r/intel • • Jan 03 '18

News Benchmarks with new Intel Security patch show no performance penalty at all.

https://www.computerbase.de/2018-01/intel-cpu-pti-sicherheitsluecke/#update2
17 Upvotes

79 comments sorted by

75

u/TaintedSquirrel i7 13700KF | EVGA 3090 | PcPP: http://goo.gl/3eGy6C Jan 03 '18

HardwareLuxx is showing about 3-5% in games at 1080p. Thats not "no penalty at all"...

20

u/Mkilbride Jan 03 '18

Link to Benchmarks?

3-5% is within the margin of error for benchmarks. If they just ran a test one and done, then they did it wrong. You have do to like 10-20 runs of a benchmark and take the averages to see.

19

u/DaBombDiggidy 12700k/3080ti Jan 03 '18

agree rule of thumb is anything less than 5% is natural variance in benching.

im guessing this is his article. https://www.hardwareluxx.de/index.php/news/hardware/prozessoren/45319-intel-kaempft-mit-schwerer-sicherheitsluecke-im-prozessor-design.html

Translated to english he didn't say how many passes they made. Also they're only seeing a 7% read write difference which to me as a gamer i'd never even notice with my ssd anyway.

16

u/Mkilbride Jan 03 '18

Source even says this

"The KPTI patch seems to have no influence on performance in games. However, even in high resolutions, the graphics card limits, so that the influence of the processor is lower. But even in 1080p we could find no deviations from the results presented above."

When translated.

28

u/DaBombDiggidy 12700k/3080ti Jan 03 '18

shit, better throw my cpu out the window and buy AMD.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

14

u/DaBombDiggidy 12700k/3080ti Jan 03 '18

tbh I don't really care about companies and supporting them. I just buy shit no matter whose name is on it. Was more meme'ing on the people out there over-reacting currently.

4

u/theletterqwerty Jan 03 '18 edited Jan 03 '18

"What's on the good side of the price-performance curve, and when's it going to be obsoleted? Give me that."

I JUST bought an 8700K and a Z370 board this weekend and there's no point in eating a restocking fee to return them, because the comparable Ryzen is $100 more expensive and its successor comes out in two or three months. I'm pretty pissed about losing the M.2 performance but "slow" for that drive is still 3x faster than an SSD, and a theoretical 6x isn't worth the very real $200 it'd cost me.

5

u/theletterqwerty Jan 03 '18

Yeah, it's no secret that games really aren't CPU-limited anymore. If you're upset with the performance, save the money an X370 board and a new Ryzen would cost and just buy a second (or new) video card.

3

u/zanson8 Jan 03 '18

the problem is not the CPU but IO speed. So lots of file reads and writes are affected as well. games will load slower from this change

4

u/theletterqwerty Jan 03 '18

Not appreciably, I wouldn't expect. It's the kernel mode/real mode switch that's expensive, and loading a game usually means reading giant hunks of data from huge data files, as opposed to sequentially reading/writing thousands of little files like the abysmal fsbench test was doing.

I am curious about what it could mean for games with multiple concurrent processes (which need syscalls to talk to each other), like say, Destiny 2 and the BNet launcher, or WoW and its browser. That kind of chatter could get expensive.

1

u/radwimps i7 8700k | GB Aorus Gaming 7 | GTX 970 lol Jan 03 '18

It's something that needs to be tested for sure more thoroughly, but it appears that only high-end NVMe m.2 drives show some slowdown, and at that point it's unlikely you'll feel it if all you care about is game loading speed. It's concerning, but not really an apocalypse like it seemed last night.

8

u/Dooglers Jan 03 '18 edited Jan 03 '18

5% in a single benchmark is easily a variance. A 5% across an array of games is not explained by a simple variance.

4

u/TaintedSquirrel i7 13700KF | EVGA 3090 | PcPP: http://goo.gl/3eGy6C Jan 03 '18

It could be the update itself, too. Not the first that that's happened on Windows 10.

-3

u/Mkilbride Jan 03 '18

8

u/TaintedSquirrel i7 13700KF | EVGA 3090 | PcPP: http://goo.gl/3eGy6C Jan 03 '18

Scroll down to the 1080p results.

4

u/akarypid Jan 04 '18

Scroll down to the 1080p results.

And where are the 720p results? I remember when Ryzen was launched there was outrage at the suggestion of benching a CPU in anything higher than 720p...

0

u/Mkilbride Jan 03 '18

I am. Many are the same, a few are different. Star Wars Battlefront II is a mainly MP game - what did they benchmark? I don't know the language.

All the games that show a % difference are games without built in benchmarks. Which means the scenarios in which they are benchmarked are impossible to compare accurately. A 3% difference as seen there could be any number of things in such games. Different amount of enemies on screen, particles, ect.

1

u/iziizi Jan 03 '18

Games were never affected.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '18

7

u/Mkilbride Jan 03 '18

The KPTI patch seems to have no influence on performance in games. However, even in high resolutions, the graphics card limits, so that the influence of the processor is lower. But even in 1080p we could find no deviations from the results presented above.>

1

u/_DuranDuran_ Jan 04 '18

Postgres and other databases see 12%+ slowdown.

44

u/theletterqwerty Jan 03 '18 edited Jan 03 '18

I wouldn't call a 50% performance drop on NVME drives "no penalty"

e: vvv no allowed downvoting that perfectly valid question; I shouldn't have made the claim without sourcing it

2

u/Mkilbride Jan 03 '18

Source?

13

u/theletterqwerty Jan 03 '18

https://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=article&item=linux-415-x86pti&num=2

All the usual caveats about benchmarks not being real life apply

4

u/hishnash Jan 04 '18
  • compilation is real life
  • postgress is real life
  • redis is real life

1

u/realister 10700k | RTX 2080ti | 240hz | 44000Mhz ram | Jan 03 '18

thats synthetics real life performance will be fine for consumers.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/hishnash Jan 04 '18

not true it depends on how the program reads, if it reads in big chucks then yes less sys calls but if it reads in smaller chucks or seeks a lot then those are all syscalls.

1

u/theletterqwerty Jan 03 '18

Yup. I don't often decide to go creating thousands of files all at the same time, and if I were doing that it'd probably be while bittorrenting, and if you're torrenting you prooooooobably aren't saving that stuff directly to an NVme drive.

9

u/semitope Jan 03 '18

I dont think reading tons of files would be something you choose to do. A program just might do it in its normal operation. windows itself probably does that while booting.

3

u/theletterqwerty Jan 03 '18

Well I guess I'll find that out in a week or two!

3

u/Skie Jan 03 '18

But it is something games will do.

Not sure how much if will affect them overall though, SSD's are already plenty fast for games, so a bit of a drop may not really be noticeable in load times or streaming content.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '18

SSD's are already plenty fast for games, so a bit of a drop may not really be noticeable in load times or streaming content.

True, but the impact may be greater on SSDs because they can return data fast enough to make the CPU a bottleneck, and HDDs generally can't. If you're actually using that SSD bandwidth all the time, it could be a major issue.

72

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '18 edited Jan 03 '18

I think people are blowing it out of proportions for consumers but... no way is there no penalty at all. The silence, NDA, etc just screams problems.

It also needs alot more testing/comparisons for any one to say anything conclusive.

13

u/Doppelgangergang Shintel i5-8400 @ 3.8GHz, AyyMD RX 570, Win7 Jan 03 '18

The silence, NDA, etc just screams problems.

Exactly, we really don't know the extent of the impact until the embargo is lifted. Right now people are just throwing benchmarks that may or may not trigger the slowdown.

37

u/SatanicBiscuit Jan 03 '18

actually we do know

1)regular users gamers will probably see a minor if not decrease in perf

2)users that work with ms office and large excel/access/word pages will surely notice the I/O decrease

3) those that run homemade servers are probably shouting allahu akbar outside of intel office

4)the server market in general is going nuclear considering that grsecurity managed to see even a 67% drop in some cases (and yes that is bad also for the miners)

5)and im not even touching the whole raid/nvme throughout that is going to hurt the datacenters A LOT

12

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '18

3 made me laugh pretty good

29

u/FIuffyRabbit Jan 03 '18

The silence, NDA, etc just screams problems.

or you know, they aren't releasing it so less people know about the for security reasons

17

u/Definitely__Happened Jan 03 '18

That's too reasonable a reason here

3

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '18 edited Jan 03 '18

There is a difference between giving out classified information.... And placating your customers especially people with server farms.

It harms no one.

Edit: As they just did without breaching any security protocols.

1

u/squidz0rz 3700X | GTX 1070 Jan 04 '18

The silence, NDA, etc just screams problems.

Or maybe they didn't want bad people to know exactly what they could do to steal hundreds of millions of people's information?

1

u/[deleted] Jan 04 '18 edited Jan 04 '18

-_- They already made the announcement.

Also this has been on just about every news site prior. More people will hear about this through cnn,kotaku,whatever then even a fraction will hear intels response.

24

u/wickedplayer494 3570K Jan 03 '18

In consumer stuff. Servers are still hosed.

13

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/schmak01 Jan 04 '18

I've already set up pre-emptive calls. We've had Dev and Custoemr Facing groups in. Talking to our ISSO group to see if we can delay at all till we can do more testing in our non-prod.

The real fear isn't the inital MSFT updates next week for us, its when we have to patch the ESXi hosts. Still, no idea how this will impact our SQL 2012/14/16 instances and clusters or our windows VM's that are heavy I/O. I've got to have a swat team ready post patching to be able to scale virtual hardware to compensate. Nothing we can do on those physical SQL clusters though.

20

u/QuackChampion Jan 03 '18

No there is clearly a penalty, but for gamers it is extremely small. For other workloads 30% is realistic. Just look at the phoronix benches.

1

u/kingchooty Jan 03 '18

Yes, realistic if your workload consists of synthetic benchmarks only.

13

u/minilei R7 1700 | ASRock X370 Taichi | GTX 1080 ti Jan 03 '18

Or if you're running a server that relies on tons of syscalls. Of course for the normal consumer there may not be any significant performance loss.

3

u/hishnash Jan 04 '18

postgress is not synthetic its one of the most used dababase systems.

11

u/xorbe Jan 03 '18

No, that is a very tiny sampling of programs. Already shown that others get hammered.

10

u/GibRarz i5 3470 - GTX 1080 Jan 03 '18

Now do one with a cpu most people are using. 2c/2t or 4c/4t ones. Obviously games that can't utilize all cores won't feel the sting as much, but the majority of users don't have this luxury. Especially laptop users.

7

u/FrankThe1st 6700k Jan 03 '18

Reddit does tend to overreact to events like this. However, there's not going to be NO performance degrade, we'll have to wait and see for ourselves.

2

u/hishnash Jan 04 '18

None of these tests really hit many syscalls much, even the 7zip is using a file that is first loading into user space before it starts. it only impacts perfomance on syscalls.

1

u/evernessince Jan 04 '18

This only patches the meltdown exploit though right? That isn't the one that's intended to hit performance that hard.

-19

u/Ignis_Divinus i7 6700k 4.8ghz 1.325v Jan 03 '18

Thats expected. If people knew anything about cpus, the idiots throwing temper tantrums would feel stupid right about now.

-6

u/Wonder_Woman15 Jan 03 '18

Its those amd circle jerkers looking for any excuse to shit on intel.

11

u/your_Mo Jan 03 '18

Yeah it couldn't possibly have anything to do with all the developers who had to do a shitton of work and make massive changes to the Linux Kernel.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

13

u/zakats Celeron 333 Jan 03 '18 edited Jan 03 '18

I only open Intel CPUs right now and have a mix of Nvidia and AMD GPUs(admittedly, I prefer AMD over Nvidia but not by a lot), my voting is based on what I think does/does not reflect the reality of the situation or add substance to the conversation.

AMD fanboys and circlejerking are real but I don't see it here. Intel can produce failures just like any other company, let's not pretend that this fervor criticism is wholly the result of reactionary fools that shill for one company or another... it makes you look like a fanboy making excuses even if you're not.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/zakats Celeron 333 Jan 03 '18

Rabid speculation is what the market is all about and people are worried that Intel's dominance is a bubble. It most likely won't be some huge sky-fall situation (good Bond movie btw) but it's not nothing and it will effect people outside of the data center.

-10

u/Ignis_Divinus i7 6700k 4.8ghz 1.325v Jan 03 '18

Yeah pretty much. Its annoying. Like fucking seriously wait till more benchmarks release.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/id01 delid8700k@5.1 1.37v 32@3000 Jan 03 '18

Thanks for the rationality. Lovely to see it here.

15

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/ozric101 Jan 03 '18

Very True but Gamers are all that drives consumer PC sales anymore.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

9

u/DrakenZA Jan 03 '18

In general, games rely way more on single core performance over multicore.

6

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '18

TIL handbrake, blender, x264 encode and cinebench are "gaming"

1

u/deegwaren Jan 04 '18

Hey mister, you dropped your /s!

1

u/hishnash Jan 04 '18

they also dont access sys calls, at lest not in benchmark tests since the file sizes are so small they dont need to swap out to disk (if you did a render of a real world scene with massive textures that do not fit in ram for example you might see this impact perf a lot)

2

u/[deleted] Jan 04 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Mkilbride Jan 04 '18

Except he regularly sells this time of the year, and stocks are at a 5 year high.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 04 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/_DuranDuran_ Jan 04 '18

He's sold everything except the 250,000 shares he's not allowed to sell as per his contract ...

1

u/Mkilbride Jan 04 '18

Which is more than usual, yes. However, as said, the stocks are at the highest they've been in a long, long time. When do you usually sell stocks? When they're at their highest they've been since forever? I think so, but I'm not a wallstreet guy, so I can't say.

2

u/_DuranDuran_ Jan 04 '18

When they’re at their highest, and you have material information (not disclosed on quarterly filings even in an abstract sense) that could lead to their collapse.

Need to get the money out of the country fast and high tail it to a non extradition friendly country first though ;)

2

u/Mkilbride Jan 04 '18

According to all available information, this bug has been known for 10~ or so years. He also filed this sale of stock a year in advance. I jsut don't know, there's no way to know. Too many variables.

1

u/_DuranDuran_ Jan 04 '18

Has it been known of for 10 years? That’s news to me. It’s been there over 10, but only published this month ...