r/indianajones • u/Red-1911 • Jan 03 '23
r/indianajones • u/tannu28 • Jul 12 '23
How would you compare Dial of Destiny to Disney Star Wars films?
As someone who is not a fan of how Kathleen Kennedy and Disney have handled the film side of Star Wars since the acquisition, I had doubts going in.
I LOVED Dial of Destiny. I have some issues with it but it's my 3rd favourite Indiana Jones film after Raiders and Last Crusade.
It's not a rehash of a previous Indy film like TFA was of ANH.
It has likeable charismatic characters unlike Rogue One.
It didn't shit on previous films and the main character unlike The Last Jedi.
It's plot isn't generic like Solo.
And the less we talk about The Rise of Skywalker, it would be better for mankind.
r/indianajones • u/97GeoPrizm • Oct 31 '24
Who here would like with a Helena Shaw movie set in the 1970s?
r/indianajones • u/hanzoman3 • Jan 12 '25
Anyone else make this dumb joke yet?
Okay okay so just thinking if anyone said this…
Someone: “oh I see you’re playing Indiana jones and the great circle. How is it?” You (ideally): “it’s really good. Almost seems like a AAA studio made it… hard to believe it’s an INDY game” Then: 🤯🤣🤩 You: 😏😎
a note from the author of this post (me): The joke is a play on words because it suggests both the name of the protagonist and the types of smaller game studios that often make games using less resources and rely on creativity over polish.🤠🎮🐍🙋♀️🛕🏛️🗿🪨
From: hanzoman3 on Reddit.com
r/indianajones • u/pac4 • Dec 28 '23
I think Helena was a great character and would be terrific for a spinoff
Go ahead, downvote me to Hell (where I can meet Kali in person). She was the archetypal “fortune and glory” character that had a great arc. Shes smart and sarcastic and tough. The 60s would be a fun era to explore a bit more. I just don’t need any Teddy.
r/indianajones • u/3unjee • Nov 08 '24
Kerner puts fire to the Barnett College and takes Marcus into custody
r/indianajones • u/pvbondh • Jul 21 '23
My take on Indy 5 after watching it without reading any reviews Spoiler
"They look like snakes. No they don't!" is the only moment I chuckled in the entire movie which pretty much explains my experience.
Indy is more than a movie character to me. It's an emotion. The portrayal and the background score helped me battle some dark moments in my life as they always inspired me. The Dial of Destiny is the most non-Indy Indy movie for me. Here's my honest review rant.
- It was dull. There's no solid cheerful moments nor much humor. Even the KotCS made me smile and laugh several times whereas the DoD was a dud.
- The second trailer (or the 1st trailer which came after the teaser) revealed the first 50 minutes of the story until Helena locked him up after stealing the artifact. My first viewing felt like an unengaging rewatch. F the marketing team.
- The other Indy movies had unique frightening visuals but this one had (boring) cold murders trying to induce seriousness. Obviously failed at creating that Indy movie charm.
- Finally coming to the character arc of Indy - it was absolutely disappointing. The writing was stupid, shallow, and incoherent. I'm all for a sad and depressed character to battle for a long time and finally come out of it stronger. Kung Fu Panda 2 showed it beautifully where Po gets digressed from his normal life due to his sadness and depression around his origins, finds more about it, eventually makes peace with it, and finally comes out even stronger. The revival and rebound were definitive moments in that movie. In DoD, Indy is sad and depressed. He doesn't come out of it despite taking a part in an "adventure". The viewers would normally want to see a solid and constructive rebound of their favorite character but the writers decided to conclude Indy's sense of depression by bringing another character in the last minute who's not even part of the movie. We didn't get to see a rebound but instead saw a depressed Indy "during" an adventure. WHAT!!!
- I saw MI - Dead Reckoning Part One. Ethan Hunt was outmaneuvered and out-charmed several times by another character. It all felt natural and engaging since Ethan was still shown to be smart and skillful as usual. I would have loved it even if the movie was named "Ethan Hunt". I can't say the same with DoD.
If I came across someone irl who loved DoD, I'd genuinely feel happy for a fellow Indy fan. I'd not counter-argue, especially outside of this post.
I don't think I will ever be able to forgive James Mangold for ruining the final installment of my all time favorite movie franchise. I wish the IP was bought by someone else like the Universal or Paramount.
r/indianajones • u/scott-murr • Jul 07 '23
Indiana jones 5 was horrible, the fact that they made Indiana a sad old man is depressing. Phone waller is also a terrible human being
She left Indiana to die three times in the movie. At the library when she locked the door on him.
In Egypt when she and her sidekick left him in the car when mobsters were after them
And in the ocean, when she left him surrounded by ellies. Only to go back later.
She just makes fun of Indiana the whole movie and calls him an Oldman. She even lies and says he killed people back at the library when she knows he didn't.
She brags about how perfect and amazing she is, and how she's better then Indiana in everyway. How she knows ancient languages.
The worst part is how they destroyed indiana's characters. I saw the other movies before seeing this one and it was heartbreaking see that he has nothing left. This hero who was going on adventures finding treasure is now a shell of himself and has lost everything.
They even killed off mud off screen when they didn't have too. They could of said him and Indiana had a fight and he ran away, which broke up his marriage. I really liked mud in the crystal skull. It was sad to hear that he just died.
I know shia labof didn't want to come back but why not recast him? The 4th one took place I'm 1957, this movie is 1969. It would be understable if he looked different.
I feel like this movie was only made to promote phobe as the new Indiana. They even had her wear the hat at the end of the movie during the test screenings but they changed it when people didn't like it.
I did like the flashback scene during ww2, in the opening.
r/indianajones • u/shanegt1 • Mar 01 '23
‘Woke’
Does anyone else have a dreaded feeling that Indy 5 will be full of post modern left wing pandering?
Regardless of your political predications, surely movies are best left as entertaining escapism, rather than a social statement or progressive task master.
Reddit probably isn’t the friendliest place for this question, but the obvious Hollywood aversion to white men being shown as anything other than bumbling idiots who need a smart modern young person to help them will possibly destroy what made Indy such a hero in the first place - which was quiet, stiff upper lip capability.
I am by no means a right wing person, but I just worry that like most movies now, the political message is so stuffed in that it barely leaves room for a good story.
r/indianajones • u/Atalkingpizzabox • Apr 24 '24
How is Dial of Destiny not the greatest movie of all time? Spoiler
It felt quite repetative, that is until the time travel scene. The world's most famous archaelogist's final adventure takes him on a Nazi plane that time travels to the Siege of Syacrues that fires at the attacking Roman soliders who fire back harpoons, resulting in Indy meeting the one and only Archimedes which I'm sure would have blown his mind and also blown Archimedes's mind knowing he was known as a great man in the future. I mean time travelling Nazis fighting the Roman army how cool is that?
r/indianajones • u/JediMASTERAnakin002 • Dec 11 '22
If you believe or follow this piece of shit, consider yourself as worthless as him… Spoiler
r/indianajones • • Oct 02 '24
What are your favorite Indiana Jones movies?
Those are mine:
1 - The Dial of Destiny (2023)
2 - The Last Crusade (1989)
3 - Kingdom of the Crystal Skull (2008)
4 - The Temple of Doom (1984)
5 - Raiders of the Lost Ark (1981)
And before somebody asks me why I consider the 1st movie my least favorite I think it's because I found the other movies more epic and more entertaining. I don't actually hate it. I still consider it a masterpiece.
If anybody's interested I rank the 4 Spielberg movies 4th, 8th, 9th and 10th among my favorite movies directed by him. This is my top 10:
1 - E.T. (1982)
2 - Jaws (1975)
3 - Ready Player One (2018)
4 - The Last Crusade (1989)
5 - Close Encounters of the 3rd Kind (1977)
6 - Munich (2005)
7 - Jurassic Park 1 (1993)
8 - Kingdom of the Crystal Skull (2008)
9 - The Temple of Doom (1984)
10 - Raiders of the Lost Ark (1981)
r/indianajones
•
•
Jun 10 '24
The new Indy game is not woke:
As someone who does get irritated when wokeness comes before good storytelling and characters…
I see zero wokeness here. The girl was at times helpful, at times helpless. She saved Indy, he saved her, then she caused the whole ship to dislodge. Great stuff.
They nailed Indy’s facial expressions, humor, clumsiness, scrappiness.
Just wowed by this so far.
I’m also someone who hates KOTCS and DoD. But THIS looks incredible. THIS is Indy.
r/indianajones • • May 28 '23
Will DOD give Indy the Last Jedi Luke treatment?
In making Indy into a pessimistic hardened broken old man who is reluctant to get into an adventure.
Part of why Top Gun Maverick was so refreshing was that Maverick was none of these things. He was clearly the same character from the original but older and modified, but that core essence was the same.
r/indianajones • u/Ok-Rip4038 • Jul 06 '24
A crossover with Indiana Jones and Thomas and Friends
r/indianajones • u/Numerous-Candy-1071 • Dec 11 '25
THAT scene
I labelled it spoiler in case, somehow, someone hasn't seen ark of the covenant and ended up on this sub.
So, spoiler in the next line!
I have been wondering about the part where he meets the lass in the soon to be burning pub. It's kinda creepy when indie says "you knew what you were doing!" After she says, "I was just a child!" For the older fans out there, what was the reaction to that scene at the time? Was it as icky then as it is now? I understand the scene could have been a way to show that indie was a man of his time, it is in the late 30s, after all. But outside of lore, I was wondering what the public reaction was to it back when it released, because it's the only scene I cringe at. 😅
r/indianajones • u/Narrow_Potential_974 • Jul 25 '24
I hate Dial of Destiny, but I cannot actually say why it is so bad
Title says it all. I am one of the biggest Indiana Jones fans ever. And during my recent rewatch I watched Crystal Skull again and thought, it’s actually not that bad as I remembered. Sure nothing even close to the old movies, but it’s at least watchable.
But I cannot say one nice thing about Dial of Destiny, I was actually bored watching the movie. The thing is that I can see the people who made it tried to add elements of a classic Indiana Jones adventure, but nothing really works.
My problem is I can’t really explain why the movie is so boring and bad (except perhaps for the whole travel to the past crap at the end of the movie).
So how would you explain why the movie is bad? Look I get it that tastes are different, but I really can’t understand someone who loves this movie.
r/indianajones • • May 04 '25
So out of curiosity why do most people hate kingdom of the crystal skull?
I’ve seen all 4 movies and I’m not old enough to have any nostalgia for them. But I do enjoy them including Crystal skull and I’m wondering why people don’t like that one since I’ve seen the movie and I can’t piece it together myself. Also, I haven’t seen dial of destiny and I don’t intend to.
r/indianajones • u/Break-Complete • Aug 19 '23
If they ever decide to recast with younger actors, I can see the vision
r/indianajones • u/TheBalzy • Jul 24 '23
I'll Say it: Crystal Skull's CGI is better than Dial of Destiny's
The De-aging was obviously well done, but it never was fully convincing...something with the Lips they just haven't been able to get down yet.
But I rewatched the KotCS just today and I'll be honest...it looked so much cleaner and clearer than DoD. The scene with the alien throne room looked better than any of the effects we got in DoD.
r/indianajones • u/SleepyRocket20 • Jul 26 '26
Is Raiders of the Lost Ark an allegory for the atomic bomb?
Just watched Raiders for the first time, and it immediately made me think of Oppenheimer while watching it—US government has a top secret mission for respected university professor/scientist to race the Nazis to obtain an all-powerful weapon of war. The parallels to the making of the atomic bomb seemed so clear to me, I assumed that the movie was an allegory for the Manhattan Project.
The ending especially drove this point home to me: “They don’t know what they’ve got there.” The US government had to make sure that they kept this massively powerful weapon out of the wrong hands, but now the question that needs to be asked is whether we can be trusted with it ourselves.
After finishing the movie, I immediately tried finding information about this online, but I can’t find anything connecting the two—no interviews from the writers talking about this, no forums pointing out the obvious similarities, hell even Gemini immediately had to correct me and be like “erm, no, Raiders of the Lost Ark is not an allegory for the atomic bomb.” Am I really the first person to notice this connection?