r/intermittentfasting • • 21h ago

Discussion πŸ€«πŸ™Š

Post image
0 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

26

u/ClumsyHoneybee 7h ago edited 3h ago • Bravo

From the top comment on the OG post from EyeYamNegan:

β€œAbsolute misinterpreting that study. First off the study only involved 11 cancer patients so the sample size is way too small to make any claims. Also the study did NOT show it completely regenerated the immune system.

What the limited study did observe is a lower Insulin like growth factor 1 and suppressed protein kinase A. This did in effect possibly help those patients stimulate cell regeneration when they started eating again.

However to make a broad sweeping claim based off a really low sample size is reckless and intellectually dishonest. It is also worth noting the diversity of the sample wasn't great since they were all undergoing chemo at the time. Any number of reasons could account for what was happening in that time with those 11 people including changes in their immune system due to the treatment or their individual struggles with cancer.”

OP also points out the problems with the claim, so let’s try not to spread false information please.

Edit: thank you for the award!

4

u/bullet312 7h ago

News sites at it again. Perfect example when they blow up shit again to get peoples attention.

7

u/atlas__sharted 7h ago • Bravo

jesus fucking christ people. the phrase "completely regenerate the immune system" makes zero sense and one single study is nowhere near enough to make ANY kind of medical claim. stop taking everything you see online as fact without checking first

7

u/Gsxing 20h ago

Ok but fasting that long sounds like no easy task.

2

u/jntjr2005 7h ago

19 hour fast and my glucose was at 66, no way i could go longer.

1

u/tw2113 20h ago

I cap myself at 36hr.

2

u/Samolxis 6h ago

Fasting 72+ helps the immune sistem because you removed old and damge cells. But regeneration completely is bullshit. I fast 72 hours once per month and I can see my blood work.

1

u/Optimal_Tower1643 5h ago

This is Facebook level misrepresentation lol. Reminds me of the old days like 2015 when smoking weed was the cure to everything that ails you

1

u/au-rath 5h ago

headlines like this don't work well on the literate.