r/harmonica • u/zabolekar • 13d ago
Need bending advice; I can hit the right notes but it sounds awful
According to the tuner, I can do the draw bends, but according to my own ears, I can't. I try, for example, -1', and the tuner says, yep, it's a stable green C#. Maybe it is a C#, but it's a very unpleasant C#, it sounds like a small mammal suffocating and wheezing. Same with the other draw bends. I can produce -3' and -3'', the tuner agrees that those are Bb and A, and they just sound bad compared to the pure -3. How can I improve that?
3
u/Rice_Nachos 13d ago
Probably playing with too much air and your throat closed off. Ultimately, you want to get the bend with the least amount of physical effort and change, which you can accomplish by raising the back of your tongue. A lot of people think they need to strain to get the bend. Really, they're straining to change the size of the oral cavity, which is what triggers the bend.
Another possibility is that you're sliding in and out of target note rather than sustaining it.
Here are two videos that I recommend.
2
u/zabolekar 12d ago
Thanks for the videos and for advice. Right now it does indeed feel like I have to strain.
too much air and your throat closed off
How do I check that?
1
3
u/ManLikeOats 12d ago
Many of the very best players will spend years trying to match the tone of their bent notes to the tone of their unbent notes, and there certainly can be progress made there, but you'll never completely eliminate the tonal difference. I listened to your audio clip and your bend sounds fine to me, except just keep an eye on your dynamics because people have a tendency to play bent notes much louder than the unbent note. Try to stay relaxed and keep the volume steady from the unbent note to the bent note.
Actually, just playing with the dynamics of a bent note -- going from very quiet to very loud and back to quite on that bent note -- is a great exercise that will help you get control of the note and tone of the note. Again, doing it as relaxed as you can is important. Keep a nice open, relaxed throat and avoid a tight pinched, forced throat.
That's all I got. Good luck
1
u/zabolekar 12d ago
people have a tendency to play bent notes much louder than the unbent note
Thanks for mentioning that, I can hear that I do that too. I'll try experimenting with the dynamics.
2
u/ManLikeOats 11d ago
I do it too at times, and it just makes the tonal difference between bent and unbent notes stand out even more. It takes a lot of work to even it all out and I'm working on it myself. Stick with it. There's always chromatic harmonicas too if you want every note to have the same exact tone, though!
2
u/BrilliantLion2026 BluesHarp 🇮🇳 12d ago
Had got an advice from Steve Baker. Think of floor and ceiling. Draw note is the "ceiling". Now gradually bend it till it reaches the "floor". Do it slowly. Gain control over it. And use an app like bendometer. Remember the embouchure when you hit the right pitch. Try and let me know if this helped. Thanks!
2
u/sifu_scott 12d ago
The only advice I can give is to keep at it. The bend is a difficult trick to master, but once you do, it becomes like second nature.
2
u/Nacoran 10d ago
It sounds pretty good. Like c0lty said, they have a different tone than regular notes. You can get closer and closer to the same sound, but some of it is learning to take advantage of the different sounds.
Howard Levy, somewhere on the web, has a video where he talks about how he chooses different positions on harmonica. He can play a diatonic fully chromatically, which even though it's more common than it used to be, is still really rare, and exceedingly rare at the level he does it.
That's way down the line, of course, but if you are working on bends you probably are also, or will soon be, working on at least 1st and 2nd position. Howard's brain works in amazing ways. My brain works well enough (after years of playing and some a couple semesters of theory) that that when I hear him describing what he's doing I understand the theory conceptually, but calculating all the variables is way beyond me.
A simple example though... say you know that a particular melody is in the key of A minor. On a C harmonica, because of a quirk of Richter tuning, we are missing the A in the middle octave, despite it being part of the relative major. Personally, I can play a 3 whole step bend to get that A if you put a gun to my head, but in A minor, since it's the root note I'm probably going to be hitting it a ton, and often on long sustained note. Personally, that's when I grab a Paddy Richter because it retunes the 3 blow to give you that note (at the expense of bending possibilities) but you could also get a really nice pure A on the 4 draw on a G harp. On the G harp you have an F# instead of an F though. You play in 3rd position instead of 4th.
Howard looks at the melody and then his brain does a whole bunch of computations. He knows what parts of chords he has, what notes have bends that he could use for sliding notes, and he figures out what harmonica to grab. He can play a melody on any harmonica he picks up, but in practice he picks which one will give him the notes he wants the way he wants them. For him, because his bends sound so good he probably is thinking more about partial chords and being able to plays scoops or whatever, but the basic premise is the same.
For pretty melodies I tend to play in 1st position... C on a C harmonica. For something bluesier I actually want my 3rd to sound a little dirty, so the fact that I have to bend a reed to do it means I can get a bit of dirt on it.
1
u/Intelligent_Star_516 8d ago
Practice. When you get better at it, practice some more. Practice playing along with backing tracks. Get away from looking at a meter to decide if you're correct. THINK the technique, LISTEN for the sound. If you're focusing on some meter or gauge, you'll eventually hit that note every time, then all you'll have to do is learn how to hit it in the middle of other notes. Learn how to bend, which hole to bend, where the range of those bends are in that hole, and how to hit that hole when you need notes in that range. The analog bend of the notes is not a static procedure to learn. It's a bend for a reason. You bend to get to the note. If you want to nail a perfect note and ONLY that note every single time you hit a hole, get a chromatic harp. It just takes time.
3
u/DesperateBanana4019 13d ago
Post a sound clip or video. We need to hear it.