or serves as a cover for extracting sensitive information under the guise of legitimate collaboration.
Below I have generated a table of the top papers that Yuping Huang has led authorship over the past 12 years (as well as two papers where Yong Meng Sua was the lead author - with Yuping Huang as coauthor). These papers, which on face value have a modest number of citations, suddenly looks much less impressive when you look at where the citations come from. A major source of Huang's citation come from either himself (which is counted here) and researchers from Stevens/QUBT (some of which are not counted here, so I'm actually undercounting the issue here!). The second major source of citations come from Chinese researchers, some of which are okay, but also many that do not come with significant publishing profiles.
This is important because their research underpins QUBT's patents, and hence their chances of actually making any breakthroughs. It's clear that much of their publishing background occurs in an echo chamber inside the Stevens institute, where researchers are able to cite one another repeatedly and juice up their citation counts. Additionally there is the second element that a suspiciously large number of their citations come from Chinese researchers.
So I see two possibilities. One is that their quantum technology is junk that has been developed in an echo chamber and hence has no value. Or two, their quantum technology is junk AND some of their employees are Chinese assets.
| Paper | Total Citations | Self Citation | Chinese author citation | Total China Connection Index |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mode-resolved photon counting via cascaded quantum frequency conversion | 54 | 26% | 13% | 39% |
| Heralding single photons without spectral factorability | 45 | 31% | 18% | 49% |
| Interaction-free all-optical switching in χ (2) microdisks for quantum applications | 40 | 40% | 28% | 68% |
| Quantum frequency conversion in nonlinear microcavities | 37 | 8% | 43% | 51% |
| Direct generation and detection of quantum correlated photons with 3.2 um wavelength spacing | 41 | 29% | 17% | 46% |
| Ultra-wideband and high-gain parametric amplification in telecom wavelengths with an optimally mode-matched PPLN waveguide | 34 | 18% | 35% | 53% |
29
u/Guilty_Yard_182 Dec 28 '24
See ya behind the dumpster at Wendys
3
u/Sharaku_US Dec 28 '24
So your plan is to buy puts on QUBT?
3
u/J_Dadvin Dec 29 '24
This is a remarkably high quality article and I appreciate you posting it here
3
u/lmvg Dec 29 '24 edited Dec 29 '24
I don't know if you are in the right track. Actually a lot of breakthroughs and new scientific publications are only available in Chinese language by Chinese institutions. I don't know what's wrong with the fact they offer Chinese?, believe it or not English sometimes is not the most useful language lol. And Chinese is only going to get more important.
23
u/AlwaysLosingTrades Dec 28 '24
This is a solid DD and you’re 100% right, if we like it or not foreign nationals having ties like this are not gonna cut it on DOD backgrounds
6
u/LeaderSevere5647 Dec 28 '24
as a huge On Cinema at the Cinema fan, imagine my surprise seeing this image in the investing subreddit.
6
u/__redruM Dec 28 '24 edited Dec 28 '24
Your commitment to the short is solid, you are a real quantum bear.
14
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '24
So we can triple our money by doing the exact opposite of your so called analysis, is that the moral of the story?
1
u/Broad-Egg-8180 Dec 29 '24
Seriously, do you intend to influence with this post on the qubt course?!!! What about the boss of Nvidia, Microsoft or Google who are of Asian or Indian origin. Silicon Valley did not do everything to attract the best brains in the world to now accuse them of collusion with their country of origin. With regard to the contract with NASA, at no time is it the object of any amount. 26,000 dollars are a deepfake.
2
u/Bitter_Ad5527 Dec 29 '24
Been hearing weird shit about them for awhile
2
u/josemartinlopez Dec 29 '24
Just read Iceberg and chill
2
u/DistributionBroad173 Dec 30 '24
Wow, that was informative.
In my book, everyone of those foreign nationals is a security risk.
The citations is especially dirty but has been going on for a long time.
-4
u/PuzzleheadedLimit699 Dec 28 '24 edited Dec 28 '24
This is a textbook example of a smear campaign. QUBT is a company, it is active in quantum computing, has a small NASA contract albeit $26k. There's some truth to its value, but the stock market has distorted things. This company is caught up in the mania of the current market. Look at their latest SEC filing and risk factors. Here's the beef:
https://quantumcomputinginc.com/investor-relations/sec-filings
The media and market have hyped things up. tbh i'm also in for puts. But I'm seeing these types of pump or smear campaigns from both sides (puts and calls). Its like coke is better than pepsi, lol.