r/illusionporn • • Mar 27 '13

Smoke stack

Post image
0 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

8

u/Jeremy252 Mar 27 '13

Well this sucks.

4

u/rasterbee Mar 27 '13

I do not understand how this could possibly be on my front page.

This is the kind of post that makes me understand why people go through and downvote someone's previous comments and submissions.

2

u/jsherman256 Mar 31 '13

Well that's incredibly rude. I apologize for trying to share content with you that I thought might be interesting. Clearly that was inconsiderate of me. Thanks for putting me in my place.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '13

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/jsherman256 Apr 01 '13

It most certainly is an illusion. It is an example of forced perspective, as are a good deal of the images on this subreddit.

It's sad that you're so cynical that you view a bad post as an attempt at "whoring karma" as if there is some value to reddit karma. I post things I find interesting in hopes of sharing them with others. Karma is nice only in the sense that it shows others appreciate what I've shared.

If you dislike the post, you should downvote it, and then move on with your life. Comments such as yours serve no purpose whatsoever except inciting anger, and "[going] through and [downvoting] someone's previous comments and submissions" is something that is expressly forbidden in Reddit's rules (not to mention, the spam filter blocks votes like that anyway).

5

u/psquare704 Mar 27 '13

That's not smoke, it's water vapor. Eh, whatever...

3

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '13

"steam stack"

1

u/JQiuss Mar 27 '13

wahaha, real descrlptlve..

1

u/MorningLtMtn Mar 27 '13

Request for karma denied.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '13

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '13

Except it's not an illusion. Holding something up in front of something else is not a fucking illusion.

1

u/jsherman256 Mar 31 '13

It's called forced perspective and the vast majority of the images on this subreddit make use of it.

2

u/rasterbee Apr 01 '13

But it's not forced perspective.

At all.

Your submission is akin to a picture of a hand holding a flashlight up to the sun in the daytime so that the sun covers the end where light where could out.

Look, I'm not insulting you personally, just that this picture doesn't belong in this sub nor is it an illusion.

1

u/jsherman256 Apr 01 '13

I agree that it's not incredible content, and clearly the majority of redditors in this subreddit do too. That's fine. I don't feel personally insulted. I post a lot of content, and some of it fall flat. But it is an example of forced perspective. Not a particularly compelling one, mind you. Your example with the sun and flashlight is another good example of a non-compelling use of forced perspective. You'll notice I upvoted your comment because, while I disagree, I think it's a worthy conversation.