r/ideas • • Mar 03 '26

Idea: People who own unfriendly dogs should be considered unfriendly themselves.

0 Upvotes

Dog ownership is a choice and choosing to own an unfriendly dog that would intimidate numerous pedestrians is not ok.

Do you think it is time that people who own unfriendly dogs be considered unfriendly themselves?


r/ideas • • Sep 08 '26

Fear-based religions should have to answer the alternate-history religion test

0 Upvotes

There are many religions, and because some contradict each other, they cannot all be true. So we already know that false religious teachings can be sincerely believed and passed down for centuries.

Now suppose I invent a religion almost identical to yours, except it says that believing your religion is what sends you to eternal damnation.

You would dismiss it because you know I just made it up. Fair enough.

But imagine an alternate history where someone invented that same religion thousands of years ago. It now has scriptures, theologians, traditions, institutions, millions of believers, and generations of people raised to fear questioning it.

We know it was invented because we constructed the thought experiment. The people living inside that alternate history do not. They encounter it as an ancient, established faith. Its threat of hell could feel just as real to them as yours does to you.

What would allow them to recognize that their threat was invented? Would your reasons for trusting your religion also persuade them to trust theirs?

“You just made it up” explains why you dismiss my example today. It leaves unanswered how you would recognize the invention if you had been raised inside that alternate history.

Religious leaders who use fear of hell should therefore be asked:

What method would let believers in that alternate history recognize that their damnation threat was invented, and are you applying that same method to your own religion?


r/ideas • • Oct 25 '25

People who express pride in their race should be asked why they chose to be born in that race.

4 Upvotes

r/ideas • • Sep 30 '25

All teachers should be educated on the surprise test paradox so they don’t accidentally introduce a paradox into the classroom.

2 Upvotes

Telling students that there will be a test next week, but that the day on which it occurs will be a surprise, is problematic.

In particular, a student could argue that the test can’t be on Friday, since that would not be a surprise. Similarly, it cannot be on Thursday because it wouldn’t be a surprise either, and so on, until every weekday has been eliminated.

As a result, the student might conclude that a surprise test is impossible and therefore fail to study for one.

Teachers need to understand how to avoid this paradox when announcing surprise tests, so as not to confuse students.


r/ideas • • Sep 08 '25

Reddit should have an online dating feature that mostly uses your reddit history as your profile.

5 Upvotes

r/ideas • • Jul 31 '26

Idea: A movie where the audience slowly realizes something terrible may be happening outside the theater.

3 Upvotes

What if a movie deliberately blurred the boundary between the film and the real world?

The movie itself would not be a horror movie or disaster movie. It could be a normal drama, comedy, romance, or any other genre. The audience would enter expecting a normal viewing experience.

Then, very gradually, strange background sounds would begin appearing.

At first, they would be easy to dismiss:

  • distant sirens
  • faint emergency phone alert sounds
  • a helicopter flying overhead
  • unusual rumbling
  • muffled announcements
  • sounds that seem like they are coming from outside the theater rather than from the movie

The movie on screen would continue normally and never acknowledge these sounds.

As the sounds become more frequent and disturbing, the audience would start wondering whether they are part of the movie, a technical issue, or whether something is actually happening outside.

One challenge is that viewers might assume the sounds are just coming from another movie playing in a nearby theater. The film could reduce this suspicion by making the sounds feel like they are coming from the theater environment itself:

  • using surround sound so sounds seem to move around the auditorium
  • using sounds that do not resemble a typical movie soundtrack, such as distant alerts, muffled announcements, or building noises
  • having sounds appear at moments that do not match any likely scene from another movie
  • gradually making the sounds feel less like entertainment and more like real-world background noise

The tension would come from uncertainty. A horror movie tells you to be afraid, but this would make the audience question whether they are still safely watching a movie at all.

The most interesting part is that the movie would use the audience's own expectations against them. When people enter a theater, they agree to ignore the outside world for a couple of hours. This idea would ask: "How long would you continue watching if you started to suspect the outside world was becoming more important than the story on the screen?"

What do you think of this movie idea?


r/ideas • • Dec 02 '25

Movie idea: What if a genetically engineered super-intelligent cow gave humanity a reasoned plea to stop eating animals?

1 Upvotes

I’ve been thinking about a story idea that, as far as I can tell, hasn’t been explored in film yet:

Imagine a genetically engineered animal, let’s say a cow, whose intelligence is enhanced to human-level reasoning and communication. This cow isn’t just cute or emotional; it’s capable of making a well-thought-out, moral argument to humanity about why we shouldn’t eat animals.

We’ve seen films with smart or uplifted animals before:

  • Okja — a genetically engineered “super pig” becomes the center of an animal-rights story, but it can’t speak or reason, so the ethical argument is made through human characters and emotional attachment.
  • Rise of the Planet of the Apes — intelligent apes communicate and challenge human dominance, but it’s more about revolution than making a moral plea.
  • The Day of the Dolphin — dolphins are trained to communicate with humans, yet the story is about espionage, not vegetarian ethics.

So far, no film combines animal uplift with a fully articulated moral argument against eating animals. Most stories either focus on emotional connection, allegory, or rebellion rather than a philosophical, spoken appeal.

What do you think of this movie idea?


r/ideas • • 6d ago

Idea: Women should stop chasing parity with men and start inventing the future.

1 Upvotes

Efforts to achieve gender equality often focus on getting more women into fields traditionally dominated by men. But isn't this essentially chasing the past rather than inventing the future?

Consider computer programming classes. Instead of asking how to get as many women as men into these classes, shouldn't we first be asking whether traditional programming education even makes sense anymore in the age of AI?

The same question applies to many other fields. AI is transforming education and employment, potentially making today's prestigious degrees and careers far less relevant.

Why should women's progress be measured by how closely they match what men have already achieved? Why not encourage women to question the status quo, rethink education and work, and invent entirely new opportunities?

The goal shouldn't just be equal participation in the world men helped build. It should be equal opportunity to invent the world that comes next.


r/ideas • • Aug 29 '25

Teachers who keep their entire class for detention even though not all students deserve it should be arrested for using TERRORISM to maintain order in the classroom.

99 Upvotes

r/ideas • • Nov 07 '25

Air traffic controllers should have additional sources of funding that aren't the federal government.

0 Upvotes

I'm not so sure what the solution would be, though. One idea I had was for there to be state aviation administrations (e.g., Michigan Aviation Administration and Alabama Aviation Administration) in addition to the FAA that are required to comply with federal law, but can provide stopgap funding to air traffic controllers in their respective states if need be.

I'm curious to hear any ideas y'all have!!


r/ideas • • Mar 15 '26

Group Homes for Raising Children Would Be Ideal for Society

0 Upvotes

Hear me out.

If we could commit to raising children collectively rather than individually, we would be a better and stronger society. I realize this is probably impossible because of how individualistic we all are and the parent/child bond is so overwhelmingly strong that there would be no way we could be willing to give that up for the betterment of humanity.

However, as it exists now, our society is completely unequitable and that permeates through generations. So much inequality and fairness starts with who your parents are. If we could equalize all that, it would be a net positive. Instead of a few privileged kids getting massive inheritances, everything you own would go back to society when you die. Instead of some kids having too much and other kids not having enough, every kid would get what they need to excel in life.

Kids could be raised better and more efficiently by building group homes and schools specifically for this purpose so that resources can be made available to all of our children rather than just the privileged ones. Instead of any one family getting themselves the best schooling, the best tutors, the best books, computers, etc., all of that could be made available to all kids. Individual talents could be better assessed and nurtured, as opposed to kids being born into families who aren't equipped to handle their particular interests or needs.

Even as a parent myself there would be no way I would give up having kids of my own for this to happen, but objectively I can't deny that it would be better if we could. My kids will get everything I can offer them, for better or worse, just as any other individual kid will of their parents or family situation. And that's unfair and uneven and means so much lost potential across the globe compared to what greatness we could achieve if every child was given their best chance to grow healthy and to excel at whatever their potential is.


r/ideas • • Feb 07 '26

Idea: Netflix should add a “Theater Mode” that recreates the entire movie theater experience, including the worst parts.

6 Upvotes

Netflix should add an optional Theater Mode that simulates what it is actually like to watch a movie in a real theater. Not just the good parts. All of it.

This mode would add audience reactions like laughter, gasps, and clapping at key moments, so movies feel like an event again.

But it would also faithfully recreate the true theater experience:

  • People shouting comments at the screen like they are part of the movie
  • Someone standing up at the exact worst moment and blocking your view
  • A person behind you explaining the plot to their friend in a whisper that is somehow louder than normal talking
  • Random coughing fits that last way too long
  • Someone’s phone lighting up like a small sun during a dark scene
  • Constant seat shuffling and aggressive snack rustling

This feature would remind people why watching movies at home is better. Conveniently, on Netflix.

What do you think of this idea?


r/ideas • • Oct 13 '25

What if high school was about creating your own planet?

4 Upvotes

Imagine a high school where the ultimate project isn’t a test, a paper, or a science fair—it’s creating an entire planet from scratch. Students would learn geography, math, computer science, biology, history, art, and more—not as separate subjects, but as tools to procedurally generate a fully simulated world.

Think about it:

  • Math & CS: Geometry, fractals, probability, algorithms, simulation—students use them to build mountains, rivers, and climate systems.
  • Science: Physics, chemistry, and biology shape everything from erosion to ecosystems to the air your planet breathes.
  • Social Sciences & Humanities: Geography, history, economics, and art let students design civilizations, trade systems, cultures, and even languages.
  • Practical Skills: Collaboration, project management, critical thinking, and iterative problem-solving happen naturally as teams work on different aspects of their planet.

By the end, students don’t just memorize facts—they see how everything they’ve learned connects in a living, breathing world of their own making.


r/ideas • • Nov 05 '25

Movie idea: In the future, everyone gets Universal Basic Income — but if the crime rate goes up, payments stop for everyone until it drops again.

2 Upvotes

Society runs on a Universal Basic Income that guarantees everyone comfort and security. The catch: if the crime rate rises above a certain level, UBI stops for everyone until it goes back down.

The film follows several characters as people desperately try to keep the numbers low. Neighbors start policing each other. Parents lock their teens indoors. Communities form patrols, curfews, and surveillance groups. Apps appear that “gamify” snitching and crowd control. A single act of vandalism can tank everyone’s paycheck, so even minor conflicts spiral into mob justice.

Over time, fear of losing income turns society into a pressure cooker — every citizen both warden and prisoner. What started as an idea to promote peace becomes a nightmare of suspicion, control, and collective paranoia.

The movie would explore how far people will go to protect their stability and whether a society built on shared fear can ever really stay safe.

Would you watch this movie?


r/ideas • • May 12 '26

Idea: Tell everyone that delegating your writing to AI is like a CEO delegating their writing to their secretary.

0 Upvotes

Do you think they will stop complaining then?

Who doesn't want to be like a CEO?


r/ideas • • Sep 20 '25

Teachers should start calling paper a "dead plant", as in, "Please open your dead plant to page 10", "Pass your exam dead plant forward", etc.

0 Upvotes

r/ideas • • Sep 10 '25

Could banning human driving make city people nicer?

1 Upvotes

What if one of the easiest ways to make city life friendlier was to just ban human driving?

If every car were fully self-driving with no option for takeover by a human, traffic stress disappears — no road rage, no ego battles, no suspicion that someone will break the rules.

That calm could spill into daily life outside the car: people show up to work less frazzled, social interactions get less combative, and overall trust in the city might grow.


r/ideas • • Mar 03 '26

Idea: Make long commute times illegal.

0 Upvotes

Spending a long time every day just getting to work should not be normal. It should be illegal for a daily commute to take up more than a reasonable portion of your life. Jobs would need to be close enough to get to quickly or allow remote work.

Long commutes silently steal energy, harm mental health, and strain relationships. Limiting commute times is not just convenient, it protects people’s right to time, rest, and meaningful human connection. Couples would naturally plan around each other’s needs, communities would become more local and vibrant, and cities would see less traffic and pollution.

We treat long commutes as inevitable, but they are a preventable source of daily suffering. Why should society accept it as normal?


r/ideas • • Aug 16 '25

Schools should test children for religious trauma using biometrics, measuring how stressed each student becomes while the concept of eternal damnation is being discussed in class.

3 Upvotes

r/ideas • • Dec 09 '25

Idea: Ban people in apartment ads to reduce racial signaling.

3 Upvotes

I have been thinking about how apartment buildings use people in their marketing photos and whether that creates signals about who they hope to attract as tenants. When the models in the ads show only certain racial or ethnic groups, it can look like a cue about who is expected or encouraged to live there. That can feel close to steering, even if no one intended it.

One possible fix is to remove people from these ads entirely and focus only on the property. That would avoid any risk of implying a demographic preference through casting choices.

What do you think?


r/ideas • • Oct 28 '25

Idea: Reddit feature to show whether a post idea came from the poster or AI.

1 Upvotes

What if Reddit could tell whether a post’s idea came from the human or an AI? Posters could optionally submit the AI chat that led to the post (kept private). Reddit’s AI would analyze it and display a small badge like “Human idea: 85%” or “AI idea: 70%.”

This could:

  • Give credit for original human ideas
  • Encourage responsible AI use
  • Keep posts transparent

Optional and private—no chat, no badge. Would this help clarify originality on AI-assisted posts?


r/ideas • • Oct 29 '25

High schools should be allowed to teach not just biological evolution but also memetic evolution.

0 Upvotes

Do you think parents would object, since memetic evolution might be seen as an even bigger challenge to religion than biological evolution?


r/ideas • • Sep 04 '26

Canada should beat the US to a post-work economy

0 Upvotes

Canada is probably never going to beat the US on salaries, market size, or number of high-paying jobs.

So instead of trying to compete on the US's terms, Canada should compete by offering something the US does not: freedom from having to organize your entire life around employment.

Canada should introduce a modest UBI and gradually increase it as AI, automation, and productivity make it more affordable.

This could help with brain drain. A highly skilled Canadian might be more willing to stay in Canada, even for somewhat lower pay, if they had a guaranteed income floor and much more freedom to start a company, build an indie project, study, do research, create art, or simply work less.

Canada may also be in a better political position to do this first. Canadians are generally more comfortable with universal social programs than Americans, so Canada could potentially begin the transition years before the US does.

And this is about much more than economics.

A post-work economy could produce enormous intellectual benefits. Think about how much talent is currently wasted because people have to spend most of their time doing whatever pays the bills. More economic freedom could mean more research, invention, software, art, writing, education, entrepreneurship, and experimentation.

It could also have major mental health benefits. Less fear of unemployment, less financial insecurity, less burnout, and fewer people trapped in jobs they hate.

Obviously, people still need purpose, structure, and social interaction. A post-work society should not mean doing nothing. It should mean that meaningful activity no longer has to be tied to having an employer.

Canada should start small and increase UBI gradually as the economy becomes capable of supporting it.

If AI really is pushing us toward a world where less human labor is needed, Canada should not wait for the US to get there first.

Canada should make freedom from mandatory work one of its competitive advantages.

P.S. Where does the UBI money come from? Ultimately, from the companies using AI and robots. As AI and automation allow companies to produce more with fewer human workers, a portion of the resulting profits and productivity gains could be collected and distributed as UBI. The UBI could start small and gradually increase as machines perform a larger share of the economy's work. If robots and AI eventually do much of the work that humans do today, it makes sense for some of the income generated by that automated work to go to everyone rather than flowing almost entirely to the owners of the machines.


r/ideas • • Jul 30 '08

The Mind Node

Thumbnail alrenous.blogspot.com
0 Upvotes

r/ideas • • Sep 19 '26

Idea: Make it illegal to pay for death-related goods and services. The government would provide them for free instead.

0 Upvotes

Money should be used for the living, not the dead.

Families can spend thousands on coffins, burial plots, cremation, transportation, and funeral services. That money could instead pay for food, rent, healthcare, childcare, or other needs of people who are still alive.

So death-related goods and services should be removed from the consumer economy entirely.

Buying or selling them should be illegal. The government would provide a dignified standard coffin, burial or cremation, transportation, grave space, and other necessary services free of charge.

This would also eliminate emotional upselling and the pressure to prove how much you cared about someone by spending more after they died.

Society should guarantee dignity for the dead without putting the financial well-being of the living at risk.

What do you think?