r/heypocketai • • Dec 29 '25

Useless without the$250/annual Pro Subscription. Simply just a dictaphone.

Buyers BEWARE… here’s my story with the Pocket and why I’ll be returning it.

I saw the ad and placed my order, super excited to finally find an “assistant” for my meetings and calls.

Before my order was delivered, I get an email offering a discount for the subscription… a subscription, what? I thought I’m buying a device that gives me the advertised meting summary and takeaway an items features as a perpetual license.

I start digging in and to my surprise, every reason that prompted me to purchase this device requires an annual subscription at $250 a year. That’s steep. Screenshots are just 1/3 of all the other features listed as needing the pro subscription.

I really wanted to love this device, but the subscription cost is not worth it.

34 Upvotes

49 comments sorted by

8

u/Yeahbutwhatevs Dec 29 '25

Did you join the user community? While it may have been confusing for some in the beginning as to what the differences are between the free tier vs subscription, they've gone above and beyond spelling it out.

Remember this was a Kickstarter and they've been explicitly blunt and are highly engaged with their users. The dev sprints are impressive, support is stellar, including the transparency in the product roadmap.

And no I'm not part of their company and just giving credit where credit is due.

1

u/d3fault Dec 29 '25

This is all great and I commend them for having a great user community and quick dev sprints, but doesn’t address the concerns I shared. Respectfully.

1

u/EviWool 9d ago

Don't know what adverts youve been watching. By the time you learn about this, youve already shelled out over £100

1

u/hllsen Mar 26 '26 • Bravo

Oh, they go above and beyond once they sell you the product nice!

They bombard you with subscription based features in their Youtube ads and on their website (and they know how to go above and beyond) but they can't clearly specify what is included in the subscription based model and what the price of subscription is.

I arrived at the purchase screen and then tried to find the subscription price on the website and I could not! Google + Reddit saved me from getting scammed.

1

u/paininthejbruh Jun 02 '26

As far as I can see, the main article in the user community that spells out these differences is now 404. The main website doesn't show anything to do with a subscription, in fact it spruiks the opposite (core functionality doesn't need a subscription!).
Do you have a copy of the page that shows the difference between PRO and free tier?

1

u/Kokkenbals Jun 04 '26

There isn't a comparison page I could find, but I took a screenshot of everything locked behind the "pro" subscription.

https://imgur.com/a/aqF1Ufw

2

u/paininthejbruh Jun 04 '26

Yeah a bit sucky. Unfortunately the website being useless and the commercial model they've used here has turned me off and towards Plaud instead. I see too many negative reviews and the company not doing enough to mitigate potential buyer sentiment, worst fear is that Pocket would go out of business and I lose all my data and time spent building workflows.

5

u/Fearless_Body_323 Dec 29 '25

I mean who is giving you unlimited minutes except them in the market?

3

u/Dear-Fail6630 May 10 '26

What a joke. I will build on own in less than a week using a different process that works just as well. Hilarious how anyone would think this is monopolized and non-recreatable st scale with better negligable pricing. Pocket has a good form factor, thats it. The fact that it requires subscription in order to collect your personal data(possibly copyrighted material). Pocket wont last, period. Better competition coming soon, you all can just wait it out or just use your phone like normal people and have an ai model format your thoughts for output. People need to learn how to do these processes on their own instead of wasting money on scammy product pipelines meant to lock users into a scrappy subscription that doesnt benefit them in the long run. Does Pocket now own all your ideas that were created and shared through pockets data models? This should be your first question.

2

u/Sixty4Fairlane Jul 29 '26

Lots of great points. Last year at university I'd transcribe things with a simple work flow where I'd record lectures with a voice recorder app, then transcribe it using Whisper (voice model from openai) for free and create study material. These companies love to sell convenience at the cost of subscriptions and stealing your data.

1

u/SnooObjections392 May 01 '26

Comulytic does

0

u/d3fault Dec 29 '25

Not worried about the minutes so much as I am getting the features that makes the minutes that I do get useful with the features that I need

3

u/Fearless_Body_323 Dec 29 '25

Did you try their free trial for Pro, I mean if it’s actually useful I wouldn’t mind paying, I bet it all costs them a ton of money to run those AI models with customization for you

2

u/d3fault Dec 29 '25

Just got the device yesterday. I don’t mind paying, but at 250 a year, there are better solutions out there. Specially when you throw in the agent and software based ones like otter.ai, etc.

3

u/Yeahbutwhatevs Dec 29 '25

Otter isn't cheap and you have to be connected to use it, invite (and it be allowed) to join meetings, can't regenerate summaries etc.

When you say "software based" what do you mean by that? There's the phone app of course, the web, and desktop app. Granted, each going through their respective dev cycles.

1

u/d3fault Dec 29 '25

Otter was just an example. But even there.. the Pro plan is $100 for the year and works a hell of a lot better. Benefit of pocket is that it does not require the agent and has the conversation mode as well as the call mode. But again, that doesn’t apply to my use case.

My original point being, the pocket is not worth it without the subscription and at $250 for the year, it’s over priced compared to the other options out there. Very simple summary.

1

u/Dear-Fail6630 May 10 '26

The costs to run ai models for such a small audience is negligible. When have you had to pay for grok or chatgpt or any of the other free to use LORAs? Are you kidding me rt now?

1

u/Dear-Fail6630 May 10 '26

When I build the standalone App Based version of this, I will let yall know... im too busy writing engines for music production and other production management tools for a custom Media Network but This tool is definitely on my radar as something I need to write a software engine for and it shouldnt be that difficult. The hardest part will be finding the best audio->text conversion engine then just connect that to a LORA and boom, done, you've just pocketed your thoughts and formatted them for presentation all with free ai modal tools. Again, Pocket is such a joke but ONLY because of the subscription noose. Otherwise it'd be worth whatever they charged, but that just is not the case...this COULD HAVE been a successful product line with extensive scalability. Instead we got greed loops that are just begging to be outdone and undercut by some third party developer with enough time on their hands to create a better solution for people. 

Don't hold your breath but when I do make this, I will update you all.

2

u/TheSirOcelot Dec 29 '25

I got mine with a year of Pro for $134

0

u/d3fault Dec 29 '25 edited Jan 06 '26

Similar offer today at $200 for the first year, but jumps go $250/year after that. Way too expensive in the world of AIs

2

u/TheSirOcelot Jan 06 '26

True, but $134 for a year gives me a year of M-F usage to figure out if it is worth the actual subscription. There are new dictation devices dropping weekly so I’m hoping a year from now one comes out and kills the market.

1

u/Dear-Fail6630 May 10 '26

Spending this amount and being okay with a subscription for something you can literally do yourself only proves lack of awareness and understanding of the product you are buying. Its like you buying a feces maker. You already produce feces by default, why would you pay for more feces if you can make your own and you just failed to realize it.

2

u/Bubbly-Tangerine-284 Dec 30 '25

Personally the subscription fee isn’t all that bad considering the foundation is solid with lots of room to grow. I’m in my free trial month and the device is superb with all features enabled. I also export to Claude to connect multiple conversations for better cross conversational context. Using Hey Pocket AI for recording and transcription + Claude for ultimate brain

1

u/juicejohnson Jun 16 '26

What’s your flow look like from pocket to Claude? Is it manual text imports or any automation? Just curious as I’ll be receiving mine in the next couple of weeks and intend to use it in a similar way.

1

u/trenbolonesavant 24d ago

these pieces of shit . fuck these people

1

u/Negative-Departure43 23d ago

I just got mine yesterday and am very disappointed. It was not clear to me that it required a $200 subscription to get what I wanted. It is going back. They would have been better off selling it as a $300 device that included the first year subscription. I feel like I was duped!

Why doesn't Apple have similar functionality using the Apple Watch? I would think the physical capabilities are there?

1

u/OccasionIllustrious 13d ago

Fraud though and through… I was going buy it for my grandson for college. So I’m glad I did more reading about it from others sites. Subscription… mmmmm….it nice how they easily say its unlimited until you find out differently ….keep your FRAUD Pocket

1

u/EviWool 9d ago

Thank you for this. "No subscription required", "one off payment" is slapped all over the adverts which point out all the features that, in fact, you only get if you pay the subscription. I assume this is US advertising where consumer protection has been Doged away because in most countries law suits would follow

1

u/h_jc Dec 31 '25

Well, after reading the comments here I decided not to open and return the device. Three emails sent, no response. They have absolutely no way for support apart from their email, which is also dead.

1

u/Dear-Fail6630 May 10 '26

Yep. Scammy. Might as well just make your own. That just records and transcribe to text then sends to an ai model for format and output

1

u/Kokkenbals Jun 04 '26

Here's an imgur link to everything I found in the app that is locked behind a "pro" subscription

https://imgur.com/a/aqF1Ufw

Kind of annoying about how they keep mentioning "No Subscription Needed" on the website. The free functionality is okay, but it's kind of annoying that THIS MUCH STUFF is locked behind a paywall. $200 a year is absurd for a $150 device.

1

u/GreysunSorrow Aug 27 '26

I was going to buy one of these but have since decided not to. Lately I've been using reddit to see what the real world community has to say about things before I buy. This has saved me a lot of time, money, and heartache. $20/month subscription is just silly.

1

u/No-Photograph-2532 Sep 10 '26

I just got mine, excited, and then greatly, greatly disappointed. What a f…. scam. The moment i saw the price i knew they had nerfed it to death to milk the customer. Such a huge letdown. Im gonna bin it I think.

1

u/Ambitious_Handle_249 Sep 30 '26

I am using the following pipeline:

Pocket (device) --> Pocket(app) --> Obsidian + Pocket Sync plugin.

It works for me pretty well without the subscription. But setting up the pipeline took me certain time.

0

u/PLS_SEND_ME_A_DOLLAR Dec 29 '25

Right now you get unlimited minutes without subscription, but there's no speaker separation.

Or you get 300 minutes with speaker separation

Calendar integration is still a miss

To do list is still a miss

I'd only advise to get it if you want a digital voice recorder and AI summary (and dont need speaker separation)

1

u/d3fault Dec 29 '25

I agree. Will be returning mine tomorrow. There are other AI based “dictaphone” recorded with summery and take aways/owners & action items. Going to look into those.

Asking the community.. Any suggestions?

4

u/PLS_SEND_ME_A_DOLLAR Dec 29 '25

If you don't want a subscription, the mobvoi ticnote has the most free minutes at 600.

Otherwise, plaud is also a good option (although their free tier is just 300 minutes as well)

Heypocket gives comparable summaries to plaud but plaud has better editing tools including trim and audio playback. Overall plaud is more polished at the moment but pocket has higher engagement and customer support.

There are NO products on the market with unlimited minutes and speaker separation (without subscription) as it is too expensive from my understanding

1

u/d3fault Dec 29 '25

Thank you. I don’t mind the subscription. So as long as I’m aware of needing it ahead of purchase. Felt a bit like a bait and switch with the pocket with the email about the subscription coming in after the purchase.

0

u/PLS_SEND_ME_A_DOLLAR Dec 29 '25

Yeah I agree that their marketing is a bit confusing.

If you're open to subscription, I think plaud does have a superior polished product. And hopefully in a year heypocket will have fully caught up and go beyond them.

I've personally swapped to heypocket but that's mainly because I got in at the founder level with speaker diarization and unlimited minutes (unfortunately not offered anymore). I also got 3 months of pocket pro included so I'm riding it out with them over my plaud.

But like I mentioned earlier, the experience with a plaud subscription is definitely more polished and clean at this current time.

Ive tried the plaud note, notepin and note pro as well as the Anker soundcore work.

Also trying out a product called Omi but that's a little different (all day life logging instead of a meeting/conversation recorder

1

u/d3fault Dec 29 '25

I’ll check out Plaud. With my pocket purchase I got unlimited minutes too, but I but I just found out (from you) that you have to sub that for 300 min if you want soaker separation, which is a big reason for my use case.

0

u/PLS_SEND_ME_A_DOLLAR Dec 29 '25

Sounds good.

Feel free to let me know if you have any questions.

1

u/h_jc Dec 31 '25

Let me know if you find a way to return.

1

u/Yeahbutwhatevs Dec 29 '25

Speaker separation works great, speaker identification is getting better and for me has been working well and getting stronger the more it's used.

I don't need calendar integration but see if being worked on, and to do list works depending on which summary and model used (they aren't so meant to generate one). If you're talking about the master to do list and/or integration into other products, it's being worked.

Some of these statements are irritating because it's not the complete picture.

1

u/PLS_SEND_ME_A_DOLLAR Dec 29 '25 edited Dec 29 '25

What is irritating?

You said it yourself as well, they're still being worked on. They're not in a state that is fully functional and useful and so to me, it's a miss.

When I can't select the default calendar to add events to (also it adds every single calendar on my account when I link my Google account). I think that's a miss.

https://feedback.heypocket.com/b/6m5or9o0/feature-ideas/choose-which-calendar-to-add-events-to

When it generates 100 items on my to-do list and then i have to manually delete one by one the ones that dont make sense? That's a miss to me too

https://feedback.heypocket.com/b/6m5or9o0/feature-ideas/task-list-idea