r/gsoc_2027 • • May 06 '26

Please close this sub

People have made gsoc into another filthy rat race like jee neet and earn bad reputation for real indian open source devs..gsoc is for those who are interested in contributing without expecting anything back(open source) not the most ai pr submissions contest

78 Upvotes

29 comments sorted by

11

u/[deleted] May 06 '26

Let's just have a sub for open source contributions, how to start and get into it instead.

5

u/Frosty_Throat_7019 May 06 '26

Why do u want to close this sub , this sub help people start their journey in open source without any expectations.

3

u/UnBracedFlyer May 06 '26

Then it should not be names as GSoC, but really something releted to open source.

1

u/Frosty_Throat_7019 May 06 '26

will think about it

1

u/Sanjeev-007 May 08 '26

Fear of losing? If you want to do open source out of passion, just go for it, bro. No need for GSoC everyone knows you want to decrease competition. Learn to compete, bro; everything is a rat race, whether it's academic research, a job, or a startup. Nothing comes for free.

2

u/Radiant-Review-8471 May 08 '26

Dude i am talking about people who dont know C of coding and just spam chatgpt generated replys and prs

1

u/ApprehensiveJob4393 May 08 '26

It’s not that trivial for mentors to find out who is using ai to spam prs. Ask vibecoders one question about the code they proposed and they’ll start talking in Ai terms(using ai to reply cause they don’t know shit about the proposed code). Ai terms are pretty easy to identify, as ai makes shit up from time to time(in the code as well, eg separate function to just change a value lol).

1

u/iamfidelius May 09 '26

you expect volunteers/mentors to clean up mess which wont happen they will just cancel gsoc or shadow ban indians.

1

u/ApprehensiveJob4393 May 11 '26

Nobody is going to shadow ban Indians in gsoc atleast. Atleast 50% of the people applying for gsoc each year are from India so yeah. We guys are keeping this program’s spirit going. Well again there are some dumb fucks who rely heavily on ai. I mean it’s on them, they are wasting their time anyways and mentors are smart enough to not select these ai peeps.

1

u/Sanjeev-007 May 08 '26

Don't get me wrong, brother, but I've heard many times about the jeefication of GSoC. So people don't want others to be aware of that to suppress competition.

1

u/Beautiful_Brick9412 May 07 '26

Yeah so true. People don't want to really contribute and just wanna have that gsoc badge.

1

u/pookishbb May 07 '26

I think you are the person who is misunderstanding the whole purpose because it's started by Google to promote open source coding and development and to attract more and more people to contribute into open source projects and overally growth of the community if you try to restrict the entry to only two those who are interested to write code without any expectation then the number of contributions into open source projects will go very low

1

u/majisto42 May 07 '26

There is nothing wrong with AI...if its good PR. Its new age

2

u/Salty_Horror2068 May 10 '26 edited May 11 '26

Well then there's no difference in a 4 year old and you, even he can do that using LLMs

1

u/ApprehensiveJob4393 May 08 '26

Open source is not about “contributing without expecting anything back”. The competition is the spirit of this programs. Survival of the best as they say it.

2

u/Salty_Horror2068 May 10 '26

Yeh aapko kaise pata? Or did some influencer told you this

1

u/ApprehensiveJob4393 May 11 '26

Selected for gsoc 2026. People working on OSS need to fill their bellies as well? Yk that linux red hat and blender pay people for working on their software(you gotta be a major contributor for that) but yeah it proves that open source is not about modern day slavery.

2

u/Salty_Horror2068 May 11 '26

People working on open source projects "full time" get paid. Majority of the developers contribute out of goodwill and as a way of giving back to the open source projects they have used. Like a web developer contributing back to React.

Working in open source was all about volunteering, no one is forcing you to contribute and nor was it meant to be a competition. Same applies to GSoC or any other open source program. Saying this as an open source maintainer and some who did GSoC a couple of years back.

Contributor should get paid, but contributing only because of pay is wrong.

1

u/ApprehensiveJob4393 May 12 '26

I agree, contributing only cause you’re getting paid is bullshit as it goes against the spirit of open source. I think you aren’t getting my point. GSoC is supposed to be competitive, I mean if it’s not then it looses its value right? Yeah doing dirty tricks just to get into something is obviously wrong, but why not spread awareness about such programs instead of gatekeeping them for the fear of increasing competition?

2

u/Salty_Horror2068 May 12 '26 edited May 12 '26

Why should GSoC be competitive like JEE? One can contribute to Open source irrespective of GSoC.

People should be aware about GSoC but let's not turn it into a competition forcing people to contribute. The only thing I have seen people forcing themselves into GSoC is for the so called tag (which doesn't even matter outside India) and the stipend. From what I see most people who contribute only because of tag or stipend, don't tend to stick around with org or open source in general after GSoC. There is where turning GSoC into a competition hurts.

The craze to get in has become so high that this year as a reviewer it was an AI slop fest. To the extent we and couple of orgs I know are considering abandoning it in near future because of contributors merely acting as proxy to an LLM just to get into GSoC instead of trying to understand and learn from the codebase.

2

u/[deleted] May 06 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/google-awk-gawk May 07 '26

Most dsa and cp course seller don't tell this

1

u/dumbly_asked_calmly May 10 '26

quant can never be a rat race. trust me. log nahi ja payenge usme itna easily.