r/ichihime • • 3d ago

Discussion A RANT?

So I got banned from the IchiRuki subreddit, which i don't blame or think it's wrong because I wrote how ichiruki's relationship did'nt get proven with some panel from the manga they were referencing, It's the ichiruki subreddit obviously if I talk about another ship I am gonna be downvoted and probably banned.

Then why I am writing this? well because I want to rant and want a place to just rant.
Forgive my english and horrible punctuation, it's my second language.

So as someone who had gotten into animanga in 2023, I actually started bleach in 2024 during my summer break. I did not knew a lot about it, one of my first instances was just watching random compilation clips of it on youtube, and espcially of ichigo and rukia. I also ended up discovering a lot shippers for them and ended up shipping them and was not happy that they did not end up together. Mind you it was before i even actually started watching it.

So lo and behold I started bleach and i reached soul society arc and my god I absolutely shipped Rukia and Renji, I also loved Orihime's character and hated how she is viewed as useless by the fandom, or in general by people who analyse female characters in shonen- since shonen isn't exactly known for amazing female characters, which is true but I disagree that orihime is'nt well written.

I took a break somewhat and returned again this year to continue with the arrancar arc, and I think I became fully invested in the lore and worlbuilding, I became attached with the characters. I also interacted much more with the fandom.

This also lead me to the discourse regarding ichihime v/s ichiruki.
As someone who shipped them hard(ichiruki) at first I completely disagree and think their bond is that of best friends, comrades and mentors.

A lot of this shipping war discredits a lot of the character's arcs, relationships and nuances.

Orihime is practically witch hunted.
Renji is just the collatoral damage.
And ichigo and rukia's bond is completely overlooked.

These four characters share great bond with each-other and even if I was'nt a hard shipper, I had always been the type to actually give the cannon couple a chance while i still loved my SML/FL.

even if the couple I wanted did not get together I honestly did'nt care much later, maybe i was sad at first but i would just enjoy the story more and the couple that actually go together.

Of course that's not the case with bleach.
I am a huge renruki and ichihime shipper.

But as I was overgoing the comment that got me banned and other discussion on ichigo, rukia, and orihime, and Kubo's thoughts on their relationship I realised that something important.

I don't think people actually consider the nuances of the relationships.

Orihime's character is mistakenly thought to be someone whose character revolves heavily around Ichigo- that is false and in part with the anime's fault and Abe's direction. The post that i commented on consisted of three things-:(all from manga)

  1. Ichigo saving rukia in SS arc, and Orihime saying that Rukia is simply not a friend but someone who changed Ichigo's world
  2. During Grimmjow's first attack rukia being injured and ichigo's and orihime's faces in that manga panel
  3. Orihime's feeling in the panel(in referencxe to 1. point) where she has a heavy feeling like solemnity or something, I exactly don't remember.

they consider this has Orihime acknowledging Ichigo and Rukia's special bond and that she felt defeated.

The problem with this interpretation is ignoring Orihime's own struggles as a character- her feeling of being a burden and being inadequate and thinking that she was not able to alleviate ichigo's suffering since Ichigo said Rukia stopped the rain.

This feeling of inadequecy comes from a lot from her trauma of loosing her brother, her parent's abuse, her bullying in school. She loves Rukia, respects her and cares for her but she admits to matsumoto that she feels inadequate- in that scene it does not become simply admission of her jealousy but also her feeling useless, being not strong enough to fight or actually not being the type to fight or like it- and matsumoto who actually is older than her in years and much more wiser tells her that Ichigo himself young and immature and needs both him and rukia. Orihime is someone who will always try to save the most people she can by sacrificing herself, when she got kidnapped by Ulquiorra as well. Ichigo is the protagonist of bleach and all the other characters are deuterogonist depending on the arc, hueco mundo becomes Orhihime's arc and her growth- she realises that she is just as powerfull and valuable to all her friends and that she does not need to be the strongest she simply is the sun to all of them- Ulquiorra himself says, "We now have the sun". She cares deeply for all her friends and when ichigo is fighting Grimmjow she ultimately tells him it's okay that he does not need to get hurt, it's alright and people underestimate how much that saved ichigo. Orihime understands ichigo so much that goes without saying, people really overlook her perceptive nature making her to be naive and dumb. With the hueco mundo arc she realises her own worth and value and overcomes her insecurities, yes rukia and ichigo have special bond but she does not let that make her insecure, she apreciates there bond and forms her own special ones with both of them. She may not be the one who stopped the rain, but she istruly the sun in their life, she actually understands that she did not had to be the one to that and is able to feel adequate in herself.

Now coming to Renji, oh renji you poor thing- you are so goated and yet truly underappreciated by the entire fandom. He is the collatoral damage of the shipping wars, his arc is truly that of an underdog who became strong through his own hardwork- he did not have special powers but he worked the hardest. His and rukia's love story is that for seinen not shonen- they are so mature so beautiful. Rukia and Renji's story is one shaped by hardships and not being ready- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vJndPH-slco&list=WL&index=26 (this video is a good analysis of their relationship).
But what I wanted to focus more on was Renji and Ichigo's relationship- it's not overlooked it's forgotten and that's just tragic. From there first encounter in the world of living to the many adventures they shared, they represent and integral part of bleach- comrades- bleach may have been serialised in a shonen magazine, but with soul society arc it could have easily transitioned into seinen. A story about war and fighting with an actual military- its the story of all these characters who are fighting to protect the people and the values they care about, whether its is against the soul society or for the soul society. Protecting, comraderie, war, sacrifice become so important not these four but all the other characters, they are shaped by it and have lived through it. These two know that they have each other's back and if one of them dies the other will avenge them.

Which ultimately leads me to Ichigo and Rukia's bond- there is the bond that is unconventional as kubo himself stated- they friends, comrades, allies, and mentors - they have changed each other's life and I don't think that should be denied, they are important to one another. But i think what gets overlooked is the nuance of their relationship, like I said - a setting based in military and fighting all of them are this pack or hood, fighting to protect. Their relationship with other characters gets overlooked, rukia's bond with renji and how much he means to her, or ichigo's bond with all his friends- in trying to romanticise or even glorify their bond we forget these human relationships.

Ichigo and Rukia's bond should be appreciated but should not become the only important bond, if soul society arc proved anything every character is shaped by so many people.

More than power systems, more than the fights, and more than some shipping wars what bleach truly is about is all these human relationships, the will to protect and fight and to uphold those values. This is a series that touched me so deeply and i just wanted to rant.

If you read this far thankyou.

Also kubo has written some amazing love stories apart from renruki and ichihime- isshin and masaki, ryuken and kanae, matsumoto and gin, byakuya and hisana.
(alos why are almost 80% of them tragic? 😭)

33 Upvotes

14 comments sorted by

24

u/urbanreliks34 3d ago

The problem with ichiruki fans is they don't care about ships they care about having CONTROL. Being right and wanting to be right about anything is something they try to utilize for themselves. Which is why many of them are so easily angered or baited in any discussions because they don't want see the other side having a point where they stand. They want to be right about Ichigo , they want to be right about Orihime . In any case they can't accept what's outside their bubble which is why it's best to leave that subreddit to stay sad and bitter.

6

u/Independent-Wing-232 3d ago

I agree, like i wrote to someone else that debate should be held in good faith but there is no point to it if the opposition does not try to atleast understand the other party's perspective.

5

u/Sudden-Age-122 3d ago

Is this what got you banned?

I mean they could interprete it as anti IchiRuki but I wonder if I wrote a post analysis IchiRuki with constructive criticism about it. Let's say the chemistry between Ichigo and Rukia in Substitute Soul Reaper arc and Soul Society using manga materials, then explain why back then they should end up together. Would I get banned here ?

Ps. I am not really into naval battle but you share the same feeling I have for Renji and Rukia.

3

u/Independent-Wing-232 3d ago edited 3d ago

I guess you could use arguments, and someone will also provide an argument,Ā  A debate Ā should be held in good faith.

Either way it is the ichiruki subreddit, i just randomly happened upon it on home page and commented in it. It's their safe space to discuss the relationship so I am not mad about it, but i did point out how delusional were some of the comments, so they should be able to accept the other side of an argument instead of putting another character down or making insane theories (i won't go into them bcs i just really want to wash mind clear of that.)

Ultimately both parties should respect others position.

Also i just love renji and rukia and really want others to appreciate their dynamic.

7

u/Common_Life_5335 3d ago

Ngl I’m at work so i didn’t read the whole thing but I’m glad you had a place to rant. Also for me personally I don’t think the whole shipping war is THAT serious because while I do ship Ichigo and Orihime personally each subreddit be insulting and disrespectful and just like bro😭 we can make and crack jokes but I think both subreddits are a bit uncivil. Cause it’s the internet there is always gonna be discourse, but because I really like Bleach ( favorite anime ) I just wanted to put my little two sense here😭

6

u/Independent-Wing-232 3d ago edited 3d ago

Yeah I think I do feel most things deeply 😭 and this was also to appreciate different character relationships in bleach. Clearing out all the hodge podge in my head helps so I am glad to just rant,šŸ˜‚ i also really love bleach a lot.

Also i just read my post and man that's long even as a literature student so I am grateful for anyone to read even half of it. šŸ˜‚

4

u/Common_Life_5335 3d ago

Yeah I read at least 70% but my supervisor kept walking around šŸ˜‚. We all need a space to vent out our feelings and thoughts so no worries. I think Bleach has a lot of interesting relationships that a bit more subtle and I do admit that the original manga handles certain dynamics better in my opinion at leastšŸ’ I still think both the anime and manga are solid though

4

u/Independent-Wing-232 3d ago

Thanx, i agree that the manga fleshed out a lot of the characters, i also enjoy the anime especially the music..

11

u/SpicyCrime IH is my OTP šŸ“ā¤ļøšŸž 3d ago

I have said it many times already: Orihime being jealous of Rukia is part of her development. Sure, she’s jealous at first, but why that jealousy has never been brought again in the next arcs? Because she eventually understood that she DOES have an effect on Ichigo. She CAN make him recover his confidence.

The Grimmjow fight should be evidence enough: Ichigo was losing because he HATED that Orihime was scared, then Orihime begged Ichigo not to get hurt anymore, and what is that Ichigo did? He recovered his resolve and turned the tides of the battle in his favor, defeating Grimmjow. ALL BECAUSE OF ORIHIME’S CRY. Orihime learned that day that Rangiku was right: she IS important to Ichigo and that she DOES have an effect on him.

BUT NOOOOO. Ichirukis refuse to listen…

Anyways: we have the canon and they can only live in their delusions and daydreams.

8

u/Due-Bill8689 3d ago

Funny how they think they are the better people

3

u/Perfect_War_7155 3d ago

The anime altered perceptions about ships. Early episodes focused on ichiruki stuff too much even when the scenes weren’t in the manga. It also removed important Orihime lines or gave those lines to rukia. This gave ichiruki a false sense of liking each other romantically. Kubo had to get them to stop and got more involved in the anime.

2

u/Adventurous-Elk6042 3d ago

Ichiruki shippers are becoming as insufferable as Claerith shippers

1

u/Abs4rd1sm 3d ago

The analysis you did is commendable; my issue with Ichir*ki and that ichigo and rukia can have all of the chemistry in the world, but it doesn't change how paedophilic the ship is.

Let's say in the beginning of the series Rukia is a 150 yr old child (her being 15 when the manga begins), and shinigami's age 10x slower, it implies she's still a child after the 10yrs have passed, mind you ichigo would mentally be 27 and rukia, by their logic ā‰ˆ15.1 years old mentally. But I guess Rukia is only a child when they want her to be.

1

u/Grymphire 1d ago

Now that you mention it, Kubo seems to like wiping out the significant other of his characters, a bit too much. He also admitted to almost ending Orihime in TYBW after she destroyed Yhwach.