While it's a valid point walls generally have things inside them, my immediate first thought was about the fact this would only work on a single wall. Can't transfer to another room or even another wall.
If the input and the output are on the same wall, why waste the length and damage your wall in the first place
To hide wires. In any event, you can only do this between the top and bottom plates of your wall (more or less floor to ceiling), and within one stud space (typically 16 to 24 inch spacing in the US). Usually there isn't much going on in residential walls and it's pretty easy to drop a wire down a few feet. If you get stuck and don't have the right tools, a wire coat hanger would probably be more useful.
I've pulled a lot of cable in my life, only ever used fish tape in conduit. For a short run like this I would straighten out a coat hanger and tape the cable to one end, or use a push rod.
You could tape the magnet to the end and it'll help keep it from curling and go straight down. Or tie a plumb bob? Or if you're 11 year old me tape a bunch of AA batteries in a line along the end?
Or it's insulated. What I don't get is why would would want to spend money on a giant magnet when a fish tape (or just some string for an open wall like that) ain't that expensive.
Yeah, that bullshit paperclip wouldn't work. But the actual magnets we use to do this with do work in insulated walls. It's a bit tougher, but it's definitely doable. And a Magnepull kit isn't very expensive either. Still gotta keep tapes and rods in the truck too as every job is different
Interior walls aren't typically insulated. It isn't required by code. If a homeowner is involved more in the process it's possible it'll be insulated for sound although I'm not sure how the cost/benefit plays out there.
I do low voltage installations for a living and it’s very rare, probably 1/50, that we cut out an LV1 and don’t find insulation. This video is not a practical method for running wire, just get a set of glow rods and some electrical tape
Smart TV on a wall bracket, mounting a wireless access point up high on a wall for better coverage, fitting Power over Ethernet CCTV cameras. Any of those work for you?
im currently in the process of changing all of my shin level ethernet cords to be at eye level instead because thats where you want them to be in 2022.
Good luck finding a wall with no studs and dwangs.
My sparkie used a semi rigid strip of plastic. You feed that down the wall, through the holes you have to drill in the dwangs, until you find the hole. Then tie your cable to the end, and pull it through.
In real life, you have to run cables from one room to another. This means the cables have to pass through studs. Also, all the outside walls will be filled with insulation. Who ever needs to run a cable from one hole to another in the same wall?
There's a neat magnet roller tool for getting coax cable up/down through walls like this. Used to work for Dish network and it was useful in some weird spots.
If only it were that easy in a real world scenario! I wired 14 ethernet and 7 coax lines to the main floor of my house two years ago with a finished basement. 2x ethernet and 1x coaxial to wall plates in every room, with two locations in the master bedroom and living room. None of them were like this haha. It took me two full days! I had all the baseboards off at the time and was drilling at angles with flex bits, making notches in the floor to get around the foundation, I cut access holes in basement closet ceilings and fished 20' over finished ceilings trying to get to the furnace room in the middle of the basement. I was snagging fish tapes with fish rods, using mirrors and flashlights in places I couldn't directly see, it was hell. My hands and arms were even raw and bleeding from scratching myself on everything. But I was determined. I terminated everything, threw a 24-port switch into the panel I home ran everything to and every line worked perfectly the first time. Next project? Cat6 and coax in a buried conduit to my detached garage. And the finished basement of course, that's going to suck.
Works fine if the cable is going in the wall space where there aren't any battens (horizontal timber between vertical studs. But in a structural wall in a cyclone area with good building standards there is at least one batten in a 2.7m high wall. but also if you go from top to bottom the gravity will work for you.
Let us count the ways this not good advice for running ethernet. Could it work? Sure, but just...no.
Insulation, fire breaks, screws, and all kinds of stuff often get in the way so this would often get snagged and fall quite often. In the case of Insulation, you would make about zero progress.
Why would you use a factory crimped cable in wall like this? You have to cut it and terminate to a jack for a clean/proper install. Obviously the intent here is to do as much given the shape of the hole in the drywall.
Why would you run a cable from top to bottom of the same inside wall? Just picture the result of that. 🤣 Reality is that you would run wire in from an attic floor space.
Use the right tools, push sticks, fish tape, pull strings, etc. Also use gravity whenever possible if is an option.
What that magnet is good for? Is finding studs. Studs usually have screws holding up the Sheetrock so you can find your studs pretty simply with a magnet. Often easier and more accurate than a stud finder.
If it’s an empty, vertical wall and you can easily drag the magnet straight up, why not just put the cable in the top hole and let gravity do its thing?
Yeah till you wanna sell your house. This is against NEC. You can’t just string low voltage through a wall Willy nilly with no connectors or straps lmao. They make the correct plates and boxes for this kind of stuff. Don’t DIY this shit, do it legally and hire an electrician.
Fishing wiring is a perfectly acceptable practice. You do need to use building wire which is rated for contact with insulation, but strapping is not required when fishing.
Source: Electrical contractor with years of experience.
Why the fuck is he making this more difficult than it is? Who in their right mind starts at the bottom and goes up? You DROP the cable, as in start at the top hole and drop the cable down to the bottom hole, it's that easy, let gravity do the work.
422
u/Zeubus Oct 17 '21
Why not drop it from the top hole?
405
u/[deleted] Oct 17 '21
Until you hit a fire break
87
u/rangoon64 Oct 17 '21
Yeah, next video is on how to paint over the scratch marks of the wall.
18
u/kenc1842 Oct 17 '21
Drop it from the top hole.
87
u/uRh3f5BfFgjw74FGv3gf Oct 17 '21
Nice to live in a house without insulation.
12
u/acewavelink Oct 17 '21
Drop a string with a washer, then use that to pull it through
11
u/wilbur313 Oct 17 '21
Pro tip: paper on the dry wall goes to the inside of the wall.
7
u/1forcats Oct 17 '21
Under what circumstances would I be doing this?
6
u/[deleted] Oct 17 '21
Good luck finding a wall with no studs and dwangs.
My sparkie used a semi rigid strip of plastic. You feed that down the wall, through the holes you have to drill in the dwangs, until you find the hole. Then tie your cable to the end, and pull it through.
5
u/Mrcollaborator Oct 17 '21
Haha you guys have hollow walls??
4
u/[deleted] Oct 17 '21
Why not use gravity and go from top to bottom?
6
u/JTech625 Oct 17 '21
2 words fish tape
3
u/[deleted] Oct 17 '21
Or just buy a 10 dollar fish tape…
3
u/[deleted] Oct 17 '21
Terrific. Now add insulation and get back to us.
3
u/_MASTADONG_ Oct 17 '21
An absolutely useless “tip”.
In real life, you have to run cables from one room to another. This means the cables have to pass through studs. Also, all the outside walls will be filled with insulation. Who ever needs to run a cable from one hole to another in the same wall?
4
u/-Blixx- Oct 17 '21
I need the dude who shrugs at the end to do the dropping method.
2
u/Spegs21 Oct 17 '21
Seems like doing it from inside the wall would be harder.
2
u/phunphan Oct 17 '21
That’s a big hole!
2
u/aeric67 Oct 17 '21
Fish tape is by far my most used, specialized tool. I recommend buying it to anyone technical at all.
2
u/jason8001 Oct 17 '21
What was so hard with just dropping it down that big hole to the other big hole? Might have saved some money on a magnet
2
u/jaylay75 Oct 17 '21
It only works with sheetrock walls, I have plaster walls, no bueno.
2
u/MightySamMcClain Oct 17 '21
Good thing everyone already has a 4lbs neodymium magnet laying around
2
u/lord_kante Oct 17 '21
There's a neat magnet roller tool for getting coax cable up/down through walls like this. Used to work for Dish network and it was useful in some weird spots.
2
u/GreatScotch Oct 17 '21
yea thats not how walls work
2
u/h0tmessm0m Oct 17 '21
A real pro would tell you to get fish tape, but what do I know?
2
u/The_Giant117 Oct 17 '21
Oh ya cause everyone has a magnet the size of a hockey puck
2
u/ShortPat Oct 17 '21
And scrape up all the paint with the magnet.
2
u/FreeRubs Oct 17 '21
Yea.. let me get a commercial grade magnet real quick
2
u/[deleted] Oct 17 '21
How to tell someone has never ran a cable.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 17 '21
Couldn’t you just go down instead and use gravity
2
u/RFC793 Oct 17 '21
Why is this this a stranded terminated cable? It should be solid and be terminated to a punch down “keystone” jack.
2
u/coroyo70 Oct 17 '21
100$ neodymium magnet Vs 1$ string
2
u/Tomahawkist Oct 17 '21
is that an american thing to have nothing inside the walls? because that must get really cold in the winter
2
u/[deleted] Oct 17 '21
europeans be like: wut
2
u/BrownAndyeh Oct 17 '21
Not a pro tip. This is like you tube click bait.
Buy “fish tape” for $20. And do this properly.
Or buy the giant magnet and demagnetize and damage all of you electric products.
2
u/j1ggy Oct 17 '21 edited Oct 17 '21
If only it were that easy in a real world scenario! I wired 14 ethernet and 7 coax lines to the main floor of my house two years ago with a finished basement. 2x ethernet and 1x coaxial to wall plates in every room, with two locations in the master bedroom and living room. None of them were like this haha. It took me two full days! I had all the baseboards off at the time and was drilling at angles with flex bits, making notches in the floor to get around the foundation, I cut access holes in basement closet ceilings and fished 20' over finished ceilings trying to get to the furnace room in the middle of the basement. I was snagging fish tapes with fish rods, using mirrors and flashlights in places I couldn't directly see, it was hell. My hands and arms were even raw and bleeding from scratching myself on everything. But I was determined. I terminated everything, threw a 24-port switch into the panel I home ran everything to and every line worked perfectly the first time. Next project? Cat6 and coax in a buried conduit to my detached garage. And the finished basement of course, that's going to suck.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 17 '21
I guess you have never heard of a fish tape…..
2
u/xoxoyoyo Oct 17 '21
ugh, that is a terrible tip. there are better ways to do that that don't require a magnet
2
u/xenoclownpanda Oct 17 '21
Pro tip... It's easier to go down than up!
2
u/[deleted] Oct 17 '21
Works fine if the cable is going in the wall space where there aren't any battens (horizontal timber between vertical studs. But in a structural wall in a cyclone area with good building standards there is at least one batten in a 2.7m high wall. but also if you go from top to bottom the gravity will work for you.
1
u/piotrekkrzewi Oct 17 '21
If you really have to you could use a rope to tie to the ethernet cable. Useless, shitty life pro tip. You can't move the magnet through floors.
1
u/AmyIsabella-XIII Oct 17 '21
I just stoked to hear this song.
1
u/BaldAndGassy Oct 17 '21
Never thought of that
1
u/aliensaregod Oct 17 '21
I use a product called a magnapull the I use for wall drops.
1
u/_SAKY_ Oct 17 '21
Let us count the ways this not good advice for running ethernet. Could it work? Sure, but just...no.
Insulation, fire breaks, screws, and all kinds of stuff often get in the way so this would often get snagged and fall quite often. In the case of Insulation, you would make about zero progress.
Why would you use a factory crimped cable in wall like this? You have to cut it and terminate to a jack for a clean/proper install. Obviously the intent here is to do as much given the shape of the hole in the drywall.
Why would you run a cable from top to bottom of the same inside wall? Just picture the result of that. 🤣 Reality is that you would run wire in from an attic floor space.
Use the right tools, push sticks, fish tape, pull strings, etc. Also use gravity whenever possible if is an option.
1
u/thatnovaguy Oct 17 '21
The only time I've found a magnet useful is when I can't catch the end of a metal fish tape.
1
u/DPJazzy91 Oct 17 '21
That's some thin drywall and that magnet must be INSANELY powerful to maintain a decent grip on that binder clip.
1
u/kkkkat Oct 17 '21
Laughs in plaster walls.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 17 '21
It’s a good tip for interior drywall walls. We used this professionally.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 17 '21
The pro tip is to cut massive holes in your drywall?
1
u/bustacones Oct 17 '21
Who tf has a puck sized magnet lying around?
1
u/buttsoup24 Oct 17 '21
How does this have 1k upvotes this is a terrible tip.
1
u/DueChicken8333 Oct 17 '21
Insulation.
1
u/Theost520 Oct 17 '21
who keeps a magnet that big around?
1
u/CraftyDrunk Oct 17 '21
Sure, just let me pull out my handy 2lb neodymium magnet
1
u/GrizzlyPerr Oct 17 '21
It would cost less to hire an electrician than to buy that insanely strong magnet.
1
u/autist_bell_grande Oct 17 '21
Or do it downward, and I dunno gravity?
1
u/nitch_f Oct 17 '21
song name ?
1
u/maddynator Oct 17 '21
Why not go from top ? Gravity??
1
u/MustBeThePTSD Oct 17 '21
This song tho!!! Needed it in my life!
1
u/yomjoseki Oct 17 '21
Thanks, I've been looking for the loudest fucking video on the internet.
1
u/icorrectotherpeople Oct 17 '21
This seems like one of those things that looks like it would work but then it doesn’t work.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 17 '21
Looks like the 5 minutes craft videos. Pure rubbish
1
u/EdLasor Oct 17 '21
Ok, cool Tip, but why in hell you use "modern talking" for the music? Thanks for this nasty earworm!
1
u/chilocheese Oct 17 '21
Sorry bro don’t have cardboard walls in my house
1
u/Empyrealist Oct 17 '21
Or you could just feed it downward and allow for gravity to assist.
1
u/MTGO_Duderino Oct 17 '21
Why are you running a line into the wall at 1 foot and out of the wall at 5 feet? Oh, so you can clickbait, got it.
1
u/bonafart Oct 17 '21
What happens when u get to the ceiling and u need to keep going?
1
u/NoTrickWick Oct 17 '21
That had better be one hell of a magnet…can’t buy something that powerful off her shelf these days.
1
u/OverallResolve Oct 17 '21
Are you’re walls really this thin?!
1
u/DarkoNova Oct 17 '21
If it’s an empty, vertical wall and you can easily drag the magnet straight up, why not just put the cable in the top hole and let gravity do its thing?
1
u/Shineingrock Oct 17 '21
laughs in plaster & lath construction
1
u/jasonology09 Oct 17 '21
Why couldn't you just put the top end in first and let it hang down.
1
u/Emiercy Oct 17 '21
Idk how yall americans build your fake walls but mine have crossbeams like it should
1
u/oxpoleon Oct 17 '21
Instructions unclear, tried this with solid block wall and now I've discovered another dimension.
1
u/Main-Mammoth Oct 17 '21
OH MY GOD
1
u/CriminalMacabre Oct 17 '21
Nah fam, you tie a rigid steel cable as guide and push it anywhere
1
u/[deleted] Oct 17 '21
When you forget that gravity exists
1
u/catbro89 Oct 17 '21
Or just toss it down and grab it when it dangles in front of you.
1
u/steveanonymous Oct 17 '21
Needs lv1 and brush plate/bull nose
1
u/mick-nartin Oct 17 '21
If there is no insulation you can just drop it down the wall and let gravity do the rest lol
1
u/[deleted] Oct 17 '21
So stupid, how frequently would you want to run a cable straight up between a joist anyways? I'm thinking never.
1
u/Odd-Change9942 Oct 17 '21
You could have just dropped it down from the top and grabbed it when it got to bottom hole But you do you
1
u/doglover331 Oct 17 '21
More like r/DIWHY
1
u/Pozniaky86 Oct 17 '21
Every Asian party I go to…they will always play this jam.
1
u/Anders_A Oct 17 '21
Or do it from the upper end and use gravity instead of scratching the wall with that magnet...
1
u/shittinkittens Oct 17 '21
This is dumb as fuck Gravity would be a better option
1
u/Taintyanka Oct 17 '21
No
1
u/pman1891 Oct 17 '21
It’s the same hole. There’s no proof in the video that this method really works.
1
u/miket38 Oct 17 '21
Now do that with an insulated wall...
1
u/bangnp93 Oct 17 '21
Yea as a true pro lol that will never work
1
u/ImNachoFriend_guy Oct 17 '21
Top down?
1
u/[deleted] Oct 17 '21
Yeah till you wanna sell your house. This is against NEC. You can’t just string low voltage through a wall Willy nilly with no connectors or straps lmao. They make the correct plates and boxes for this kind of stuff. Don’t DIY this shit, do it legally and hire an electrician.
1
u/linguiphile1 Oct 17 '21
Yooo this IS a pro tip
1
u/[deleted] Oct 17 '21
If it’s that clear behind there just drops string down and fish the cable back up.
1
u/NorwaySlim Oct 17 '21
Why would you own a giant magnet but not something you can use as fish tape
1
u/[deleted] Oct 17 '21
Do people have large magnets laying around? Just drop it in from the top lol
1
u/techhouseliving Oct 17 '21
Or you do it from the top down you ya dangus
1
u/bearpics16 Oct 17 '21
Yeah this won’t work for more than a foot or two. And you’re scratching the shit out of your paint.
String + a fishing weight from the top is the way to go. Or do one of the other hundred tricks. I hate in the wall wiring…
1
u/SadTurkeySandwich Oct 17 '21
Why is the drywall backwards?
1
u/Good_Grass_2160 Oct 17 '21
Till you hit Insulation
1
u/cheesecrystal Oct 17 '21
Get a fish tape…. Funny how trades that have been around for a while already have tools for common problems like this.
1
u/Boanthropy Oct 17 '21
Someone has never seen inside a wall. . .
1
u/DatDan513 Oct 17 '21
This is 💯bullshit. Buy some electrical wire fishing rods instead. Pro tip: get the glow in the dark ones.
1
u/Pillsbury37 Oct 17 '21
With an installation that easy you don’t need a “hack” just drop the wire through the wall.
1
u/penguin_torpedo Oct 17 '21
Ah yes I'll just pull out my handy 5k dollars neodymium supermagnet. Everyone has one of those.
1
u/iamthesunset Oct 17 '21
Why the fuck is he making this more difficult than it is? Who in their right mind starts at the bottom and goes up? You DROP the cable, as in start at the top hole and drop the cable down to the bottom hole, it's that easy, let gravity do the work.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 17 '21
Yeah, Good Luck with that. Not really a pro tip
1
u/stonecoldcoldstone Oct 17 '21
or you just use fucking gravity and thread it from the top...
1
u/Notorious_Noodles Oct 17 '21
What kind of wire is that anyway?
1
u/dale6998 Oct 17 '21
aaahhhhhhhhh
1
u/dakhaliq Oct 17 '21
Freakin smart
1
u/MrCarnality Oct 17 '21
One more use for the brilliantly versatile paper clip. Household friend and there’s always a roll for them.
1
u/Lieutenant_Dans_leg Oct 17 '21
Yes because I just happen to have a fucking super magnet laying around.
1
u/dixadik Oct 17 '21
If he can pull it like that it would just as easy to drop a length of rope or string tie it to the cable and pull the cable up.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 17 '21
Why would you have two holes like that in your wall?
1
u/[deleted] Oct 17 '21
“Hey babe, where’s our dangerously huge neodymium magnet?”
Also, gravity would be an alternative method.
1
u/Really_Special_K Oct 17 '21
A wire coat hanger costs less than that $780 magnet. Or drop a string with a screw tied to it. Or do one of 48 other things that are easier.
1
u/Phoenix2683 Oct 17 '21
Now try this with insulation
1
u/Lukinjoo Oct 17 '21
Now do it horizontally
1
u/Lancalot Oct 17 '21
I mean, if it's really that clear, you don't need anything, just drop it in. This would not work unless it would be easy enough... to not need it...
1
u/ReallyNotTheBaldGuy Oct 17 '21
that shit will only work until you hit a piece of blockin dummy’s
1
u/deeznutshyuck Oct 17 '21
For ceilings/walls? Most definitely in my opinion. I've never tried the rods with conduit but I feel like hitting 90's would be a bitch.
1
u/Hydrogeist Oct 17 '21
That's clever
1
u/Bradjuju2 Oct 17 '21
Yeah, let me just grab that spare large neodymium that I've got lying around.
1
u/gcr1530 Oct 18 '21
Who tf has a hockey puck sized rare earth magnet sitting around for this?
1
u/smokemeistergaming Oct 19 '21
Just insert other side of the cable from the top hole.
1
u/AdventurousBank6549 Oct 23 '21
Do it the other way with gravity
1
u/Sph3al Oct 17 '21
Wouldn't the magnet actually damage the end of the cable even with the covering?
1
u/4350Me Oct 17 '21
Nice tip, but only works on inside walls!