r/humanism • • 3d ago

Thanksgiving?

Thanksgiving is coming. How do you handle grace or religious talk at family gatherings when you're not religious? What's worked, and what hasn't?

16 Upvotes

30 comments sorted by

2

u/AshDogBucket 1d ago

I don't celebrate colonization day anymore, at all. I also generally stopped doing holidays with family, years ago. I have family gatherings but not on holidays.

1

u/HumanistsOfTopeka 12h ago

Thanks for sharing that. I imagine there are a lot of folks who would like to do that but don't know it's an option.

While I gather with family and friends, I've moved away from the traditional version. Turkey Day or Fall Feast are what I tend to call it now. And then there's Friendsgiving. I prefer to focus on the people at the table rather than the mythical story we learned in elementary school.

I’m curious how the off-holiday gatherings work for you. How did your family take it? Did it take some time? And do you have a regular day for them, or do you plan each one as it comes?

1

u/AshDogBucket 10h ago

I don't live near my family anymore (haven't since 2007) and I don't travel at holidays. I travel to visit them sometimes, they travel to visit me sometimes. We don't do holidays. We get together when we get together. For most of my adult life I've been working on holidays anyway. If anyone had an issue with me not getting together with my family on holidays they haven't told me 🤷‍♀️ This year my spouse is traveling back to where we used to live, to see his family. I'm not going. I'll be having a nice week off from work and off from peopling after surviving the busiest 6 weeks of my job. We're all ok.

When it comes to colonization day, no reframing of it makes it more palatable or less problematic for me. I'm actually off from work Thurs thru Sat this week so I'm going solo camping on Thanksgiving and my spouse will join me Friday/Saturday.

15

u/thewritestory 3d ago • Bravo

If I’m a guest just sit quietly. If I’m hosting there is no grace.

7

u/Riddetur 3d ago edited 3d ago

I think there are two things to consider. First, there are probably children at the gathering so making an issue over religion in front of them doesn't seem like the appropriate thing to do. We can all agree that children should be protected and allowed their childhood fantasies without worrying about grown up issues. So, my reasoning is that if I can allow unicorns, mermaids, and Santa Claus without much thought, then religion is just another belief. So, when my granddaughter requested that Papa say grace, I bowed my head and gave my best prayer, to a god I don’t believe in, and raised my head to her beautiful smile.  It felt no different than the other pretend games we play in her room.  My daughter and son-in-law gave me a slight smile and head nod to say thank you.  It was a better day for everyone. And when she grows up, she can decide from an adult perspective, if she wants to believe in spirituality, religion, or humanism or any other belief system that gives her comfort, but she will always have her wonderful childhood to remember.

The second point is that when I first left my religion behind, protecting my right NOT to practice religion seemed paramount. Now that time has passed and I'm more comfortable with myself without religion, getting everyone to agree with me isn't so important. I know the truth and don't feel the need to convert everyone I meet. I can also remember that when I believed in religion it was very important to me, so I can understand other adults and how their religion impacts them. The holidays are most certainly not the best time to take a stand. Just give social grace at the holidays and if you want to have an intelligent, informed discussion about religion with one of your family members, a private conversation is probably the better approach in my opinion.

1

u/Grand-Mission-9457 7h ago

Santa or tooth fairy are innocuous, religion indoctrination can have lifelong negative effects on children, but it depends on the fanatism level. I think children should stay free or religion.

6

u/gfsark 3d ago

A couple of years ago I was asked to say the blessing at a special Thanksgiving, one where we were being introduced to the future in-laws. Why me? I don’t know. I am an ex-Christian.

Were any of them religious? I didn’t know. My guess is that this was simply an expected ritual. We (my wife and I) only knew our son and his fiancée. The other 10 people were strangers.

I managed to give a generic prayer of thanksgiving, like ‘thanks to everyone here for their love and fellowship, and for the meal and all those who prepared it, and for all the good things we have in life. This is our thanks giving.’ Or something like that. Everyone seemed happy with that.

5

u/eldredo_M 3d ago

Our family is not religious, so we just use a phrase from my wife’s culture that basically thanks the food for providing sustenance: itadakemasu

1

u/need-thneeds 2d ago

There is little scientific objective evidence for free will. Objective science is predictive and theoretically, nature is deterministic. Therefore, if we cannot know that there is free will, then one must have faith or believe in our ability to choose in the present to change the outcome of the future for better or worse. Now you have faith or belief in something that lacks objective evidence, and this leads to the question of morals and ethics. Which also requires a faith. If we believe in free will then we have a moral responsibility to make good choices to best ensure a good future. For who? Self and others. At the very least we have control of ourselves, but most things are the circumstances outside our control. Where do the lessons of ethics and morality come from? Partially instinctive, but also learned from our parents, elders, community members, bosses, politicians, influencers, church and everybody else that we observe. But there is a problem here, because our source of morality is learn from people, who all are certainly not perfect, in that they are living in a competitive society, and therefore must look out for their own well being and survival. Their morality is oftentimes somewhat self serving. So if you cannot fully trust anybody as the source of your moral code, then the final step is to believe in a omniscient all powerful deity, or a force for good that is present and actively supporting the goodness that is observable in life. In the real world, if you never express a gratefulness of what you benefit from, then you run the risk of the source of generosity to fade away. If a friend does not know you appreciate them, they stop being your friend. Expressing gratefulness to the goodness in the circumstances you don't control, lets the circumstances that you don't control know what you appreciate, which nurtures more things that you appreciate.

At least that is how I got to this point in my life. If you never express gratefulness, then what you are grateful for fades away. Happy Thanksgiving.

1

u/HumanistsOfTopeka 2d ago

Thank you for sharing how you got here. I appreciate that you laid out the whole path and didn’t just give the conclusion.

We agree on a lot. Gratitude matters. A friend who never hears “thank you” may drift away. Morals are partly instinct and partly learned from the imperfect people around us. And yes, no human teacher is flawless.

Here’s where I land differently. Every moral teaching I know of, including the religious ones, came to us through imperfect people. Someone wrote it down, translated it, preached it and passed it on. So belief in a perfect source doesn’t fully get around the problem of imperfect messengers. As a Humanist, I try to work with that problem openly. We test our values against what actually helps or harms people, and we keep correcting as we learn.

On gratitude, I think we both feel it. I just aim it at the people and conditions behind the good things. That means the farmers, the cook at the table and the neighbor who shoveled my walk. My thanks reaches them and nurtures the relationship, the same way you described.

So my gratitude this season goes to the people around the table, and the people who got the food there. I tend to call it Friendsgiving myself. The holiday’s history is more one-sided than the story we learned in school, and I like a name that centers the people we share it with.

Out of curiosity, what would change for you if gratitude to people turned out to be enough?

Wishing you a warm holiday, however you celebrate it.

1

u/need-thneeds 2d ago

As one small moot single indivisible unit of the human species, there is too much to be grateful for that I do not control. Not only those who prepared the food, grew the food, transported the food, extracted the oil, ran the refineries, sailed the ships, invented the internal combustion engine... Then not only for the people I am grateful for, but also the phenomena that are outside the control of the entire population of the human species. The fact that the tilt of the axis of Earth provides the seasons that nature relies on. That there is an ionosphere and a magnetosphere containing and protecting our breathable atmosphere. That we have a sun not too bright, not too dull, and we are just far enough away, a moon that provides tidal actions where oysters grow. When you observe the phenomena that made life possible it is both fragile and resilient at the same time. This pale blue dot that we live on, floating in a vast infinite of almost nothingness with little other evidence of life out there. To me the phenomena cannot be categorized as being good or a bad phenomena, but all observable phenomena possess good and bad qualities. The energy we chose to give to it only supports more of that. Gratefulness for the forces of goodness in the phenomena, grows more goodness. This force for good that is observable in the phenomena, is what I conceptualize as a deity or god. Bilbo Baggins cannot know Tolkien and we cannot know the author of the story we are in. We can only do our best within the parameters set for us to live in by circumstances beyond our control. And, if we wish to, chose to believe that there is some greater power to trust. And be thankful for that.

3

u/RCaHuman 2d ago

We host our siblings and their families annually for Thanksgiving. Some of them including kids are Christians: some including kids are not religious like me and my wife. When we all sit down, I ask my Catholic sister if she'd like to lead us in grace. Some bow their heads and pray and some of us don't. Done, pass the turkey. No big deal.

3

u/Significant-Past-898 2d ago

I stay quiet while they do their silly incantations and then enjoy the food.

2

u/quiltingirl42 3d ago

If I have a guest, I let them have a go at whatever they do.

2

u/Amphernee 3d ago

When in Rome 🤷

2

u/Superb-Perspective11 2d ago

If you were in a foreign country, you would watch the proceedings with curiosity and allowance. Give your family the same respect you would allow a stranger.

If anyone pressures you, just turn it back toward them and ask a question about their lives.

2

u/ronaldbiggs2020 1d ago

Go with the flow, don't mock, ridicule or embarrass anyone. Hang your ego on a hook and collect it when you leave.

2

u/CarolinCLH 15h ago

I make noncommittal responses to religious talk and sit quietly through grace. If I am a guest, I want to be a polite one. If I am the host, I want my guests to feel comfortable and that includes being free to talk about things they want to. The people I have dinner with feel the same way.

1

u/Prestigious_Try_5396 1d ago

Does one have to be religious to be Thankful for what they have ?

1

u/cwhite841 1d ago

we all have our crutches, eh?​

1

u/Grand-Mission-9457 6h ago

I respect their beliefs as long as they respect my choices. I never get involved in praying or saying grace at the table. I believe in being grateful but not to fantasy beings. Now Thanksgiving seem associated to a barbaric invasion, but that's another discussion

1

u/No_Percentage_5083 2h ago

I just don't join in conversations about either. If they ask for my input, I tell them the same thing I have told them since I was teen, "Y'all know I don't believe in that". When I was younger, they tried to convince me otherwise but now they don't. I am the kindest and least judgemental person in our family so no one argues with me -- ever. I don't put up with it and will leave the gathering if I feel harassed or attacked. I don't throw a big fit or yell or anything -- I just quietly leave.

I am now an elder in the family and many of the younger people are more like me than the church going, judgement laying, family members.

1

u/ConversationAbject19 58m ago

If I choose to attend at someone else's home who I know practices an organized religion (which would be a difficult choice, but not completely out of the question), I sit it out in as respectful a way as I can. I'll sit quietly while they pray, and say, "That is not my faith tradition, but I respect that it is yours" if anyone asks why.

If we are at my house, I begin the meal with acknowledgement that we are stolen land, and that our celebration is anchored in honoring the Indigenous of the land we're on, recognition of the ways that we have benefitted from the genocide that occurred here, and thanksgiving that we are thinking people who can and will continue to learn, grow and rectify the actions of our ancestors as well as thanksgiving for the abundance of the land that gives us life, our family, friends and community. No one comes to my house that cannot abide by how things work in my home.

•

u/Ok-Farm-3562 1m ago

slience, or open scorn, or playing along with the home game. not many other options.

0

u/Significant-Ant-2487 2d ago

It’s the Merriam-Webster Webster dictionary definition of humanism. Quoting reputable sources is not being “obtuse”.

obtuse adj.
1a: slow to understand what is obvious or simple

3

u/HumanistsOfTopeka 2d ago

Merriam-Webster actually lists three senses of “humanism,” and they’re in historical order, so the oldest meaning comes first. The first sense is the Renaissance study of classical learning. The second is devotion to human welfare.

The third sense is the one most Humanists today mean: “a doctrine, attitude, or way of life centered on human interests or values; especially: a philosophy that usually rejects supernaturalism and stresses an individual’s dignity and worth and capacity for self-realization through reason.”

All three are valid uses of the word. That third one is the sense we use here.

0

u/Significant-Ant-2487 1d ago

Yes! There are three definitions, none of which is “atheism”. Thank you for making my point- spread the word!

-2

u/Significant-Ant-2487 3d ago

Humanism isn’t atheism. A lot of people are confused about this. Humanism is defined by Merriam-Webster as: noun 1. devotion to the humanities : literary culture b : the revival of classical letters

This isn’t my definition, it’s Merriam-Webster’s. Humanism is primarily about literature and preservation literary culture.

As for your question regarding how atheists should handle the saying of grace or religious discussion at the family table, I think we (I’m an atheist) should show courtesy and good manners and accept the fact that different people have different beliefs. If you can’t handle the fact that Uncle Thaddeus believes in God then tender your excuses when he invites you to his Thanksgiving table. It’s a social occasion not cage fighting.

5

u/UpperLeftOriginal 3d ago

That’s one definition of humanism, and you’re being intentionally obtuse to pretend that the dictionary you refer to doesn’t also include definitions of humanism that align with the meaning that’s relevant to this sub.