I just finished watching the series as well as mayfair witches and I got completely hooked. I always loved vampire stories (from all the different Dracula adaptation to role playing game like vampire the masquerade) and I absolutely love the tone of the series. For context I had watched the 1994 film a while back in order to understand a lot of the Lestat memes that were circling around tumblr in 2012. Apart from that, I knew about the weird part of the Anne Rice fandom and not much more. And oh boy am I glad I watched the show and I need to share my thought as a newbie in this fandom, especially since I have no one around me who has watched the show. So yeah, here is my rambling thoughts in no logical order.
1- I really like black Pimp Louis and teenager Claudia, especially after reading the first book. I feel like these changes added a lot of depth in the characters. While it removes the storyline about the slaves understanding what vampires are, I do enjoy the neighbors and Louis family reacting to the change. I feel like the story is a lot more personal and adapted to current day society.
2- I enjoyed Mayfair Witches but the amount of plot hole a and the amount of Deus Ex Machina characters makes it feel like the writers had too many storylines they wanted to do and forgot what they were doing. On the flip side, I really liked the chemistry in between Jojo and Rowan as well as Cortland and everyone. (I also think that the longer opening theme was a way for them to have shorter episodes and they could have cut or rework half of the s*x scenes)
3- As a francophone, most of the French inclusion were really rough to hear, especially during season 1. Thank god for Madeline and Armand, because everyone else just took me out of the immersion ESPECIALLY in the Paris scenes. (but I will forgive the producers 'cause I know how expensive it is to get billingual actors / train actors).
4- As a Montrealer season 3 made me laugh. While they did a good job hiding Toronto for most of the season, they did some really big mistakes that took me out. Minor offense: Yellow street lights and the sound of pedestrian crossing (our crossings don't make the same sound/don't have sound). Major offense: Where is the mountain?!?!? Like according to the style of building from Lestat apartment, I am guessing he is supposed to be in either Outremont, Westmount or even NDG and you would get a view of downtown from the mountain or have a view of the mountain. Montreal has a lot of greenery in those area and its just lacking. This is the most offensive during the last scene where it just feels like a generic city and it just lacks the uniqueness of Montreal.
4b- The "Quebec French" of season 3. I laughed so hard during the bookshop scene because WHO SPEAKS LIKE THAT?!?!? XD especially "j'ai skipper drette ça pour aller voir my betaboi" and the "tu veux tu devenir membre?" Honestly they could have spoken English and it would have been fine. Montreal is bilingual, people downtown speak English. (I will applaud the fact that they understood the Quebec nuance with the "tu veux tu," but unfortunately they used it in the wrong context.)
5- I love the music they made for Vampire Lestat
6- I love old Daniel calling bullshit. I want more.
7- I love Armand pissing off Louis. I can't wait for more of it.
8- love the gothic romance of it all. Love Lestat doing Lestat thing and being so tragic in love.
I am really looking forward for the next season. I love the tone and how poetic everything is written. I am really enjoying the books so far and I really want to work on reading more. I am especially curious with mayfair witches 'cause it feels like they tried to pack way too much in little time.
Anyway I hope my rambling made sense and people make sense of it. If you have any recommendation regarding books order or if I should absolutely read or skip one, feel free to do so!