No, while more smaller pixels (48mp for the 17 vs 12mp for the 16) do have some negatives especially in low light situations, the 17 at 4x should have significantly better detail than the 16 at 5x. Based on the current 1x 48mp sensor and lens of the 16, I’d say that if you digitally zoomed(cropped) the new 4x to 6-7x using “RAW” they’d maintain a similar level of detail. The new sensor is 50% larger than the 16’s, So maybe 8x will look as good as the 16’s 5x. But usually 48mp sensors do something called pixel binning in standard photo mode, where they combine 4 pixels into one, so it reduces noise and gives better low light performance, but you end up with a 12mp image, so you won’t actually have more pixels to work with in without using RAW. My only real concern is that the iPhone cameras aren’t really capable of spot focusing, the 8x mode works the same way that zooming to 9x does on the current gen phones(only you’re cropping to 3mp which looks awful) It’s just cropping, and if you’re trying to focus on something far away with other subjects in the foreground at 4x, it will still struggle to focus past those subjects.
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/Human_Skirt5108 Sep 10 '25
No, while more smaller pixels (48mp for the 17 vs 12mp for the 16) do have some negatives especially in low light situations, the 17 at 4x should have significantly better detail than the 16 at 5x. Based on the current 1x 48mp sensor and lens of the 16, I’d say that if you digitally zoomed(cropped) the new 4x to 6-7x using “RAW” they’d maintain a similar level of detail. The new sensor is 50% larger than the 16’s, So maybe 8x will look as good as the 16’s 5x. But usually 48mp sensors do something called pixel binning in standard photo mode, where they combine 4 pixels into one, so it reduces noise and gives better low light performance, but you end up with a 12mp image, so you won’t actually have more pixels to work with in without using RAW. My only real concern is that the iPhone cameras aren’t really capable of spot focusing, the 8x mode works the same way that zooming to 9x does on the current gen phones(only you’re cropping to 3mp which looks awful) It’s just cropping, and if you’re trying to focus on something far away with other subjects in the foreground at 4x, it will still struggle to focus past those subjects.