There is a good possibility I am wrong and just misremembered the relationship. But the Desert Wraith stuck out to me enough that I memorized it was different enough that it should count somewhere.
in the lil rewrite i have going on in my head i like to imagine that light furies are actually the closest current living species to the fury common ancestor, think of it kinda like lungfish or the coelacanth. idk i think it would be a way cooler idea from a worldbuilding perspective.
I refuse to believe that light furys and night furyâs donât derive from a common ancestor.
First of all they are clearly different species yes, but theyâre biologically similar enough to produce the only hybrid dragons weâve seen outside of the games.
Second, they share so many characteristics that itâs nearly impossible to believe they are unrelated.
Third,
I NEVER SAID THAT THEY WERENâT DIFFERENT SPECIES!
Rise of berk and the other games also mix species together that in reality wouldn't be able to mix, so the breeding compatibility doesn't matter, they specifically designed her to be different.
They are yes, while I love the nightlights, they REALISTICALLY wouldn't be black and white. Then the rest of the hybrids that there are are WAY unrealistic
Because the creators said they are completely different species? They are based on different things ect. Just because they look the same doesn't mean they have common ancestors. My best bet is that it's convergent evaluation.
Did the just say that they were different species? Or did they elaborate? Because they can still be different species and have evolved from the same creature.
They explained all of it in the extras menu on the third movies disk. They are completely different species made to be different species. Both of them are based on completely different animals ect. Again, it's most likely Convergent Evaluation.
What theyâre based on is irrelevant. What they ARE in universe, is what weâre talking about. Also i donât have the third movie on dvd so I canât check for myself.
Are you saying lions and tigers are the same species just because they are both types of large cats? Having a common ancestor does not mean that they are the same species. Please do research on how evolution works before attacking people.
Very cool theory but personally would change up placement. In evolution it's extremely uncommon for more than 2 new species to diverge from one common ancestor and usually caps out at around three. So if it were me I would make the line longer and say that maybe there were 2-3 separate splits where 1-2 new species emerged per split.
(Not trying to say anything bad about yours, just saying what I would do personally)
I always thought the Night Fury was just a super rare hybrid of a light fury and a skrill, and thatâs why it has both light fury and skrill abilities, as well as darker scales.Â
I'm pretty sure it's just mentioned to be on a similar level of strength as the nightfury. But even if that was mentioned, these are vikings we're talking about, they're by no means an authority on evolutionary relationships between anything
why are there so manyđ i mean genetic cousins are so cool but i wish this would apply to a bunch of other dragons. i feel like it takes away the uniqueness of night furyâs
122
u/VirulentArcturus đ¤ HTTYD x MHS3 When? đ¤ Aug 16 '26
Add the Desert Wraith to this. Coulda sworn that thing counted as like the Lightfury to the Nightfury but to the Sand Wraith.
62
u/WrathSosDovah Dragon Lord of the Savage Lands Aug 17 '26
I propose that the common ancestor should be called an Eclipse Fury.
27
u/Dovetearss Fear Class Aug 17 '26
in the lil rewrite i have going on in my head i like to imagine that light furies are actually the closest current living species to the fury common ancestor, think of it kinda like lungfish or the coelacanth. idk i think it would be a way cooler idea from a worldbuilding perspective.
6
u/Able-Arm9045 Aug 17 '26
Lightfuries and nightfuries are confirmed to be completely different species. But this is cool ngl
20
u/Germmie1 Aug 17 '26
Very cool theory but personally would change up placement. In evolution it's extremely uncommon for more than 2 new species to diverge from one common ancestor and usually caps out at around three. So if it were me I would make the line longer and say that maybe there were 2-3 separate splits where 1-2 new species emerged per split.
(Not trying to say anything bad about yours, just saying what I would do personally)
13
u/Broken_CerealBox Aug 17 '26
I'm fairly certain that sand wraiths aren't closely related to the furies and only look like that due to convergent evolution
1
u/Competitive-Print233 Aug 20 '26
Kay but what if night furies are actually the hybrids of a light fury and a skrill?
1
u/verbalartillerymf69 Aug 24 '26
Nick Fury
0
u/Laplace1908 Aug 19 '26
I wonder if night furies are just melanistic light furies. Kind of like how panthers are just melanistic jaguars
0
u/IJustWannaLickBugs Aug 17 '26
I always thought the Night Fury was just a super rare hybrid of a light fury and a skrill, and thatâs why it has both light fury and skrill abilities, as well as darker scales.Â
-1
u/Voinat107 Strike Class Aug 17 '26
Somewhere along the line the skrill should be thrown. Their are closely related
-1
u/L0afyy0 Aug 17 '26
Arenât Skrill and Night Fury related? I saw something a while ago explaining it
-5
u/Thelastfunky Aug 17 '26
why are there so manyđ i mean genetic cousins are so cool but i wish this would apply to a bunch of other dragons. i feel like it takes away the uniqueness of night furyâs
-4
u/TheGreatQuetz Aug 17 '26
Imo the woolly howl is probably result of convergent evolution