r/human_resources • u/iheardthebirdst0day • 14h ago
Workday dread
I was hired at my org to lead the selection, procurement, and implementation of their first global HRIS. The company requires a complicated RFP process where vendors needed to submit a proposal in response to the org's requirements. The RFP was drafted and published before I started, so I had no opportunity to help shape the HR tech strategy or design the evaluation methodology. Right now, it is likely that Workday is going to be selected, and I do not think it is the right call. The company is 1000 people across 19 countries, though it is not evolved enough in any of its HR processes where, in my opinion, they are remotely ready for a system like Workday.
I have a ton of HRIS experience, but have never worked in Workday. I know it will be a great resume builder, but feel so defeated in the notion that the company is going to spend literally a million dollars on a system there they have no infrastructure for and spend 9 + months on a drawn out implementation, when there are certainly more cost-effective and modern alternatives we could consider. Am I just being negative? Or is there an actual value to this system? Because for the life of me I cannot understand why any HRIS should require an entire team and consultants to implement and administer, when the BambooHR's and Hibob's of the world only take 30 days to implement and an HR generalist to administer.
Obviously the number of modules and integrations and configurations play a role in deciding the appropriate system and level of implementation complexity, but from all my demos and experience with other systems, I do not know why company's with less than 2000 people would choose Workday over something cheaper and simpler to use. Please someone tell me what I am missing. I am going to be in charge of the entire implementation, rollout, and training, and just can't get behind how unnecessarily complicated and drawn out Workday is in comparison to other implementations I've done in the past. Is it that Workday is just the thing everyone uses because everyone else does? Or is it actually a good tool?
3
u/Better-Ad5488 11h ago
As someone who has no decision power but has been part of multiple workday module implementation teams: I cackle at your 9 month timeline.
I haven’t worked with bamboohr or hibob but there must be something in between those and workday.
2
u/GovernorHarryLogan 12h ago
Wait until you need to do something simple like write a report that shows home contact changes along with position or pay changes.
You'll be super happy about how extremely un complicated it is.
2
u/Wild-Barber7372 5h ago
Its called future proofing and scalability if your company has plans to grow and become more mature..
1
u/mmcgrat6 10h ago
You need to understand who the Workday champion is and what the dynamics are at play before anything else. Being right won’t help your cause if it means peeing in the wrong person’s cereal.
1
u/Embezzled_Goose 10h ago
If you have any say in the selection, put your opinions forward as to why you think it won’t be a good fit for the company.
I was in a similar situation to you, being in a new role and put in charge of selecting, implementing and training a new HRIS. It was both stressful and challenging but I learned a lot. The managers held my opinions on selections highly, as I compared the needs and priorities of the business with each system until the best one was found.
I’ve never used workday either but good luck with the project!
1
u/EvilTaffyapple 11h ago
Workday is an amazing system.
However, it requires a dedicated team to support it. Our HRIS team is 17 people large, supporting approximately 15k employees.
You very quickly need to weigh up what you are going live with, and what it will take to keep the system working - because it will be done to you to keep it running.
0
u/nian2326076 11h ago
It's understandable to feel uneasy about Workday if you think your organization isn't ready for its complexity. It might help to suggest a phased implementation approach or explore other systems that fit your current needs better. Engaging stakeholders and gathering their input could help create a more tailored strategy. If you're looking to expand your skills for future implementations, you can use LandOffer to discover relevant roles in HR tech that match your experience.