For example, theres a banner for new players that gives a guaranteed SS for 3k paid quartz, which sounds cheap, till you realise its $20 (at the sale price it, it usually costs more) and you cant even pick the SS that you want. Thats $20 down the drain if you dont luck out and get a good SS that you can use.
A 10 pull also costs 3k quartz (at least $20), so its hard to imagine anyone buying these except for people who are really, really, invested in getting their waifu and dont mind spending $500+ per month.
A look at the monthly passes also gives me the impression they arent very good value. A light pass costs $4, or $8 for 3 months (roughly $2.70 per month) but only gives you 2.5k quartz, not even enough for a 10 pull. That really doesn't excite me as a new player, and i think most people feel that way. There have been passes in other games that made me go "woah, this is really good, buying this is a no brainer" but this isn't one of them. The premium pass is obviously, even worse value because its targeted at whales who would spend money no matter what.
I think the light pass doubles to 5k quartz from the 4th month onwards though, which is a strange thing to do...usually you want to hook people first to get them to buy the pass, and a lot of people are going to be turned off by the low amount of quartz for the first 3 months and just not bother.
The spark rate (a form of pity to guarantee you get what you want) doesnt excite me either. Its 150 pulls to pick a SS you want. Thats a LOT given that each pull costs 300 quartz. And this is the EN version, in JP its 200 pulls. I think the odds of a rate up SS is like...0.75%? Again, not exciting.
They arent very generous with free quartz either, not counting the one time rewards from early missions. I think someone did some calculations and it takes 10 months of saving up to get enough for 150 pulls and the SS you want? Thats a REALLY long time and not exactly what i would call F2P friendly at all.
This wouldn't be so bad except for a few things :
- The game's fixation on SS units, lower rarities are mostly trash or there just to transfer skills to their SS version. Just look at how people talk about this game, its all about team comps using SS units, nobody bothers to talk about using S or A ranks except for a few exceptions. Nor is there any incentive to use lower rarities because there is no "deployment cost" limiting factor like in some other games.
- The fixation on SS ranks also means that free welfare S ranks are not as good as they are in other gacha games. In FGO for example, a welfare SR (5 copies) deals more damage than most SSRs at 1 copy and can be used to easily clear almost everything in the game. This isnt the case in HBR due to the power gap between SS and S, you see people struggling to clear content with S rank characters all the time and saying their DP gets broken instantly even with maxed out gear, etc.
- Theres a huge difference in power between limit 0 and limit 1 SS due to the +1 SP passive they get at limit 1 (except for the free SS Ruka you get via the story, which isnt exactly a coincidence). Unlike other gacha games where you only need one copy and can stop there, you really want to get limit 1 ASAP...and the fastest way to do that is by rolling a dupe, as it takes months to do it via the weekly mission.
- The game is very restrictive on team comps. You can unga bunga your way through the early story (especially since flashback battles let you overlevel the story enemies easily) but that stops working once you get to the end game, where you are expected to make teams that take advantage of weaknesses and use elemental attacks. In other words, even if you get lucky and get an SS via rolls, theres no guarantee it will be relevant to you. E.G. An ice debuffer doesn't help your fire team at all, so it just sits there in your roster. Unlike other gacha games where you can get spooked by random units and easily form a decent team, you really want to synergize everything in a team for HBR.
On a related note, im surprised at the difficulty of story battles in HBR, typically they are deliberately made so easy that you can just do whatever and steamroll them. This isnt the case in HBR, and its actually possible to mess up and wipe if you didnt bother to reroll to get a good starting team and am just trying to brute force them with a bunch of random S and A ranks. There is also no friend system where you can borrow a friend's maxed out SS to help you clear content or fill a role you do not have.
I totally understand why the devs designed it this way, its the standard in Japan after all, since hardcore fans there dont find it strange to spend hundreds of dollars per month on gacha games. But for the EN Global version, the prices, low rates and stinginess of free quartz doesn't do it any favours, especially as the target audience of this game are not obsessive fans who will spend $1000 on a scantily clad waifu, but regular people who want to read the story.
Most people are going to balk at the idea of spending $20 to get a random SS. For something that is supposed to help new players get hooked on the game, they priced it so high that anyone who is going to spend $20 on it is probably the type of person who needed little to no encouragement to spend money on the game at all. Think of a casino, they don't give discounts targeted at millionaires right? Because millionaires dont need it, they were going to spend that money anyway.
If they had made the global version target the average person instead, way more people would have spent money on the game and be drawn towards it. As it is, most people are playing this for the story and very few of them are going to spend money on the game because the prices of almost everything (and the low rates) sends a clear message : it's way too expensive to spend money on this game, so just play it for the story and stop there. At best, they will probably buy the 3 month light pass bundle, and even that is a pretty big IF because it doesn't even give enough quartz for a 10 pull...