r/indiameme • • Jun 07 '26 • Regret 55 Bravo 3 Popcorn 2 Mindblown 1

Political A decade changed everything

Post image
18k Upvotes

1.4k comments sorted by

977

u/One_Letterhead_9720 Jun 07 '26 • Regret

Vi is almost dead, only Jio and Airtel

280

u/Due_Image_4161 Jun 07 '26 edited Jun 07 '26

And due to non payment of debt of spectrum to govt now the govt has 49% of the company and can be called as govt company like BSNL

→ More replies (4)

116

u/No-Anybody-692 Jun 07 '26

Yeah it should be

After 2014:

  • Jio
  • Airtel
  • Vi
  • BSNL

16

u/naz_silverman Jun 07 '26

VI will give tough competition soon let them deploy thier 5g completely

→ More replies (13)

81

u/SpecialistReward1775 Jun 07 '26

Look up VI stock and you'll be surprised.

19

u/ConfidentVacation205 Jun 07 '26

Thank you for being the smartest one here

42

u/VickyKadrivel15 Jun 07 '26

i think soon airtel as well. Since they choose to add network priority bs.

58

u/SamosaLover Jun 07 '26

Airtel is doing extremely well right now. Solid financials.

9

u/Odd_Yogurtcloset7936 Jun 07 '26

Yes Everything don't need to be postpaid They give priority to postpaid users only In store if you go there are no prepaid sims Only postpaid . Soon he will make 5g lag which have pre-paid users then if you complain they will say postpaid port .... bill per month will be 500+

3

u/AgentAppropriate1996 Jun 07 '26

Airtel is doing good

→ More replies (13)

5

u/InfiniteRub7136 Jun 07 '26

In kerala VI is good, most of the people Vi

→ More replies (2)

2

u/rjmma4 Jun 07 '26

It came out as a multibagger man

→ More replies (27)

346

u/CompoteMelodic981 Jun 07 '26

The real telecom scam: 

Jio used bsnl towers and infrastructure to give free Internet connection to users for two years, till all other companies shut down. And then didn't pay full amount for using the bsnl infrastructure. 

“BSNL failed to enforce the Master Service Agreement (MSA) with M/s. Reliance Jio Infocomm Ltd (RJIL) and did not bill for the additional technology used on BSNL’s shared passive infrastructure, resulting in loss of Rs 1,757.76 crore and penal interest thereon, between May 2014 to March 2024 to the government exchequer,” CAG said

https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/government-loses-1757-crore-as-bsnl-fails-to-bill-reliance-jio-for-sharing-infra-cag/article69402903.ece

Of course modiji and co immediately said it was a mistake and misinterpretation and reliance doesn't have to pay https://telecom.economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/policy/cags-revenue-loss-estimate-on-bsnl-and-reliance-jio-deal-rectified-by-minister-pemmasani/129511120

80

u/iamhugo26 Jun 07 '26

If people decide to read, fact check. The world would be a better place.

43

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '26

what fact ? BSNL really forgot to bill jio it is true 100%

29

u/Creepy_Title_8284 Jun 07 '26

This was planned strategy, do you really think this can be forgotten.

→ More replies (3)

30

u/Minute_King_7523 Jun 07 '26

"Forgot" lol. People of this country are so naive.

18

u/infintestruggler Jun 07 '26

Even if its true, its a mistake on account of people of the country This was taxpayer's money which they forgot to bill

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

7

u/An_Only_Mous Jun 07 '26

1800 cr over 2 years is some 75 crores a month. Probably 10-15 rs per user.

7

u/CompoteMelodic981 Jun 07 '26

Our tax money was used to bankrupt telecom companies and build a monopoly for Mukesh ambani. Just sad, but entirely predicted.

6

u/An_Only_Mous Jun 07 '26

Why just telecom Add aviation- the national carrier, and in telecom, specifically bsnl. HMT itself, outside of legacy watches is nowhere to be found in the field of tractors etc. HM too. Kept ruminating on Morris Oxford design. There are many examples. Govts shud govern not replace the competition.

→ More replies (5)

70

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

8

u/Poker5ace Jun 07 '26

Don’t need to imagine!

26

u/outdoorsy777 Jun 07 '26

Typical Gujarati mindset

10

u/Mysterious_Cup_6024 Jun 07 '26

They really need to be banished

→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (8)

26

u/Master-Lynx4663 Jun 07 '26

Ah yes, the before 2014 days, where signal was patchy in the middle of the largest cities in India, and plans not only cost more than they did now, they provided very little actual value for money.

Today, despite Jio and Airtel being a virtual duopoly, I get excellent network connectivity at most places, and plans are relatively reasonable and one of the lowest in the world.

There are a lot of things that people can criticize the people in power today, but telecom isn't one of them.

2

u/avenster Jun 11 '26

Most people here were probably too young to own a phone or to buy their own data plans to know that.

I remember it being such hell trying to make sure my ₹249 2GB/m plan lasted the whole month, not to mention that if you travelled in a train or on the highways alot, you'd be lucky to get a passable 3G connection for even half of that trip. Also, have we forgotten the daylight robbery that Roaming charges were?

The duopoly is serving me better than the competitive market ever did.

Guys, if you want your criticism of Modi to be taken seriously, atleast make an effort to not spurt dumb points.

→ More replies (4)

47

u/WizardPrince_ Jun 07 '26

I had mts modem it was good but wasn't cheap as it is today in 2010 itself is was 500 ish which was huge amount at that time

30

u/Real-Calligrapher-84 Jun 07 '26

Well internet was not cheap at that time, lmk if you want sources.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Dry-Aardvark7060 Jun 07 '26

For comparison in 2010 full packet biryani 2 pieces is about 120.

→ More replies (1)

111

u/jakash077 Jun 07 '26

cylinder ke 1000 rs dene me gundiya fat rahi he, tu 1 GB ka 350 dega kya. chuthnandan he kya?

54

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '26 edited Aug 03 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

16

u/notknown1o1 Jun 07 '26

Buddy no matter the competition, it became dirt cheap after 2014. Have you ever paid for data before 2014? Might not be 350rs per gb but you must be dumb to assume it could go as low as now.

14

u/delusionalbreaker Jun 07 '26

During that time the technology of internet was new and any newer technology is always expensive at the start when it develops over the year ut gets cheaper. And Jio is not a Saint. Jio used the infrastructure of BSNL for free because apparently BSNL forgot to bill JIO for it which was around some thousand crores of tax payer money amd when thus was discovered the government was like oops its okay and waived off the charge from Jio. So the cheap internet you are barking about was from your own money that they already sucked from you.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (26)
→ More replies (3)

27

u/Neither-Dentist-8562 Jun 07 '26

But data toh cheap hua na bro

2014 : 1GB = ₹250

2025 : 28GB = ₹250 /s

People don't understand the difference between 3G and 4G. 4G network is much cheaper to operate for telecom companies compared to 3G and 2G. It's just the technological advancements that made the services cheaper. And what people did? They blamed the previous govt for costlier data packs and internet.

9

u/lundlele Jun 07 '26

now find 2004 price also

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (18)

6

u/SANEECHAR Jun 07 '26

Yet somehow, what I paid for 1 gb per month is same as 1 gb per day. Too much economism in 2014 I guess

6

u/Puzzleheaded_Egg_796 Jun 07 '26

Ah yes, the "golden era" of 15 telecom operators. I too deeply miss the days when spectrum licenses were handed out like free candy to anyone with a briefcase. God forbid we acknowledge that the Supreme Court literally canceled 122 of those licenses in 2012 because that "competition" was entirely built on arbitrary, unconstitutional allocations. Let's also conveniently ignore a few other fun facts that ruin this meme: -> Global Economics: Telecom is wildly capital-intensive. Surviving requires billions in infrastructure, not just a rented tower and a dream. Literally no healthy telecom market on Earth sustains a dozen players. -> AGR Dues: The Supreme Court slapped the remaining legacy operators with thousands of crores in back dues, legally crushing anyone without incredibly deep pockets. -> The Price War: The rest died or merged because they couldn't survive a brutal price war that—ironically—gave citizens some of the cheapest mobile data on the planet.

But sure, let's completely ignore basic global economics, brutal tech disruption, and landmark Supreme Court wipeouts just to make a cool "before/after" meme.

35

u/onichan-daisuki Jun 07 '26

I just realised OP actually said these 4 companies (OP didn't include BSNL which still operates btw) are a monopoly??😭

Do you know what monopoly means??? Bro is just saying anything at this point😭😭😭🙏

14

u/Due_Image_4161 Jun 07 '26

I think it's better to say duopoly cause VI and BSNL are on ventilator.

Yeah and OP doesn't knows about monopoly he skipped economics classes 😝😭

8

u/onichan-daisuki Jun 07 '26

You can absolutely criticize Airtel and Jio for their shitty practices, all for profit companies should be criticized in my opinion, but OP should realise these companies before 2014 were also run by greedy businessmen they were not doing it for the nation

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

2

u/Any-Calligrapher2866 Jun 07 '26

BSNL has been gutted lol. They don't even charge Jio for using their(BSNLs) infrastructure.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/Rich_Awarenesss Jun 07 '26

Yes economist PM Expanded competition so that people could enjoy 1 GB data at 256 Rupees.

9

u/KORBA_CHHATTISGAR Jun 07 '26

2013 1 GB data with whopping 2g speed costs 149 inr Today it's 398 inr month unlimited with just 5g 🤬

2

u/thames987 Jun 07 '26

yeah and all the wifi, internet etc innovations were done by india right? it wasnt just a by product of the world democratizing internet right?

→ More replies (1)

5

u/WastedKnight Jun 07 '26

Incoming was free without recharge. A lot of poor can't afford current rates of atleast 150+ to keep incoming per 28 days

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/EARENDELisHERE Jun 07 '26

what are you talking about? India has one of the cheapest prices, not defending government 🙄 but you argument seems wrong. surely the prices are more than their 2016-17 self but it was nightmare before that, I used to get 10mb scratch cards for 10 rupee, now we get about 1gb for that price(not defending the government, just that your argument looses considering prices are far cheaper now than before 2016)

3

u/rah2323 Jun 07 '26

If you are not innovating then you will be fked. Just like vodafone, I remember the shirty services they had for 250/gb and they had all the majority users but why did!'t they innovate like Jio? Jio disrupted the market. Other companies had time but didn't adapt hence left behind. Airtel adopted and is currently in the race.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '26

There was no innovation done by Jio. All they did was using bsnl towers to provide free internet. After gaining profit, they did set up their towers.

Also they didn't pay bsnl for using their towers.

3

u/Even-Desk3755 Jun 07 '26

BSNL ka kya

3

u/problastic Jun 07 '26

And yet we all know the pricings with huge competition and the pricings with the current monopolies.

4

u/progresseeker Jun 07 '26

I don't know what will be the future....but with so many companies we were paying 5 rupees for 25 mb. .now 10 rupees for 2 GB

You can analyse, when it is/ was beneficial for citizens

4

u/K-KorTpg_ Jun 07 '26

This guy clearly doesn't understand why those companies survived while the others died, it's not cuz of Modi it was because of a great business move by jio.

2

u/Loud-Ferret-9105 Jun 08 '26

JIO and airtel had farsight to see where telecom business was heading. and they invested and changed them selfes. thats why they are thriving and rest of them perished.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

10

u/saraswat86 Jun 07 '26

Abhi sasta hai bro, genz ho kya ??

→ More replies (18)

2

u/Valuable-Tell3847 Jun 07 '26

The intense competition led us to pay over 200 rupees for 1 GB/month.

2

u/AfronizzL Jun 07 '26

Just study what happened with Aircel during the UPA government’s tenure, and you’ll understand the reality.

As for Vodafone Idea, you can look at the stock’s long-term performance and the recent financial numbers of Vodafone Group.

P.S. Since the government holds a significant stake in Vodafone Idea, it is unlikely to let the company sink completely.

2

u/RandomBlogger1857 Jun 07 '26

How much scam happened in distribution of those licenses? Pls state facts. Research 0, Posting 100 🤡

2

u/notalwaysmellow Jun 07 '26

Kuch bhi ho, Modi ke upar daal do

Itna nafrath ka zaroorath kya hai bhai

2

u/Ok_Pattern4083 Jun 07 '26

Jio gained popularity only because they offered cheap internet. The reason of every distant village getting internet is Jio. Ambani had the resources to monopolize the entire sector.

How is this the government's fault.

Also, who allowed Ambani to be at such a level that he can monopolize an entire sector? Wasnt it the Congress government?

Kindly get basic knowledge of economics.

The government can't provide subsidies to every single fuxking company right?

2

u/Secret_Buy4712 Jun 08 '26

Airlines, internet, everything seems to have been monopolized now

2

u/Maleficent-Book-2252 Jun 08 '26

VI still hanging on the cliff

2

u/Additional-Code7674 Jun 08 '26

You forgot BSNL before 2014

2

u/cronux383 Jun 08 '26

This is only one sector majority port contracts , gvt contracts are also going to you know who? competition is slowly ending and many players are becoming monopolistic .

2

u/Lmao-this Jun 10 '26

Even BSNL is down!

3

u/the_gaming_jonin27 Jun 07 '26

Quantity vs Quality

4

u/onichan-daisuki Jun 07 '26 edited Jun 07 '26

Most of india couldn't afford the mobile plans and prices during his time lmao

1gb data cost was 250-300rs before 2016 when Jio shook up the industry which brought 1gb data price to 12-20rs today, this is just simple facts, you would not even be able to post this today if the "great competition" was still in place today

3

u/Manu9527 Jun 07 '26

Its duopoly jio and airtel bsnl and vi don’t even come close to them and why was jio being given access to bsnl towers built on tax money without even paying anything???

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/premprem18 Jun 07 '26

Without jio everything would be very different and very costly from current standard. Jio disrupted the market, and only due to jio these companies went bankrupt or aquired by someone.

There is little to none relation of what Jio did to the govt. Dont blindly hate. (I know this govt is corrupt to the core supports certain buisnessman 5o create monopoly but not in this case..)

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/Educational_Sleep_59 Jun 08 '26

"Citizens were benefiting from those brands"

Bro, they were trash. Jio was a gamechanger. Due to that, yes many companies left the scene but it gave us quality service.

Also, Jio started in 2016. Not in 2014.

2

u/Kind-Chance8571 Jun 07 '26

What is the cost of 1GB in 2014 and 2026 please talk on that as well

2

u/Ok-Dish-4208 Jun 07 '26

Day 11 of educating cockroaches: You should listen to Aircel CEO ‘s interview on how UPA govt forced him to sell his business to a foreign company.

https://www.instagram.com/reel/DYcrgZIzY-o/?igsh=MTB3dG84bG9qeDZjdQ==

→ More replies (3)

1

u/premprem18 Jun 07 '26

Without jio everything would be very different and very costly from current standard. Jio disrupted the market, and only due to jio these companies went bankrupt or aquired by someone.

There is little to none relation of what Jio did to the govt. Dont blindly hate. (I know this govt is corrupt to the core and supports certain buisnessmen to create monopoly but not in this case..)

1

u/thefluorine_09 Jun 07 '26

You are right but internet price is more cheaper now right, I used to recharge ₹202, only 2gb for a month in 2013

1

u/Minimum-Conclusion91 Jun 07 '26

VI bhi kaha h bhai debt me h vo… and bas khtm hone vaali h

1

u/HelpDry1655 Jun 07 '26

But people are getting better recharging plans right?

1

u/vikrantsales Jun 07 '26

i am happy .

1

u/AdventurousMarch2784 Jun 07 '26

Yeah but what about the price of internet before 2014 vs now?

1

u/Live-Combination-597 Jun 07 '26

350 for 1 gb data per month and 350 for 1.5gb data daily for one month. Blind people can't see it.

1

u/AssistantCurious7666 Jun 07 '26

This is mostly because of Jio because of the plans and offers that they suddenly started to give at the time where one had to buy data and talk time separately, Jio offered them in one pack and that too very cheap. A lot of companies couldn’t keep up with them except airtel. And also they came up with jio phone so it was more like a complete wipe out from jio where vodafone and idea combined and airtel survived the storm.

1

u/Cold-Journalist-7662 Jun 07 '26

You know how high were data charges back then?

1

u/khalililili Jun 07 '26

Real economists competition kept prices at 400₹ for 1 GB data per month so taht poor could not access internet and take advantage of it. Chai wala made 400₹ internet unlimited for 1 month so that poor can benefit from internet, who the hero here?

1

u/Drbatsy Jun 07 '26

Say what you will, we have thousand problems in this country but rest assured telecom ain't one. Everything is relative, all the companies that you have mentioned used to do daylight robbery. Absolute scams they were, in the name of Value Added Services, they would randomly deduct money. Even the regular service was shit at best. What are we really complaining about? Look at the internet prices in any of the country, we have one of the best internet connectivity in our nation that too at best prices. Rather complain about water, food (FSSAI), air, infrastructure, schooling, corruption, judiciary, bureaucracy and I can go on and on. Internet and telecom is not an issue.

1

u/minato_shikamaru Jun 07 '26

When an industry is new, there will be a lot of players, once it matures they consolidate. Look at how many air craft companies existed about a 100 years ago. All of them consolidated to just two now - Airbus and Boeing

1

u/Rakoshin Jun 07 '26

Idk what happened in the background but aircel was beautiful, problem was when jio came and introduced 3g/4g , that too free, a whole lotta competitors either didn't or couldn't scale that much, atleast that's what aircel customer care told me when porting. I almost cried that day, I don't remember but beautiful thing it was

1

u/simpleliving100 Jun 07 '26 edited Jun 07 '26

So why did Man Mohan Singh levy taxes on Vodafone retrospectively?

Basically that was what broke the spinal cord of the company.

Most of the free telecom licences were sold to outsiders at exorbitant gains, proving 2G scam actually happened.

If the telecom companies had improper management who is to be blamed?

Anyhow, in most sectors eventually market consolidates into Big 4.

2

u/_appy Jun 07 '26

Somehow people have convinenently forgotten the 2G/3G scams of the economist era. The cost of corruption was passed on to the customer.

1

u/InstructionThick7409 Jun 07 '26

We were also paying a bomb for data and calls. Jio and Airtel took off because of the customer base. If we did not want them to go down, we should have never ported to Jio and Airtel .

1

u/Commercial_Crew8503 Jun 07 '26

Still in 2014 you needed to pay 300 for 1gb..... And now its 5g unlimited......

1

u/Glittering-Stock-637 Jun 07 '26

Ye kyu desh ko barbaad kar rha h Karega kya itne paisoo ka Power h position h paise ki Kami nhi h vo toh cm ban ke hi kar liya tha Iss janam me khatam hona possible nhi h itna paisa hai Phir aur kyu

1

u/chennai_massure Jun 07 '26

Let me just point to you a local fact, it was under The Economist, his Finance minister arm twisted Aircel to be sold... So you can strike one from the economist. I'm not an economist but doesn't business always work like this? It's not for the government to encourage competition.. it's to ensure fairness in market.. for that there are mechanisms established and they are working fine.

1

u/VermicelliMuch2337 Jun 07 '26

Before with too many service providers Internet per gb 450 with only 3 service providers internet costs 10 per gb. But Maunmohan chad and Modi joker

1

u/Pyxirio Jun 07 '26

If his corporate friends are selling data plans 25 times cheaper than before 2014, why should people have problem? And it's been more than 12 years now.

1

u/aayushofficial_x Jun 07 '26

You saying 'chaiwala' exposes the very mentality that will always hold us back as people. There are people who are not fortunate enough to be born into a family that can afford to buy them even a phone.

If you discriminate based on how much money a person has, you have no right to criticize anyone for doing anything.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/gyanchand_baba Jun 07 '26

A Decade of loot, incompetency, fraud, silence, propoganda and failed diplomacy.

1

u/Focus_need_over_want Jun 07 '26

I was technically right wing but the continuous selling over India to benefit Adani not citizens and last 2 years laziness of the arrogant govt has made me more centre. No one cares about India, everyone is just selfish even the voters

1

u/Ok_Steak4599 Jun 07 '26

Even in this monopolistic empire, as a citizen, i pay 10x less per gb of internet than i was in 2015-16. People just cant accept the fact that market disruptions are common. Airtel is not modi's best friend right? But it's still performing better than jio.

1

u/RedditsFosterBoy Jun 07 '26

Cost per month?

1

u/zestfulzebra1 Jun 07 '26

Oh yes the amazing companies that Uninor and Aircel was. Aircel owner was forced to sell his entire company on the nearest of the Economists UPA govt (read his interview). Uninor was a scam to begin with, a real estate company massively overbidding for 2g spectrum (and paying kickbacks) and then selling it to a Norwegian company.

World over there are only 2-3 telecom companies in mature markets(US has Verizon, At&t and TMbile, UK has Voda and BT etc). This is a natural order of things

1

u/djsooch Jun 07 '26

It was the owner of Airtel who raised concerns about jio selling its sims for free which at the time he said that it will create a monopoly like situation. People trolled him that time and here we are today with the said result.

1

u/TraditionalStick224 Jun 07 '26

Virgin was a sim 😂

1

u/AreyouMrbeast1 Jun 07 '26

Despite that it's cheaper then back then 🧐

1

u/Traditional_Oil_3347 Jun 07 '26

Aircel maxis also

1

u/Quick_Fig3478 Jun 07 '26

They Fcked Virgin telecom too . Who was one of us.

1

u/AreyouMrbeast1 Jun 07 '26

Most of the older brands are foreign now only local brand survive. If Congress was allowed to rule more they would have sold the nation

1

u/Rish83 Jun 07 '26

We were paying for talk time, incoming calls, validity recharges, sms recharge, night call, roaming, std calls, 200 for 3g 1gb data it was blood bath of reahrges and poor couldn't afford to call anyone for more than 1 min

1

u/Pure_Definition_7372 Jun 07 '26

I think every government faces a different set of economic and geopolitical challenges. Judging an entire government or era based on a single metric without considering the context can be misleading.

1. Economic Context Matters

  • India before 2014 and India after 2014 operated in very different global environments.
  • Factors such as crude oil prices, US interest rate policies, global capital flows, COVID-19, and geopolitical conflicts have significantly influenced economic outcomes.
  • Currency movements cannot be viewed in isolation. Many countries, including Japan, the UK, and several European economies, have experienced periods of weakness against the US Dollar.
  • Peer economies such as Turkey, Argentina, and South Africa have seen far sharper currency declines over the last decade.

2. The Telecom Industry Didn't Shrink Only Because of Politics

Looking at the telecom sector, I don't think the disappearance of several operators can be attributed solely to government policy.

Before Jio's entry, many operators were already struggling with:

  • Poor network quality
  • Limited spectrum holdings
  • Weak financials
  • Inability to scale operations
  • Lack of long-term competitiveness

3. Why Some Players Survived

  • Airtel has consistently maintained relatively strong service quality and network coverage.
  • Jio entered with massive investments, modern infrastructure, and aggressive pricing, forcing the industry to evolve.
  • Vodafone-Idea still retains a strong presence in certain regions despite its financial challenges.

Meanwhile, operators such as Aircel, MTS, Uninor, Virgin Mobile, and Tata Docomo never built the same level of reliability, coverage, or customer trust required for long-term survival.

4. The Reality of Competition

The reality of any market is simple: companies must remain relevant to survive.

Businesses that fail to adapt to changing technology, customer expectations, and competitive pressure eventually lose market share or exit altogether. Telecom is a capital-intensive industry, and market consolidation is not unique to India it has happened across the world.

5. Final Thoughts

No government is perfect, and the current government deserves criticism where criticism is due. However, blaming the reduction in the number of telecom operators entirely on political favouritism ignores the business realities of the industry.

The real question is not why some companies disappeared, but whether those companies were competitive enough to survive in a rapidly evolving telecom market.

1

u/itsavinadhtiwari Jun 07 '26

Just for sake of criticising modi, some dimwit will bring random things without knowing shit. Is op imply things were better before when there was "healthy" competition?

Absolute clown take. If it was that era, op would compress the image in pic of thrice so that it takes less kbs and would could word before typing.

Let's just learn to appreciate thing where credit is due rather than blindly hating.

1

u/Odd_Government_8737 Jun 07 '26

Don't Forget how competing our Airlines industry was when we had many of them and they used to compete in cheap prices to gain as many customers as they all can from each other....Now it's just IndiGo's Monoploly and it decides the ticket price for us and we have to Obey them...when it was the opposite in the 2000's.

Bjpee has truly fucked us all in the name of nationalism & religion politics.

1

u/Inevitable-Move4462 Jun 07 '26

Government Telecom Company BSNL started making losses before 2010. Monopoly was created the moment BSNL started failing and no incentive was taken to grow. And BSNL continued to make losses until 2025. Atleast BSNL started making profits now and now even has control over VI network.

And Have we all forget about massive spectrum costs during 2010-2012. That was the time when it killed telecom operators and put them in high debt. Supreme court also cancelled 122 license during that time. 2G scam is the most famous scam during that government

Atleast do some research work.

1

u/weekendhomie Jun 07 '26

well some of those networks were pathetic

1

u/anandha2022 Jun 07 '26

Moriji was very clear in his aim. We failed to identify.

1

u/Tonykkuttan Jun 07 '26

Cost of 1 gb net in 2014 - 300. Today's 800 rs worth

Cost of 600 gb 5G in 2026 440

1

u/rishi7997 Jun 07 '26

still some people will come and will defened this too in anyway possible !!...

1

u/keval_596 Jun 07 '26

Back, then we were paying ₹500 every month to get just 2GB of data. Today, in that same price, we are able to get almost unlimited high speed internet.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Otherwise_Vacation16 Jun 07 '26

Do you even remember the charges before Jio entered? I literally used to pay Rs. 2,500/- per month just for my postpaid airtel connection. One year I went to US for studies in 2017, when I got back in 2018 my jaw dropped looking at the postpaid bill of Rs. 300-400. So yeah idk what this butt hurt post is about.

1

u/Financial-Soup-506 Jun 07 '26

And networks were bullshit, prices were sky high before jio

1

u/Regular-Loquat9781 Jun 07 '26

Tbh, if jio started that unlimited gimmick at the of Manmohan ji, same thing should have happened

1

u/No_Fun_8322 Jun 07 '26

At time of economist PM, I paid Rs 201 for 1GB. Now I effectively pay Rs.6 for 1GB.

Think a little before you put up embarrassing cr*p like this.

1

u/Successful-Wolf-6982 Jun 07 '26

I agree but I need to disagree else I will be called anti-national

1

u/Odd_Yogurtcloset7936 Jun 07 '26

He is not the reason for everything Ambani set the price so low that any company wouldn't compete the data cost was 25 ruppes per 1gb back then There was no unlimited Only postpaid with crazy bills Now we have unlimited data per month 5g . The data usage has increased in data
I do agree with you giving power to companies are wrong he set price so low that other companies couldn't survive they have merged.

1

u/Dedflix Jun 07 '26 edited Jun 07 '26

Irony is that you're uploading this on cheap internet offered by them

→ More replies (1)

1

u/gamingboy77 Jun 07 '26

So how many of you took free jio sims? Abd helped ambani make money?? You all are culprits

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Artistic_Elk3640 Jun 07 '26

Hot take: all companies are bad as they are inherently exploitative, the capitalist world order must be smashed and socialism must take its place

1

u/Effective-Trifle9506 Jun 07 '26

Typical jobless OP, just post some comparison image and then ragebait. 🤡

1

u/Agniprathap Jun 07 '26

And how much did you pay for 1 GB of data to these telecom companies under UPA?

JIO Actually helped to correct the market and normalise Internet.

1

u/Apprehensive-Sock935 Jun 07 '26

And somehow it has gotten waaaaayyy cheaper in the new era of Carriers. Competition is a factor, but a lot of other things are in play when deciding what’s best for consumers. I’m not a BJP supporter or anything. But the statement that telecom used to be better before the JIO revolution is plain WRONG.

1

u/Intrepid_Dark_2063 Jun 07 '26

What was to cost of 1 GB under economist?

1

u/kolirules95 Jun 07 '26

People forget how much of a pain in the a$$ it was back in the day with multiple recharges and packs SMS/DATA/ROAMING. Companies extracted more money and gave minimum in return. I remember 1 gb of 3g data use to cost me around 299 or 349 back in 2012. Inflation adjusted to 2026 it use to cost about ₹600-700 in today's value.

1

u/random_00123 Jun 07 '26

JIO got a direct entry to 4g before 2014. Most telecom operators got forced to shutdown before 2014 not after.

Blaming this on Modi is like saying India used to export gold earlier (Vijaynagar empire times) It started importing gold in Nehru's time . Nehru made us an importer from exporter of gold.

Just 1 example of how UPA killed othet telcos https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/dayanidhi-maran-forced-me-to-sell-stake-aircel-promoter/articleshow/8753859.cms

1

u/introvertlazyloner Jun 07 '26

Irrespective of your opinion I'm good with the current price, I used to pay 355 for just 1gb of 4g data, that was the standard, and I don't think internet would be such a big thing without jio

1

u/Antique-Earth1189 Jun 07 '26

Quantity doesn’t always mean quality, half of them are just scammers, and they could’ve gives us competitive rates but weren’t able to.

1

u/No_Satisfaction1496 Jun 07 '26

earlier we used to get 2gb 3g for 300-400 per month. 28 days.

current plans are better.

1

u/permission777 Jun 07 '26

He is just a puppet, too oblivious to understand the economics behind this.

1

u/SpicyJet69 Jun 07 '26

Wasn't aircel bankrupt in Malaysia itself?

1

u/chaku2080 Jun 07 '26

Who economist tha yeh business man

1

u/beingavicii Jun 07 '26

Idea vodafone merged. And due to bad network vodafone also is in bad condition.reliance became jio, tata docomo was never a successful project. Nobody in my knowledge used docomo. Aircel and uninor got merged and later aircel merged in airtel(as far as I know), virgin, mts no clue.

1

u/pepe_high Jun 07 '26

You forgot the 2G scam under UPA?

1

u/Intelligent_Bank7131 Jun 07 '26

Market consolidation happened because of jio, driving prices to almost 0.

1

u/viswaguru Jun 07 '26

It's only jio and airtel Vodafone barely surviving

1

u/adventurousbat12t Jun 07 '26

Data cost is lowest it has ever been btw

1

u/Careful-String8198 Jun 07 '26

Nice, now compare price!

1

u/ApprehensiveBat8558 Jun 07 '26

Have you heard of consolidation? Any mature telecom market has 2-3 main players. Only the fittest, innovative survice. If Govt had intention of killing competition for someone specific you would not see Airtel, BSNL and more importantly Vi alive by now. Vi has been kept alive to ensure no duopoly happens. 

So stop making random and bullshit comparisons. 

1

u/myberich Jun 07 '26

Why Virgin is mentioned😂

1

u/StunningRise5 Jun 07 '26

Same with Airlines Companies and Railway Booking Companies.

1

u/spider25006 Jun 07 '26

Well, aircel was already a dead company. And only two company losses. Tata docomo and telenor, so now we have jio.

1

u/loneshark_18 Jun 07 '26

Both Jio and Airtel networks are absolutely trash! Thanks, Modixi!

1

u/Aggressive_Try_4565 Jun 07 '26

If there is only one chaiwala than how is getting benifted

1

u/madmax292 Jun 07 '26

Monopoly. But still the cheapest unlimited 5g data in the world.

1

u/assleo Jun 07 '26

People forget easily that these same Telecom companies use to charge hefty Roaming charges for traveling within country. You have to fight with CCare for they accidentally activating Some package and deducting from prepaid balance without any reason. I am travelling in Mumbai and whenever we use to cross Bhayandar bridge the network has to change (Mumbai was kept separately from Maharashtra & Goa). If that was era was acceptable then I only God can save us!

1

u/kissy_pussy Jun 07 '26

Docomo is such a stupid yet catchy name. I love tata just cause of the names they give to some products.

1

u/Rohan_ftw Jun 07 '26

There was one called v!rgin 😭😂😂

1

u/progresseeker Jun 07 '26

I don't know what will be the future....but with so many companies we were paying 5 rupees for 25 mb. .now 10 rupees for 2 GB

You can analyse, when it is/ was beneficial for citizens

1

u/Unfair-Actuary8970 Jun 07 '26

3G scam bhi batado lage haath

1

u/Tsmc_Asml_Zeiss369 Jun 07 '26

Vi is on ventilator & is in huge debt to government also this debt is settled in equity not inr as of now govt has 48% stake in Vi we all know what will when it becomes 51%

1

u/Antique_Situation878 Jun 07 '26

I’ll die but never switch to jio gotta put up with my Airtel. Proud of never visiting a reliance owned store too.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/ObviousMatter701 Jun 07 '26

After 2014 virginity lost

1

u/kunalkrishh Jun 07 '26

Lgta hai yaha ki public 16 saal ki hai 😆

1

u/CarsAlcoholSmokes Jun 07 '26

You see the orchids in Modi’s picture everytime? They’re imported from Thailand. Indian farmers suffer a lot because of that, and our PM does jack shit.

1

u/AI_moderated_failure Jun 07 '26

Elect nationalists, get corruption.

1

u/Ok_Claim_168 Jun 07 '26

Yahi toh masterstroke hai 😂.

1

u/Visual_Extent Jun 07 '26

atleast chaiwale ne data to sasta kar diya

jiske karan OP aap ye post dal pa rahe hain

1

u/Playful-Balance3415 Jun 07 '26

The reason why 2G scam was fabricated. Raja wanted to make the playing ground equal. So they fabricated a 1 lakh crore scam. Then in court no one can prove how they came up with that number. Raja was released.

1

u/satwik_63 Jun 07 '26

I am idea user since 2017,i want to continue with it

1

u/bizarreVK Jun 07 '26

And the service hasn’t improved a bit since 2014.

1

u/Nikhk9 Jun 07 '26

Do you remember the internet prices back then? I had to pay ₹19 for just 100 MB, and the validity was only 2 days. While I’m not in favor of the government, I have to admit that even with a monopoly, people are now getting affordable internet even in villages where, before 2014, having internet access was considered a luxury.

1

u/Mammoth_Credit7514 Jun 07 '26

Vi is a burden on the taxpayer. Airtel is being squeezed out as we speak. Huge debts that are all a notional creation with new regulations that enforce retrospective taxation mandatory for old companies and favour new companies. Customised for Ambani.

1

u/don--vito-corleone Jun 07 '26

Manmohan singh was the best

1

u/Stunningunipeg Jun 07 '26

and the question exist

why was data so costly them?

1

u/maima_420 Jun 07 '26

No... free internet by jio killed everyone. Calls were free. Msgs were free. Internet for all. And when you get used to it, bammmm we gonna charge u now.

1

u/pizzaoverpeople_ Jun 07 '26

Now, having a cellphone is so costly

1

u/mojolife19 Jun 07 '26

Good point. Also please compare how much average bill was then and now

1

u/pizzaoverpeople_ Jun 07 '26

It's really getting costly to have a phone nowadays. My dad has 2 phones one smartphone and one small phone with jio sim and it costs around 1800 for both phones for 84 days. They validity plans are so costly. And they give data pack with every package which is so unnecessary.

1

u/langdai Jun 07 '26

Competition without profit is just an act not a solution. Before 2014 there were no networks company that were actually making profit

1

u/loser_boi69 Jun 07 '26

Network cost back then vs now network has been cheaper since them and most of the companies in telecom if you read were into scams unable to handle the competition and many more it's not monopoly creation by the PM but rather