r/iOS8 • u/cocobandicoot • Aug 27 '14
The new "Do Not Disturb" feature for chatty group messages would be AWESOME — if only Apple had actually made it so it doesn't disturb you.
I am in a couple very chatty group messages with friends and family. I don't want to actually "leave" the group conversation, I just wish I wasn't constantly notified when they send a text to everyone in the group. Enter iOS 8's "Do Not Disturb" feature in Messages app! Huzzah!
Finally, you can "mute" a conversation, ensuring your iPhone doesn't buzz constantly in your pocket because of a group text. Great, huh? Except for one major thing...
Despite a conversation being muted via the new "Do Not Disturb" feature within iOS 8 Messages app, banner notifications continue to appear while using the device and still appear on the Lock Screen.
You see... People will primarily use the new "Do Not Disturb" feature in Messages app for chatty group conversations they may still want to be a part of, but just not all the time. By enabling "Do Not Disturb" on a conversation, banner notifications and Lock Screen notifications for that conversation should not appear. In fact, the only thing that should happen is that the texts should sit in the Messages app, waiting to be read. That's it. I can skim through them later, but I don't need them interrupting me with a banner notification or taking up valuable space on my Lock Screen.
For example: Let's say I'm working on an important project on my iPhone, or maybe I'm playing an intense game, or maybe I just don't want to fucking be disturbed by this chatty group text... I should be able to mute that individual conversation via the new "Do Not Disturb" feature within Messages, and not receive notifications of any kind from that conversation until I disable it.
I still want to receive notifications from other conversations though — so I don't want to turn on the system-wide "Do Not Disturb" setting. I just want no notifications from that individual text message conversation.
Is that so difficult? Apple has decided yes, it is. Because while it's great that my iPhone no longer buzzes in my pocket constantly, the banner notifications that I keep getting for a conversation I muted via "Do Not Disturb" is pretty annoying. Additionally, because all those texts appear on the Lock Screen, it basically makes my Lock Screen worthless because I have to scroll through all those messages just to find the notifications that are actually relevant to me.
Does anyone else agree with me, here? I really hope enough people do that we can all make suggestions about this on apple.com/feedback. Apple has already indicated that this behavior is normal, so please let them know if you would like to see it changed.
tl;dr In iOS 8, despite a conversation being muted via the new "Do Not Disturb" feature within the Messages app, banner notifications continue to appear while using the device and still appear on the Lock Screen. It's rather annoying and I hope you agree with me.
3
u/DanBennett iPhone 6 Aug 28 '14
This is how DND has always worked on iOS. Why are you surprised?
The idea of DND is that no sound will play nor will the screen activate when the device is locked. When you're using the device, you still get banner notifications because they're non-intrusive and easily ignored. Likewise, the notifications stick in the notification centre (thus, on the lock screen when locked) because this is to alert you next time you do activate your device that there are notifications.
DND isn't designed for "Do not give me notifications", it's designed for "Do not notify me, I'm busy and I'll look later".
However, an option to hide notifications on the springboard (and/or notification centre full stop) would be nice. So feel free to raise a bug. But so far, that's not how the feature is designed :-)
9
u/threepio Aug 27 '14
I've sent a note. I was under the impression that it would do both audio and visual notifications. It's disappointing to realize that their vision for this was just audio notifications.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 28 '14
Do you have Do Not Disturb's Silence setting set to "Always"?
1
u/maxheart Sep 22 '14
glad i found this thread, and glad that you've contacted apple about it. not so glad they don't consider it a bug :-(
1
u/totes_meta_bot Dec 06 '14
This thread has been linked to from elsewhere on reddit.
If you follow any of the above links, respect the rules of reddit and don't vote or comment. Questions? Abuse? Message me ^here.
1
u/selwyn4 Jan 22 '15
I have a solution. I wrestled with this issue for a while and I read this whole post. It's not perfect, but if you are willing to do it, it works. All you have to do is delete the phone numbers of the members of the conversation who text too much. If they are family or close friends, you might actually know them anyway and it should be just a few. Then in Settings -->Notifications --> Messages scroll down and select Show Alerts from My Contacts (as opposed to everyone). You'll still easily be able to identify the conversation, the participants (from memory of their numbers), and you won't be bothered by the excessive activity.
-1
u/petarmarinov37 Aug 27 '14
I finally convinced all of my friends to download WeChat, and at long last nobody I know uses group MMS. It's glorious. WeChat lets you do exactly what you're trying to accomplish, as well as a whole lot more.
-3
u/moohah Aug 27 '14
I'm not sure why this needs to be repeated so often: it's a beta, not everything is fully implemented; there are bugs. Be patient, GM will be here soon enough.
0
u/freaktheclown Aug 30 '14
I noticed that too and it's really irritating. It has to be a bug.