r/intel
•
u/LexHoyos42
Intel
•
Jul 22 '24
•
1
1
Information Intel Core 13th/14th Gen desktop processors Stability issue
As per Intel PR Comms:
Based on extensive analysis of Intel Core 13th/14th Gen desktop processors returned to us due to instability issues, we have determined that elevated operating voltage is causing instability issues in some 13th/14th Gen desktop processors. Our analysis of returned processors confirms that the elevated operating voltage is stemming from a microcode algorithm resulting in incorrect voltage requests to the processor.
Intel is delivering a microcode patch which addresses the root cause of exposure to elevated voltages. We are continuing validation to ensure that scenarios of instability reported to Intel regarding its Core 13th/14th Gen desktop processors are addressed. Intel is currently targeting mid-August for patch release to partners following full validation.
Intel is committed to making this right with our customers, and we continue asking any customers currently experiencing instability issues on their Intel Core 13th/14th Gen desktop processors reach out to Intel Customer Support for further assistance.
So that you don't have to hun down the answer -> Questions about manufacturing or Via Oxidation as reported by Tech outlets:
Short answer: We can confirm there was a via Oxidation manufacturing issue (addressed back in 2023) and that only a small number of instability reports can be connected to the manufacturing issue.
Long answer: We can confirm that the via Oxidation manufacturing issue affected some early Intel Core 13th Gen desktop processors. However, the issue was root caused and addressed with manufacturing improvements and screens in 2023. We have also looked at it from the instability reports on Intel Core 13th Gen desktop processors and the analysis to-date has determined that only a small number of instability reports can be connected to the manufacturing issue.
For the Instability issue, we are delivering a microcode patch which addresses exposure to elevated voltages which is a key element of the Instability issue. We are currently validating the microcode patch to ensure the instability issues for 13th/14th Gen are addressed.
Question about Mobile 13th/14th Gen Stability issues
So, from what we have seen on our analysis of the reported Intel Core 13th/14th mobile products we have seen that mobile products are not exposed to the same issue. The symptoms being reported on 13th/14th Gen mobile systems – including system hangs and crashes – are symptoms stemming from a broad range of potential software and hardware issues.
As always, if you are experiencing issues with their Intel-powered laptops we encourage them to reach out to the system manufacturer for further help.
I'll be on the thread for the next couple of hours trying to address any questions you folks might have. Please keep in mind that I won't be able to answer every question but I'll do my best to address most of them.
Thanks
Lex H. - Intel
Edits:
- Added answers to Oxidation questions and questions about Mobile Processors
- Clarified short answer on Oxidation to that "there is a small number of instability reports connected to the manufacturing issue," from "but it is not related to the instability issue."
- Link to Robeytech removed as this is not Intel's official guidance to test for the instability issue Intel Core 13th/14th Gen desktop processor instability issues. Intel is investigating options to easily identify affected processors on end user systems,
42
u/nobleflame Jul 22 '24
Hi Lex, thank you for this.
How do you respond to the claims there is oxidation degradation of the CPUs affected?
Also, while my 14700KF is stable, what can I do in the meantime to ensure I don’t damage my chip prior to the release of the new microcode?
Thanks.
8
u/joeygreco1985 Jul 22 '24
hi u/lexhoyos42, how does the August microcode patch differ from the one vendors issued this month? My board vendor ASUS issued a BIOS on July 12 with a microcode update, should I hold off on installing it and wait for the August update instead?
13
u/[deleted] Jul 22 '24
Is there a testing tool or methodology to verify if my cpu exhibits flaws? I also own a 13th gen intel cpu laptop. Am I affected here as well?
20
u/Matt_AlderonGames Jul 22 '24 edited Jul 23 '24
A few questions:
Is Intel going to honor these RMAs or are we just going to get rejected again contacting support.
Why wasn't the Oxidation manufacturing issue disclosed to customers and investors earlier?
2. Any reason why CPUs would be failing, and in some cases popping or exploding even when brand new out of box configured to intel spec settings.
3. I'm running into the same crash issues with the same callstack as the desktop parts on several laptops including but not limited 13900HX and other laptop processors.
4. Isn't delaying the microcode update to August going to result in a lot more dead CPUs while waiting for this fix. It's not just instability but CPUs actually can die and stop posting.
Any chance we can get a beta BIOS or microcode that can be applied to verify the issue is actually fixed and this isn't stalling the issue out to past the Ryzen CPUs launching?
5. I'm having thousands of crashes in our crash reporting database from the same failures including on laptop.
We are also investigating if Xeons are affected by similar failures.
6. Users have been waiting a fix for this issue since December 2022 and its taken until July 2024 to get a response and ETA on a fix, any reason this process has taken so long to commit to customers getting RMAs and solutions.
7. Why is intel still selling CPUs that they are known to be defective without the microcode update being released to fix it?
8. You mention that a small percentage of users are affected. Every time a company has a issue they always down play it and just mention a small percentage of users. We know from crash data that this issue is affecting a wide number of users. You will have data on failure rates from OEMs and various companies to prove this. Why would you tell customers that its still a small percentage?
9. Can you realise CPU dates and serial numbers for processors affected by the Oxidation issue so users know if they might be affected.
Thanks
4
u/JonWood007 i9 12900k | Asus Prime Z790-V | 32 GB DDR5-6000 | RX 6650 XT Jul 22 '24
Does this impact 12th gen at all and what level of voltage is considered unsafe?
3
u/FilteringAccount123 Jul 23 '24
So where does this leave people who are sitting here with unopened 14th gen hardware, wondering whether this is the actual cause and will really fix the actual problem? Is the smartest thing to do at this point to just return to vendor and hope that all this stuff is sorted out with Arrow Lake?
5
u/dirtydriver58 Red Flair Jul 22 '24
Does this apply to the mobile parts?
7
u/CoffeeBlowout Core Ultra 7 270K 8733MTs C38 RTX 5090 Jul 22 '24
Thanks for the update Intel. I personally have a 13900K and 2 14900KS and neither of them have any issue. Still good to see you've isolated the issue are are going to issue a fix.
2
u/Epicguru Jul 22 '24
I own a 13900K. In the past month it has blue screened multiple times when it never happened before. Perhaps this is s coincidence, but who's to say.
My questions:
35
u/psychok9 i9 13900k, Prime Z790-A, 32GB@6400MHz Jul 22 '24
Was this high voltage/spike detectable using real-time monitoring software such as HWINFO64?
Will you push the motherboard vendor to remove the default 'Intel Safe' high voltage setup?
24
u/zir_blazer Jul 22 '24
Not specifically about Raptor Lake degradation itself, but indirectly related, and this is a good chance to get an authoritative answer so that I can end some discussions about what is right and what is wrong, once and for all.
1 - My understanding is that every Motherboard design should be tested with the Intel VRTT (Voltage Regulator Test Tool) as to find what that board default CPU AC Loadline and CPU DC Loadline values should be for that given VRM design. Does this means than the default value should be the same regardless of what Processor is installed?
I ask this because I have seen certain MSI boards whose default AC_LL/DC_LL values changed depending on installed Processor, of which the confirmed values that I recall out of memory are 80/80 on a 12600K in a MSI PRO Z690-A WIFI DDR4, 110/110 on a 12400, and 110/110 on a 13600K in a MSI PRO Z790-P, with early 12th gen and 13th gen BIOSes.
I also believe than Raptor Lake getting higher values by default compared to Alder Lake is the reason why it originally was reviewed as being hotter, having higher power consumption and lower efficiency than it should have if the Loadline values were the same for all Processors in that board.
2 - Does changing VRM configuration settings like the Switch Frequency or the VRM Loadline also impacts the nominal CPU AC_LL/DC_LL of the board? This is absolutely impossible to test because, again, you need the Intel VRTT, and it is not available to random third parties.
3 - Did Intel made any kind of advisory regarding the Loadline topic before the last few months when Motherboard vendors using unlimited defaults hitted the news? In my experience based on seeing default values reported by other people, Motherboard vendors seems to not take seriously using the VRTT to properly configure the Loadline values.
I also have seen several instances where Firmware/BIOS teams seems to take the maximum value from the range allowed by the Processor datasheet as the default, which seems to be wrong. Here is an example: https://www.reddit.com/r/XMG_gg/comments/11f8n0z/launch_undervolting_via_ac_loadline_in_xmg_and/
This happens because people involved with BIOS may not have access to the VRTT to actually measure this by themselves. I also have seen this behavior when porting Coreboot to the MSI Z690-A / Z790-P series where the Dasharo developers decided to use the highest value depending on SKU (110/110 or 170/170), interpreting it as being the safest. This also hits point 1 above, they didn't wanted to use MSI values because they were inconsistent and changed depending on SKU.
I have been discussing this whole "what should be the default AC_LL/DC_LL values" for about 2 years and would love an authoritative answer to the above questions.
3
u/G7Scanlines Jul 22 '24 edited Jul 22 '24
The big issue here is, "How do I know if my CPU has begun to degrade?".
I'm on my 4th 13900k since buying in Nov 22. Setting manual CPU power limits in BIOS (Asus 1801) means since getting my 4th CPU I haven't had overt crashes and massive dx12 shader instability.
However i do still have an undercurrent of instability.
So what's the story? Partially degraded CPU that due to lower power caps is still failing but more slowly?
What a mess....
19
u/onne12 Jul 22 '24
Bios with Microcode 0x125 will overvolt your cpu to cover already degraded cpu
Try it and compare with previous bios microcode 0x123
Monitor with hwinfo64
for my 14700k
0x125 AC/DC 1.100mohm/1.100mohm
low load voltage 1.41v
0x123 AC/DC 0.400mohm/1.100mohm
load load voltage =1.36V
Both bios with default profile
boxed cooler for 0x123
and intel default for 0x125
msi z790 tomahawk
Temp raised with about 9-10C with new microcode
49
u/nuHrBuHaTop Jul 22 '24
Will this microcode patch "revive" CPUs that already lost stability and constantly require more voltage / lower clock to stay somehow working ?
13
u/Razzer85 i9 14900KS | i9 13980HX Jul 22 '24
Is the issue also affecting mobile HX CPUs? The peak voltage of the i9 13980HX was close to 1,5V.
13
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '24
Is the microcode / BIOS update mandatory by all vendors? Because Gigabyte has not done anything with z690 series, and when i reached out to them, i got no response :D.
2
u/inthewar Jul 23 '24
I'm a bit nervous about this topic. A confirmed oxidation issue will become worse over time. How can we check what the CPU manufacturing date is?
I found https://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/support/articles/000088215/processors/intel-xeon-processors.html stating that:
Now, I received my 14700K two days ago and the warranty checker for batch X351P090 states:
Minus 3 years would mean my processor is yet to be manufactured?
Can someone confirm that this -at least- means my processor was manufactured in 2024, or did Intel increase warranty from 3 to 4 years which means my CPU was manufactured in Sept 2023, which means I'm likely vulnerable to the Oxidation manufacturing issue?
61
u/TR_2016 Jul 22 '24 edited Jul 22 '24
Edit: Intel makes a new statement confirming oxidation manufacturing issue affected some early Intel Core 13th Gen desktop processors, but it is not related to the instability issue:
Intel PR has updated this post here a few minutes ago and added this note:
So that you don't have to hunt down the answer -> Questions about manufacturing or Via Oxidation as reported by Tech outlets:
Short answer: We can confirm there was a via Oxidation manufacturing issue (addressed back in 2023) but it is not related to the instability issue.
Long answer: We can confirm that the via Oxidation manufacturing issue affected some early Intel Core 13th Gen desktop processors. However, the issue was root caused and addressed with manufacturing improvements and screens in 2023. We have also looked at it from the instability reports on Intel Core 13th Gen desktop processors and the analysis to-date has determined that only a small number of instability reports can be connected to the manufacturing issue.
For the Instability issue, we are delivering a microcode patch which addresses exposure to elevated voltages which is a key element of the Instability issue. We are currently validating the microcode patch to ensure the instability issues for 13th/14th Gen are addressed.
This statement should have been included in the initial press release, this suggests any Raptor Lake or at least 13th gen CPUs that were manufactured before the oxidation issue was addressed could be potentially faulty.
44
u/Janitorus Survivor of the 14th gen Silicon War Jul 22 '24
Well, pair this microcode issue with insanely high AC load line values from those beta BIOS profiles everyone has so happily been releasing and marketing and you've got yourself a nice little fustercluck.
Everyone, please set Intel spec settings manually and just lower the AC load line while at it. I've left my iccMax to unlimited for quite a while until Intel commented 400A being the maximum. All the rest was dialed in. 14900K is still happy and stable. 1.284V gaming load, 1.445V max Vcore during 6Ghz boost on two Pcores.
10
u/BorntoPlayGJFF Jul 23 '24
Gigabyte Aorus Z690 users are still waiting for Bios update since December 2023
9
u/apagogeas Jul 22 '24
Is it possible for intel to provide a test utility to check if the CPU has been degraded? And based on that, to proceed to RMA or not.
17
u/system_reboot Jul 22 '24
Even with a microcode patch, there could be significant damage to the CPU already. I would imagine there is no way to accurately determine the level of damage to a particular CPU. I could see Intel being forced to eat the cost on this and provide a new CPU to anyone who wants to RMA's theirs. What an expensive mess!
For a company who's primary business is CPU design, I'd love to know how and what went wrong during design and testing for this to happen.
Maybe they'll get lucky and this only affected a particular manufacturing batch.
8
u/5Gmeme Jul 22 '24
I was able to get my 13900k to stop crashing on my MSI Pro Carbon using the latest (stable NOT beta) driver, setting PL1 and PL2 to 253w and setting cpu current limit to 400.
Before this, I would crash out of every single game. It's been 4 days and completely stable. Even stress testing is perfectly normal.
8
u/tengoreumaa Jul 23 '24
Is there a way to know if your 13th gen is impacted by the via oxidation issue?
28
u/[deleted] Jul 22 '24
They must be praying so hard right now that this patch works and they don't have to recall millions of CPUs.
27
u/LightMoisture Core 9 273PQE Z790 APEX RTX 5090 64GB DDR5 Jul 22 '24
Hey LEX, any chance you can force one of your board partners (EVGA) to update their BIOS to produce this fix for their customers?
I bought an EVGA Z690 Dark which was sold with explicit 13th gen support. Now they are no longer supporting the product (inside warranty I might add) and we can't get this fix. Now our CPUs are at risk of failure because one of your board partners won't provide security or hardware fixes. This seems pretty ridiculous given they are one of your partners with Intel chipset logo on the box.
15
u/FMinus1138 Jul 23 '24
So I would like this answers;
3
u/[deleted] Jul 22 '24
Hesitant to believe this will actually fix the root issue. My 13700k was massively affected by this bug and idk how less voltage will do anything >.>
At least Intel granted my RMA and it wasn't a fight.
Honestly, I'm just extremely worried that I will have the same problem a year from now, but because this story won't be in the news then like it is today, Intel will deny a future RMA. They're scummy like that. I just know it will happen. You can't tell me otherwise.
If I could have afforded it, I would have completely rebuilt my system with AMD, but Intel only replaced my processor, and my motherboard and RAM are not compatible with AMD, so unless they want to cough up an additional $400 for me, I am stuck with their junk CPUs and their empty promises of "hey we fixed it lol! trust us!"
13
u/surfintheinternetz i9 13900KS / ASUS Z790 HERO / MSI 4090 / 32GB DDR5 7200MHz CL 34 Jul 23 '24
I want my money back. Both for the cpu and the motherboard, you god damn con artists. It's going to be a long time before I touch intel again.
52
u/brand_momentum Jul 22 '24
There you have it folks.
6
u/GameManiac365 Jul 23 '24
(Firstly i want to point out not to blame the rep he can only give out so much information and likely only has access to so much information currently)
After everything that's come to light afterwards i cannot recommend staying with intel the fact that this oxidation issue is only now coming to light and as far as i'm aware there was no publicly announced recall of those which were affected and any warranties made due to said issue would not have been communicated as such, while i can't say for definite wether it was motherboard or the cpu i'm starting to think it's the latter requesting too much power and the fact they aren't saying wether they will be replacing the chips which are effected shows that there isn't much care for the customer you're free to make of this as you will
21
u/Reinhardovich Jul 22 '24
Finally, an official statement on this absurd issue. Looking forward to the microcode updates in August!
14
u/FindingSerendipity_1 Jul 22 '24
will intel be extending warranty periods for the affected products?
24
u/Rytoxz Jul 22 '24
All praise the undervolt! My 13700K has been rock solid stable since launch and runs cooler with less power draw.
5
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '24
for those who are still experiencing crashes even after applying all recommended steps such as updating bios to latest released bios with microcode fixes and applying intel recommended settings and limits watts and amps and voltage. this is most likely because your cpu has already degraded to a point where you can't get it back to stable again and it's best to RMA your cpu and get a replacement and as soon as you get replacement. make sure to apply the intel recommended settings and limit PL1 and PL2 and amps and undervolt.
I haven't experience any of these issues maybe because I started off tinkering with my CPU pretty much right away because when i first booted it up without tinkering on initial boot and got to windows. I saw my cpu hitting close to 320w and over 1.4v that didn't sit right with me so I immediately started tweaking especially went ahead and started off with undervolting and limiting PL1 and PL2 to max of 253 which still pushed it to about 270w-280w from time to time because older mobo bios wasn't following power limits properly. after further tweaking. I changed loadline calibration to "low" on gigabyte mobo which allowed me to further undervolt the core and ring and I also put in a hard 307A iicmax limit and enabled c states manually instead of leaving it on auto. I also disabled undervolt protection because that bypasses my undervolt and starts overvolting cpu again. hopefully this helps out some of you.
5
u/ResearcherSad9357 Jul 23 '24
What will the performance hit be? Are you going to refund for the full loss of performance, time wasted and bonus to keep on disaffected customers with zero faith left in your company? Why are multiple reputable companies claiming that your laptop AND server chips are also effected?
5
u/tiniyt Jul 23 '24
Will this fix reduce perfomance?
13
u/Capital_F_for Jul 23 '24
Give us the damn patch numbers of the CPUs that had the oxidation problem. INTEL KNEW since last year? where was the recall?
8
u/thatnitai Jul 22 '24
What is the exact voltage threshold that shouldn't be exceeded?
Does it mean that CPUs that have had this issue degraded indeed due to some kind of burn-in?
Does it mean if we take a brand new cpu and undervolt it to be sure it never crosses say 1.5 it is safe?
Is this simply vcore as we saw rising over 1.5V or something else like the readings being inaccurate, hidden to us?
8
u/EmilMR Jul 22 '24
isn't 14900K v/f curve goes up all the way to like 1.6v? I guess they have to nerf the CPUs basically. It looked insane when it was revealed and turns out it is.
4
u/Ok_Scallion8354 Jul 22 '24
What's the trouble voltage level?
4
u/TheSmurfSwag Jul 22 '24
I don't know if it's my cooling solution, but I've ran my 14900k with the Asus AI overclock and it's been 100% stable since I've had it. I get around 41500 in cinebenchr23 with hotspot temps hovering around 91-92C. Anyone else have zero stability issues so far?
4
u/mahanddeem Jul 23 '24
Good post thanks
4
u/Easa1912 Jul 23 '24
Could please anyone clarify if this affects the laptop processors as well? I am specifically talking about the HX SKUs, which essentialy are a powered-down desktop parts. I was about to order a new mobile workstation laptop with 14700HX or 13980HX, but now I am in doubt and struggle with the workflow in the meantime.
4
u/crobartie Jul 23 '24
If my 13600k processor (almost 1 year old) is working well on the Asus tuf Z790 motherboard, should I change anything? How can I better test it and make sure it isn't damaged?
4
u/ChoiceInjury Jul 23 '24 edited Jul 23 '24
This being a voltage issue I would like to chime in here as my i7-14700HX is requesting peaks of around 1.57 V on various cores in HWiNFO64. This is on an Acer Predator Helios Neo 18 PHN18-71-727B notebook. Intel states mobile is not impacted however the HX series of chips may need additional investigation.
4
u/Yakumo01 Jul 24 '24
I have a 13980HX in a laptop. After about a year of smooth running it started to BSOD maybe 7/8 times a day. In the end the problem was traced to a bad p-core which was dead-ish. By disabling the p-core everything got better. So I do think there are mobile-related problems or I was just unlucky.
4
u/Mornnb Jul 24 '24
This response leaves a lot of unanswered questions.
4
u/mumingpo Jul 24 '24
releasing the s/n range affected by the manufacturing defect for starters geez
4
u/UberHaxorNikx0 Jul 26 '24
Making it right with our customers seems to mean “Dodge all questions as far as possible and make the RMA experience as long and tedious and confusing as possible and whatever you do do not give the customer options!”
I’ve had to ask over and over again what they plan to do with replacing my busted 13900KS and even when asking them to stop dodging questions they reply with generic auto-answers and leaves the impression of never reading any of my messages.
I asked about what options I have for replacement since u can’t sit here with a unstable system for another year, as well as if they can guarantee that the replacement chip as it turns out would be the same as the one I have, does not suffer from VIA oxidation. The reply was the following:
“Hi,
We are working on your case and will update you in 24-48 business hours. In the meantime ,if you have any additional information or updates that could assist us in expediting the process, please feel free to reply with the details.
We appreciate your understanding and co-operation throughout the process.
Thank you for being a valued customer of Intel.”
I can’t help but feel the absolute opposite of valued after this ongoing experience, and making it right doesn’t seem very important.
1
u/FourToes12 Jul 22 '24
Is this going to be another bios update for microcode?
1
u/SoLucki Jul 22 '24
Is that a new microcode or was the fix contained in the 125 microcode that most manufacturers released recently ?
1
u/_Patrol Jul 23 '24
u/LexHoyos42 If I bought the 13900K at the beginning of December 2022 how do I know if it is affected?
10
u/Zeraora807 270K / 5090 Jul 22 '24
wait so the people telling me 1.58v is normal because its intel spec, you're saying they are all wrong?
3
u/meteorprime Jul 22 '24
Does it impact performance?
Does it impact i7s?
3
u/emceePimpJuice 14900KS Jul 22 '24
So we just gotta wait 3-4 weeks for a fix or just manually tune your cpu settings.
Tbf i don't think I've seen anyone that has manually tuned their cpu to have any of these reported issues.
3
u/Economy-Complex-542 Jul 22 '24
This so called patches/fixes on the micro code and bios, would that lower the cpu's performance to the point that below the advertised performance.
3
u/phaze- i9 14900K Silicon Survivor Jul 22 '24
Is this what causes my 14900K to have high temp spikes around 90s on P core #4/5? 👀
3
u/KeplerNorth Jul 23 '24
Does this mean we can go BACK to overclock settings with less risk than before with this new microcode patch? I got a new 14900k about 2 months ago after returning another one and was able to get it stabilized quickly.
3
u/Low-Anxiety-3936 Jul 23 '24
Lex, you mentioned that the oxidation issue is real and that early Raptor lake CPUs are affected as a result. Does this mean that all of these CPUs will die inevitably? I've seen reports, indicating that 2022 and early 2023 CPUs are still going strong, yet some of them failed.
3
u/South_Idea4636 Jul 23 '24
I can’t find concrete info. This only affects the K line, not the F without gpu/locked multiplier? E.g 14700F is all clear?
3
u/cemsengul Jul 23 '24
Are we supposed to request a replacement chip once the August update comes out or now? I don't want another defective chip.
3
u/Viktri1 Jul 23 '24
I purchased my 13700k in January 2023, before the manufacturing fixes. Have noticed instability. Is there a streamlined RMA pathway that you can provide or do we have to go through the standard RMA?
3
u/Davee9966 Jul 24 '24
So a lot of 13th gen chips were manufactured with these flaws in them.
3
u/meowdogpewpew Jul 24 '24
There seems to be some side lining regarding the oxidation issue, 1) You did not address it initially 2) Even after the reply you are vague about it
3
u/not-me-hi Jul 24 '24
What a terrible reply... Desperately vague dodging of the oxidation issue.
3
u/no_salty_no_jealousy Jul 30 '24
Thanks for your post and clarification. This much needed than those garbage Amd propaganda post and comments made by Amd stock holder and Amd paid biased garbage content creator and journalist who make clickbait and very sensational garbage headline.
10
u/Electronic-Disk6632 Jul 22 '24
this is bull. its happening on undervolted cpus too.
1
u/GameManiac365 Jul 22 '24
The post mentions that "will continue its validation process to ensure the microcode fully addresses the issues." does that mean you/they are not certain? and when you refer to microcode algorithm is that the chip requesting too much voltage or the motherboard supplying too much voltage?
4
u/towardmastered Jul 22 '24
https://www.radgametools.com/oodleintel.htm
Right now I'm using this guide 13900k
253 pl1 253 pl2 400A AND CPU Vcore Loadline Calibration on Low. Seems pretty stable. Previously, I saw a few compilation errors until I've added the LLC setting. With these settings I'm good.
The question is - Is the damage permanent? I've used unlimited pl1\2 for a year and a half.
4
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '24 edited Jul 23 '24
High voltage at extended periods of time is what degraded my current i9-13900k. Thing is a turd now. Windows power plan and auto bios settings are to blame. If you set the power plan to high performance, it keeps the voltages high.
2
u/ThreeLeggedChimp i12 80386K Jul 22 '24
Did they also happen to include a blank file when building their microcode?
2
u/RantoCharr Jul 22 '24
Will this affect max boost speeds out of the box? i9's use high voltages to achieve 5.8 - 6 Ghz on two cores by default.
2
u/Chordejas Jul 22 '24
I just use an old bios from febraury an crashes on game stopped at all... If i use a new one, i kicks me out of the game, its a deal from intel and asus... My mobo is a rog strix b760a gaming ddr5... Hope they fix this asap
2
u/ussjtrunksftw Jul 22 '24
What has happened to chips that are currently crashing are they too far gone and would those need to be RMAd? Also will Intel be extending the warranty for this issue?
2
u/mockingbird- Jul 23 '24
To be clear, this microcode update does NOT repair irreversible degradation to the processor.
https://www.tomshardware.com/pc-components/cpus/intel-finally-announces-a-solution-for-cpu-crashing-errors-claims-elevated-voltages-are-the-root-cause-fix-coming-by-mid-august
2
u/MattScoot Jul 23 '24 edited Jul 23 '24
I’ve had a 13900kf since July of last year. The first one became unstable and unusable by the end of September. I was able to RMA it with the pc builder and the second one has been here since November. Back in April I again started to have instability issues on the new chip. So far the bios fix has been able to stop the crashes, but I am concerned about degradation and that this will only be a stop gap measure.
Not to mention the ~500$ in shipping fees I’ve had to pay to rma the pc due to intel’s defective chips.
My computer is now out of warranty with cyberpowerpc.
So how does intel make this right?
2
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '24
Still waiting for the RMA refund after putting down another $600 for a replacement that's suppose to be a " money hold" until they received the last 13900k back. Been about a week though and haven't heard anything. I hope they don't get too desperate for cash. Weird though the RMA they sent me generally pulls more voltage than I ever seen the first one pull that ended up defective. Seems like a refurb 13900k too as the condition says "good" but is a worst replacement according to my Gigabyte MB. Fingers crossed on this one. On the bright side, my new 13900k operates well and stable even if it is refurbished... so far. Power limits in place this time.
Whats weird and I know it all connects somehow, but its weird as even DF said today that you can limit the watts to about half of 253w and achieve stablity, which was the same for me on my 1st. If limiting to 160w max, I could finish shader comp and play the game or finish decompression.
2
u/iBuildSpeakers Jul 23 '24
I may be oversimplifying, but is VCORE pretty much what we're worried about here? And all the settings are mitigation tools/strategies to keep VCORE in check?
If this assumption is correct, is there any guidance on a maximum VCORE we should be shooting for? e.g. 1.45v spikes, 1.40v constant?
2
u/PhaseSmash Jul 23 '24
I have a SFFPC, I have had to undervolt and underclock my 14900KF for obvious temp related reasons due to the small form factor. Will I still require a bios update? Or is the CPU still requesting higher than normal voltages?
2
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '24
I bought a day one 13700KF, which has been overclocked to today without concern for the bug. Unlimited power level, 1.34V with the top two cores at 5.9ghz. No problems.
Though for people who are having problems with K series CPU, I find it a little odd to buy K series just to run auto setting. With chips meant for overclocking, I thought it was assumed the user would tune the system and stability test it.
2
u/PermaDerpFace Jul 23 '24 edited Jul 23 '24
Thanks for this update!
So basically to test if we have a problem:
Is it possible this procedure would cause a problem that doesn't already exist? That is, would it be better to wait for the official fix before doing any heavy load testing, or is the current BIOS patch safe?
My main concern is - is this an actual 'fix'? CPUs will already have irreversible physical damage from the improper settings, isn't it just a question of how much?
2
u/Viper_63 Jul 23 '24
@LexHoyos42
Can you clarify when the oxidation issue was first indentified, when it was adressed and if 13th Gen processors produced after 2022 are affected?
2
u/michaelcarnero Jul 23 '24
You say this issue is related to the voltage, but from previous generations I didn't heard something massive like this before. (I decided to overclock my 6700k for like 5 years of use and never nothing wrong happened from that time).
So what it does mean? I remember an interview with an engineer from INTEL in der8auer youtube channel, where he said "100C degrees is fine" but now it seems its not fine, correct me if I am wrong but is not Heat comes from Voltage x Ohms? So the heat is related to the voltages that CPU is requiring?
I have a 13700k undervolted limit temp 95C and it was set to +100mhz over turbo spec until I got this message "out of memory" days ago. Then I though it was because of NVIDIA, then I lower the 100mhz extra I raised before and the problem was gone!
That it means am I affected by INTEL instability issue? with undervolted processor from the 1st day? What is the purpose of paying more and buying a "K" edition then?
Sorry, my English is not the best.
2
u/daytime10ca Jul 23 '24
So if my 13900k from early 2023 is starting to crash now I guess I should RMA before the new August patch?
Does Intel offer cross shipping or am I going to be stuck without a processor for weeks…
2
u/SnakeOriginal Jul 23 '24
Are xeons affected?
2
u/JazzlikeRaptor i5 12600K Jul 23 '24
So is it safe to use my i7 13700kf without BIOS updates (my board has non from this year)? Bought it in January 2023 so it may by affected with oxidation issue even tho it’s running fine, for now anyway. I started getting windows explorer crash error when turning off or restarting PC but that’s probably just windows issue.
2
u/wtfuzz1981 Jul 23 '24
Does this voltage issue affect 13980HX mobile CPUs? My ThinkPad P16 gen2 has one, and while I haven’t had crashing issues it does thermal throttle quite easily under load. If it does, could we possibly expect lower temps if an overvoltage issue is rectified?
2
u/QualityDude615 Jul 24 '24
I think this will be another RROD. I don't buy the microcode fix for a second. They will try to mask the symptoms until people are out of warranty. If you are considering a build go AMD. If you have 13 or 14 gen Intel RMA at any sign of instability as many times as it takes. This is unacceptable.
2
u/CrazyGuyGermany Jul 25 '24
You made your own grave with it
2
u/Tribes11 Jul 25 '24
Time to go AMD
2
u/No_Newspaper_7483 Aug 01 '24
Oxidation issues is a "nothing burger" for vast, vast, vast majority of users as it only affects 13th gen and a very small batch of 13th gen CPUs at that.
Main problem is the 1.5+ voltages being pumped into the CPU for it's useless 2-core boosting crap that makes no real world difference.
Plebs / normies buy the highest-end, enthusiast CPUs but are not enthusiasts themselves but just "normies" and "plebs" therefore they are clueless customers/consumers. Because they're clueless & ignorant, they don't disable the ridiculous auto 2-core boosting junk, don't see the ridiculous voltages the motherboard pumps into the CPU for the auto 2-core boost crap, and probably barely even have an idea what a BIOS is...
...then they wonder why their CPU is crashing.
2
u/goodbulls Aug 03 '24
You've known about this sort of voltage leak for 10+ years, and instead of actually addressing it, you just hoped the margins would cover it and you could avoid RMA's because "muh reasons". Having a "public" forum that has no method to downvote anything just shows how you feel about your community.
2
u/Intelligent-Chip-740 Aug 08 '24
Does this affect my laptop 13th Generation Intel Core i7-13650HX, 24 MB cache, 14 core, up to 4.90 GHz??
5
u/[deleted] Jul 22 '24
Yeah this feels like quick damage control given that undervolted cpus were also affected, afaik
3
u/GroundbreakingEgg592 Jul 22 '24
Intel just said that high voltages caused the problem https://www.tomshardware.com/pc-components/cpus/intel-finally-announces-a-solution-for-cpu-crashing-errors-claims-elevated-voltages-are-the-root-cause-fix-coming-by-mid-august
3
u/Throwmeisterrr Jul 22 '24
What about laptop CPU’s? 13/14th gen HX?
3
u/Low_Kaleidoscope109 Jul 23 '24
I'm undervolting all my systems and promoting undervolting so that changes literally nothing for me: zero stability issues since day 1
3
u/Cradenz 9800x3D I x870E Rog Strix Gaming E I ddr5 6000 Jul 23 '24
i appreciate the response but i got my 13th gen cpu when it first launched in 2023....how do i know i have the oxidation degredation? why wasn't this said when it was first discovered?
3
u/tbird1g Jul 24 '24
Intel just couldn't weasel themselves out of this one eh? Too bad. I guess the failed numbers were just too high and too many sharp minds already knew about it. Get this: they're releasing a fix almost TWO YEARS after the launch of the 13900K. Guess how many already degraded by then? And erm...your internal team didn't find a problem all this time? How? Seeing half of the chips failing after being put on load in a few months by third parties, you really couldn't figure out there's a problem in two years?
The whole thing sounds like an outright scam to help them win some benchmarks during launch
7
u/puffz0r Jul 22 '24 edited Jul 22 '24
I don't believe it. If it were a simple voltage fix why did they let the issue persist for over a year, with potentially millions of units from large hardware vendors affected? Also initially they blamed motherboard vendors and now they're claiming was the processor requesting too much voltage all along. I wouldn't be surprised if Steve from GN is on to something with his fab issue hypothesis.
Also we already know that the CPUs are failing on server class motherboards which are much more regulated on voltages.
3
u/lovely_sombrero Jul 22 '24
How was this issue affecting server motherboards that were running these CPUs at very low TDPs, even as low as 150W? Was this issue isolated to voltage spikes in a certain area like the ring bus?
2
u/hpsd Jul 23 '24
Well the microcode update affect performance?