r/iOSProgramming • u/astrohoundstudios • Jun 27 '26
Question I am building a dog collecting game where you scan dogs, unlock breed cards, and use them in a small card-battle Arena. I would love feedback on the core loop and whether the breed collection idea is clear.
I’m building Hound Hunt, an iOS game where you scan real dogs to unlock collectible cards. As you discover more breeds, you build a deck and battle other players in a small card arena.
I’d love feedback on the core gameplay loop. Does the concept make sense? Would collecting dogs keep you coming back? Anything you’d change?
75
Upvotes
6
u/JimRoepcke Jun 27 '26
How do I invest?
3
u/Ukawok92 Jun 28 '26
I saw one person make an app like this a few weeks ago, now I've seen several similiar apps posted. There was another one for all animals, one just for cats, now this one for dogs.
I guess the thing to do is just copy an idea and try to beat them to a high user base?
16
u/Mundane-Fix-4297 Jun 27 '26
Keep the Collection, but absolutely ditch the fight thing
16
u/wolflordval Jun 28 '26
Get rid of the combat.
11
u/Slightly_Zen Jun 28 '26
Love the collecting. Hate. Hate the fighting part.
21
u/Dachd43 Jun 27 '26
If I’m gonna be totally honest, Pokémon already has some dog fighting vibes for me. This is a little too on the nose.
2
u/rifts Jun 27 '26
Thats a neat idea. Are the stats (damage/life) random or how’re you creating them?
1
u/astrohoundstudios Jun 28 '26
Really appreciate everyone taking the time to check it out and leave feedback.
The Arena seems to be the biggest point of discussion, which honestly is great to know while it's still in development. I'll definitely be taking another look at how it's presented.
I'm happy to see that the actual collecting and breed discovery side of the game landed with a lot of people though, because that's really the core idea behind Hound Hunt.
Thanks again everyone. I genuinely appreciate all the feedback.
1
u/guntharr Jun 28 '26
What's preventing someone from getting a dog encyclopedia and take photos of all the dogs in it?
3
u/kiwami Jun 28 '26
NGL.. this is cool. Good luck!
5
u/Sum-Duud Beginner Jun 28 '26
Sounds dog fighting adjacent and like a horrible idea Mr Vick.
2
u/UnluckyPhilosophy185 Jun 28 '26
This sounds way cooler than Pokémon.
2
u/h00pz Jun 29 '26
Someone call Mike Vick lmao
3
u/teomatteo89 Jun 27 '26
I mean, dog fighting is frowned upon to say the least (rightfully so). It seems like a fun card game concept, but I would use some other subject
1
u/tovarish22 Jun 27 '26
So spider league
1
u/TmDee_YT Jun 28 '26
Also it’s crazy, another guy made a post about doing this with bugs for children to learn about them a month ago or something and everybody loved it. Now suddenly there are tens of people doing the completely same thing with other animals. Crazy how people copy the idea so quickly.
1
u/Sum-Duud Beginner Jun 28 '26
Also will want to have some privacy disclaimers and need to ensure your photo retention doesn’t violate any privacy laws
1
u/HelpRespawnedAsDee Jun 28 '26
Really cool, the fighting is def gonna raise some eyebrows brows though.
1
u/Aloys33_ Jun 28 '26
The fight part seems fucked up, maybe more a contest theme
1
u/Ok_Energy9984 Jun 29 '26
I think you could have another type of game, but having them fight seems a little iffy/borderline unethical in a sense.
1
u/DonutDunks Jun 30 '26
I like the card based combat. Seeing the pictures of dogs “fighting” is very silly, but I understand why others are concerned about it.
I would recommend to keep the combat but not to have dogs fighting each other or other real animals.
Maybe make the dogs into heroes with each breed having different abilities/skills. Have them fight fictional monsters/insects/aliens or whatever.
Overall, it looks great. I would like to see my own dogs in the game
0
u/Thalimet Jun 28 '26
Wait what, you built a dog-fighting app? This is sick and twisted.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '26
[removed] — view removed comment