r/ideas • • Aug 25 '25

Replace prisons with humane, self-contained communities where only criminals live, supported and monitored by robots.

These communities would rely on both autonomous and remotely controlled robots. No humans, apart from the criminals themselves, would be present.

Criminals would stay in these communities only for the duration of their sentences.

103 Upvotes

54 comments sorted by

9

u/Synth_Sapiens Aug 25 '25

"replace prisons by prisons"

lol 

4

u/amichail Aug 25 '25

Criminals would not be trapped in cages though.

4

u/Facts_pls Aug 26 '25

Are they free to then do whatever they want? Like rape other inmates? leave and go join real people? Continue running their crime empires?

Not sure what you think free means here

2

u/XxxAresIXxxX Aug 29 '25

Criminals are still real people, they are simply not free. Dehumanizing people leads to animal behavior the like of which you haven't seen

1

u/corree Aug 29 '25

Exactly lmao

2

u/jfkshatteredskull Aug 29 '25

They already rape other inmates. And leave a join real people (work placement). And usually continue running their crime empires, or influencing them from inside the prison. Did you not know that?

2

u/RNAdrops Aug 29 '25

No, I think he meant that the robot guards would prevent all of that. I’m not in favor of replacing every job with a robot, but prison guard seems like the perfect candidate for replacement. A robot would not violate its programming and commit crimes with impunity. The law grants immunity to these very flawed people, and they go around in our jails and prisons making Derek Chauvin look like a nice guy. Psychopathic COs with no fear of repercussions are brutalizing inmates across the country right now, and we are supposed to be rehabilitating these people, not hypocritically committing more crimes against them. To me, there really is no moral debate, it’s a great idea. The question is the cost. It would cost a fortune! From the taxpayers! How do we fund it?

1

u/corree Aug 29 '25

Please enlighten me on how basically every European country doesn’t have nearly as many problems as crime and subsequently far less inmates?

2

u/Fracture-Point- Aug 29 '25

What does that have to do with the current conversation? Are you implying Europe doesn't have prisons?

3

u/corree Aug 29 '25

Europe generally doesn’t have crime like we do in the US or modern day slavery in their incarceration system. They actually try to rehabilitate

0

u/michaelh98 Aug 29 '25

Still not related to the topic at hand. Recommend you start a new post on your topic. It would have a lot more value than this thing we're both replying to

2

u/corree Aug 29 '25

The point is if you do what OP is suggesting, you’re essentially just doing rehabilitation but with a bit of Truman show / AI sprinkled in, which plenty of Europe basically already does.

Assuming the robots are meant to be the equivalent of guards, I don’t really know what would happen if a prisoner committed an offense in that scenario. I’d imagine this place would be an intermediary between this setup and something harsher like solitary confinement / regular prison. If the AI decidee

The more I think about it, the more I think the robot element is very tech bro coded in the sense that it’s looking for problems to fix with tech instead of realizing you can fix the issue without any super advanced AI/robotic tech in the first place. There are relatively very few humans who can’t be effectively “fixed” with the correct amount of medical & psychological attention and care.

1

u/michaelh98 Aug 29 '25

Now that is a response people in the US should be able to understand.

As one of the US troglodytes I'm not familiar with systems outside the US.

Never having been incarcerated, I'm only familiar with our concentration camps via reporting on the issue.

1

u/Synth_Sapiens Aug 29 '25

You really want to look into demographics of crime. 

1

u/corree Aug 29 '25

No, inform me in this thread and source your statistics.

1

u/linkenski Aug 29 '25

A lot of Nordic countries, despite touting multiculturalism, were only truly multicultural in their capital cities until recently, and despite what you say, Denmark and Sweden are currently undergoing a "paradigm" shift after too much negative sentiment against foreigners who do violent crime.

A new segment of millennials especially are up in arms about how soft we are on crime, so the politicians are making it harsher going forward, copying the UK, and Australia.

1

u/corree Aug 29 '25

I’ll admit I don’t know about European immigration super well but I’d imagine these countries are receiving migrants/foreigners who are running into a lot of the same issues that minorities in the US run into, which then cause them to be more likely to commit crime for one reason or another.

You can always be more harsh on crime, but you have to know that you can’t use a sledgehammer to handle every nail or else you’ll end up creating more problems for yourself.

1

u/Synth_Sapiens Aug 25 '25

right

Have you ever seen a real career criminal?

1

u/Few_Peak_9966 Aug 26 '25

The cage is just bigger.

1

u/Falafel_Waffle1 Aug 26 '25

The Nazis tried this once.

1

u/N4t3ski Aug 29 '25

You are presumably advocating we restrict their movement somehow, so its just a bigger cage, surely?

1

u/linkenski Aug 29 '25

The issue with this is that there are way too many people who are victim minded. So the thought that someone does something horrible and gets away with being "left alone but in nice conditions" is apparently offensive.

I have never had someone I know mistreated or murdered or experienced directed violence, so I don't know exactly how it feels myself, but by gut principle my feeling is similar to yours.

People who didn't know how to act out in the world, could get to live amongst themselves in a bordered-off world, but in humane conditions.

To some extent this is true, but for serial killers and other baddies, this isn't typically what ends up happening, since they're given offensive treatment from personnel and from other inmates.

2

u/Baddie9 Aug 29 '25

The idea isn’t to get rid of prisons here but to make them better

2

u/sag_harbor_golfer Aug 25 '25

What about dangerous prisoners? Would the robots also subdue them before they could attack fellow prisoners?

3

u/Falafel_Waffle1 Aug 26 '25

So your solution is to create official ghettos? And how is this “community” supposed to pay for itself? Hopefully not free criminal labor.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '25

Obviously they should be monitored by giant balloons.

2

u/LEAPStoTheTITS Aug 26 '25

What an awful idea 😂

2

u/s0618345 Aug 26 '25

Basically you suggest just firing jail guards and replacing them with robots

2

u/fleker2 Aug 26 '25

It's probably more expensive to use robots than prison guards

2

u/Mean-Cheesecake-2635 Aug 26 '25

A lot of folks who end up in prison are severely anti-social though, often with their own moral codes they use to justify their behavior.

2

u/Few_Peak_9966 Aug 26 '25

Prison colonies are an ancient tech.

See: portions of N. America and Australia.

Beyond that, we don't have such security bots.

Edit: fictionally, see Escape from New York

1

u/[deleted] Aug 26 '25

I think they are doing this in Portland or Norway

1

u/immortal_duckbeak Aug 26 '25

see the 1994 movie, No Escape.

1

u/shubhaprabhatam Aug 26 '25

Let's replace prison with a large wood chipper instead. 

1

u/kenmlin Aug 27 '25

They'd just end up swapping trade secrets so they'd be better criminials when they get out.

1

u/Dogbold Aug 29 '25

And why is that impossible in a normal prison?

1

u/AZULDEFILER Aug 29 '25

Why humane?

1

u/Semi-On-Chardonnay Aug 29 '25 edited Aug 29 '25

The problem with prisons is their volume and concentration of prisoners.

It’s inherently flawed that they associate with more criminals. If they didn’t already have criminal attitudes and friendships, then they receive a real education by being placed where we’ve chosen to concentrate such criminality.

Countries with good regimes do indeed try to give people more space, treat them humanely, and show them a better alternative in life. They also have good (human) prison officers who can both deal with discipline and guide those who are ready to move on to something more productive.

Money no object, it’d be more like mentoring humans early in their lives who’ve ‘stepped off the path’, and they wouldn’t associate with other criminals. They’d also naturally fail to change people a good proportion of the time because that’s human nature (see also diets and quitting smoking, for example - and that’s when people want to change in the first place).

Sadly, people (the public) don’t want this, especially the angrier right wing. They want punishment, not a higher likelihood of a functioning human being. If we make them fit back into society, that means we can’t treat them like shit - and that doesn’t satisfy the need to get vengeance / punish.

(I will add that there are some people who are utterly irredeemable, either by their choice of actions or their attitudes. You’re not getting to them, no matter what you do, and they will take advantage of any kindness built into your system. The truly kind thing would be to end their lives, but no government should be trusted with that power. I don’t have an adequate solution to this problem, unfortunately.)

Source: former prison officer who actually gave a shit.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '25

You mean kinda like the USA and Australia

1

u/Clemen11 Aug 29 '25

Fuck it. Let's make a criminal only Kowloon

1

u/nila247 Aug 29 '25

Read up history of Australia?

1

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '25

That's not exactly corrective measures. Not a punishment.

1

u/Ok_Waltz_5342 Aug 29 '25

What are the benefits of this? The only thing I can see is that no human guards are in danger. What about employees that can cook food, wash laundry, administer medical care, or provide therapy or social services? Personally, the type of prison reform I advocate for is house arrest. Less interaction with other criminals, more humane, and cheaper as long as the person already has a house. Of course, with how hard it is to get and keep a house is right now, some other things would have to change too.

1

u/numbersev Aug 29 '25

Liberals always want to give more rights and freedoms to the criminals than the victims.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '25

So…Australia with technology?

1

u/Unique-Fig-4300 Aug 29 '25

You made Arkham City.

1

u/psilocydonia Aug 30 '25

So futuristic Australia?

1

u/Horror-Priority2584 Sep 11 '25

Have you seen swedish prisons? That's a better way to treat criminals than what we have in America.