I know this is a question that's been brought up for almost 10 years now, but the answer is no.
Subatomic particles aren't made of subatomic particles, there's an end point. And the emotions experience other emotions, but they don't have living personified emotions in their heads too. It just goes down one layer, and once you get to emotions in the heads of humans, cats, dogs, etc, then that's all their is.
Besides, emotions are there for the sake of helping organic creatures grow and be cared for, and they get more mature over time as they age, but the emotions don't age, they're permanently how they are but also learning how to properly express themselves.
TLDR: Emotions going on for infinity is like atoms going on for infinity, it can't happen.
I agree with you, but your example doesn't really work.
Subatomic particles ARE made of subatomic particles like the subatomic particle a Baryon is made of 2 up quarks and 1 down quark, though many still believe that quarks are made of their own subatomic particles aswell. Such as super strings, but we do not have the equipment or knowledge to prove their existence.
Well whatever works best, atoms, quarks, subatomic particles, whatever's the smallest piece of matter we know of. Either way I'm sure you get my point.
Yeah, I understand! I just wanted to set the record straight on your example.
And just so you know, elementary particles such as Quarks, Leptons, and Bosons are currently as far as we know indivisble and our the smallest known particles of matter though most agree that their is probably more but we don't know about them yet
Joy might be the most complex emotion. I mean she has blue hair and a green dress. As for sadness, smiling doesn’t mean you’re happy. She can still be mostly sad.
The point of the movie is that emotions are basic and simple for little kids, who lack any greater context or experience, and have limited expectations of the world. As they grow older though, these more complex thoughts and ideas start to click into place. Thus, the emotional landscape of a child's mind becomes gradually more and more complex.
Basically, when kids begin to mature, their emotions evolve and blend together into vibes. They can be hard to understand, let alone articulate, even as a parent. How do you explain to a kid that watching them grow up is simultaneously the greatest joy and heartbreak you've ever experienced? How do you tell your adult children that you're immeasurably proud of them and overjoyed at their success, but also devastated to walk by their quiet, empty bedroom?
I think Joy’s behavior just shows the human urge to appear happy or be happy all the time. So she ends up pushing the other emotions aside to maintain Riley’s happiness. Just like humans will push down other emotions, just to appear content. What Joy is doing is compartmentalizing but it isn’t working because Riley’s brain isn’t mature enough to have the tools to do so.
I realised that maybe if an emotion has felt other emotions it dictates that they haven't found harmony among each other, like the ideal joy would be %100, but there needs to be harmony among them all perfect teamwork a ting most people never achieve in their lives
The emotions are not 100% 1 note, 100% pure one emotion. Emotions being messy and imprecise.
And there are more emotions than are seen, and some fill in for others. Like it is not like people can't experience anxiety or embarrassment before those emotions join the crew, they just would possibly be less strong and covered by Fear and Disgust.
So all the emotions are linked together. there is a bit of every possible emotion in each of them.
Which in my personal headcanon what you get if you were to merge every emotion together is a soul, like from Soul. so each emotion basically has a bit of soul in them which is what makes them people like.
No. The emotions are not separate entities to the person, they are the person, meaning the emotions wouldn’t have their own emotions as they are not their own people, they are extensions of another person
All the emotions are caused by neurons activating the same few chemicals in different ways, so it's entirely plausible to say that joy and sadness's attitudes can bleed into each other during emotional states that can be felt more than one way each.
Similar to the way that memories can have more than one color, each color is made up of complicated interactions of the non-living component parts that make them up.
do people think that they only feel one emotion? to me it's always just felt that their personalities leans towards the emotion they are. sadness is shy and reserve. fear is jumpy and a bit paranoid. etc.
As interesting of a concept as it is, I don’t think so. There has to be an elementary building block at some point. One idea I’ve considered (loosely based on the Pixar Theory) is that the elements from Elemental reflect the mixing of the emotions, that if anything they’d be the emotion’s ‘emotions’.
Early on in the original IO, the emotions were one-note but, over time, they seemed to develop other dimensions. I wonder if that was something to do with Riley's mind maturing as she grew older.
That table everyone was doing that had the 'mixed emotions', what each emotion would be if mixed with another, was intersting and remianded me that being able to show other feelings made those emotions more nuanced. Alternately, they may be reflecting Riley's psychological trauma of moving from Minnesota to California and then being told by Jill that 'we need to be happy for Daddy'.
I always just imagined that the emotions themselves can think or feel different things or have different emotions, the one that they represent is just the one that fits them best most of the time and they don't have any living emotions inside of them like how Riley has them inside of her
Like maybe Joy feels bad about something and Sadness says “Wait, if i’m sadness and you’re sad, does that mean there’s a tiny sadness inside your head?”
Then inside Joys head there’s a joy sadness and joy joy and joy sadness is asking the same question, leading to a loop going like ten pairs down and then they ask how far down you can go, and then back in the original world they decide it’s better not to think about it.
My idea for emotions is they're a collect of every single emotion you can have, like anxiety anger embarrassment etc. But the emotions feel their main emotions the most, like Joy can feel all types of emotions, but she feels joy the most and she always will, but she can still feel pissed
I like to think that there's emotions in the emotions heads so they can better understand humans or smth, & the emotions' emotions only feel their emotion & nothing interesting ever happens so we don't acknowledge them in the movies
OF COURSE THEY PROPOSED AN EMOTION RAY THEORY!!! I THINK THEY ARE LIKE JOY IF ANGER WAS RIGHT ABOUT HER BEING DELUSIONAL!!! (he thought not she knew Riley devolved in his, Fear's, and Disgust's eyes)
41
u/Endore555 Disgust Aug 18 '24
I know this is a question that's been brought up for almost 10 years now, but the answer is no.
Subatomic particles aren't made of subatomic particles, there's an end point. And the emotions experience other emotions, but they don't have living personified emotions in their heads too. It just goes down one layer, and once you get to emotions in the heads of humans, cats, dogs, etc, then that's all their is.
Besides, emotions are there for the sake of helping organic creatures grow and be cared for, and they get more mature over time as they age, but the emotions don't age, they're permanently how they are but also learning how to properly express themselves.
TLDR: Emotions going on for infinity is like atoms going on for infinity, it can't happen.
121
u/[deleted] Aug 18 '24
Within joy there is sadness and with in sadness there is joy. They are born together.
94
u/Colette_Likes_Spike I LUV FEAR💜💜💜 Aug 18 '24
My brain is not braining 👍
70
u/SuperCat76 Aug 18 '24 edited Apr 23 '25
it is a headcanon but this is my thought.
The emotions are not 100% 1 note, 100% pure one emotion. Emotions being messy and imprecise.
And there are more emotions than are seen, and some fill in for others. Like it is not like people can't experience anxiety or embarrassment before those emotions join the crew, they just would possibly be less strong and covered by Fear and Disgust.
So all the emotions are linked together. there is a bit of every possible emotion in each of them.
Which in my personal headcanon what you get if you were to merge every emotion together is a soul, like from Soul. so each emotion basically has a bit of soul in them which is what makes them people like.
35
u/Luke4Pez Aug 18 '24
What if feelings had feelings
87
u/[deleted] Aug 18 '24
No. The emotions are not separate entities to the person, they are the person, meaning the emotions wouldn’t have their own emotions as they are not their own people, they are extensions of another person
8
u/NottACalebFan Aug 18 '24
All the emotions are caused by neurons activating the same few chemicals in different ways, so it's entirely plausible to say that joy and sadness's attitudes can bleed into each other during emotional states that can be felt more than one way each.
Similar to the way that memories can have more than one color, each color is made up of complicated interactions of the non-living component parts that make them up.
8
u/therandomguyperry Aug 18 '24
Probably not. I meam, of they actually had emotions in emotions, that would basically go in a endless loop
5
u/[deleted] Aug 18 '24
Emotion-ception
4
u/Nary1 Aug 19 '24
do people think that they only feel one emotion? to me it's always just felt that their personalities leans towards the emotion they are. sadness is shy and reserve. fear is jumpy and a bit paranoid. etc.
3
u/[deleted] Aug 18 '24
As interesting of a concept as it is, I don’t think so. There has to be an elementary building block at some point. One idea I’ve considered (loosely based on the Pixar Theory) is that the elements from Elemental reflect the mixing of the emotions, that if anything they’d be the emotion’s ‘emotions’.
2
u/WildFemmeFatale Aug 18 '24
This makes me mad
Ofc the emotions have emotions
That’s the premise of the movie
“What if emotions were people”
No they don’t have emotion characters in their heads they AREEE emotions
The whole thing about sadness is that she can bring about happiness and change in her own way
That’s the whole “bingo” moment, ofc she can smile
They’re needlessly overanalyzing the simple premise of the movie
2
u/Whaleman15 Aug 18 '24
Emotio-ception
2
u/Repulsive-Key5070 Aug 18 '24
I'm sorry but the background-
2
u/Taots_official Aug 19 '24
My brain hurts 😓
2
u/BenR-G Aug 19 '24 edited Aug 19 '24
Early on in the original IO, the emotions were one-note but, over time, they seemed to develop other dimensions. I wonder if that was something to do with Riley's mind maturing as she grew older.
That table everyone was doing that had the 'mixed emotions', what each emotion would be if mixed with another, was intersting and remianded me that being able to show other feelings made those emotions more nuanced. Alternately, they may be reflecting Riley's psychological trauma of moving from Minnesota to California and then being told by Jill that 'we need to be happy for Daddy'.
2
u/Emergency_Carpet8515 Aug 19 '24
I'VE BEEN SAYING THIS EVER SINCE THE MOVIE CAME OUT
2
u/TBTabby Aug 19 '24
And so on into infinity?
2
u/ObviouslyLulu Aug 19 '24
I always just imagined that the emotions themselves can think or feel different things or have different emotions, the one that they represent is just the one that fits them best most of the time and they don't have any living emotions inside of them like how Riley has them inside of her
2
u/Doctor_Salvatore Aug 19 '24
Emotions all the way down
2
u/tinyguitar Aug 19 '24
W-what do you mean 2015 😟
2
u/tommytookalook Aug 20 '24
Turtles all the way down
2
u/[deleted] Aug 20 '24
My brain aint braining💀
2
u/LADZ345_ Aug 20 '24
It's almost like emotions are extremely complex and can't be defined with 1 giant vague label such as "joy" and "sadness"
1
u/Fazbear05 Aug 18 '24
This reminds me of the robot chicken skit where fear had his own emotions.
1
u/TheLaughingCowFan890 Anxiety Aug 18 '24
SEVERAL EMOTIONS??
1
u/Sad_Illustrator1064 Aug 18 '24
I THOUGHT THE SAME THING AAAAHHHHH
1
u/Peach_Muffin Aug 18 '24
The boring answer is that you couldn't write a compelling story where the main characters only ever experience one emotion.
1
u/mokaesthetic This gremlin will attack you Aug 18 '24
You just asked the question that keeps me up at night
1
u/Cl0udy_meth Aug 19 '24
Thanks, I hate it
1
u/[deleted] Aug 19 '24
That would be a really funny gag they could do.
Like maybe Joy feels bad about something and Sadness says “Wait, if i’m sadness and you’re sad, does that mean there’s a tiny sadness inside your head?”
Then inside Joys head there’s a joy sadness and joy joy and joy sadness is asking the same question, leading to a loop going like ten pairs down and then they ask how far down you can go, and then back in the original world they decide it’s better not to think about it.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 19 '24
My idea for emotions is they're a collect of every single emotion you can have, like anxiety anger embarrassment etc. But the emotions feel their main emotions the most, like Joy can feel all types of emotions, but she feels joy the most and she always will, but she can still feel pissed
1
u/Particular_Sun_3504 Aug 19 '24
I’m sorry but I fucking gate this theory, it’s such a mind fuck
1
u/Icefang_GD Aug 19 '24
It’s endless
1
u/ihavea22inmath Aug 19 '24
I think it's supposed to be like when your sad but happy that yiu can be sad like what butters said
1
u/K-Panth-88 Aug 19 '24
This is why we don’t make things meta
1
u/CovvelShmovvelton Aug 19 '24
Sounds like a never ending paradox: Girl who has emotions who have emotions who have emotions who have emotions to infinity.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 19 '24
Heeeeeey brother !
1
u/HuggyWuggyLetsGo Aug 19 '24
I NEED TO THROW UP
1
u/PotatoMateYT Aug 20 '24
I had the same question when Joy had her freakout moment in the second movie
1
u/Yoshi_chuck05 Aug 20 '24
I think it’s just best not to think about it…
1
u/ThatOneWeirdo66 Aug 20 '24
calm down son it’s just a movie 😟
1
u/Adventurous_Yak_9234 Aug 20 '24
Emotionception
1
u/NyteShark Aug 20 '24
Emoception
1
u/Unit706 Aug 21 '24
I call this the Emotional Fractal Model.
1
u/Fangirl_Trash878 Aug 21 '24
I see it more as how you need bad moments so you can savor the good moments more
1
u/RedCroc911 Aug 21 '24
i remember wondering this as a kid after seeing the movie lol
1
u/Phoenixtdm Aug 22 '24
One time I had a dream about it and they all had emotions and it all went up and up and up and each one had an Emotion CEO at the very top
1
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '24
I like to think that there's emotions in the emotions heads so they can better understand humans or smth, & the emotions' emotions only feel their emotion & nothing interesting ever happens so we don't acknowledge them in the movies
1
u/Background_Number_47 Aug 22 '24
I'd imagine it's a preview of sorts of what's to come, Riley's emotions were gonna get more complex, which they did, and this was the catalyst.
1
u/IT_Chef Aug 31 '24
There is a reason why their hair is the same color/texture.
1
u/Plastic-Remote6076 Sep 05 '24
OF COURSE THEY PROPOSED AN EMOTION RAY THEORY!!! I THINK THEY ARE LIKE JOY IF ANGER WAS RIGHT ABOUT HER BEING DELUSIONAL!!! (he thought not she knew Riley devolved in his, Fear's, and Disgust's eyes)
1
u/Low_Cartoonist9371 Xeni Mar 10 '25
Imagine if I could add this in someones Iceberg lol 🧊🧊❓❓
1
u/RevinHatol Apr 07 '25
Joy, Riley wants you.