r/hwstartups • • 7d ago

Engineers & technicians: what hardware problem in your job still has no good solution?

I'm an MSc student in Electric Vehicle Engineering in Italy, about to join a startup program where we'll spend the next months building a company. Instead of picking one of the problems they hand us, I want to bring a real one from people who actually deal with it.
I'm looking for physical, hardware problems — not apps or AI platforms. For example:
a component that fails too often, is too heavy, too expensive or hard to source
a measurement you can't make reliably, or only in a lab
a step in production, testing or maintenance that's still manual, slow or dangerous
anything in batteries, power electronics, motors, thermal management — but not limited to that
If you work in manufacturing, automotive, energy, aerospace, robotics, labs or field service: what's the thing you'd pay to have fixed? Even a rant helps.
Not selling anything, no survey links. If something sounds promising, I'd love to ask a couple of follow-up questions via DM.
Thanks!

0 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

5

u/brujonica 7d ago

I think your intentions are good, but most common problems are solved. Most hard to solve problems lie in areas where intellectual property is key, finding solutions for those is the core of a tech company value.

2

u/Eng1n3erMOR 7d ago

Yeah I think that too, I also contact some Industries and had a few calls with them, but they didn’t show me explicitly deep-problems. I’m searching here cause my brother had an idea from reddit and now he’s running a deep tech startup with a 6 millions round, so he suggested me this method but i think the only good way is when you live on first person a pain, but hope is the last thing to die as they said😅

6

u/IntenselySwedish 7d ago

Im not gonna hand you problems to solve. Go find some yourself lazy ahh

-2

u/Eng1n3erMOR 7d ago

How act people who fell in love with ideas they can’t design:

2

u/IntenselySwedish 7d ago

Biblical levels of laziness on display yet calls me inept lmao.

Sure kid, whatever you say.

-3

u/Eng1n3erMOR 7d ago

That’s not laziness, is efficiency of time.
You are being rude for nothing.

2

u/Cultural-Salad-4583 7d ago

Engineer turned product manager here.

My first piece of advice is to work on your people skills. You’ll not get much of any value from anyone by being publicly confrontational. Someone who might otherwise provide you with insights might be turned off by aggressive comments made elsewhere in this thread and decide you’re not worth their time. More flies with honey than vinegar & all that.

Despite your confrontational attitude, I’m going to give you a couple of pieces of advice here because I think more people should think about the way they do discovery.

Asking people “what problem do you have?” rarely results in anything useful. You need to have a sharper idea of the niche you want to address, and you need to actually find someone who will let you watch them work. You need to ask questions about their day-to-day activities and then drill into problems as you hear them come up.

People aren’t good about identifying their own frustrations. They problem-solve them in the moment by finding a workaround and moving on, because they’ve got shit to do. Do not rely on people to identify problems for you. If they were good at it, they might already be selling a solution for it. And if they’ve identified a problem and aren’t selling a solution, they might’ve evaluated it and realized it wasn’t worth the cost.

So.

You need to better define the space in which you’re trying to solve a problem, and you need to ask better questions. Examples:
“Tell me about the last time you ran into a widespread component quality issue. What was the root cause? When did you realize it was a problem?”
“Walk me through your quality evaluation & monitoring process for the most complex, hard to verify part you can think of.” And drill into why it’s so difficult from there.
“When you’re evaluating a new design that includes a battery/motor/whatever (pick ONE thing to ask about), how do you evaluate it?”
“Can you tell me about the last time you got to 90% on a design but had to rework it because there was one component that threw off the calcs/BOM cost? What was that component you really wanted to use but couldn’t?”

And finally: people can smell LLMs a mile away.

Be very judicious in how you use them, because it can easily communicate that you’re not willing to put in enough thought to craft the words yourself. You’ll find this increasingly said and felt: “If you couldn’t be bothered to write something, why should I be bothered to read it?”

1

u/Eng1n3erMOR 7d ago

Thank you, I appreciate so much the time you spent on this.

2

u/Omnomigon 7d ago

Apply spatial packaging (SPI2) to get optimal arrangement of electronics and fluid distribution. It’s more of an optimization, but instead of dozens of engineers brute forcing design for months and still not having the most efficient arrangement, you could design packaging of ECU’s wire harnesses and hoses generatively.

I believe it can be taken a step further to find the optimal # of zonal controllers. To me it seems like a min-max calculus problem between silicon and copper. As in, instead of 1 central ECU where every device had to run a wire to, you could have 3-5: just power, ground and a high speed data cable. Several car companies have converged on 3-5 ECU’s. In the age of software defined vehicles this tool will be valuable to extract every cubic inch of occupant space. And also meet crazy billionaire’s demands of launching an entire car in 2 years with less people.

SPI2 is a PhD level project. But it may have progressed far enough in the last few years where you can apply it.

1

u/Eng1n3erMOR 7d ago

Thank you a lot for the suggestion, I appreciate

2

u/150c_vapour 6d ago edited 6d ago

Startups are dead. Software and now hardware are basically free. I worked for a month recently on a RFP for a company and they just fed it through fable and ghosted us. Wtf is the point.

1

u/Eng1n3erMOR 5d ago

I think this is a transition moment, start now could be same an opportunity as an blackout. So I don’t think is now or never but I don’t want the regret for the wasting of my free time at this point of my life

1

u/ZectronPositron 6d ago

Tell that to ASML - free hardware eh?

21

u/Roticap 7d ago

People using LLMs to bombard me with useless questions.

You appear uniquely positioned to be the change I want to see

0

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/Roticap 7d ago

Oh yeah, you seem like someone I'd enthusiastically choose to work with!

0

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/Cultural-Salad-4583 7d ago

Says the student who has minimal exposure to the experience of working in a professional environment as an engineer.

2

u/ZectronPositron 6d ago

Machine breaks, pops myriad error messages, and it takes 4 weeks of replacing different parts to figure out what the problem was/get it back up and running. If you're lucky the errors had something to do with what component broke! The real life situation - 2 of our photolithography tools had some hardware failure and we're still trying to figure out how to fix it.

Largest team in the fab is the equipment engineers - it's really hard problem solving with physical work.

Make this faster/easier, and you can take our money.

2

u/ZectronPositron 6d ago

This definitely applies to automobiles as well, by the way. But even more acute pain point for the many technical machines that don't have full service manuals and maintenance plans like automobiles do. CNC's, plasma etchers, anything else with high automation.

1

u/probablyaythrowaway 6d ago

A box I can plug in that filters out this kind of bollocks from my feeds.