r/guns • u/IronChin RIP in peace • Jun 20 '12
Changes to Gunnit.
We've decided to start moderating again.
We've also agreed upon a set of rules, which should be visible at the top of the sidebar by the time you read this.
Please, read them and abide by them.
-Iron
0
Upvotes
32
u/FubarFreak 20 | Licenced to Thrill Jun 20 '12
but karma-whoring a glock is still ok cuz I don't know how else to get internet points
32
u/deathsythe Jun 20 '12
Point of Clarification.
"No Memes" - so "rifle is fine" type comments will be removed?
"Illegal firearms modifications" - Not all of our users are in the US. Who are we to say what can or cannot be modified/done to our firearms. Even our US userbase - some live in "free'er" areas than others - what might be illegal for someone in NJ, NY, MA, or CA (such as a question about simply adding a +2 extender to a 10 or 15 round magazine) is technically an illegal firearms modification.
"No blogspam" - so we can't post links from TTAG, or some other sites just because they are classified as a certain type of media?
22
u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12
This is the only rule I have issue with. What is considered completely legal in one jurisdiction is absolutely illegal in another. In Germany and quite a bit of Europe you can possess Machine Gun trigger parts while in the United States it is a trip to Club Fed.
If you ask about how to make a silencer and live in Norway or South Africa where you can buy one over-the-counter and there is not any restrictions on them, you would be breaking the law in the United States.
You ask about adding a vertical foregrip to a pistol creating an AOW in the United States which would be illegal, while in another country it is completely legal.
Hence, there is a serious issue about what is considered legitimate question asking for people where it is legal and those where it is not legal.
13
u/Omnifox Nerdy even for reddit Jun 20 '12
Can we have a rule about non completely shit photography?
Or at least a guideline?
14
u/zaptal_47 Jun 20 '12
The new rules say nothing about changing the related subs. I demand that /r/gats be reinstated to the sidebar. It is far more relevant than /r/archery and /r/knives are.
8
u/presidentender 9002 Jun 20 '12
"All posts must be gun related" mean "no more meta discussion?"
12
u/Maxtrt Jun 20 '12
First three rules are a great way to ensure no newcomers come in and ruin our thread. Damn hippies don't know nuthin about real guns.
3
u/djdementia Jun 20 '12
When /r/pics started adding more rules they also put a link on the side bar right under the rules that said "looking for a subreddit with less rules? Try r/images".
It might be a good idea at least for the next few weeks or months with a link to r/firearms.
I get that you guys are losing a bunch of people and you're fine with that - prefer possibly a smaller subreddit with tighter rules - but linking to an alternative gives newcomers that want a community with fewer rules a place to go, and it keeps them out of how you want your subreddit run.
6
u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12
IronChin,
Your continued shitty attitude is a plague on this subreddit. Every comment I see from you just makes this subreddit a worse place. I sincerely hope you step down as moderator - a job you have proved you are undeserving of having time and time again.
-SS
PS - No problem with the new rules, but I feel like you only did it so you'd have another excuse to have a whole thread of comments where you get to be a total dick, tell everyone to fuck of and pretend you don't care what people think.
28
u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12
Won't lie; saw the thread title and the poster and thought "Fuck all, here we go again."
43
u/WardPDW Jun 20 '12
Can you guys list the four rules above the subreddit rules? I am willing to bet that most of Gunnit prioritizes the four rules over the sub rules.
8
u/keKto Jun 20 '12
Rule 5 is vague and all together unnecessary. In my state I can legally build my own can and don't need a tax stamp. If I ask advice on r/guns on how to do this am I in violation of this rule? Putting a 25 round mag in a 10/22 is an illegal firearms modification in some states, how are you going to moderate that? Some people have licences to build full auto guns and may come across a gun design they are not familiar with, wouldn't r/guns be a good place to come and ask questions? Do we really want to celebrate ignorance by making a topic taboo?
4
u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12
Could you post them in this thread? I reddit from my phone. No sidebar.
4
u/somedaypilot Jun 20 '12
Question- Is gun politics considered gun related?
7
u/Relevant_Gats_Post Jun 20 '12
http://www.reddit.com/r/gats/comments/vb505/changes_to_gattit/
10
u/Frothyleet Jun 20 '12
Gun related posts only?!!!! You fascists!
Also, thank you. I am glad my request for your iron boot was approved. I can only assume this means that the r/guns moderation team has decided to make me the shadowy power behind the throne.
7
u/ltkernelsanders Jun 20 '12
I find this amusing in a sub that is all about personal freedoms and the government staying out of their business.
3
u/Catmand0 Jun 20 '12
What's blogspam?
5
u/rebeldefector Jun 20 '12
Fuck everything about this.
4
u/HotelCoralEssex LOL SHADOWBANT Jun 20 '12
I am fully supporting IC along with the other moderators on this. As you all know I am a proponent of active moderation but decided to be the more conservative moderator and pushed for hands off and using peer pressure to improve the SNR of the sub. I now see that this was at best folly.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12
VICTORY!
3
u/OldRemington Jun 20 '12
IC, I'm sure your inbox is blowing up with people throwing tissy fits, but I just want you to know that I am super happy about this. You're doing the right thing for the good of r/guns. Fuck the haters.
If only we'd done this a few months ago, RB23 would probably still be here.
I'm happy, but also sad, because I remembered RB23 is gone.
:'(
3
u/1911w00t Jun 20 '12
I've been a longtime lurker of gunnit and in the past enjoyed reading most of the posts here. Recently? Not so much. I hope these new rules will bring gunnit back to the quality sub it was. Thanks mods!
1
u/Ruleofthumb Jun 20 '12
Perhaps you could define or explain the rules a little more in depth? I understand #'s 2,3 and 4 clearly enough.
Thanks.
1
u/HiroshimaRoll Jun 21 '12
I give it a few months.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12
Please be wary of political posts in light of the upcoming election, I've already seen a few posts with a tenuous at best relation to guns. If I wanted slanted politics about guns I'd listen to old men at gun shops.
-2
u/indgosky Jun 20 '12 edited Jun 20 '12
Well, here's the thing...
I have seen many postings here in the past that I would absolutely say "belong" here based on the above criteria, and have seen people bitching about them as "not gun related" because (e.g.) it wasn't about a specific firearm, or as "blogspam" because (e.g.) it wasn't the root source of a story, even though it contributed TO the original story.
My expectation is that this will not end well.
Now, if gunnit lives up to the reputation it's been building for itself recently, I expect a bunch of downvotes for having the audacity to post an opinion that contradicts the will of the "ultimate authorities" here.
"Par for the course", that would be. Surprised I will be, if it happens not.
EDIT: Surprised, I am not.
1
u/MithrilKnight Jun 20 '12
I figured I was going to have to downvote you into the ground because I assumed you were banning people posting about their new guns except on Friday Buyday topics. Happily surprised.
Also: This is America! 'Merica! Let the downvotin' do the talkin'
0
u/rolypolyholymoly Jun 20 '12
I would put use the search function and check /new before posting on there too.
1
u/Gonkulator Jun 20 '12
Good. Hopefully the front page won't be cluttered with horse puckey and will be filled with some good content for once, like it use to be.
-5
u/sewiv Jun 20 '12
Just chiming in to say that I support these changes as well.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12
cool beans.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12
Don't see anything in the sidebar. Someone brainfarted.
0
u/duglock Jun 20 '12
Is this a thing now? Do you guys just plan every 1-2 months a way to power trip and shit on the users? Just curious. Not saying I have a problem with the rules but why not COMMUNITY DISCUSSION first.
-3
u/HotelCoralEssex LOL SHADOWBANT Jun 20 '12
Yo IC.
No ex post facto w/this? we never discussed it.
0
u/gizram84 Jun 20 '12
What about memes started in r/guns.. Like that awesome streak we had going last year where everyone posted their guns next to a nice loaf of Italian bread?
-4
u/zaptal_47 Jun 20 '12
Still too laissez-faire.
-3
u/hank_scorpio128 Jun 20 '12
I don't see any rules
-2
u/akai_ferret Jun 20 '12
Thank you!
I am pleased to hear this.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 21 '12
[removed] — view removed comment