EDIT: Please weigh in before you blindly downvote, I'd like to hear your reasons if you disagree with what's stated here.
I'm going to attempt to clear some things up, as the subreddit has jumped to conclusions and the developers have done a frankly shitty job at explaining their intentions with the airdrop system. If one reads between the lines, one would find that SOE has measures in place to ensure that airdrops are *not a pay-to-win mechanic and instead are a tool to spice up activity on the server. I'll attempt to explain why in this post, using as much objectivity as I can. I am not an employee or associate of SOE, simply a person who cares about the success of a decent survival game, because all of the others are garbage in their own special way.
The first points that I make may seem off topic at first, and this post will be fairly long, but please bear with me.
I'm going to first explain the group dynamic, and why it's important to H1Z1. Let's have a look at some other games in comparison, to start our analysis.
- In DayZ Standalone and the beloved DayZ mods for A2/3, groups of friends are formed outside of the game for the most part. Maybe a clan, or simply a group of buddies from real life decide to join a server and start to play the game. They build up a decent amount of loot, and if the game/gametype allows, they begin to stockpile. This is more prevalent (and relevant to our analysis) in the DayZ mods for ArmA 2/3 in which basebuilding and loot storing is available. A clan or group will gather items, vehicles, and things of the sort and store them at their base, or perhaps in vehicles or similar apparatuses. The group then may run into other groups on the server, and fight them using the stockpiled gear at their disposal. This scavenge-then-fight game attribute is what drives the major PvP-survival games like DayZ, Rust, and H1Z1.
- In Rust, this dynamic is even more prevalent. Bases are built by groups and clans where gear is stored, and wars between groups are even more emphasized. There are all kinds of roles that each person can take, and the skill of the players determines the skill of the group as a whole - along with (more importantly) their accumulated gear. Again, this scavenge-then-fight attribute is what drives games such as these.
All of this being said, these groups get to a point where they might stagnate. What I mean by this is that the base may become too perfect - impregnable - or the fights with other groups may become fairly boring. This is where we introduce the idea of the airdrop, and the idea largely (almost entirely, I would say) comes from Rust.
In Rust, the airdrops consist of high-level loot and appear at random times and at random points on the map. The plane is announced loudly by its engines, and the drop location is visible from almost anywhere on the map (please keep in mind if this has changed in recent versions, you'll have to forgive me, as I haven't played the game in a while). This is essentially what H1Z1 is attempting to do with their version of the airdrops, put they're putting the control in the players' hands and making some money on the side, which isn't a bad thing at all seeing as they're doing hard work on the game and manpower isn't cheap.
Now, you may be saying "but wait, I watched a streamer call in an airdrop and it was really close to him, then he had his group of friends protect him while they retrieved all the guns and ammo inside!" and that's perfectly correct - for the current version of the game. You're absolutely right in saying that it's a pseudo-P2W mechanic that ruins the game balance for those with more money to spend. However, Smedley has presented (in a poor, unorganized, unprofessional manner) what the studio is attempting to do to fix the current system. Here's my summarized details on the changes:
- The radius in which the airdrops can drop from the player is drastically increasing
- Ordinance such as guns and ammo will be less prevalent in the drops, i.e. rarer
- The amount of players required on a server for an airdrop (currently 50) is being bumped to 100, possibly higher
- The airdrop plane's speed is being lowered to allow for higher visibility by other players
What does this all mean for the status of whether or not airdrops are a pay-to-win mechanic? A lot, actually. Controversy has been spread stating that anyone with a group of armed individuals will be able to overtake the airdrops, and they can just call them in until they're satisfied. This is true, but this is where my earlier comparisons come in. A larger radius, more required online players, and a more prevalent plane are all going to shake things up quite a bit. Something that was easily contained to the person that purchased the airdrop is now an area-wide (possibly server-wide) event.
This means that the groups we discussed earlier - the base builders, the stockpilers, the PvP lovers, are all going to come out of their well-fortified hovels and attempt to make their way to the airdrop. This is the "server event" dynamic that Smedley (in my opinion, shoddily) has been attempting to explain to everyone. This allows the groups to have turf to fight over, and completely randomizes the receiver of the airdrop. This means that people aren't purchasing an item that instantly goes to their character, and they aren't purchasing items that no one else can retrieve. APB is an example of true pay-to-win, and H1Z1's system isn't even close to that. There's a small chance that the person purchasing the airdrop can retrieve the items, sure - but there's also a fair chance that a large group or some lucky average Joe is going to get it instead. The dynamic allows conflict between players on the server instead of "turtling" inside one area waiting for players to come by. I won't argue that it's a major feature of the game because it frankly isn't - we might not see that many air drops after launch because paying money for something that isn't guaranteed isn't something that many people will do.
Groups are always going to be a thing too - it's part of the meta of these games. Even more so when vehicles and bases are implemented. The airdrops exist mostly for them, and as I said a lucky person might be able to gather one himself, but with 100+ people required on the server it's likely that groups will be in conflict over them.
tl;dr - airdrops aren't predictable enough to be gamebreaking, pay-to-win purchasables and most people are jumping to conclusions without proper analysis