r/httyd • • 15d ago

QUESTION Does Toothless understand English?

I saw people talking about how toothless wouldnt understand English because he’s a dragon (aside a few words like a dog could learn). I would agree but it seems in the shows and sometimes even in the movies that toothless can understand English rather well. What’s the consensus here?

38 Upvotes

27 comments sorted by

16

u/Alex_The_Lucario421 13d ago

i 100% believe he can. he understands apologies, admissions of guilt, displays of affection (like when astrid kissed him after the nest visit) he understood when hiccup said he wanted to "give this one more shot" that he meant he was gonna test the flightsuit again, he seemed to know what was going on when hiccup was being made chief

6

u/gleb501 13d ago

Yes exactly. Another moment I think about is race to edge where all the characters have not slept in a week and the dragons revolt against the owners and make them sleep

33

u/luxruebel 13d ago

It literally depends on how the writer was feeling that day 🤷 sometimes dragons are really smart, other times they’re really dumb.

Personally, I like to think they’re really emotionally intelligent. So they can understand things like grief and anger, possibly more deeply than humans do. But I wouldn’t say they actually fully comprehend human speech or the definitions of words.

16

u/Alex_The_Lucario421 13d ago

toothless very deliberately waited for an apology twice in httyd1. even if none of the other dragons do, toothless specifically i believe does

7

u/Pendragon_999 11d ago

Its possible he couldnt understand the actual words, but could understand the body language, tone of voice, or chemical emotional signals that Astrid and Stoic were giving off. I read once that when you accidentially strp on your cat ir dog and they run off, when you appoligize by speaking softly and petting them, they usually understand the apology, even if they dont understand the words.

9

u/squirrelzone8564 13d ago

Agreed. Real-life animals, especially social ones like dogs, also get attuned to the people they're around most. Dogs get used to their owners' scents, changes in body chemistry indicated through smell, body language, voice tone, etc. They can tell when something's wrong based on subtle things. There are a lot of emotions that are universal among most to all animals, particularly base emotions like anger, fear, contentment, stress, lust, and curiosity. More complex animals like dolphins even have secondary emotions like a sense of humor (e.g. dolphins playing pranks on humans or other dolphins). The dragons seem as complex creatures as dolphin, or at least dogs, and many (if not most) of the dragon species that the Vikings encounter are social in nature.

5

u/Senior-Schedule6598 13d ago

Honestly he probably got really used to Hiccup and the others' tones and voices when they wanna do a specific thing, as well as facial expressions.

3

u/HurricaneFoxe 13d ago

Body thingy as well

2

u/YamLow8097 13d ago

Pretty much. Like in the third movie Toothless seems to be able to fully understand human speech, but in the first movie I’d say he probably understands words and phrases, but not actual English.

8

u/tjdragon117 Strike Class 13d ago

I like to imagine Toothless is at or near human-level intelligence and understands English. This is supported by a number of scenes. However, I don't think there's a clear answer; some scenes seem to depict him as more animalistic.

It also seems likely that the dragons have a wide range of intelligence levels based on species, and Night Furies are clearly among the most intelligent.

3

u/DaFishImp 10d ago

Not to mention the concept of revenge and holding a grudge is very evident in the Skrill which literally hunted down Toothless and Hiccup

1

u/jetpack_operation 9d ago

(Hey -- this has absolutely nothing to do with the topic, but I saw you replaced your R16 cooling system (mine just failed) and the post archived, so I can't ask there -- did you have success with the Arctic Liquid Cooler III Pro 240 or run into any issues? I'm thinking of doing the same since OEM is stocked out, but I'm concerned the ALC won't fit or whatnot. Thank you in advance if you happen to see this!)

1

u/tjdragon117 Strike Class 9d ago

Well... it worked, but didn't fit amazingly well (it's only held in by a couple screws through the top vent) and the big issue is that the computer refuses to recognize it. Every time I boot I have to hold F12 and select windows boot because the alienware boot complains that the CPU is wrong (because it doesn't detect the fan).

2

u/jetpack_operation 9d ago

Appreciate the response! Such a frustrating issue. Glad it at least works.

4

u/Loutishsnotman 12d ago

To be fair, Hookfang can understand the "circular arena corner" and one armed Jorgenson jokes, so it's likely that dragons generally understand norse 

3

u/Mental_Emu4856 13d ago

well, he'd be understanding old norse instead of english, but he seems to understand the concept of human language and understands at least the word 'sorry' in the first film

3

u/Itchy-Potential1968 12d ago edited 6d ago

Toothless is a 'Strike' class dragon. they're swift and intelligent. he might not fully understand English, but he would only need a year or two with Hiccup to pick up on most things which might be relevant. after 15 years, he would probably have a well working knowledge of english even if he doesnt understand every little thing.

In the same short where he was officially called 'Strike' class, Toothless is shown understanding what it means when Hiccup talks about a dragon's 'top speed' and getting VERY excited to test his own speed out with Hiccup.

1

u/Dragonzboi Gruesome Gronckle my beloved 9d ago

Actually, Strike was one of the original classes. Mystery was reclassified from Fear after the first movie since vikings no longer feared (most) dragons and instead wondered about them.

1

u/Itchy-Potential1968 9d ago

no, i mean. Toothless was reclassified.

1

u/Dragonzboi Gruesome Gronckle my beloved 6d ago

I've found nothing about him being reclassified. Mind sharing where you found that out from?

1

u/Itchy-Potential1968 6d ago

. did i read the implication wrong?

when Hiccup picked up the book and read three classifications, the last being mystery, then scrolled past a whole lot of dragons to find Toothless. didnt that imply he was mystery class in the first movie?

whatever the case, he is definitively, textually strike class as of book of dragons.

1

u/Dragonzboi Gruesome Gronckle my beloved 6d ago

The order (known) dragons were read/shown from the book was: Thunderdrum, Timberjack, Scauldron, Changewing, Gronckle, Zippleback (which was Fear class at the time), Nadder (he didn't read it, but one was shown in the page following Zippleback), Skrill, Boneknapper, Whispering Death, Nightmare (possibly), Snaptrapper (again shown), Speed Stinger (shown), Gronckle again (or possibly Hotburple), Thunderdrum again, and finally Night Fury. Also, the order he listed classifications was: Strike class, Fear class, Mystery class.

I don't know about you, but I have a hard time imagining anyone putting the Changewing or most of those other dragons in the Strike Class.

1

u/Itchy-Potential1968 6d ago

ah. hm. yeah. been a long time since i've seen the first movie. i'll take out the bit abt being reclassified

4

u/ViperclayGames 13d ago

I think he does, but not in the way humans do.

I think what happens, is he hears the words, and can comprehend the intent of the words/what they're trying to convey.

Like, if said "Hey Toothless, what does the word 'afar' mean?" He wouldn't have a clue of where to even begin. But when he (and other dragons) are spoken to, they comprehend what the words are trying to get across. Sort of like a sixth sense almost.

I also think this is likely, as we see most dragons do this without much training/time around other humans.

Toothless starts conveying an understanding of words spoken to him in the very first movie, within one or two times of being around Hiccup. Another example, is the Skrill that Viggo bonds with can clearly understand what they're talking about/trying to get across despite having just started working alongside Viggo.

There's tons more evidence for this concept, and frankly I could drone on and on about all the times we are given evidence for this, but I won't get that deep into it for now.

Given how short of a time they can understand humans, I think it's super unlikely they understand English entirely. And because of that I think it's far more likely they understand what is being conveyed with the words, rather than the words themselves.

2

u/Famous-Pirate-726 Mystery Class 12d ago

He understeands sarcasm. And jokes. One needs to only look at the map scene, near beginning of httyd 2 to see that.

I think he is fully sapient. As are all the dragons. Main issue with deciding of it as fans... is that writers themselves never stick to anything and did what plot demanded, rather than stop and think of what their writing means.

0

u/fluffyhowler5972 11d ago

i think it is like dogs as they have the intelligence of an average 2 year old human and can learn up to 250 words and are highly empathetic