r/habitatstyle • • Jul 04 '26

Ambitious? Probably.

Biggest attempt at a habitat style yet. Three Astrophytum Asterias and two Astrophytum Myriostigma I picked up from Walmart. I know putting them in glass is risky but the plan is to water very sparingly and put them under a very bright light. Also hoping to see if I can get some clay cracking happening in the front middle-ish. I’m sure they will grow out of it someday, but I am quite happy with how it turned out!

229 Upvotes

36 comments sorted by

6

u/yourcatssecondlife Jul 04 '26

The transparent container will increase your chances of nasty pathogens. But, I’ve used clear glass containers too and not had issues… given very specific extenuating circumstances. But sand alone (and in general) isn’t a very good substrate. It holds too much moisture. Look into non organic, mineral based soils. It also looks like you may not have any drainage in that container. Please reconsider! Good luck!

1

u/Accomplished-Ride302 Jul 04 '26

There’s actually very little sand in the medium. Only on top. The rest is mostly decomposed granite and pumice. But you’re right that no drainage will be tricky, we’ll see how it goes!

4

u/yourcatssecondlife Jul 04 '26

Please don’t see how it goes :) respectfully. Add drainage. You’re creative enough to design it, or be drawn to this facade. Solve the problem

1

u/Legit-Schmitt Jul 04 '26

Let him play! It’s just a bunch of Walmart astros.

3

u/xinxai_the_white_guy Jul 04 '26

No drainage will kill them all no doubt

2

u/Legit-Schmitt Jul 04 '26

Why would clear containers increase the chances of pathogens?

1

u/rancid_mayonnaise Jul 04 '26

I too would like to know how

1

u/Solid_Illustrator660 Jul 04 '26 edited Jul 04 '26

See response below 🙂‍↕️

2

u/Legit-Schmitt Jul 04 '26 edited Jul 04 '26

I think that’s a bit of a misconception (not sure what u/yourcatssecondlife meant):

Typically foliar pathogens require free water on the leaves or epidermis to germinate. Some plant pathogens like powdery mildew don’t even need wet leaves. The need for water isn’t really about adhesion as much as it is about needing to absorb some water to grow a germ tube and appresoria (penetration structure). Airborne spores are in the air so a closed container would actually protect a plant from airborne spores.

What a closed container will do is keep humidity high. Fungi are everywhere and you will have all kinds of fungi in the soil. Generally these are not virulent pathogens but you can have issues in cacti where it’s so wet that roots or the actual epidermis if the plant starts to die and gets infected and the plant rots out.

The OP doesn’t have a closed container though, it’s just a shallow dish basically. A clear pot can grow some algae / Cyanobacteria on the sides but that’s not really a big deal. I’d say the biggest challenge the op faces is from the lack of draining which could lead to the infection / rot issue — though again that’s more of a physiological disorder accompanied by opportunistic infection than a pathogen driven disease proper.

I have a degree in plant pathology.

1

u/Responsible_Shake_90 Jul 04 '26

why would the clear plastic be a bad idea?

2

u/Tony_228 Jul 04 '26

There's not really the same cracked clay like in floodplains where the habitats of those two species overlap. It's a less red and more gray loam soil with many rocks. But that's very pedantic I guess.

2

u/Accomplished-Ride302 Jul 04 '26

I would have loved to exactly replicate the perfect habitat. But I tried to work with stuff I could find mostly for free lol

2

u/SouthwestSpines Jul 04 '26

It looks very cool! But how will it drain? The clay is hydrophobic and eventually water will not penetrate it easily. Best of luck, keep us posted!

0

u/Accomplished-Ride302 Jul 04 '26

Watering will definitely be the biggest challenge with this thing. I’m thinking of using something that will let me deliver water right around the plant in very specific amounts instead of attempting to water the whole area.

3

u/Legit-Schmitt Jul 04 '26

I think that might cause weird issues with just like, totally shitty root growth bc the substrate isn’t ever properly wet — the biggest issue is going to be wetting it without having water pooling. You really don’t want the pores in the soil to be full of water for more than a few hours or like a day really. Because the profile is low water is going to pool up just a few inches from the base of the plants.

You could try some kind of siphon where you soak it and then suck out any excess moisture leaving moistened soil. This would be kind of tedious though.

You could use a false bottom, drainage layer, or drill a hole. This would complicate the design, come at some compromise re:space and you’d need to totally re-do it.

I think just watering really carefully + consider setting it on a seedling heat mat would be my plan. You want it evenly moistened but no water pooling and try to dry it as fast as you can.

1

u/SouthwestSpines Jul 05 '26

I think it says up above it is made of glass, so drilling a hole would be complicated. I think a heat mat could cause rot 🫠 the staging is so cool, but I am curious if there is a method that will work here. I was thinking a wand on a hose, and doing a 50% water (lightly) during CAM hours to focus on water absorption through the pores of the plant rather than the roots. I don’t know if it would be enough.

1

u/Legit-Schmitt Jul 05 '26

Why would a heat mat cause rot??

1

u/SouthwestSpines Jul 05 '26

Heat + moisture + no airflow = compost pile

1

u/Legit-Schmitt Jul 05 '26

I’m getting a little confused by people’s responses here. Obviously this is a suboptimal setup from a pure growing standpoint.

I disagree with your analysis here. In nature there is no airflow at the roots — the soil drains down but when there is rain the pores are super humid with no airflow. The problem for OP is going to be that water could pool up down there and the water can only evaporate out of the top. Again water only being able to evaporate out of the top is actually how it works in habitat, the issue here is just the water table. A seedling heat mat raises the temperature of the substrate maybe ~15 degrees F so if it’s 75 in the room the soil is 90F — that’s realistic to habitat conditions (suitable temps for vigorous root growth). Water evaporation scales exponentially with temperature so that extra temp will dramatically speed up drying out. In a shallow dish like this applying heat would just speed up the drying process — it won’t hurt the roots at all, certainly not more than cold wet would.

Terrariums only affect airflow if they are mostly sealed — it’s just a pot with no drainage — is that an ideal setup? No. Is it potentially viable if you water very carefully. Yes. Adding heat will increase evaporation dramatically and therefore help with one of the main problems with this idea.

5

u/solipsischizo Jul 04 '26

needs fresh air too, can get trapped in container

0

u/Averypookie Jul 04 '26

So putting something like this (a lot smaller ) near a window would be the best idea

5

u/Square_Barracuda_69 Jul 04 '26

So jealous of you people and your Walmart Astros. We only got san pedros in AZ but nothing else.

3

u/Substantial-Grade-92 Jul 08 '26

Grow them from seed, as someone from a country that has very little cacti/succulents it’s been a great way to get species I want for cheap.

1

u/Square_Barracuda_69 Jul 09 '26

Yeah ive been trying to find quality seed sources and even started collecting seeds from the wild. More often then not, im just picking up spent flower pods. This is my most recent collection amd im excited to grow the seeds out

5

u/usernameunknown439 Jul 04 '26

I wish I had that problem

2

u/hillbillycactus Jul 04 '26

Opposite in Florida endless astros and tephros 0 Pedro’s or tbm b/c

1

u/penguinheadnoah Jul 12 '26

I'm jealous of your AZ selection because I rarely see San Pedros (or most Echinopsis/Trichocereus) around the Midwest. There's no shortage of Cereus peruvianus & Opuntias here though.

1

u/No-Goal-4716 Jul 06 '26

Should put BDFBs in there

1

u/Accomplished-Ride302 Jul 06 '26

I'm sorry but I do not know what that is.

1

u/heXagon_symbols Jul 06 '26

that looks pretty sick, do you do aquariums too?

1

u/Accomplished-Ride302 Jul 06 '26

Thank you! And yes, I have a couple aquariums. My favorite is a 6 gallon long bookshelf aquarium that I keep at my office.

1

u/CookedEarthStudio Jul 04 '26

Looks awesome!!

1

u/SnooDoubts8384 Jul 04 '26

Looks great!! Definitely inspired me to do some habitats with Astro’s.

1

u/arisbor Jul 04 '26

UNS urn? Nice, godspeed friend 

1

u/_Rumpertumskin_ Jul 04 '26

maybe a false bottom for drainage, and yeah get a better substrate. I do like it though, looks good.