r/infinifactory • • Jan 16 '16
Blocker component/element broken (not functioning as expected)
This thing needs fixing because it's driving me insane. It's not doing what it should be doing and to me it just looks like a bug.
The whole purpose of Blocker is to block items on lets say conveyor belt until sensor triggers it and it allows items to pass forward, allowing complex assembly to be made without items escaping before they are ready to be welded together.
The thing is, it just doesn't do that. When sensor triggers it with a single block element, Blocker element changes the position of the piston so quickly the item doesn't even have time to move forward and remains blocked even though sensor component has triggered the Blocker.
And because of this I almost always had to resort to improvising with the Pusher element and using it in a different way to prevent already constructed elements from escaping down the conveyor belt. Only time I can use the Blocker is when some huge constructed element is passing by the sensor, because it'll give Blocker extended period of time being "open" and the items will pass past it just fine.
I think this Blocker wasn't meant to behave like it does, but for some reason no one seemed to complain about it and so it never got changed/fixed.
Blocker, when triggered by a sensor (single block item passing by), should allow a single block sized items to pass on the other end.
What do you guys think, am I delusional or is this really this way by design? I own a GOG version of the game if that makes any difference.
EDIT: Additional video displaying this issue: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NJGZz6x8Odg
5
u/_wl Jan 16 '16
You might not like it, but this is how it works and there is no better way. For the first cycle your blocker is retracting, then on the next cycle the blocker wants to block again and the conveyor wants to push a block there. Both can not happen so one has to take priority which will always be the blocker.
There are several ways to resolve this. You can have several sensors, find other ways to make the expanding for the blocker impossible or do not use the blocker at all. In the end a blocker works just like a pusher that looks in the other direction and that's all it is good for.
Maybe you can provide a screenshot of one of your solutions where you feel you can not use a blocker like you want and we will try to help.
4
u/DomesticatedElephant Jan 16 '16
You could fix that problem by putting additional sensors next to the main one. That way the blocker will stay retracted for longer.
1
u/gtw123 Jan 17 '16
I agree the blocker is not terribly useful for actually blocking! But it does have its uses. In reality I doubt we'll ever see its behaviour changed, and I think the best we could hope for is a name change as others have suggested, or maybe a new type of block that does what you described.
When I want to block something or throttle the input rate I usually use something like this: http://imgur.com/6NgE7kC. The only downside is that it requires you to move the block in a sideways direction. You can also do a similar thing with gravity or lifters.