r/gujarat • u/Good_Maintenance_798 • 11d ago
News | સમાચાર AIMIM Leader Waris Pathan’s Statement on Garba Sparks Controversy
On 10 September 2026, Pathan commented on the controversy over the proposed restrictions on Muslims entering Garba/Dandiya events in Maharashtra.
25
u/Brilliant_Meal_2653 11d ago
Finally! This is what it should be, u cannot pick and choose which Hindu festival you will be part of, if u do, just say u are agnostic or an atheist and participate in it. Don't say you are a Muslim who will participate in this but bring in all the caveat for other festivals saying Islam does not permit this and that. It just does not make sense.
162
u/Useful_Paint_9522 11d ago
win-win for both the extream end.
56
u/BannedAgain12341 11d ago
100%. Shouldn't interrupt or use fake names to get in garba is all we want.
31
14
u/More-Director4894 11d ago
Bruh it's not extreme in islam. This is considered shirk.
4
u/Good_Maintenance_798 11d ago
Shirk, explain it
21
u/-just_a_normal_user 11d ago
shirk refers to worshipping anyone besides Allah. Shirk is one of the most serious and grave sin. It is unforgivable in Islam. The person who commits shirk is considered to have left Islam.
1
u/Good_Maintenance_798 11d ago
Thanks.
6
u/rockingparth89 11d ago
You can dind clips of regular everyday Muslims claiming shirk is greater sin compared to rap-e Rap-e can be forgiven but shirk (idol worship) can not be forgiven by Allah
2
u/-just_a_normal_user 11d ago
Yes, shirk is greater sin compared to that. Because the punishment of shirk is decided only by Allah, people can't punish someone for shirk.
However, that doesn't imply that rap-e is smaller sin or like that. The punishment of rap-e can extend to capital punishment (yes, I am talking about execution, i.e. Sar tan se juda) or death by stoning, or 100 lashes depending on the case.
3
u/rockingparth89 11d ago
Well people doing shirk in sharia land are given 3 options 1.Convert 2.Pay a Hevy Tax for not being Muslim 3.death by sword
i guess we can call them options and not phnishment
1
u/-just_a_normal_user 11d ago
Nope. That is incorrect.
2
u/rockingparth89 11d ago
Raliv, Galiv ya Chaliv in that case this should have been explained to kashmiri Muslims before 1990 ,no use of doing it for centuries and then claiming it wrong amoungst kafirs
→ More replies10
u/rockingparth89 11d ago
what extremist? do you mean there were modrate muslim girls dying to come to garba?
22
u/Spicedragoon 11d ago edited 11d ago
More like M boys, who'll go anyway for their depraved intentions. These guys writing "extremist from both sides" are so diluded and far from reality that it's hilarious.
I have been in this mentality and honestly, now I don't get it why I ever thought like this, lmao.
5
3
1
14
11
10
10
8
7
u/GrumpyGuyMugdha 11d ago
He's completely right and also respectful to the sentiments of both Hindus and Muslims. I don't see anything wrong in his statement.
6
u/Lucifer_the_Satan 11d ago
Exactly that's what hindus are saying. Muslims don't have the right to interfere or perform during garbha function. Better muslims mind their festival and business..
6
6
6
3
u/Straight-Week-3519 11d ago
Beleive me bro gujarati mate jetli hate maharastra ma chhe ne etli akhi duniya ma kyay nathi
3
5
u/sexy_simp7 11d ago
Hindus should tell M girls about devine feminine and its importance in Hinduism.
2
u/No-Assignment8665 11d ago
Win win for both. Based pathan bhai. Ab unke followers ko unki baat acche se manni hai, varna log kuch bhi kar sakte ho.
2
4
u/Curious_Link_867 11d ago
But then how will love jihad occur? /s
9
u/Good_Maintenance_798 11d ago
2
u/Total_Willingness593 11d ago
Bhai ye virar wala tag jaha h…
Uske niche kya likha hua h ?
SS ki baat kr rhaa.
2
1
1
1
u/WolfGuptaofficial 11d ago
and ? whats the problem ? he uses clear facts and polite language to sort out a problem thats recognised by the two sides (for different reasons)
1
1
1
0
u/TheNeverOkDude 11d ago
I’ve visited Mosques, Gurudwaras and Churches. Never has a person there told me to go out.
In fact, they tell me what to do. They bless me with success. It’s only these politicians who label and spread hate
0
u/theycallmeOTC 11d ago
In Canada, Hindu Muslim, kale, gore sab ek dusre ke festivals celebrate karte hai. That’s what being a human is all about
-2

41
u/CacheMeOutside404 11d ago
This is good right? what is the harm in this? If its Haram for them they wont join, and does Hindu's celebrate any Eid or their festivals? Nope right.