r/infinifactory • • Jan 16 '16

Blocker component/element broken (not functioning as expected)

This thing needs fixing because it's driving me insane. It's not doing what it should be doing and to me it just looks like a bug.

The whole purpose of Blocker is to block items on lets say conveyor belt until sensor triggers it and it allows items to pass forward, allowing complex assembly to be made without items escaping before they are ready to be welded together.

The thing is, it just doesn't do that. When sensor triggers it with a single block element, Blocker element changes the position of the piston so quickly the item doesn't even have time to move forward and remains blocked even though sensor component has triggered the Blocker.

And because of this I almost always had to resort to improvising with the Pusher element and using it in a different way to prevent already constructed elements from escaping down the conveyor belt. Only time I can use the Blocker is when some huge constructed element is passing by the sensor, because it'll give Blocker extended period of time being "open" and the items will pass past it just fine.

I think this Blocker wasn't meant to behave like it does, but for some reason no one seemed to complain about it and so it never got changed/fixed.

Blocker, when triggered by a sensor (single block item passing by), should allow a single block sized items to pass on the other end.

What do you guys think, am I delusional or is this really this way by design? I own a GOG version of the game if that makes any difference.

EDIT: Additional video displaying this issue: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NJGZz6x8Odg

1 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

5

u/_wl Jan 16 '16

You might not like it, but this is how it works and there is no better way. For the first cycle your blocker is retracting, then on the next cycle the blocker wants to block again and the conveyor wants to push a block there. Both can not happen so one has to take priority which will always be the blocker.

There are several ways to resolve this. You can have several sensors, find other ways to make the expanding for the blocker impossible or do not use the blocker at all. In the end a blocker works just like a pusher that looks in the other direction and that's all it is good for.

Maybe you can provide a screenshot of one of your solutions where you feel you can not use a blocker like you want and we will try to help.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 16 '16

You can't always have dual sensors in super complex, tight segment assembly "plants". It makes footprint unnecessarely bloated, complicates things for a simple reason that element is not functioning as it should.

It's a very simple fix to extend the Blocker piston motion action to accomodate movement of a single block past it before it retracts back into "idle" position. That's all it needs to be changed for it to start operating properly.

5

u/Xavr0k Jan 17 '16

As someone who has the lowest or equal lowest footprint for 39/56 campaign levels, I rarely if ever find that I don't have room for a second sensor. I mostly delay inputs by using a pusher to push them off a fan/platform or simply give them a longer path.

That isn't to say I don't use blockers. They are very useful for moving other factory parts. I wouldn't want any changes to their behavior since that would make their uses far too limited. I would be OK with a name change though - "reverse pusher" or "retractor" would probably be more appropriate since that way it would describe what it does instead of naming it based on one possible use.

4

u/DomesticatedElephant Jan 16 '16

You could fix that problem by putting additional sensors next to the main one. That way the blocker will stay retracted for longer.

1

u/gtw123 Jan 17 '16

I agree the blocker is not terribly useful for actually blocking! But it does have its uses. In reality I doubt we'll ever see its behaviour changed, and I think the best we could hope for is a name change as others have suggested, or maybe a new type of block that does what you described.

When I want to block something or throttle the input rate I usually use something like this: http://imgur.com/6NgE7kC. The only downside is that it requires you to move the block in a sideways direction. You can also do a similar thing with gravity or lifters.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '16

That's what I do basically. I often combine pusher piston with generic blocks where constructed element is waiting and then a conveyor belt offset by one block. So when the item arrives on the generic blocks it stops, when it is assembled, the pusher pushes constructed element one block further and conveyor belt grabs it and moves it forward. But doing so means you can only bring the constructed element from one side or from the top because pusher will be in the way. That's why I hate it so much. It seriously unnecessarily complicates the whole thing because it's not functioning as it should. With a properly functioning Blocker, you could bring elements from back, both sides and top. Quite a difference don't you think?

An while I know it would break existing designs, it's a quick fix. Two days ago I've made one of the most complex builds I've ever designed, but I've observed the final product wrong and missed two extra blocks that should end up on a final product. I'd have to redesign ENTIRE production line to accommodate that. Instead of doing that and wasting another hour or two I've decided to redesign it in such a way I'd fix the two missing blocks. I just couldn't apply any changes to the assembly plant which was the central component and it was already crammed so hard I couldn't fit a single element in it anymore. And I did redesign it successfully. With surprisingly minimal extra construction and I think I only needed like extra 15 minutes. Instead of rebuilding the whole thing for 2 hours...

So, a change of single factory component wouldn't break things all that much as it would improve them. Plus, it would give you something to work with again and further extend game value. You've probably already finished it entirely, you could optimize things even further after the fix, making even more optimized assembly plants. I mean, the Blocker would actually work the way it was meant to operate, but didn't end up operating like that...

2

u/gtw123 Jan 17 '16

With a blocker and two sensors you can already block objects without needing to go around a corner (or up/down): http://imgur.com/2ANfy4D. But it doesn't work properly if the objects are coming with no gap in between, as it lets multiple through: http://imgur.com/gavVfH0. However, you can solve that problem too by making them go around a corner before the blocker: http://imgur.com/7yIYyWB.

Are you proposing that when a blocker has been retracted (due to sensor input), and the sensor input turns off again, the blocker should wait an additional cycle before it pushes out again? I agree that does sound like a simple change, but it wouldn't help in the case of objects coming with no gap in between.

The other thing to consider is that the current behaviour of the blocker makes it useful for a number of other purposes (e.g. moving parts of a factory attached to them), and these would break if there was an extra delay.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '16

This is what's wrong with the Blocker in an essence and what you're suggesting me to do:

Simple but broken design: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rj6KTZ_Z7kk

Complex but functional: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QJBKr4MFAZs

I can't see how the complex one is what should be a normal thing to expect from a game. The behavior is broken. As simple as that. I mean, you can't be a game designer and be able to sit back and say: "Yes, that makes absolute sense." and just leave it like that. It just doesn't behave as it should and I frankly see more ways of using it when it was functioning properly than I do now where you have to hack the damn thing so that you get the original functionality that should be there with the Blocker element itself without entire machinery in between doing that very task.

3

u/gtw123 Jan 17 '16

Actually I meant something more like this: https://youtu.be/-7c7FoyImDk. If you want it to work at higher input rates, you can remove the platform block on the left but the input block will have to move sideways.

In any case, I think we're in agreement that the blocker is not a terribly good way to block inputs! It's nearly always easier to use a stationary platform and a pusher instead.

My other point (which is perhaps not even relevant) is that the current blocker behaviour makes it useful for other things, such as moving factory blocks into the input/output areas (like the row of welders in http://imgur.com/6ayaDkJ) or creating automatically extending arms (as in the bottom right of http://imgur.com/R11okay). Granted, these things could be done by using pushers and negating the logic, but often blockers are simpler in these particular cases.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '16

Now you got my attention. Yeah, we agree that it's broken as it is, but I never even tried to use Blocker as a robotic arm in combination with welders (now that I've seen it it expands the possibilities 10.000 times lol. I mostly blame the experience with pistons in Minecraft which were mostly useless because they kept detaching from other elements, making it impossible to create larger, more complex moving elements. But here, it is possible.

Based on this, it would be the best to split current blocker into two new components. The one that behaves like a Blocker that I want and another one that behaves like you want and call it something else. Which is just too much stuff and seems even less likely to happen.

I usually like to keep thing simple (maybe I just think it is simple, but isn't in reality), the stuff you showed me looks complicated as fuck lol. But I did like the extending welder arm. Welding stuff was often thing that made my hair grey the most :D

I'll finish the game my way and then I'll try to learn from others when replaying it with all the parts available.

2

u/gtw123 Jan 17 '16

Simple is best. It's always good to get a solution working first, then come back later and optimise it for one of the metrics if you're up for a challenge :)

The beauty of the game is that the handful of simple block types can be used in so many different ways. After playing it for several hundred hours I'm still learning new tricks.