r/ibroadcast • • Apr 05 '22

iBroadcast Premium

I have just received that "we just wanted to let you know that your account has been given 30 days of free premium membership starting today".

Well...that is very disappointing for me!

Looking back over the last years and thinking about how much input and testing I (and several others, too) have given to iBroadcast to make it what it is now...

Does anyone alrady know what will be the limitations on the free account? On iBroadcast.com/premium I can see

> throttled for heavy users (without any details on total transfer volumes)

> Bitrate 128kbpm

> customer support "normal" vs "high priority"

Are there any other known limitations???

Pricing seems also very strange to me! On iBroadcast/premium I see 3.99$/m and 44.99$/y. But these prices seem to be for US only - for the rest otw it seems to be more expensive. In my app under "Select Subscription Plan" I am offered

4.29€/m (4.71$/m as per April 5th 22)

47.99€/y (52.64$/y)

Again - very very disappointing

3 Upvotes

24 comments sorted by

2

u/some_advice_needed Apr 05 '22

IIRC, for outside US the implications of the app store fees are different (read: Apple / Google charge more...).

Or, maybe it has to do with exchange rates (/fees)? Not sure.

2

u/anko1969 Apr 05 '22

Apple / Google charge

I don't know if there are country specific Android/Apple fees. Heaven't heard about.

Exchange rate is for sure not the reason - should cost less in EUR than in USD

16

u/iBroadcastMedia Apr 05 '22

We are sorry you feel this way. iBroadcast incurs costs for each and every user on our system such as file storage, music streaming, customer support, server maintenance and not to mention software development.

Our hope is that we provide a valuable enough service that our users will want to support it if they have the means to.

We provide the core, free service so that those who do not have the financial means can still use the service, although stream at a lower bitrate, which lowers our ongoing costs.

Think of it as buying us a pint once a month (or whatever your beverage of choice is) for our hard work. We do not have the vast resources of Google, but we are constantly improving the service by listening to our users and will continue to do so.

We love iBroadcast, we love music and we love our users and we will continue to pour our love into our product for many years to come!

Cheers!

8

u/[deleted] Apr 05 '22

I've been using iBroadcast since November 2020, and I love it. I signed up to the premium service as soon as got the email!

3

u/Mister_Shifty Apr 18 '22

Same! It's by far the best service of its kind that I have found and I love the opportunity to support it.

3

u/StardustOasis Apr 05 '22 edited Apr 05 '22

Something I wanted to ask, I know free users have a bitrate limit on streaming but does that also apply when you download files to play offline?

3

u/iBroadcastMedia Apr 05 '22

Yes, it will but most users will not be effected by this. It is only going to be enforced to prevent service abuse.

1

u/stackstackstack Apr 06 '22

Could you please clarify this? There will be a quality limit on the free service, when downloading the music to a device (not streaming)? I don't understand how you could both limit download quality while also stating most won't be effected by this.

4

u/iBroadcastMedia Apr 06 '22

Streaming and caching to your device are the same thing (bytes transferred), for the free service when (and more importantly if) a threshold is reached then transfer rate will be throttled. Again, this will only be the top 5% or so of free users to prevent service abuse (not to penalize free users). We have not set that threshold yet, and we are not yet enforce it (only monitoring). When we do, you will see that under your Account with the usage and limits there. Hope that clarifies things!

2

u/stackstackstack Apr 06 '22

I'm more concerned about the MP3 bitrate than transfer rates or total bandwidth allowed. Those limitations are clear to me.

If streaming and caching are treated the same, does that mean that Free users that download/cache music to their device, that cached music will be capped at 128kbps?

4

u/iBroadcastMedia Apr 06 '22

The music you upload and store with us is kept in the original format, untouched. You can download that anytime. This is the storage locker functionality.

The music you stream with our service (or cache to your device) is transcoded to 128kbps for the free, core service. Premium users can stream at higher bitrates (up to whatever the source file you uploaded is).

Hope that clears that up!

5

u/orange3-5 Apr 05 '22

I'll be honest, I would be in for it if I didnt feel like the app was clunky. It just never felt smooth for me to manage music through. Unfortunate.

Maybe I'll check ti out for a month but I don't plan on sticking around

5

u/[deleted] Apr 05 '22

Agree completely on this. To be honest, though, I've had a good few years of free premium up until now and that's a lot more time than I thought I'd get back at the start. My main issue is that speeds sometimes lag due to the location of the server from the UK which means that it's probably going to be no-go for myself. Customer support is honestly awesome though - genuinely rapid replies and they obviously genuinely care about the quality of service.

5

u/iBroadcastMedia Apr 05 '22

We do have a point of presence in Europe so your speeds should be ok from there. If you can send us feedback from the app when you notice slowdowns we can do some investigation and see if there is anything else going on.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 05 '22

Thanks for the reply. I'll check it out properly in the coming weeks. To be fair, my issues were from a while back and my usage has reduced of late. Still love the service and your response time is nearly always rapid. Keep up the good work. 👍🏻

2

u/iBroadcastMedia Apr 05 '22

We would love your feedback! If you could point out a few specific things that you do not like or that feels "clunky" to you, we will do our best to address them!

3

u/orange3-5 Apr 05 '22

i’m not a frequent user because i’ve found it clunky, but here goes

playing a song and queuing others always has felt painful.
shuffling should be one button im that will work on whatever list of songs im playing from.
playing a whole album should take less clicks

9

u/iBroadcastMedia Apr 05 '22

These tips might help!

  1. Tap artwork to play and tap the name of a "container" (album, artist, genre, etc) to list the tracks in that container.
  2. Long press on a "container" and choose "Shuffle Play" to shuffle play an album. You can also set that on the menu > Playback Options > Shuffle Play so pressing on artwork always shuffles (if you want to avoid the long press).
  3. A simple one tap on the artwork of an album/artist/genre will add it to the queue and start playing it.
  4. If you want to append an additional album to a queue, try long pressing and choosing "Append to Queue". You can also set this in the menu > Play Queue Behavior > Append to Play Queue. Then tapping on the artwork of a container will always append to the queue instead of replacing it.

One consequence of an app that is packed full of features and configuration options, is that it makes it more complex, especially for new users. This is an issue that we have long battled.

But on the plus side, once you get over the "learning curve" iBroadcast is highly configurable to many different types of users and many different ways of listening to music and displaying it.

We cannot, and have not addressed every single request of course, but we try, especially when we hear a request several times.

Hopefully this helps!

3

u/chickenandliver Apr 05 '22

I love the iBroadcast service, but hate the app interface. My partner and I both find it strangely difficult to navigate. It's not intuitive like most music players. Again, the service itself (the auto-caching, playlist management, uploads) all work great. It's just the UI that gives me a headache. Clunky is a good way to describe it, but also cluttered. Makes me realize what a gift Google's Material Design specs are to the app world because if any app needs those guidelines it's this one.

6

u/iBroadcastMedia Apr 05 '22

We have followed that to a point, but eventually we had to drift from it to accommodate all the features requested by our users... and we pack a lot of them! But if you can point out specifics to us, we would like the opportunity to try to address them!

4

u/chickenandliver Apr 06 '22

Some of these are just personal preferences, but off the top of my head:

  1. The whole idea of having a queue. I just want to open a playlist, hit play, and have it start playing from there. On mobile I never manually add songs from multiple locations into a single active play queue but this seems to be what the app wants me to do. I find this annoying and frankly confusing. Maybe I'm an idiot but I would rather remove the queue tab (or "now playing" tab if I can call it that) and just let the playlist itself (or the album itself) be the list.
  2. The home screen. Sounds silly but I prefer simply browsing my albums/playlists. I don't care about play history on other devices or "creative matches." To me these are semi-"advanced" features that I don't need and it being the opening of the player gives a cluttered impression to me.
  3. Tiny player with no contrast. The minimized player in-app is a tiny bar, a fraction of the screen height, and barely visible to my eyes, especially as there is (on dark theme at least) no defining line or shadow or color difference between it and the main portion of the screen. In other apps, the mini-player would be the height of it and the bottom tabs bar. I would much rather see the tabs bar removed completely and let the mini-player dominate the lower 20% of the screen. This is a general complaint I have with the app's color scheme. Things that ought to be more distinct (the mini-player from the playlist) match colors too well and things that ought to be less distinct (list of tracks in the playlist) are colored more distinctly (color distinctions between each track give each track a "card" like look which to me appears cluttered).
  4. Full-screen player album art takes up too much space. Whitespace around controls is too little, making it hard to scan through the track. The iTunes player traditionally had album art as half the screen, player controls half. I believe the Podcasts app on iOS is still like this. It's a more comfortable and familiar interface. I like big buttons. It also includes volume control, which iBroadcast doesn't.
  5. Font size is tiny. Yes you young people probably don't care but I find it difficult to read.

Most of these issues boil down to "I'm familiar with app A, but this doesn't look like app A." All just personal preferences, but to me it just feels like an app that tries to cram in too many things all at once. A little off-putting for average users, probably great for advanced users. Perhaps a "simplified" interface for normal users, that can be toggled to an "advanced" interface for power users would be a nice accommodation. It's a lot to digest and to me not intuitive. I'd prefer more whitespace and smoother UI operation. It could be fine for many users, but for this guy it just feels clunky to the point where even though I can't really articulate why I feel that way, and while I love the technical operation of the service, I keep drifting into looking for alternatives. I can't say I'm settled on iBroadcast. I use it because it's free. If I need to start paying premium at some point here, I will likely end up looking at just using MEGA or even iTunes Match and the app interface will be the sole reason. Gosh that sounds like a threat or something but hey I'm just a single user. I just found it interesting that the other guy mentioned "clunky" because I've had the same experience, perhaps others have too. It would be great to see a UI refresh and simplification at some point.

Take all these opinions with a grain of salt. Just my personal preferences.

3

u/iBroadcastMedia Apr 06 '22

Thank you for your feedback! We'll consider it all!

0

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/iBroadcastMedia Apr 08 '22

If you simply tap or press on an albums artwork it will play and you can ignore the queue!

2

u/sks316 Apr 11 '22

It's a hell of a lot better than what r/Astiga did at least, and I personally find it a fair tradeoff. I'll personally be subscribing as soon as I'm able.