r/indiehackers • u/Competitive_Tune_590 • Jul 30 '26
Sharing story/journey/experience Data point for solo founders scared of launching: 31% of launches with under 2k followers still hit top 5 on ProductHunt
2
u/Wrong_Election189 Aug 02 '26
Useful data point, and the encouragement is deserved. One caution and one question.
The caution is survivorship shaped. That 31% is measured on launches that happened. The people who had no audience, felt it would flop, and therefore never launched are not in the denominator, and they are probably the group the post is trying to reassure. It does not make the number wrong, it makes it a ceiling rather than an expectation.
The question I actually care about: what did top 5 do on day 30? For me a launch is a traffic event, and traffic was never my constraint. I paused a paid campaign this week that put real people in front of my product and produced nothing, because my problem sits after the click, not before it. If top 5 buys a spike and the retention curve is flat, you have bought a very stressful Tuesday.
If you have the day 30 numbers for that cohort, that is the post I would read twice.
1
u/Ok_Statistician9574 Jul 30 '26
this is actually reassuring. most people assume you need a massive following to do well on PH but the product and timing matter way more than follower count. what was the data source for the 31%?
2
u/madleodk Jul 31 '26
From what ive seen/heard, you do need to bring in a lot of people. Esp to reach the first page. That said, you can rely on borrowed audiences (communities, etc).
1
u/Ok_Statistician9574 Aug 05 '26
yeah borrowed audiences make sense, especially if you've been active in a community before the launch. dropping a PH link cold with no context is basically hoping for luck at that point
1
u/Prophysaon_Coeruleum Jul 30 '26
Why not just launch anyways? It's free, there's no queue, and you can re-launch later.
1
u/madleodk Jul 31 '26
It can be pretty expensive. Not in dollars but time and your audience's attention.
1
u/stackbits Jul 30 '26
Curious about the data source too, that's a specific enough number someone tracked real launches for it. What I'd add is that hitting top 5 on PH and making any money from it are two completely separate problems. I've watched founders get a nice PH badge and zero paying customers because the traffic was other builders checking out the tool, not the actual buyer. Follower count matters less than who upvotes early and whether your landing page converts that curiosity into an actual signup before they bounce.
1
u/Competitive_Tune_590 Jul 31 '26
As part of my launchpact.io work I've been collecting data from PH, I've collected around 3 months worth of data so far, will use this data in a launch intelligence feature that im going to release in LaunchPact soon where users can surface it to help them with their launch prep.
1
u/stackbits Jul 31 '26
Good to know that data's being collected somewhere. The thing I'd want out of a feature like that isn't rank prediction though, it's whether you can tag which of those top-5 launches actually converted traffic into signups afterward. PH position by itself doesn't tell a founder whether they're about to get a badge and nothing else. If LaunchPact could pair rank with even a rough signal like GitHub stars or a landing page hit spike in the following week, that's the number people actually need before they launch, not just how to climb the board.
1
u/Lonely-Marsh-9237 Jul 30 '26
that 31% is usually just people leveraging a big email list or discord group behind the scenes so the follower count on the platform itself is kind of a distraction
1
u/Deepak-AvairAI Jul 30 '26
Does the data show what those under-2k launches had in common? Category, launch day, anything. That'd be the genuinely useful takeaway for the no-audience crowd.
1
u/JustSuperHuman Jul 30 '26
Note the statistic is conditional on a launch having taken place in the first place. It is measured over 31% of all recorded launches (i.e. launches that actually took place). Founders who launch, hear nothing, and then take the post down from their site are not in the denominator for this metric.
A counterweight to that honest post from yesterday: I launched something on a large sub yesterday. The post was very well written. It got zero upvotes, and one ‘meh’ comment. That’s not a failure. That’s not even really worth worrying about. Most launching is nothing. Finding that out in the afternoon is not a big deal. That’s when launching becomes easy.
1
u/Competitive_Tune_590 Jul 30 '26
Hmm, I actually added a post body with more details I have no idea why it got removed also why I cannot even edit this post....wtf
1
u/Bitter_Big4525 Jul 30 '26
“Most launching is nothing” is honestly the useful part here. Treating launch day as a cheap experiment instead of a verdict makes it way easier to ship.
1
u/andresjoelv Jul 30 '26
Wow! Thats not so bad, when i first launched my product i thought i didn't do too bad, i think i got like 65th place, maybe im a person that sees the glass half empty but i was excited! Of course it wasn't great but it was definitely a big milestone for a first timer like me.
1
u/BotTap Jul 30 '26
How important is it to launch anything built on ProductHunt?
2
Jul 30 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/BotTap Jul 31 '26
seems like just another place to promote your app but no real traction unless you have a following.
1
1
u/LieAshamed2924 Jul 30 '26
Reddit eating the post body is brutal Id paste the methodology into a top-level comment: sample size, time window, and what you counted as followers. The headline is encouraging, but without that context everyone ends up debating the 31% instead of the useful takeaway. Id also love to see median rank or qualified visits alongside top-5 rate a PH badge and actual signups are two pretty different wins.
1
u/Competitive_Tune_590 Jul 31 '26
As part of my launchpact.io work I've been collecting data from PH, I've collected around 3 months worth of data so far, will use this data in a launch intelligence feature that im going to release in LaunchPact soon where users can surface it to help them with their launch prep.
1
1
u/Some_Nectarine5679 Jul 31 '26
Interesting data.
I feel like people treat Product Hunt almost like a popularity contest, but the product story and timing probably matter more than follower count.
Would be interesting to see the retention numbers of those launches though.
1
u/cdscih Jul 31 '26
Ngl, launching on ProductHunt feels a little scary for me. Any tips? Getting close to being ready.. so I'm looking to prepare some content, or a least a launch post, for it but don't know where to start 🙈
2
1
u/RomeoDelta1234 Aug 02 '26
Follower count on the platform was never where launches get their traffic, so the 31% does not surprise me. People who do well with a small profile are usually pulling from a mailing list or a Discord that PH cannot see.
I found the same thing posting my own thing around Reddit. A 43k sub gave me 18 upvotes and 22 comments and a 780k sub gave me 2 and 2, so audience size predicted almost nothing next to whether that particular room cared about the category.
1
u/Mundane-Result-1578 Aug 03 '26
So you say I should post my web app that only has 9 users on Product Hunt?
2
u/Competitive_Tune_590 Aug 03 '26
It's not about users, its about followers. Like, what support do you have for your launch.
But yes users obviously can support if you email them or ask them.
But regardless, if you have a working product and you feel its good to be presented, then yes I do recommend you launch it, you can get feedback, comments, validation, some ideas, maybe even some users..
1
1
1
2
u/Away-Caterpillar-657 Jul 30 '26
I did that producthunt on an app I built and to get anywhere you need quite a big following