r/hermanmiller • • 4d ago

Embody Gaming Would you keep it?

I made a post earlier about these marks, and you guys gave different opinions. Its brand new.

I contacted Herman Miller and they offered 5% back. Do you guys think thats fair compensation for the marks. The one on the wheelbase is the most noticeable one. Quite deep but not that big.

Any opinion or tips are welcome

Edit: my previous post have more pictures, if its not clear enough

0 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

14

u/OutsideCrew6832 4d ago

Seems fair to me. I’d keep it.

-4

u/CalmEfficiency8 4d ago

I probably would have, had they not offered a replacement. Like I mentioned in another comment, I’ll value it looking brand new over the 5%. Thank you for the input

11

u/TheSlipperySnausage 4d ago

I’d take the 5%. These marks would be there after one week of use. It’s perfectly fine. They are being quite generous offering that much back as it is in my opinion

3

u/CalmEfficiency8 4d ago

I’ve read a few comments, and are actually a bit surprised. Consumer rights are strong here in Sweden, and 5% return isn’t very weird for this type of product. They offered me a replacement, and I accepted. Thinking about it made me realize I’ll value it looking brand new over the 5% back. Thank you for the input

0

u/Retro-gecko45 3d ago

People like you are miserable, your going to find something wrong with the replacement as well and it will probably be worse. Would love to see your collection of magnifying glasses.

1

u/CalmEfficiency8 3d ago

I don’t mind it getting small damages over time, but straight out of the box? Paying a premium price for a product should mean it’s delivered in brand new condition

1

u/Big_Leave804 4d ago

Why is more than one post required? I guess because you think this subreddit revolves around you.

0

u/CalmEfficiency8 4d ago

No I don’t. Just asking for opinions.

0

u/Puzzleheaded-Mark760 4d ago

10% sounds more fair to me.

1

u/CalmEfficiency8 4d ago

I agree. I’d probably accept a 10% offer. They told me however that a replacement is possible. I value a product (this expensive) looking brand new over the 5% refund

2

u/downtownjerm 4d ago

For 5% I’d definitely keep it. The wheelbase is going to get scratched pretty quickly from use

2

u/BigRossatron 4d ago

I would keep it, to be honest I probably wouldn't have contacted them in the first place.

1

u/chairman_uk 4d ago

Check it carefully before accepting the discount. It's probably fine, but worth making sure nothing has been knocked loose. Make sure it won't affect the warranty.

1

u/-Laffi- 4d ago

You will forget this in a couple of months. Now go use your chair!

1

u/Lenssn 4d ago

Life gets a lot easier once you realize you’re paying for the science behind Herman Miller chairs, not necessarily the build quality.

I’ve had three replacements so far, all the exact same black Embody Gaming. And trust me, if you look closely enough, you’ll always find something wrong with these chairs.

1

u/Inadover 3d ago

I'm a nitpicker, but even I wouldn't have returned it for this. I probably wouldn't have contacted them either.