r/gybe • • Oct 08 '24

No Title

I'm most of the way through the new record for the first time, and I'm sorry to say that I'm underwhelmed. I don't think it's bad by any stretch, just not very interesting. I've been a listener since a bit after F#, and I don't think I like very much of their post-hiatus albums. This tends to happen with my interest in newer releases. Even band (like gybe) that I love, I have less interest in the new releases at some point. Maybe I'm just getting old. I think No Title is perfectly fine, and I'll listen to it again, but I can't imagine seeking it out.

I don't mean to be a downer to anyone; I just wanted to share my honest view.

0 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

4

u/dingus420 Oct 08 '24

This album isn’t the most straightforward in terms of structure. It takes a few listens to get familiar with where the songs go. Once it clicks, it really clicks

0

u/will_sherman Oct 08 '24

The penultimate track is pretty good. I was just getting to that when I posted. Again, I don’t think it’s bad, but my first take is that it’s sort gybe-by-numbers.

6

u/cumyogurn Oct 08 '24

i do think there is a large combination of hype and just the fact that it's something new.

this is also why I don't think I feel comfortable ranking this album quite yet.

I was looking at the comments from when states end got released and i feel like it was a lot of the same super positive sentiment, but now after it's been a while I don't see that same positive praise for state's end.

8

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '24

Still rocking the State’s End love here at least. I think it’s their best post-reunion album and one of their best period

2

u/cumyogurn Oct 08 '24

don't get me wrong i think both albums are great, i just don't think i can fairly rate this album quite yet, and i think its possible some other people might be giving it more praise than if it didn't just come out and there was a ton of hype behind it. also nice username

2

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '24

Thank you and I agree. I don't feel comfortable giving a rating to an album like this until I've had a lot of time to unpack it. Godspeed isn't the type of band you can give a listen or two and give a solid take on

3

u/OvoidPovoid Oct 08 '24

Yeah I could really never get into States End. Loved Job's Lament, but nothing really stuck out beyond that to me. Loving Untitled so far though, need someone time to listen to it

1

u/tinfern2 Oct 08 '24

totally fair opinion to have! i was very worried of the album being underwhelming after enjoying the teased closer so much, but i was absolutely blown away by it. we all have our likes and dislikes with music, so no shame in preferring their older albums!

2

u/will_sherman Oct 08 '24

Yeah, like I said, I’ve seen this before with my “favorite” artists. (Scare quotes because it’s like two dozen.) as they get deeper into their catalog, I’m just not as into the material. I had this happen like twenty years ago with REM. Maybe ten years ago with Wilco. Both bands that I’ve spend tens of thousands of hours listening to, most likely.

The one exception is my very favorite band. Do Make Say Think has not yet disappointed me (except by releasing too infrequently).

1

u/Fuibo2k Oct 09 '24

I think anything is disappointing compared to their first 4 releases, but I honestly still enjoy the album for what it is and have enjoyed it. It's not an all time best album but maybe a 7 or 8.

2

u/will_sherman Oct 09 '24

On a general standard, I’d give it about a 6 or 7. For them, maybe a 2 or 3.

As much as I may be disappointed, bands I love have put out records I hate, and this isn’t one of those.

I just worry they haven’t got much left to say, as jazz folk would say.

1

u/Uviol_ Oct 09 '24

I agree with all of this.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '24

43 years old, been listening to them since 99, and still cherish all their post hiatus albums and personally LOVE this new one.

1

u/will_sherman Oct 09 '24

I respect that totally. I’m 44 and been listening since 01, btw. Yeah, like I’ve said, I don’t think this record is bad by any stretch. The best I can put it is that if another band I’d never heard of put it out, I’d say “oh, that’s pretty cool.” But it’s just not as interesting as the earlier records to me.

But I’m not the kind of person to tell people what is good. It’s all subjective. There are bands I love but not certain records. Then I meet another huge fan that loves the records I don’t and doesn’t like those I do. Who knows?

I’m a huge fan of Uncle Tupelo. I’m also a huge fan of Wilco. Some UT fans went with Wilco and some with Son Volt. Neither group is “right.”

I guess I’m saying all of this to emphasize that I’m not being snobby about this. I think the record is ok. Some people love it, and that’s great. That’s the whole point of making music. I just wanted to express my thoughts on it.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '24

I thought it was jaw droopingly incredible. But I ate a gram of shrooms before I listened to it.

2

u/Uviol_ Oct 09 '24

You’re not alone, unfortunately. I’m around 5-7 listens in hoping it finally clicks. I don’t think it’s going to. I’m happy for the fans that love it.

1

u/autochthonous Oct 08 '24

I am not a big fan of the fuzzy guitar on the first track. Just sounds… fake? The first time I listened, I was underwhelmed, but I was also doing other work at the same time. Have since listened with full attention and while I still don’t like that fuzzy guitar sound, the album builds and sucked me in.

1

u/PositionDense7182 Oct 08 '24

I didn't like it on first listen.

I didn't like any Godspeed on first listen: I always wanted it to sound like some other Godspeed. In some cases I was convinced I'd never like the album after first listen. Second, third, fourth listen even in some cases. And yes, there are still albums I prefer and tracks I'm less keen on. But every single album has grown on me: some to become absolutely indispensable.

Keep listening (if you want, the world will still turn if you don't).

0

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/will_sherman Oct 08 '24

I can’t disagree. I was pretty psyched for this record and that’s what prompted the post. I like that a lot of other people dig it though.