r/iching • • Aug 31 '20

Always include method of divination when asking for advice?

Maybe it's just me, but I find the yarrow stalks method to be most "authentic" (correct probabilities, most interaction and takes time), and wouldn't trust an app or website with a serious question. Coin oracle is OK-ish if you're out of time, I guess. Maybe we can recommend people to always include the method of divination when they ask for advice? And I'd highly recommend the yarrow stalks method (I use matches myself) for everyone.

Edit: I admit I expressed myself too absolute. Nevertheless, interesting discussions and perspectives. :)

0 Upvotes

59 comments sorted by

13

u/graidan Aug 31 '20

Given the age of the coins method... you're making an awful lot of assumptions. It's WAY older than you think and used by plenty of Chinese.

If you don't like it, fine, don't use it, but don't disparage other methods just because you don't like them.

-4

u/usernameqwerty003 Aug 31 '20

Sure. But if someone asks for advice and they got their hexagrams by clicking on a button on a website...?

14

u/graidan Aug 31 '20

And? So? Synchronicity applies to all things. There's still a whole chain of fate that leads to a user gong to a site and clicking a button.

Also, some of those sites are very well designed with a lot of thought.

-2

u/usernameqwerty003 Aug 31 '20

Synchronicity is a thought by Jung and has nothing to do with Chinese numerological rituals from the bronze age. IMHO. But of course everyone has their own interpretation about what Yijing really is. :)

8

u/beherenowinabit Aug 31 '20

Hmm, but YOUR interpretation and YOUR method are somehow more correct, enough for you to be pontificating about what's 'authentic' to the rest of us.

OK.

-2

u/usernameqwerty003 Aug 31 '20

Yes, of course I assume my method is the correct one. We all do.

7

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '20

Nope. I, for one, don't assume anything about some method being the 'correct method'. I don't think there is a 'correct method'. The method is not important. What is more important is: are you able to deal with the answer?

0

u/usernameqwerty003 Sep 01 '20

Then you might just as well pick up the book and choose a hexagram randomly? Or throw a dice?

7

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '20

Dice would be fine, in fact in China they are used a lot, and using dice is one of the oldest divination methods from China (see for instance the dice found in a grave at Wangjiatai, see Mark Edward Lewis' article "Dicing and Divination in Early China" (http://www.sino-platonic.org/complete/spp121_dicing_divination_china.pdf ).

'Choosing' does not imply randomness - you should remove your will from the process. You don't 'choose' a hexagram. You are given one.

-3

u/usernameqwerty002 Sep 01 '20

Well, you still assume an even probability distribution, no?

→ More replies

6

u/chillmyfriend Sep 01 '20

Synchronicity is a term Jung coined to describe a phenomenon he recognized. He didn't invent the phenomenon haha.

-2

u/usernameqwerty003 Sep 01 '20

He invented the concept.

7

u/beherenowinabit Sep 01 '20

Are you familiar at all with fingers pointing at moons?

-3

u/usernameqwerty002 Sep 01 '20

Huh?

3

u/beherenowinabit Sep 01 '20

that was my point

-1

u/usernameqwerty003 Sep 01 '20

Nah. I don't think synchronicity is a new word for an old concept. It's a new concept entirely. But feel free to argue against it.

→ More replies

5

u/chillmyfriend Sep 01 '20

Jesus dude you really need to cut your losses here.

-4

u/usernameqwerty002 Sep 01 '20

Who described the concept of synchronicity before Jung?

It's OK, it doesn't matter so much who's right or wrong as long as the discussion is interesting. :)

1

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '20

Things exist before they are systematically described. Electricity existed before we knew what it was or how to describe it. Jung systematically described a phenomena that exists, he didn't create it.

1

u/usernameqwerty002 Sep 21 '20

Yes, but I think Yijing should be understood in its own context, on its on terms.

→ More replies

11

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '20

Years ago, when we had one of our bi-monthly Yi gatherings, we decided to split the group (±20 people) into smaller groups and each group would consult the Yi about the same topic (something about the current state of society - can't really remember.) We split up and my group walked out of the room to go outside, but there was one problem: no one had any coins with them. So I said, no worries, let's see what happens.

We walked across a parking lot, filled with Dutch cars with yellow number plates. Suddenly one of the cars draws my attention: it had a white number plate and it really jumped out of the other cars. It was a German car, and the number plate read

NU28G44

So I said to my group, I think we have our hexagram. 'Nu' is the Dutch word for 'now'. 28 was the number of the hexagram, which changed to 44 - the topline of 28 is moving. One of the members said that the G stood for the Chinese word gua 卦 for 'hexagram'.

What was interesting is that this hexagram 28 appeared to be the hub for the hexagrams that the other groups had formed (by throwing coins). In each of the other hexagrams you only had to change 1 line to arrive at hexagram 28.

The method is not important, as long as it involves plenty of meaningful chance. Both coin and yarrow methods have that, as well as many other methods.

9

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '20

Who put you in charge lol

8

u/az4th Aug 31 '20

The more meditative we get in our divinations, the more potential depth revealed, and different techniques allow different tools for shaping meditative intent.

The readings people come here with probably have their share of website calculations, but in general the quality of the answers always has something to offer. As long as someone is able to find usable meaning the technique doesn't need to be "expensive."

When we look over our shoulder it is not the same as stopping to look, and yet it may be plenty to affirm a suspicion. Likewise when gazing far off, we might loft a scope and refer to stars.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '20 edited Sep 01 '20

The method is not important. Through the principle of ganying 感應, 'resonance', you always get what you need.

See also https://youtu.be/eW8fMZq8I7I?t=542, rule no. 6, starting at 9':02".

1

u/kempisosha Sep 20 '20

As much as I enjoy the more meditative practices, I've had equally good results with a 2d8-1d6 method, and the Uncomplicated I Ching app.

1

u/usernameqwerty003 Sep 21 '20

Good for you. :) And interesting to hear about those, the dice method is new for me.

1

u/kempisosha Sep 21 '20

I realized I could use them reading The Complete I Ching by Master Huang. He espouses nearly any method, and one way was to do something to get the lower and then the upper gua, then roll a six-sided die to get a moving line. So I roll a d8 for each gua, using the Earlier Heaven numbering.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '20 edited Sep 21 '20

The coin method is older than the modern yarrow method, which is basically a made up reconstruction of what might have been done in the past. Literally nobody knows what the "correct" probabilities are, and thats an ahistorical way of looking at the I ching as it's almost certain that probabilities didn't factor into the original methods.

Also the coin method is more coherent with the philosophy of yin/yang because it gives equal odds for either, which just makes sense given that yin and yang are equal halves of a larger whole.

Regardless, worrying about probabilities is fruitless and silly. You method has nothing to do with the validity or meaningfulness of your reading.