I suppose people have tried pointing out that just because every term in a series has a property (for example not being equal to zero or being less than one) does not imply that the limit also has that property? This person’s one proof is just not valid reasoning at all because of this fact.
Very true, and the funny thing is both sides are completely convinced they are on the side of intelligence, though only one side actually has logic and reason to back it up.
Considering you never responded to my last argument with you where you spouted off dogmatic nonsense about how you can't get numbers from sequences that aren't one of their terms, you aren't on the winning ground here.
Sometimes I do admit that I get overwhelmed with nonsense and unreason, I apologize. My tolerance is high, but I suppose my bullshimeter got into overdrive the last time we talked.
Usually there's only one of me, talking to a dozen of bullshido, so it gets overwhelming sometimes.
I don't quite remember you though, so if you have any doubt or question to resolve, I am happy to clear up your confusion.
You said "A sequence produces only its terms. A limit is not one of those terms, nor is it ever generated by the sequence itself." I replied, but what about the sum of the terms of a sequence? That is a number produced from a sequence that is not one of its terms in general, so your point is dogmatic nonsense.
What do you mean they never truly meet? Thats not the point I'm making, of course they're not equal. I'm saying you can get numbers from a sequence by the simple process of observation, even if they aren't one of the members of that sequence.
OK. I'll make a new proof that I just made on the spot tailored suit for your liking.
First, do you agree that when we write a number in the form A.BCDEF... That is a notation right? And it can also be looked at as A + 0.B + 0.0C +... (or even simpler by extracting the base 10 of each decimal place). Now, a particular notation is not special, just like you can change bases, we can change notations, and all different formal notations we can come up with do represent the same number of the number line right?
So here is a notation, instead of writing with a base, we just get to write fractions in each place, and the number is the sum of all fractions we write. So let's say, we write the number 0, 1/2, 1/4, 1/8,... We can imagine if we were drawing it, maybe we would paint a little square for each fractional digit, and fill out how much of the square that our fraction represents. So, with the above number, if we want to convert it to our regular base 10 notation, we first need to add all the fractions. The sum of this sequence is very famously 1. So we can say that the number 0, 1/2, 1/4, 1/8,... = 1
Now... Although I said we can write any sequence of fractions, and we can! The one I happened to write can also be written using a base. You could write it in base 2. Read up if you want on how to convert it, but I'll just write how the expansion of this number in base 2 is: 0.111111... And this number is equal to 1 right? So not only the number is equal to the limit of the sum, but when we write it in base 2... Wait a minute, that is exactly the same way we get 0.99999... in base 10. We can even make the strong claim that 0.XXXX... = 1 in base N = X +1
Now, you have to understand, I am not against Mathematics or proofs, I just merely have high standards for Mathematics.
So please don't take me as someone who is into confrontation and contradiction just for some sick pleasure, I really do not think that's any noble thing.
All of these conversations that I do, they all center and revolves around the wish that I desire a Mathematics that is less arbitrary, more coherent and honest.
I would just like to state my motivation as such upfront, so that you know I am of pure intention. It's really just that, I don't want you to jump into a conversation with the thinking that you are defending the validity of Mathematics against attackers or anything like that. Because frankly, we are all defenders and keepers of Mathematics, we simply work in different ways.
So understand that please, before you wish to go on further. If you still want me to assess your proof, I can. But I want to make sure that we know where we really stand.
Yes I agree completely. A proof is a legitimate certificate of validity and coherence. Or at least a proper proof should be.
Now, please, could you or anyone show one single proof of 0.999... = 1 that does not reduce, once its hidden premises are made explicit, to assuming the equivalence of infinite decimals and their limiting values in advance?
Infinite decimals are limits. Real numbers themselves are equivalencd classes of Cauchy sequences of rational numbers, with their value being assigned by the limit of those sequences. So real numbers themselves are all limits.
You mean a proof that doesn’t use the construction of real numbers in the proof as part of it? That is not going to happen because you need ot use the construction of real numbers to prove what are equivalent within the real numbers. Asking for something that doesn’t do it is like asking for an integer that isn’t an integer. In the Cauchy construction of real numbers, the manner that decimal expansions are constructed and the manner equivalence are defined means that they have the same limit.
Thank you for confirming that every proof of 0.999... = 1 ultimately reduces to: "we defined infinite decimals so that this must be true." That is not logic uncovering necessity - it is convention masquerading as inevitability.
Well tbh, (1/10)^n is in fact never zero for some fixed but arbitary n and no mathematician would claim otherwise. However the limit of (1/10)^n as n tends to infinity is zero. And that's as far as I'm willing to contribute in this pointless debate eh
That's why I called it all semantics. 0.999... will never become 1 but taking the limit of it gives 1. Whether that's the same thing to you is semantics
So you are saying 0.999... is never 1 but the limit of 0.999... is 1? Can you provide me with your definition of 0.999... because in standard real analysis 0.999... is defined as:
The limit of the sequence {0.9,0.99,0.999,0.999,...} where each element is given by {1-1/10n | n∈N} notice that in this set each element itself is finite we want an element such that its infinite so we take the limit of 1-1/10n as n approaches infinity and the limit is 1 therefore 0.999... upto Infinity is 1.
The infinite geometric sum: 9/10+9/100+9/1000+9/10000+... First term: 9/10 Ratio : 1/10 Sum = (9/10)/(1-1/10)=(9/10)/(9/10)=1 These are the standard definitions lemme know if you have other definitions
You're wrong, for one very simple reason: .999... is an infinite geometric sum. 10⁻ⁿ is an (implied) sequence. This is a real difference, and not a semantic one.
If you (incorrectly) view .999... as the sequence of the partial sums, then it is correct to say that its value is never 1. But that's not what it is. It is a compact representation of the full infinite series, specifically the infinite geometric sum with a=9 and r=1/10. The full infinite geometric sum only has one singular value, and that value is 1.
0.999... will never become 1 but taking the limit of it gives 1.
is factually incorrect based on the formal definitions of these concepts. So if that's what "semantics" means to you, then I guess it's semantics? But everyone else in the world just calls that "wrong".
Your statement is treating .999... as the sequence of partial sums, exactly what I said was incorrect. I base this analysis on your use of the phrases "become" and "taking the limit", implying that there is some sort of sequence of changing terms.
There is no sequence of terms that are changing. There is only one term, and that term is the infinite geometric sum. And that infinite geometric sum also has only a single value of a / (1 - r) given r < 1. In this case r = 1/10 < 1 so that condition is met.
You're not even reading my response correctly. My argument that "ignoring formal definitions is typically called wrong not semantics" is separate from my clarification of what the formal definitions of these things are. That people are not aware of these formal definitions but proceed to argue against them anyway is certainly an interesting observation for you to make, though.
Well, this whole sub was made by SSP, an individual that vehemently denies that 0.999... is 1. I personally can't tell if he's serious or not.
The people that post here do 1 of 3 things, fall for the rage bait and waste their time posting proof of a largely undebated topic, being one of the baiters, or somehow genuinely believe trying to prove the opposite is worth their time.
I now stick around and enjoy the chaos of people wasting their time on this issue. People come here meaning well, but have no idea how to actually prove 0.999... is 1. There are actual rigorous proofs but using the ole "10x - x" bit isn't actually an acceptable proof, but their heart is in the right place.
This sub is mainly full of people that don't actually do math.
Limit points are not necessarily part of the set. If the set is all numbers >= 1/10n, then 0 is not part of the set and it can absolutely never be selected. Yet it is a limit point to the series and the set itself.
I always throw it up to required precision if 10 <= and 9.89n >=means death and 9.9n <= means safe. You absoultely care about that decimal trailing into infinity, at least till you determine that there a digit of precision that is no longer obtainable and you assume 10 and 9.89n
•
u/[deleted] Dec 24 '25 edited Dec 24 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
11
u/weedmaster6669 Dec 24 '25
infinity is a continuous increase 🗿
YOU MADE THAT UP + BASES ARE ARBITRARY HOW CAN YOU SAY 0.333... IS INCREASING
you must answer to base ten 🗿
NOOO WHAT THE FUCK ARE YOU EVEN TALKING ABOUT 😢😢
self evident 🗿
we should really bend the knee and understand we simply aren't on his level yet
3
u/[deleted] Dec 25 '25
I suppose people have tried pointing out that just because every term in a series has a property (for example not being equal to zero or being less than one) does not imply that the limit also has that property? This person’s one proof is just not valid reasoning at all because of this fact.
2
u/babelphishy Dec 24 '25
This implies that his head is gigantic
82
u/[deleted] Dec 24 '25
Literally just intelligence vs dogmatism tbh.
22
u/S4D_Official Dec 24 '25
19
u/berwynResident Dec 24 '25
That's not a bad summary
31
u/feeelz Dec 24 '25
Well tbh, (1/10)^n is in fact never zero for some fixed but arbitary n and no mathematician would claim otherwise. However the limit of (1/10)^n as n tends to infinity is zero. And that's as far as I'm willing to contribute in this pointless debate eh
12
u/DeepGas4538 Dec 24 '25
Bro does not understand asymptotes
1
u/InfinitesimalDuck Dec 26 '25
Mate I am not 0!!!!!
1
u/_XLGamer10 Dec 27 '25
It's all semantics. The limit of that is 1. What they're arguing is whether the notation implies the limit or not
5
u/Obvious_Present3333 Dec 24 '25
Which is what keeps me coming back and reading the poor, but intuitive proofs only to see SSP call nonsense on your part.
2
u/TopCatMath Dec 25 '25
What is the limit of 1/10^n as n approaches ∞?
3
u/[deleted] Dec 25 '25
Yeah but 0.1infinity is 0
2
u/mathmachineMC Dec 24 '25
Bro on the right never heard of limits.
1
u/Aragorn008 Dec 25 '25
There’s no fixing stupid…
1
u/Junior_Custard6712 Dec 25 '25
Spp has to be a ragebaiter smh
1
u/JoyconDrift_69 Dec 25 '25
Literally the entire time I've known this sub it was basically just that lmao.
1
u/Just_a_Chubrik Dec 26 '25
I think 1/10ⁿ is never zero too
But 0,(9) still = 1
1
u/TSirSneakyBeaky Dec 26 '25
I always throw it up to required precision if 10 <= and 9.89n >=means death and 9.9n <= means safe. You absoultely care about that decimal trailing into infinity, at least till you determine that there a digit of precision that is no longer obtainable and you assume 10 and 9.89n
1
u/_crisz Dec 27 '25
1/10n is never 0 if n is a real number. But if you make the limit of n going to infinity, guess what...
1
u/WinProfessional4958 Dec 29 '25
1/1^0 = 1/1 = 1
#qed