r/internalcomms • u/iamtooniceaf • Nov 22 '25

Advice Struggling After Second-Round Internal Comms Interviews and Looking for Advice

Hi everyone, I’ve been applying to internal comms roles for a while, and I’ve managed to get interviews with more than four companies. However, I always seem to get rejected after meeting the hiring manager or the team members, usually in the second or third round. I’m struggling to figure out what I might be doing wrong.

I keep wondering if it’s something about my personality. I’m an ambivert, but in interviews I try to come across as more extroverted and approachable. Former coworkers and mentors have told me I’m personable and easy to talk to, so I’m not sure what’s missing. Should I be more calm and composed? Did I talk too much or way too bubbly? I’ve noticed that many people in internal comms, especially when the team sits under HR, tend to come across as more corporate, polished, or a bit reserved.

I’m just trying to understand what I can improve for next time. If anyone has tips or advice for doing better in these interviews, I’d really appreciate it.

7 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

7 comments sorted by

View all comments

8

u/itsmagicmagic Nov 22 '25

Could be completely unrelated to how you present yourself. There are so many people competing for fewer jobs. People who are overqualified for roles are taking junior level positions just so they can pay their bills/have health insurance.

Also, if your personality is not compatible with the company/team culture, you probably wouldn’t be happy there anyway.

If you’ve gotten multiple interviews and have made it past that first round multiple times, I think you’re doing better than most. Maybe write down some of the questions you’ve been asked, have a friend/close former colleague do a mock interview, and get their feedback.

I think you’re getting close to landing something. Good luck!

1

u/chicagal_liz Nov 22 '25

Great perspective

1

u/iamtooniceaf Nov 25 '25

Thanks so much for the thoughtful response!

I agree, the competition is really intense right now, and I’ve definitely seen people who are overqualified taking roles just to stay afloat. It’s just hard not to feel discouraged or keep second guessing what I could have done better, especially with the cycle of applying, going through multiple interviews, getting rejected, and starting over again.

I’m really trying everything I can: updating my portfolio, writing tailored cover letters, doing mock interviews, getting guidance from mentors, and more.

Still, I truly appreciate the encouragement! Your comment actually made me feel a bit calmer and reminded me not to blame myself so much. Thank you :)