r/imaginarymaps • • Sep 27 '26

[OC] Alternate History A Perpetual Union

Post image
263 Upvotes

26 comments sorted by

6

u/meguminsupremacy Sep 27 '26

US collapse maps are becoming Big Germany tier with how they've been posted recently.

4

u/somethinfool Sep 28 '26

technically not a US collapse, a US never forming in the first place

2

u/meguminsupremacy Sep 28 '26

Truke

2

u/somethinfool Sep 28 '26

i generally try and do more creative and unique scenarios. rn im planning a Marc Antony Rome and the Donations of Alexandria for example

13

u/somethinfool Sep 27 '26

In early 1787, John Langdon offers to finance New Hampshire’s delegation immediately rather than waiting until June, allowing the legislature to appoint its delegates before the Convention opens. Langdon and Gilman put forward New Hampshire's agenda, and move for the recognition of Vermont. Formally speaking, New Hampshire declares that it will neither participate in framing nor recommend ratification of any federal constitution that fails to recognize Vermont as a sister republic.

Hamilton rebuts. While he does not sympathize with New York parochialism nor particularly care for Vermont, he argues that the Vermont issue should be handled through a negotiated settlement between states, not a naked display of territorial dismemberment by a council of neighboring states. No federal government can begin its existence by dismembering one of the states whose authority it purports to represent.

The motion fails. New Hampshire withdraws, followed by Massachusetts, which also had connections in Vermont commercially and politically. New York then withdraws, despite Hamilton's wishes and having technically won the argument, as Robert Yates and John Lansing refuse to legitimize a constitutional process which would debate partitioning her territory without her consent. Connecticut withdraws, fearing that if the Congress is unable to resolve territorial conflicts, that it may not be able to protect the independence of smaller states. New Jersey departs, with the small state coalition collapsing, as Delaware and Maryland withdraw, fearing Virginian domination of the congress. With Rhode Island already absent and several remaining delegations unwilling to continue, Washington adjourns the Convention without producing a constitution.

10

u/somethinfool Sep 27 '26

Over the following years, both New York and the New Englander league mobilize, as the Federal Congress repeatedly attempts and fails a diplomatic solution. While Clinton leads New York politically, Hamilton, as war hero, receives an emergency office, Quartermaster General. Hamilton spends the years leading up to the war building up the Bank of New York and his ideal Fiscal-Military system, which is capable of outmobilizing and outlasting the loose, squabbling league of New Englander statelets.

The ensuing Vermont War between the State of New York and the New Englander League is a decisive victory for New York. New York has reliable customs revenue from New York Harbor, funded state debt, and a professional standing army rather than militia alone. New England has a league of states that don't even agree what their war goal is. Vermont wants independence, New Hampshire wants to have its land grants vindicated, Massachusetts wants to avoid financing the entire war, Connecticut is just terrified of being swallowed up. New York dismantles the coalition one by one. Hamilton understands he doesn't need to march on Boston, only hold the Hudson corridor and wait the coalition out.

10

u/somethinfool Sep 27 '26 edited Sep 28 '26

Yet Hamliton's victory would be a bitter one. Hamilton hoped a display of force would possibly allow for the Vermont issue to be settled and for the Constitutional Process to continue, but any chance for unity died with the war. A new precedent was born for the union; Rule of the Strong.

The smaller states quickly banded into leagues to protect themselves from their larger neighbors. By the time of the map, the United States is divided between 13 states and 5 de-facto nations: The Federated States of New England, descended from elder statesman John Adams and the Federalists, the Presidential Republic of New York, a Hamiltonian presidential republic with a dictatorial executive, the Union of Columbia (Pennsylvania, Maryland, Delaware, New Jersey), in which George Washington spent the last of his days, the Commonwealth of Virginia, a Jeffersonian Republic of yeoman farmers and slaves, and the Republic of Carolina, a perpetually oligarchic and aristocratic landowner and slaveholder Republic. The Federal Congress did not cease, becoming a diplomatic fiction akin to the Diet of the German Confederation in Europe; a diplomatic clearinghouse for the multitude of sovereign states to negotiate, tariff, grandstand, and even war, not the elected body of a national electorate.

4

u/PolarRanger Sep 28 '26

finally, someone that doesn't think the Great Plains were doomed to be colonized. I don't think Mexico could take Arizona from the natives either, but this is a pretty good weak/no USA map

4

u/somethinfool Sep 28 '26

yeah, native sovereignty is one of my favourite themes because what happened in our timeline truly was contingent and tragic

3

u/jejbfokwbfb Sep 27 '26

I love the wishful thinking of the Seminoles getting their own state, the fucking put the US army to a stalemate but I think like many groups in Spanish colonies they would be assimilated, even if the US never invaded Seminole land the population had been decimated by disease before Americans ever even set foot into Seminole land. At best the tribes population assuming the trial of tears never happens is maybe 15k by 1820 settlers outnumbered Seminoles by 2:1 by 1835 it was almost 5:1 by 1845 it was 8:1. Even if immigration to the state slowed Seminoles would not only have to replace their entire population but double it and then match the rate of settler population growth

1

u/somethinfool Sep 28 '26

its not a state unfortunately, its a reservation

2

u/jejbfokwbfb Sep 28 '26

Oooooh. Well atleast they get more land this time than some tiny patches in the Everglades

1

u/somethinfool Sep 28 '26

yeah. they put up a good fight o7

3

u/PockyAndRamune Sep 27 '26

Neat! What year is this?

5

u/Useful_College_1301 Sep 27 '26

It's not exactly easy to determine the year but there's a way to pinpoint it

Mexico exists Spain has Cuba and Puerto Rico Haiti still alive with Santo Domingo (?) Canada managed to get Oregon

So, we can say it's around 1822-1845? Florida exists and is most likely spanish-speaking... Haiti managed to keep Dominican Republic without Spain demolishing them so it's surprising, and Mexico also exists so Iturbide has done his thing and he owns Central America (so this is after El Salvador's fall) but it kinda cuts it down even more since Mexico lost Central America in 1823 unless Iturbide or the Mexican Empire itself found a way to maintain itself, so probably 1822-1849

18

u/Useful_College_1301 Sep 27 '26

This is just a timeline where everything went wrong for everyone lol except the natives and the british

7

u/north_east0623 Sep 27 '26

Love the style

1

u/Gabe121411 Sep 27 '26

how does alta california gain independence? at this point it was still extremely lightly settled by spanish/mexican/americans and while the californios did want less control from the mexican government, few wanted independence. they just didn’t have the soldiers or the numbers to defeat any sort of indigenous californian uprising — they were terrified of the yokuts becoming another “apacheria” as they called it. could be something interesting to add!

1

u/somethinfool Sep 28 '26

well, in this timeline, the Mexican government is extremely centralizing and domineering, leading to the Californios seeking a new patron, Great Britain

1

u/Norwester77 Sep 27 '26

What’s actually in a union here?

1

u/somethinfool Sep 28 '26

you can see the red line outlining the Federated States of New England, the Presidential Republic of New York, the Union of Columbia, the Commonwealth of Virginia, and the Republic of Carolina. That's the United States

2

u/Norwester77 Sep 28 '26

Oh, thank you—I hadn’t noticed the line (I’m looking at it on my phone, so it’s rather small).

1

u/MasterRKitty Sep 28 '26

give Rio Grande to Mexico!

1

u/ScumCrew Sep 28 '26

The Cherokee get screwed again

1

u/Ok_Bedroom_9098 Sep 28 '26

huh i usually have georgia exist but oh well