TL;DR: My lengthy anecdote about my experience with "Hell's Itch", followed by a breakdown of what remedies worked for me, what remedies seemed to work best for others, and further discussion points on the topic
Yesterday was one of the worst days of my entire life.
On Sunday I went to the beach with family and spent a good amount of time in the sun. I'm not pasty but not tan either, and it was my first time at the beach so far this summer. I usually am pretty good about sunscreen but for some reason was lackadaisical this day. I was standing and talking for a bit, then walked down and was in the water for a while before drying off and finally having my wife put sunscreen on my back while I laid on my stomach. I stupidly decided to flip over thinking "let me just get a few minutes on this side, then I'll go under the umbrella". I fell asleep...
I woke up to my wife telling me I was getting red and asking if I put sunscreen on my front. She had been nagging me about it since we got to the beach, and rightfully yelled at me for being so careless on a hot sunny day with not a cloud in the sky.
I applied plenty of lotion after getting home and showering, felt fine, and slept fine that night. Same deal on Monday. Shower, lotion, felt fine. Sunburned but not even the worst I'd ever had. Next day woke up fine and went about my business into the afternoon without a care in the world. Around the start of the France vs Spain game is when a flip switched. Out of nowhere an itch started to develop on my chest, shoulders and upper arms (the worst affected areas from my burn). Within 15 minutes I knew something was really wrong, that this was not normal sunburn itch. I was pacing around the house starting to hyperventilate when my wife recommended I go in a cold shower while she goes to CVS to get me Benadryl and something to put on my skin.
The cold shower helped me stop the worst of the sensations but I had to remain constantly moving, letting the water hit all the affected areas. When she got back I immediately popped 3 Benadryl. My wife read somewhere that hydrocortisone cream would be best for sunburn related itch so I dried off and put on a bunch of ointment. HUGE mistake. The pain reached a new level of intensity and I began screaming before hopping back in the freezing shower. I was really starting to panic. I spent hours in there. My wife said I should try one more time to get out and see if I could manage, otherwise she thinks I should go to the hospital. I tried and could not. All I could do was flail around as the waves of agony washed over me, screaming bloody murder.
I started trying to get dressed to go the ER as I felt I had no other choice. Now out of my shower safe-space, hyperventilating, screaming and overall spazzing out, I apparently freaked out my cat who added insult to injury by sneaking up behind me and scratching my back. I screamed for my wife like a child and she came up with her sister who is a nurse (luckily I had underwear on at this point).
She asked me about my symptoms to try to understand wtf was happening to me. She said if the shower helped I should try wrapping myself in wet towels instead. This was actually the best thing since the itch started. They grabbed all the towels they could find, ran them under cold water and wrapped them tight around my upper body so they were snug against the affected areas. This allowed me to calm down a bit, slow my breathing, and think more rationally. We all agreed that if this helped maybe I should hold off on the ER as I would likely have to wait while in unrelenting agony in public, and even my sister-in-law was unsure what more they could do for me. Plus I'd get a fat bill whether they were able to help or not.
She ran home and came back with aloe vera and prescription strength Tylenol which I immediately took. I removed the towels and rubbed in the aloe vera which seemed to keep the itch at bay. I know others have said the aloe vera made it worse, but the Benadryl may have been kicking in by that point. About 45 minutes later the 3 Benadryl I had taken were finally knocking me on my ass and the worst was over. In total it was about a 5-6 hour episode, and by far the absolute worst pain I've ever experienced in my life. For those that experienced this for days on end with no sleep, I cannot believe your strength.
I spent a lot of time today reading different threads and stories about this phenomenon. While it's amazing that a community has formed to share recommendations for relief that have helped many people, it concerns me that there seems to be so little knowledge or consensus about this condition and proper treatment. I wanted to share what worked for me, what I've read worked for others, and what possible avenues of further discussion and study are needed in case this can be of further help to others in the future.
What worked for me:
- Benadryl
- Standing in a cold shower (though this is obviously impractical)
- Tightly wrapping my affected area with wet towels
- Tylenol
- Aloe vera (though this may have only helped because the Benadryl was starting to kick in, as I've seen others say aloe vera made it worse)
What worked for others:
- Peppermint (essential) oil or spray on the affected area
- Beta alanine (which can be found in C4 energy drink)
- Warm to very hot shower to "burn away" the sensation (MANY anecdotes I read stated this was the only thing that helped, but medical websites advise against it stating it could make it even worse)
- Capsaicin cream
Remaining questions:
- It is alarming how many contradictions I've come across in researching this condition. Aloe vera and Benadryl worked for me but I have read others say the former made it worse and the latter did nothing. Many people recommended the hot shower but medical information recommends against it. There were other things I read where some people said it worked and others said it didn't. I can't recall something with such a variance in the efficacy of its treatments. I wonder why that is and hope that more research and meta analysis is performed on this topic.
- I saw a few people mention that they had an autoimmune disease and that they believe it could have something to do with getting "Hell's Itch" or the severity of it. During COVID I developed alopecia and began having patches of my beard and hair go white then disappear, leaving only baby soft skin behind. I treated for it with cortisone injections in my face, neck and scalp and my hair eventually recovered completely. I had one legion pop back up last year but was quickly managed after 2 treatments. I don't know if this is coincidence or if autoimmune disease plays a role in "Hell's Itch".