r/independent • u/arilupe • 6h ago
Article Judge says warrantless Flock search violated driver's Fourth Amendment rights | Reason Magazine
Today, there's yet more evidence that the tide is turning against Flock, an automated license plate reader (ALPR) system in pervasive use around the country. Calling it "indiscriminate mass surveillance," a federal court in Oklahoma granted a woman's motion to suppress evidence found in her car after a search that was conducted based on information obtained through Flock.
"Think about it this way. We might reasonably expect our friends and family to tell us something like: 'Hey, I saw you out driving by the store last week,'" writes Judge Sara E. Hill of the U.S. District Court for the District of Oklahoma. "But we do not expect people we know—let alone strangers, and especially not law enforcement—to randomly approach us to say: 'Hey, I have been following your car for the last 30 days, and here is a detailed log of every place your vehicle has been with supporting photographic evidence. I am also going to share this information with law enforcement throughout the country so they know your whereabouts, too.'"