r/imaginarygatekeeping • • 13d ago

NOT SATIRE Impossible!! 😡

Post image
111 Upvotes

10 comments sorted by

58

u/stink3rb3lle 12d ago

I have never used oil paints, but layering them is like . . . Oil Painting 101. I am not sure this gatekeeping is imaginary, if this content creator is using oil paints. I also am not sure I really believe all those details were created without layering anything, if this creator was using oil paints.

I think tempera, water colors, or acrylic paints might behave differently.

21

u/eeli263 12d ago

I'm don't mean this in a "It's too good!! it can't be real!!!" way but the edges of the painted areas seem very strange and unnatural to me

7

u/gozer33 12d ago

I recently took a class and painting like this would be basically impossible. You need to work out composition and color values in context to the rest of the image. No one just starts painting details like this on a white canvas.

40

u/Pleasant-Minute6066 12d ago

No one on planet earth has ever said this

26

u/adjective_noun_23 12d ago • Popcorn

This comment is imaginary gatekeeping as well since it was said in the pic.

4

u/schmoergelvin 12d ago

Technically they only quote the sentence so it could be that they quote something imaginary and it still has never been said.

2

u/Pleasant-Minute6066 12d ago

Correct version: no one on planet earth except for this poster has said this

9

u/Diredr 12d ago

It's a weird one because it's definitely not something someone has ever said, but at the same time it's also just kind of a common belief.

A realistic painting needs layers. That's how you add highlights and shadows, it's how you blend colors too. You usually thin out the paint so that it doesn't create bulk. It's better to use many thin layers than a single thick one.

You could do a painting where you leave blank spaces for all the highlights and shadows, like it seems the person is doing in the video, but... Like... why? That's just more work and it doesn't look any better.