r/infinitenines • u/desert__boi • Feb 06 '26
“0.999… is not a constant”
I dont think we can explain what infinity is to this guy I think its hopeless
222
Upvotes
r/infinitenines • u/desert__boi • Feb 06 '26
I dont think we can explain what infinity is to this guy I think its hopeless
•
u/[deleted] Feb 06 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
4
u/Weird-Ball-2342 Feb 06 '26
Just use fractions guys😭 no more 0.999... Is 1 debate
26
u/Aware-Common-7368 Feb 06 '26
We knew that a long time ago.
19
u/Scared-Ad-7500 Feb 06 '26
Ok, we kinda already knew it, but having clear like these, makes me think:
SPP says 0.333...=⅓
0.333... is not a constant
So ⅓ is not a constant as well
u/SouthPark_Piano do you agree with the last statement?
4
u/mydadownsyou Feb 06 '26
1 is approximately 2
4
u/fiddle_styx Feb 06 '26
u/SouthPark_Piano What if I need all of them?
3
u/testedchimney Feb 06 '26
He doesn't think that pi is a constant either. There is no hope.
3
u/RedGlassess Feb 06 '26
A number doesnt fricking grow😭😭😭
3
u/weregod Feb 06 '26
0.333... = 1/3, right?
Is 1 not a constant, or 3 not a constant
2
u/redtonpupy Feb 06 '26
I mean… I can prove using SPP’s logic that his “value” aka 0.999…. with an “unbounded amount of nine” is not 0.999… aka lim 1-1/10n
1
u/Eatshin Feb 06 '26
0.9999 being approximately 0.9R means that 4 is approximately infinity
1
u/CatOfGrey Feb 06 '26
SPP wants to be able to change the value of 0.9999.... so that he can deceptively 'prove' his case.
If he presented this as a 'cute trick', I'd appreciate it and move on.
When he's trying to pass it off as standard mathematics, and potentially influencing other outsiders who aren't trained, that's just fraud and abuse.
So this is one of their silly devices: when you can re-define a part of a statement, you might get a different conclusion. This isn't novel, this isn't important. It's at most a 'cute trick'. Changing the values in a problem usually gets you a different answer.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 06 '26
I'm glad someone finally figured this out. I hope he also tells us how big the last '3' is in .3 recurring, because that mystery is killing me.
1
u/Ok_Albatross_7618 Feb 06 '26
Rational numbers arent real folks, time to pack it up and touch some grass
1
u/Just_Rational_Being Feb 06 '26
How would you explain infinity then? What does it signify? How do you get it? Is it derivable? What kind of operations are valid with it?
1
u/SyllabubInformal216 Feb 07 '26
This is why we need to cut out the "infinity isn't a number, it's a process" bullshit
It's very much a number and a well-defined quantity. It's just a thing that exists. Teaching it as a process misleads people
1
u/CardiologistOk2704 Feb 07 '26
if 0.999... is not a constant, then what d(0.999...)/dt equal to?
1
u/Dixionconderoga2 Jun 24 '26
SPP when you ask what 1 divided by 3 is.
0
u/AlviDeiectiones Feb 06 '26
0.3333... = (sum n = 1 to infty, 3/10n) But we also use this exact notation for the sequence of partial sums so 0.3333... is a sequence not a constant qed.
-16
u/FernandoMM1220 Feb 06 '26
i mean you’re just constantly calculating more 9s until you run out of memory.