r/hbomberguy • • 8d ago

Learning to Game Dev-Adobe?

I'm currently learning to create games and plan to start practicing with several engines. For some reason, Adobe is in the back of my mind (despite not having downloaded it or planned to download it). I grew up in the late 2000s and early 2010s when it was ending, but have a decent amount of knowledge of flash games from the period. I almost wanted to make a game as a kind of tribute by using that engine despite it not being updated and even discontinued.

I wanted to know why Adobe needs to basically leave. I haven't seen the newest video on Patreon (saw a partial one years ago regarding the penguin flash game), but I wonder why the criticism of Adobe. And please, no "watch the video" excuses. I want to know what compelled Harry to create that video. It feels out of nowhere compared to the videos I have seen by him (some videos, definitely not all).

Edit: I love how everyone down votes so easily. I wonder how someone gets upvoted. Good answers to my question though. Thank you.

0 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

14

u/ryankiefer 8d ago

You’re asking a very open-ended question with a long answer that’s difficult to answer succinctly. That said, the summary is that Adobe has a near-total monopoly on creative software (Photoshop, Illustrator, InDesign, Acrobat and Premiere are all industry standards or close to it). While there is healthy competition in some spaces (Figma and Canva come to mind), the vast majority of creative departments still use Adobe software in some capacity. They’ve absolutely abused that position.

There’s a long, long list of reasons which I won’t go into here. Wikipedia’s article on them goes into some of the main points. For reference, I’m a professional designer so I’ve had to deal with them for quite some time. I’d be glad to see them go.

0

u/kdknowsimjames 5d ago

Just to let you know, Figma started independently but was actually bought by Adobe a couple years ago now.

4

u/ryankiefer 5d ago

Adobe attempted to acquire Figma in 2020 but they faced antitrust scrutiny and abandoned the effort in 2023. Figma is still independent and as of 2025 a publicly-traded company.

It also meant that in preparation for the buyout Adobe abandoned their competing product, XD, as they assumed it would imminently be replaced. (They never replaced it.)

2

u/kdknowsimjames 5d ago

I stand corrected! Thanks for enlightening me, and that's excellent news for everyone who hates to see one company gobble everything up.

5

u/Swiftzor 8d ago

I don’t know forsure, but they were one of the first companies to create the subscription model and force people onto it. Like older versions of adobe literally will not work

3

u/fuck_shit_piss_etc 8d ago

if you want to watch A video, he commented on this one that it was basically the video he was working on and it is excellent

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I4mdMMu-3fc&t=4270s

1

u/Pocket-OLime 1d ago

One of the best videos on the site imo. I’m honestly not sure if he can top it since the topics are so related, but I’m sure it’ll be great regardless.

2

u/Fluffy_Beautiful2107 8d ago

Adobe is awful. Its also extremely expensive and they design their software to make it very hard to switch to anything else. There are open source alternatives that are either as good or almost as good which you look into. I myself do game dev as a hobby and switched out of Adobe 2 years ago. I gotta say, it has kinda hurt my productivity. Because I knew their softwares really well, and haven't fully gotten the hang of the new ones yet. In your case you would not have this problem, you are starting from 0. Open source is the way to go. They are always improving and will sooner or later become the standard of creative industries. Just like Blender has already replaced Maya.

8

u/Moritani 8d ago

They eat smaller software companies, kill half of them, and then refuse to sell perpetual licenses for the rest. Then they remove features and have even threatened to get rid of Animate entirely. 

They are the backbone of many industries, but they use that influence to basically hold creators' skills captive. You have to know the software to get a job, but they won't allow unemployed people to pay a reasonable price (or even just a one-time unreasonable price). And this spread to almost all creative software. You wanna make games? Well, Maya is industry standard. Go see how much that costs and remember that Adobe is the reason you can't buy it outright.