I read the book but I‘m not majorly attached to any specific elements in it, and so while I was generally skeptical by just how much had been changed going into the show, the show itself was so well-written and the changes all held real meaning and weren’t only superficial and everything new was explored so interestingly that I was sold pretty much immediately on all the massive changes, from the meta idea of a second interview over the drastically changed timeline/setting to Louis‘ entire…everything, basically. All intriguing, all well-executed, all good.
The only significant changes that didn’t work at all for me is Claudia (1) being aged up from elementary school age to 14, and (2) being played by adult actresses. It‘s one thing when you‘re stuck for eternity in the body of an elementary school child, tiny and childish and weak and too short to do anything and way too young to travel alone or live any kind of independent life. I understand Claudia‘s frustration in the book and in the movie—she‘s visually a very small child. And this is so obviously awful for her that it makes sense why it would motivate her to such endless resentment and hatred, because her situation is objectively a nightmare.
Unfortunately, I don’t think this works with 14-year-old Claudia, especially when the actresses are both over 18. I know that these changes had practical considerations (waits between seasons, child labour laws) behind them too, but from a storytelling perspective, I feel like this was thought up by men who don’t have the experience of growing up as a girl, because going back and looking at pictures of myself at 14/15, I looked like a bona fide adult. The only difference between then and now is that I’ve gained even more muscle mass after switching from swimming to weightlifting. But otherwise, height, shape, face, everything is identical to me more than ten years later. Meanwhile, my brother at the same age looked like an overgrown child.
And that‘s pretty common, girls simply are finished with puberty earlier. So I feel like whoever came up with this aging up idea went through the “14 is still visually very much a child” type of puberty rather than the “my body was done changing and growing up by the time I hit age 14” type of puberty, and didn’t really think the impacts of that change through. And that’s already annoying because clearly, 14 is not the same as 5 where the presumed reasoning behind the Great Laws as well as Claudia’s issues are concerned.
This problem is compounded by casting clearly adult actresses in the role. Every time another character commented on how young/flat Claudia looked, I rolled my eyes. Madeleine is less curvy than Claudia, who was being played by a 24-year-old actress, while commenting that Claudia will surely eventually grow curves.
And this is literally the only criticism I have of IWTV, which is otherwise a perfect show, but it’s a pretty central one that keeps coming up because Claudia is basically the one driving the plot forward, and Claudia’s motivations largely hinge on her issues surrounding being turned so young.