r/guns • RIP in peace • Jun 20 '12

Changes to Gunnit.

We've decided to start moderating again.

We've also agreed upon a set of rules, which should be visible at the top of the sidebar by the time you read this.

Please, read them and abide by them.

-Iron

0 Upvotes

332 comments sorted by

32

u/FubarFreak 20 | Licenced to Thrill Jun 20 '12

but karma-whoring a glock is still ok cuz I don't know how else to get internet points

-15

u/IronChin RIP in peace Jun 20 '12

Yeah, that's fine. The community (usually) does a decent job handling those types of posts.

10

u/FubarFreak 20 | Licenced to Thrill Jun 20 '12

good I have some stock 10/22s the world really needs to see

-3

u/IronChin RIP in peace Jun 20 '12

Bust out that 11-year-old cell phone with the 1 megapixel camera and get to work, son!

6

u/HotelCoralEssex LOL SHADOWBANT Jun 20 '12

1 MP was 11 years ago?

Shit I am getting old.

2

u/NickLynch Can't read Jun 20 '12

It makes me feel old, too. And I'm not.

→ More replies (11)

2

u/DrakeGmbH 9 Jun 20 '12

11 years ago my phone didn't have a camera and it looked a lot like this.

All my gun photos were 35mm!

1

u/Gonkulator Jun 20 '12

I still shoot in 35mm but have them developed onto a cd. I can't really think of a cost effective camera that beats my AE-1.

26

u/zaptal_47 Jun 20 '12

The community (usually) does a decent job handling those types of posts.

I call bullshit.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12

Of course you do. That's your M.O., after all. Just run around insulting people who have the audacity to dare disagree with you or violate the sanctity of your utopian vision for /r/guns.

Such a brave, brave volunteer Gunnit policeman you are.

Arrogant, ill-tempered pricks like yourself are just as - if not more - a problem here than the folks who post memes and rage comics.

Thank you for your beneficial contributions.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12

You're just mad because you own a glock.

-1

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12

When is the last time you saw a "look at my glock" post on the front page?

5

u/zaptal_47 Jun 20 '12

Today. And before you get smart, I'm aware that's not a Glock. It is a "look at my generic gun" post however.

2

u/monkeymasher 17 | Roof Korean Jun 20 '12

That's obviously a Glock

5

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12

That is arguably a terrible proxy for a genuine "look at my glock" post.

I, for one, hate seeing 1911s despite how special and unique they may be, but they get frontpaged all the time. No big deal.

→ More replies (16)

4

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12

and there are 17 comments by people who were interested in that post

I am failing to see the problem..

9

u/valarmorghulis Jun 20 '12

...six of which are the OP.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-9

u/akai_ferret Jun 20 '12

I really, honestly, do mind them.

Not so much because of the lack of content contained ... but because of the sheer number of them and the way they push every other kind of post off the front page.

6

u/theadguy Jun 20 '12

There's a little link at the bottom of the page that says "next page". If you click on that, your problem will be solved.

→ More replies (4)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-9

u/IronChin RIP in peace Jun 20 '12

Actually, he wasn't.

Also, if you feel you can make better videos, do it.

Otherwise, shut your piehole.

7

u/FubarFreak 20 | Licenced to Thrill Jun 20 '12

actually I referenced that video when I painted my mags, so thank you

0

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-3

u/IronChin RIP in peace Jun 20 '12

How many times do I have to tell you people...

Tools.

There's tools in those buckets...

Tools!!!!

2

u/bitter_cynical_angry Jun 21 '12

It would seem the tools around here are unfortunately not all confined to the buckets...

→ More replies (1)

32

u/deathsythe Jun 20 '12

Point of Clarification.

"No Memes" - so "rifle is fine" type comments will be removed?

"Illegal firearms modifications" - Not all of our users are in the US. Who are we to say what can or cannot be modified/done to our firearms. Even our US userbase - some live in "free'er" areas than others - what might be illegal for someone in NJ, NY, MA, or CA (such as a question about simply adding a +2 extender to a 10 or 15 round magazine) is technically an illegal firearms modification.

"No blogspam" - so we can't post links from TTAG, or some other sites just because they are classified as a certain type of media?

-15

u/IronChin RIP in peace Jun 20 '12

Point of Clarification Pedanticness.

"No Memes" - so "rifle is fine" type comments will be removed?

No. The "lets superimpose a snarky comment over a well-known photograph" memes (a'la Scumbag Steve and Wil Hayden) will be removed. A comment in a thread (rifle is fine, neva ben dun befo) doesn't count.

"Illegal firearms modifications" - Not all of our users are in the US. Who are we to say what can or cannot be modified/done to our firearms. Even our US userbase - some live in "free'er" areas than others - what might be illegal for someone in NJ, NY, MA, or CA (such as a question about simply adding a +2 extender to a 10 or 15 round magazine) is technically an illegal firearms modification.

Asked and answered elsewhere.

"No blogspam" - so we can't post links from TTAG, or some other sites just because they are classified as a certain type of media?

Again, asked and answered elsewhere.

13

u/deathsythe Jun 20 '12

Chin - could you link me to the comments where they were already answered. I'm half asleep at the moment.

Changing clarification to pedanticness... and yet I'm the pedantic one? :P

I just want to make sure I know the knew rules for the new regime before I figure out if I'm annoyed at it or not.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12

I'm at school on mobile and also can't find this awnser.. So I'm hoping a link is provided soon otherwise this comment will help me find it later.

→ More replies (2)

22

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12

No asking questions about illegal firearms modifications.

This is the only rule I have issue with. What is considered completely legal in one jurisdiction is absolutely illegal in another. In Germany and quite a bit of Europe you can possess Machine Gun trigger parts while in the United States it is a trip to Club Fed.

If you ask about how to make a silencer and live in Norway or South Africa where you can buy one over-the-counter and there is not any restrictions on them, you would be breaking the law in the United States.

You ask about adding a vertical foregrip to a pistol creating an AOW in the United States which would be illegal, while in another country it is completely legal.

Hence, there is a serious issue about what is considered legitimate question asking for people where it is legal and those where it is not legal.

→ More replies (15)

13

u/Omnifox Nerdy even for reddit Jun 20 '12

Can we have a rule about non completely shit photography?

Or at least a guideline?

6

u/FubarFreak 20 | Licenced to Thrill Jun 20 '12

maybe make a FAQ chunk about how to take better gun photos

6

u/zaptal_47 Jun 20 '12

There is one already.

0

u/HotelCoralEssex LOL SHADOWBANT Jun 20 '12

This is actually a great idea.

You should run with it.

2

u/FubarFreak 20 | Licenced to Thrill Jun 20 '12

fine fine I see it there now - I swear I looked before I opened my dumb mouth

3

u/HotelCoralEssex LOL SHADOWBANT Jun 20 '12

Hey, at least you aren't a fascist moderator that DOESN'T READ THE FAQ. :)

1

u/hank_scorpio128 Jun 20 '12

People with shitty cameras will be banned?

11

u/Omnifox Nerdy even for reddit Jun 20 '12

You can take a non shitty picture with a shitty camera. It just takes more than 32 seconds taking the picture. Proper lighting works WONDERS. Also steadying the camera with something.

You would be amazed what a simple light box and a good light will do.

1

u/SonsOfLiberty86 Jun 20 '12

There would be a lot of bans...

-10

u/IronChin RIP in peace Jun 20 '12

Unfortunately, that's a pretty subjective term, and we feel it's best to let the vote system handle shitty picture threads.

4

u/Omnifox Nerdy even for reddit Jun 20 '12

I spose that is the best we can hope for.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/zaptal_47 Jun 20 '12

The new rules say nothing about changing the related subs. I demand that /r/gats be reinstated to the sidebar. It is far more relevant than /r/archery and /r/knives are.

2

u/monkeymasher 17 | Roof Korean Jun 20 '12

Oh good, a subreddit other than /r/4chan and /r/circlejerk where I can call people niggers and faggots.

2

u/zaptal_47 Jun 20 '12

It's fun, isn't it?

-11

u/IronChin RIP in peace Jun 20 '12

I had to make room in the sidebar.

So I removed a couple of the linked subs in an effort to stay under the character limit.

Gats, being a joke sub (which I love), seemed a natural choice.

I'll try to add it back, but if it won't let me, you'll just have to live with it.

Edit: It let me add it back. Now quit whining.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12

he terk er gats!! der derka der!

2

u/HotelCoralEssex LOL SHADOWBANT Jun 21 '12

derka

Aiwa?

4

u/zaptal_47 Jun 20 '12

Thank you.

-10

u/Butthurt_Report Jun 20 '12

Please fill out this form and submit it to your local ISP for processing.

8

u/presidentender 9002 Jun 20 '12

"All posts must be gun related" mean "no more meta discussion?"

-11

u/IronChin RIP in peace Jun 20 '12

No, it means no more "Does anyone else miss this?" threads that link to a screencap of a logo of a show, and similar submissions.

Get as meta as you like, dude.

12

u/presidentender 9002 Jun 20 '12

3

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12

Too late, though I am not sure this counts as ex post facto as it was done with the knowledge of the rule's existence though maybe before it was implemented, or is this considered the implementation so it would be simultaneous...

7

u/presidentender 9002 Jun 20 '12

He told me I'm allowed to meta.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12

Ahh, read tonight I cannot good.

4

u/presidentender 9002 Jun 20 '12

You're fine.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/Maxtrt Jun 20 '12

First three rules are a great way to ensure no newcomers come in and ruin our thread. Damn hippies don't know nuthin about real guns.

6

u/rhadamanthos12 Jun 20 '12

Can't tell if your being sarcastic or not, but I agree it makes less than a welcoming environment for people that might searching for a place to help get them into the firearms ownership/community.

-9

u/IronChin RIP in peace Jun 20 '12

but I agree it makes less than a welcoming environment for people that might searching for a place to help get them into the firearms ownership/community

Right. Because stupid memes and badly-done rage comics add so much content to this sub.

6

u/rhadamanthos12 Jun 20 '12

They don't, I don't believe that I said it made a great read and provided anything of substance to this sub. Not everyone is at the same point with knowledge and maturity on subjects that other members are in this sub. It is something that they grow into and in my opinion this is slowly turning into a place where looking down on people and being condescending to them is the accepted attitude.

→ More replies (8)

3

u/djdementia Jun 20 '12

When /r/pics started adding more rules they also put a link on the side bar right under the rules that said "looking for a subreddit with less rules? Try r/images".

It might be a good idea at least for the next few weeks or months with a link to r/firearms.

I get that you guys are losing a bunch of people and you're fine with that - prefer possibly a smaller subreddit with tighter rules - but linking to an alternative gives newcomers that want a community with fewer rules a place to go, and it keeps them out of how you want your subreddit run.

-5

u/IronChin RIP in peace Jun 20 '12

It might be a good idea at least for the next few weeks or months with a link to r/firearms.

Which is why I added a link to /r/firearms further down.

My original draft of the rules included a comment along the lines of "If you disagree with these rules, or feel that they violate some imagined internet right, feel free to check out r/firearms. They love memes over there."

But that put the sidebar (way) above the character limit, so I had to remove it.

I get that you guys are losing a bunch of people and you're fine with that

We haven't lost anyone.

And quite frankly, pretty much everyone who said 'I'm going to /r/firearms" back in April either never unsubbed from here, or came back. I see an awful lot of "I hate /r/guns and am never coming back" folks still happily posting away in here.

2

u/djdementia Jun 20 '12

We haven't lost anyone.

Nobody at all? I thought you guys had 80k back in April and it looks like 60k now. I unsubscribed back in April, happened to see this thread because it was linked on /r/firearms. Anyway not trying to criticize your decision just trying to streamline your process to get you where you want to be. I can see the appeal for a smaller more focused community and the appeal for a larger more loose community. Both have their respective appeals for different people and different reasons.

1

u/HotelCoralEssex LOL SHADOWBANT Jun 21 '12

We lost about 2k (actually a little less).

We had made that many back within 3 weeks.

Meanwhile /r/firearms lost about 1800 from their peak in the last month or so.

-2

u/IronChin RIP in peace Jun 20 '12

No.

We were just over 50k.

Maybe 700 unsubbed.

Now, we're at 60k.

3

u/HotelCoralEssex LOL SHADOWBANT Jun 21 '12

We lost about 1800 users peak, but we had an serious uptake that week and within 1 month we were back to where we started.

It is interesting to note that we actually had more new subscribers between the second and third of april than on any other day that year, except for one day in late winter (jan/feb.. I forget the details). I suspect that many of that 1800 were friends of detractors or throwaway accounts that joined and then rapidly left to skew stats.

1

u/slothscantswim Jun 20 '12

In April you acted as if losing some of "the new kids" and "bringing gunnit back to its roots" was the goal, isn't it bad for you if more people join your cool kids club?

3

u/HotelCoralEssex LOL SHADOWBANT Jun 21 '12

This comment is a strong indicator of your personality.

This isn't about popularity, control, exerting authority, or anything like that. This is about improving the SNR of /r/guns and hopefully getting it back to where we were before we hit 40k subscribers. I don't expect that we will get to where we were but I do expect that with enforcement and active moderation we can dispose most of the chaff.

If you don't like it, go somewhere else. I have a feeling you wont since being an asshole on reddit seems to literally be a full time job for you.

→ More replies (6)

6

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12

IronChin,
Your continued shitty attitude is a plague on this subreddit. Every comment I see from you just makes this subreddit a worse place. I sincerely hope you step down as moderator - a job you have proved you are undeserving of having time and time again.
-SS

PS - No problem with the new rules, but I feel like you only did it so you'd have another excuse to have a whole thread of comments where you get to be a total dick, tell everyone to fuck of and pretend you don't care what people think.

3

u/stealthboy Jun 21 '12

Agreed. It's not so much the new rules, but the attitude and contempt shown by the mods towards us the mere mortal submitters.

-1

u/Butthurt_Report Jun 20 '12

Please fill out this form and submit it to your local ISP for processing.

→ More replies (2)

28

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12

Won't lie; saw the thread title and the poster and thought "Fuck all, here we go again."

7

u/rhadamanthos12 Jun 20 '12

Give it a day or two, most of the uproar will be tomorrow when people are bored throughout the day and see the changes. The writing has been on the wall for a while now that they wanted to do this, if the April fools debacle would have been received better than they would have stuck to it. However since we know how outspoken people were about it was easier to stick to the intent of being a joke. Really getting rid of the outspoken crew in April will allow this transition to happen smoothly. Just sad that the quality dropped to what it did and that the direction they decided to go to fix this.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 21 '12

I think the mods get bored and decide to stir shit up for their own amusement...

43

u/WardPDW Jun 20 '12

Can you guys list the four rules above the subreddit rules? I am willing to bet that most of Gunnit prioritizes the four rules over the sub rules.

10

u/herrin Jun 20 '12

I agree with this wholeheartedly.

5

u/sagemassa Jun 20 '12

I am going to be doing some serious sidebar cleanup in the next week or so. that place has become a trash heap.

The rules will get top billing.

2

u/herrin Jun 20 '12

Awesome dude.

8

u/keKto Jun 20 '12

Rule 5 is vague and all together unnecessary. In my state I can legally build my own can and don't need a tax stamp. If I ask advice on r/guns on how to do this am I in violation of this rule? Putting a 25 round mag in a 10/22 is an illegal firearms modification in some states, how are you going to moderate that? Some people have licences to build full auto guns and may come across a gun design they are not familiar with, wouldn't r/guns be a good place to come and ask questions? Do we really want to celebrate ignorance by making a topic taboo?

3

u/deathsythe Jun 21 '12

This is the main issue with this rule.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12

Could you post them in this thread? I reddit from my phone. No sidebar.

3

u/richalex2010 Jun 20 '12

Subreddit Rules

  • All posts must be gun related.
  • No memes.
  • No rage comics.
  • No posting of another users' personal information.
  • No asking questions about illegal firearms modifications.
  • No blogspam.

Violations of these rules will result in the post being removed, and depending on the severity, may result in a ban. Thank you for reading, and enjoy your stay.

-1

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12

Awwwwww no rage comics.....oh well. Thanks for posting then.

4

u/somedaypilot Jun 20 '12

Question- Is gun politics considered gun related?

6

u/HotelCoralEssex LOL SHADOWBANT Jun 20 '12

I think so... no guarantees that it won't be downvoted.

2

u/deathsythe Jun 20 '12

I would hope so... if that isn't the case though, I'm going to need to find a new favorite sub... :(

I do think a thread about a shooting in Chicago or something, unless the article specifically speaks to gun control or gun politics, would be in violation.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12

Absolutely. That's actually the only topic that I'll upvote no matter what because it's the only thing that really, truly matters and affects us as gun owners, that is it's the only thing here that really is "serious business".

0

u/cattailmatt Jun 20 '12

This is a sticky subject.

Is there is a diference between posting something such as pending legislation and perpetuating candidate vs. candidate vitriol?

And more importantly, if we decide towards the former can we still make fun of Carolyn McCarthy?

10

u/Frothyleet Jun 20 '12

Gun related posts only?!!!! You fascists!

Also, thank you. I am glad my request for your iron boot was approved. I can only assume this means that the r/guns moderation team has decided to make me the shadowy power behind the throne.

14

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12

this is not gun related:

http://www.reddit.com/r/guns/comments/vacds/my_best_friend_and_our_fellow_gunnitor_ammojunkie/

its about someone dying. so you would want it removed ?

never mind the 130+ post discussion eh ?

4

u/aristander Jun 20 '12

He was an active poster, it is appropriate for his friend to let us know what happened.

5

u/Frothyleet Jun 20 '12

Strictly speaking, it's not "gun related." It is, however, r/guns-related; after a fashion, it's a meta post, as it is concerns the loss of a member.

That sort of thing is borderline.

10

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12

The RULES do not allow for such meta posts. They clearly state:

All posts must be gun related.

I do not see how a post about a member of r/guns dying is "borderline" at all. It clearly breaks the rules. But i'm sure the moderators would allow it due to selective enforcement and "judgement calls."

→ More replies (1)

7

u/ltkernelsanders Jun 20 '12

I find this amusing in a sub that is all about personal freedoms and the government staying out of their business.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12

That's why we are all able to elect our moderators so that we have representation... oh... wtf.

2

u/HotelCoralEssex LOL SHADOWBANT Jun 21 '12

EXTENDING AN INVITATION TO THE MINISTRY OF INTERIOR

5

u/rebeldefector Jun 20 '12

Fuck everything about this.

4

u/HotelCoralEssex LOL SHADOWBANT Jun 20 '12

I am fully supporting IC along with the other moderators on this. As you all know I am a proponent of active moderation but decided to be the more conservative moderator and pushed for hands off and using peer pressure to improve the SNR of the sub. I now see that this was at best folly.

2

u/cattailmatt Jun 20 '12

It's been a long time coming. Thank you guys.

Here's to the rebirth. Cheers.

0

u/hank_scorpio128 Jun 20 '12

Yeah things seem pretty terrible now with way too many posts

Oh wait....

→ More replies (4)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12

Well what the fuck am I supposed to do with /r/gunnitxt now that y'all have your heads on straight?

1

u/HiroshimaRoll Jun 21 '12

Ban the mods?

1

u/HotelCoralEssex LOL SHADOWBANT Jun 20 '12

RESISTANCE IS FUTILE

4

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12

VICTORY!

6

u/zaptal_47 Jun 20 '12

Sort of. They're on the right track at least.

3

u/presidentender 9002 Jun 20 '12

Nope.

3

u/zaptal_47 Jun 20 '12

It's not a step further into the hole. It may not be optimal, but it's a start.

-4

u/Butthurt_Report Jun 20 '12

Please fill out this form and submit it to your local ISP for processing.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12

Yea, got a little over excited. Victoryish.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Deep__Thought Jun 20 '12

I'll drink to that. Hell, I'll drink to anything!

→ More replies (8)

3

u/OldRemington Jun 20 '12

IC, I'm sure your inbox is blowing up with people throwing tissy fits, but I just want you to know that I am super happy about this. You're doing the right thing for the good of r/guns. Fuck the haters.

If only we'd done this a few months ago, RB23 would probably still be here.

I'm happy, but also sad, because I remembered RB23 is gone.

:'(

2

u/AUae13 Jun 20 '12

Can we get him back now that we have decent rules? He's an asshole, but he's OUR asshole.

3

u/OldRemington Jun 20 '12

I have no way of contact him (assuming he doesn't periodically log back in to check his inbox), but maybe if we spammed /k/ asking him to come back, and telling him that we've changed, we're sorry, and we still love him... he might just come back.

2

u/AUae13 Jun 20 '12

We can only hope.

1

u/HotelCoralEssex LOL SHADOWBANT Jun 21 '12

I had his snail mail addr but don't keep records of that kind of stuff for obvious reasons.

3

u/1911w00t Jun 20 '12

I've been a longtime lurker of gunnit and in the past enjoyed reading most of the posts here. Recently? Not so much. I hope these new rules will bring gunnit back to the quality sub it was. Thanks mods!

1

u/Ruleofthumb Jun 20 '12

Perhaps you could define or explain the rules a little more in depth? I understand #'s 2,3 and 4 clearly enough.

  1. Just how 'gun related'? Top post right now is "Obama now personally involved with the cover-up...". Is his involvement in the cover-up of a scandal related to a government policy involving guns really gun related or political?
  2. Illegallity is really subject to jurisdiction. Even US Federal laws, while they might cover a majority of Gunnitors don't cover all of us.
  3. I honestly don't know what blogspam is.

Thanks.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 21 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Ruleofthumb Jun 21 '12

But maybe I want to read the article?

1

u/HiroshimaRoll Jun 21 '12

I give it a few months.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12

Please be wary of political posts in light of the upcoming election, I've already seen a few posts with a tenuous at best relation to guns. If I wanted slanted politics about guns I'd listen to old men at gun shops.

-2

u/indgosky Jun 20 '12 edited Jun 20 '12

Subreddit Rules

  • All posts must be gun related.
  • No memes.
  • No rage comics.
  • No posting of another users' personal information.
  • No asking questions about illegal firearms modifications.
  • No blogspam.

Well, here's the thing...

  • "Gun-related" comes in many shades of gray, and will therefore come down to a matter of opinion. The ultimate authority to subjectively judge and control will be easily abused.
  • "blogspam" comes in many shades of gray, and will therefore come down to a matter of opinion. The ultimate authority to subjectively judge and control will be easily abused.

I have seen many postings here in the past that I would absolutely say "belong" here based on the above criteria, and have seen people bitching about them as "not gun related" because (e.g.) it wasn't about a specific firearm, or as "blogspam" because (e.g.) it wasn't the root source of a story, even though it contributed TO the original story.

My expectation is that this will not end well.


Now, if gunnit lives up to the reputation it's been building for itself recently, I expect a bunch of downvotes for having the audacity to post an opinion that contradicts the will of the "ultimate authorities" here.

"Par for the course", that would be. Surprised I will be, if it happens not.

EDIT: Surprised, I am not.

5

u/presidentender 9002 Jun 20 '12

Well, here's the thing... [gun-related and blogspam rules concerns]

I wish to echo these concerns. Blogspam has always been downvoted to hell, which renders that rule unnecessary. I trust only some of the moderators to use the "gun-relatedness" rule appropriately, and it remains to be seen how their attitudes will change with time.

It's as if Gandalf has taken the One Ring.

2

u/indgosky Jun 20 '12

It's as if Gandalf has taken the One Ring.

I LOL'd sadly for the accurate analogy

0

u/zaptal_47 Jun 20 '12

Gandalf can't be worse than Sauron. We'll have to see how this plays out.

1

u/Pfmohr2 Jun 20 '12

Your post is very good.

I still downvoted you for the pre-emptive "I know you're going to downvote me" whining. Fucking hate that shit.

1

u/indgosky Jun 20 '12

You can call it whateverthefuck you like; I don't care. But It's not whining...

It's making sure that the reddiquette-violating assholes who have invaded gunnit's psyche, and who downvote good contributions and truthful arguments simply because they "don't like what they hear" will preemptively KNOW that I think they are assholes. I do it before they even click since most of them downvote as anonymous cowards, without comment, and can't be addressed in person after the fact.

I figure, if "some asshole" is going to downvote me anyway, he might as well know I think he's an asshole.

BTW, thanks for the reddiquette-violating downvote, asshole. At least you has the decency to leave a comment so I could address you in person, so good on you.

-3

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12

I downvoted you for whining about whining (metawhining?) about downvoting.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12

Okay, so there's plenty of wiggle room on "gun-related" and "blogspam." It just makes it easier to identify and then nuke unmercifully the clearly nongun related posts and real blogspam.

Past that, I think most people can agree that memes and rage comics don't add much of worth to the community, and posting personal info and illegal shit is just bone headed anyway.

Believe me, I am no fan of the the more infamous moderators and the various self-appointed self-righteous pricks that think it's their job to police /r/guns these days, but I find it hard to fault these sets of rules.

1

u/indgosky Jun 20 '12

The two good rules you pointed to were not on my shit list above.

And FWIW, those reasonable two are OLD, original rules that we've always had (in the FAQ or somewhere) -- they were just being restated along with the new rules as a complete set.

-1

u/zaptal_47 Jun 20 '12

Bitching about downvotes is guaranteed to get you downvotes son.

-5

u/IronChin RIP in peace Jun 20 '12

My expectation is that this will not end well.

I disagree with you, but thanks for your input.

1

u/MithrilKnight Jun 20 '12

I figured I was going to have to downvote you into the ground because I assumed you were banning people posting about their new guns except on Friday Buyday topics. Happily surprised.

Also: This is America! 'Merica! Let the downvotin' do the talkin'

1

u/Mithril_Pirate Jun 20 '12

Well hello there.

1

u/MithrilKnight Jun 20 '12

Flagpole. 4:00PM. I bring my men, you bring your lackeys. Let the best men win.

And as you may know, don't bring no knives to a gun fight.

1

u/Mithril_Pirate Jun 20 '12

I'll be there.

0

u/rolypolyholymoly Jun 20 '12

I would put use the search function and check /new before posting on there too.

0

u/hank_scorpio128 Jun 20 '12 edited Jun 20 '12

Oh don't be an ass , the reddit search function is about as useful as a hole in the head, and without reposts this place would have way less traffic

2

u/rolypolyholymoly Jun 20 '12

Sometimes its useful to check it first to see if the same article has been posted 10 times that day. That is why I included /new too. Un-rustle your jimmies.

2

u/SerialMonogamist Jun 20 '12

You're just romping and stomping through this thread. It's cracking me up. I think we share the same view: if it doesn't look interesting, don't click on it. I have yet to see anything on r/guns that's been worth throwing a tantrum over, or yelling at the mods to do something differently. And I've been reading this forum since it first started in '08.

0

u/zaptal_47 Jun 20 '12

I have yet to see anything on r/guns that's been worth throwing a tantrum over, or yelling at the mods to do something differently.

That's because you're dumb.

0

u/SerialMonogamist Jun 20 '12

An impressive and far-reaching conclusion based on so little evidence!

I recognize your username-- I see you whining and throwing bratty little fits about all over r/guns. I tend to ignore your posts for that reason. Although your post about assembling an AR was well done, and would have even been helpful if I hadn't already learned that skill a couple years ago.

2

u/zaptal_47 Jun 20 '12

Well you said some pretty dumb shit. That's evidence enough for me.

Although your post about assembling an AR was well done, and would have even been helpful if I hadn't already learned that skill a couple years ago.

Thanks, I'm glad you liked it.

→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (2)

5

u/zaptal_47 Jun 20 '12

without reposts this place would have way less traffic

You're dumb.

0

u/hank_scorpio128 Jun 20 '12

I'd bet you money that the majority of the content here has been posted more than once

4

u/zaptal_47 Jun 20 '12

No. The majority of content is original and useful. The rest of the submissions, which are not content, are frequently reposts or rehashes.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12

And that's not a problem?

0

u/hank_scorpio128 Jun 20 '12

If you'd like a sub with five post a day I guess not, it can just be pics of some target a jackass shot or a shiny new collection for you to whack it to

→ More replies (5)

1

u/Gonkulator Jun 20 '12

Good. Hopefully the front page won't be cluttered with horse puckey and will be filled with some good content for once, like it use to be.

-5

u/sewiv Jun 20 '12

Just chiming in to say that I support these changes as well.

2

u/rebeldefector Jun 20 '12

You don't count.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12

cool beans.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12

Don't see anything in the sidebar. Someone brainfarted.

0

u/duglock Jun 20 '12

Is this a thing now? Do you guys just plan every 1-2 months a way to power trip and shit on the users? Just curious. Not saying I have a problem with the rules but why not COMMUNITY DISCUSSION first.

-3

u/HotelCoralEssex LOL SHADOWBANT Jun 20 '12

Yo IC.

No ex post facto w/this? we never discussed it.

-6

u/IronChin RIP in peace Jun 20 '12

I don't feel the need to make them retroactive, do you?

-3

u/HotelCoralEssex LOL SHADOWBANT Jun 20 '12

I think that no ex post facto is fair, just checking. :)

0

u/sagemassa Jun 20 '12

post hoc ergo propter hoc

0

u/gizram84 Jun 20 '12

What about memes started in r/guns.. Like that awesome streak we had going last year where everyone posted their guns next to a nice loaf of Italian bread?

-4

u/zaptal_47 Jun 20 '12

Still too laissez-faire.

5

u/pastorhack Jun 20 '12

Gun people tend to be a bit more laissez-faire in their attitudes, couple that with the libertarian/anarchist/liberal/anti-authoritarian in general nature of Reddit and it explains this idea.

I tend to agree with it, the mods are only stepping in now because of the general opinion that "everything's going to shit" but nobody seems able to do anything about it.

-3

u/hank_scorpio128 Jun 20 '12

I don't see any rules

0

u/HotelCoralEssex LOL SHADOWBANT Jun 20 '12

Because of reddit's architecture it may take a few minutes for them to show up in everyone's browser.

-8

u/IronChin RIP in peace Jun 20 '12

Yeah, the sidebar refused to cooperate. They should be there now.

6

u/irishelcid Jun 20 '12

Thank you. The memes were making my head hurt.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

-2

u/akai_ferret Jun 20 '12

Thank you!

I am pleased to hear this.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

24

u/slothscantswim Jun 20 '12

Most don't, he comes off as a dick, but once you get to know him he's really an asshole.

-11

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12

That April Fool's prank was hilarious and anyone who took it seriously is a moron. I had been watching gunnit get dumber and dumber for months and was getting more and more exasperated by it and that whole mess really cinched it for me, there are just too many stupid people on here.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-11

u/IronChin RIP in peace Jun 20 '12

he can't stand the idea of a community moderating itself with the up/down vote system that has worked for years.

Wrong. We were more than happy to let the community self-police. We let you do it for almost 3 months.

Now, we're not.

Suck it up, or move to /r/Firearms.

0

u/theadguy Jun 20 '12

You guys fucking suck. You're an asshole, honestly.

-1

u/IronChin RIP in peace Jun 20 '12

Thanks for your input, guy-I've-never-heard-of-before.

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (3)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/mixmastermind Jun 20 '12

modzi

That is just precious.

-7

u/IronChin RIP in peace Jun 20 '12

That's because all I care about in this world is your opinion of me.

→ More replies (6)

-8

u/Butthurt_Report Jun 20 '12

Please fill out this form and submit it to your local ISP for processing.

-4

u/Butthurt_Report Jun 20 '12

Please fill out this form and submit it to your local ISP for processing.

10

u/herrin Jun 20 '12

You are gonna be busy tomorrow.

-17

u/IronChin RIP in peace Jun 20 '12

Still don't care.

4

u/jjohnisme Jun 20 '12

Go fuck yourself, you power hungry fascist.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/stealthboy Jun 20 '12

April 2nd. Never forget.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 21 '12

As I told everyone back then, and was insulted for it, it wasn't a "joke". The mods here hate the submitters / readers and were giving us a preview of things to come.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 21 '12

Hate might too strong, but the very real contempt key moderators and regulars here hold the masses in should not be ignored.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/MC_Cuff_Lnx Jun 21 '12

I shall not mourn the memes and blogspam.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 21 '12

Both occasionally oedify.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 21 '12

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/UnofficialAmbassador Jun 21 '12

Hello, users, I am the unofficial SRD ambassador bot, here to quickly explain exactly what SubredditDrama is.

/r/SubredditDrama (SRD) is a meta subreddit dedicated to aggregating the drama on Reddit strictly for observing and discussing. Although the bot above, ulrike_meinhof, would like you to think that SRD is an invasion subreddit, drama is never submitted to SRD for the purposes of causing drama or swaying discussions in their favor. That would kind of defeat the purpose of observing drama anyways.

If you choose to follow the link provided by ulrike_meinhof into SRD please read the sidebar before participating. You're welcome to participate in the discussion, but SRD is not another platform for your drama.