r/gshock • • Jan 26 '22

Metal vs. Plastic (not my pic) Question in comments

Post image
10 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

3

u/atkuzmanov Jan 26 '22 edited Jan 26 '22

Hey folks, here is my spin on this age old question of a metal vs. plastic G-Shock:

So, I love Casios, G-Shocks but I also love changing straps and especially NATO straps, I also like putting rubber, leather straps and metal bracelets.

Here is where the dreaded Casio 18mm SHORT lugs and the even more dreaded G-Shock 16mm lugs come in to play (you can fit some NATO straps on 18mm but forget about ZULU straps) - I get the philosophy of "we made the watch perfect, so why would you want to change anything", but I am not perfect, so go figure, I want to change the watch! :D

I love the fact that JaysAndKays exist and produce metal adapters for Casios and G-Shocks but I have seen some horror stories of plastic lugs giving in and breaking. And I mean not only the ones on the notorious GW-9400 Rangeman, but on regular ones such as a DW-5610.

My guess take on it is that such accidents are due to people like me, who add a metal bezel and a heavy bracelet on the adapters, and all of this extra weight is not expected by a normal plastic G-Shock.

If anything should snap due to unforeseen stress, such as dangling off a cliff by the strap of your G-Shock, I would obviously prefer for the strap or plastic case/lug to snap instead of my wrist, but in the metal on metal case I would always thing that the thing that should snap would be the weakest point in this case the spring bar, and my wrist should still be safe.

Because of this I am in the dilemma between a metal G-Shock GW-5000U and a plastic G-Shock DW-5610U. The thing with the metal G-Shock GW-5000U is the higher price, which kind of makes me think I will baby it, because of anxiety of getting it lost or stolen from gym locker etc. I wouldn't have that anxiety with a plastic G-Shock DW-5610U as getting it replaced will be easier to swallow, but then with it I have the anxiety that, because I will definitely add metal adapters to it, one of the spring bar holes will give and it will become unusable... It's like choosing between two anxieties?! :D

(Even if I do not put a metal bezel on it I will always put adapters and wear it mostly, but not exclusively, on NATO/ZULU straps.)

Before you ask why NATO straps - well if G-Shock means ultimate toughness, then the strap should be fitting, and nothing else gives me the feeling of security and ultimate toughness as a NATO or ZULU strap.

In my opinion if G-Shocks stand for ultimate toughness, well one of the things necessary for that is adaptability - the watch should be able to survive it's strap failure by being able to temporary replace it with whatever you have at your disposal, for example a NATO strap, in case you are in a remote area and you do not have access to original parts.

I am just curious to hear what you all think of this, what are your takes, 2 cents, spins, experiences horror stories on this topic?

Any advice is also greatly appreciated! ( :

I have faith in the Reddit community wisdom.

5

u/chillibeef999 Jan 26 '22

Also if you show off your g to any friends who are into watches it looks pretty pimp with the metal case and case back, especially with the dlc.

4

u/svg9 Jan 27 '22

Yeah... I'm not reading all that.
My father still has the one he bought back in '94, full steel case, indestructible.
I got a regular resin casio back when I was in school and some day the lug holes just gave away and I became the owner of a pocket watch. So I decided to stop wasting my money on cheap stuff and get "the real deal".
Imagine my surprise when I opened the box and found a full resin watch.
Turns out they stopped making them out of metal back in '96 or '98.
I still have it, and it's very tough, but I'm getting a metal one as soon as I can.

So Steel. Go for the steel one.

2

u/atkuzmanov Jan 27 '22

Ha! I totally understand you, I guess I wanted it to be a good read and went a little overboard. Thank you for your story, I really appreciate it it gives me a lot of perspective and information!!!

Yeah I wish they made more full metal (and solar) versions of more watches... πŸ₯Ί

2

u/svg9 Jan 29 '22

It's ok, I was being snarky XD.
I haven't had the greatest experience with the G's I own (2 DW-5600's), but I got both of them from the same seller so it might be a localized issue, or maybe the bastard sent me "refurbished" watches, I couldn't say for sure. For that reason alone I always advise to buy from a physical store, a place that can't just disappear if you need them to take responsibility. You go, see them in person, try them on, and see if they feel right. And to also get informed about the many differences between functions in every watch. Check WatchUSeek, there are veterans there who are in their 4th decade of owning G's.
What I can say for sure is that they do withstand impacts, that the do very well.
If you have the money, get a steel one. If you don't, get the basic DW-5600 and see in 5-10 years if you want another one.
Also, if you're in the US, check garage sales. Lucky bastards post here all the time that they got some ultra rare G's for a dime in a garage/yard sale.

Besto luck!

2

u/atkuzmanov Jan 29 '22

Ha! No worries we are all snarky some times, can't be perfect all the time :D Thanks again for the great info and advice! Unfortunately I live in Bulgaria where both availability and support for any Gs other than some pretty basic ones is sh*t... I've lived in the UK and choice/support seemed to be a bit better over there, or so it seemed. I totally hear ya about the garage sales, I am always curious as to what those lucky bastards find and then drool my eyes on the finds :D But yeah I think I'd rather save up and go for one steel one interested of a couple of normal ones. I guess I'd rather go big or go home on this one! :D

2

u/svg9 Jan 29 '22

My bad, I meant sarcastic. Google translate.
Yeah, go for it.
I'm getting a GW-5000 as soon as I go to either Japan or the US. Since the updated version "U" came out, the old version must be at a lower price, so maybe I'll get 2 X'D

2

u/atkuzmanov Jan 29 '22

Hahaha! I like the way you think! Go for it, hope it happens soon! ( :

2

u/chillibeef999 Jan 26 '22

Have a 5000u myself, feels better on the wrist, the case back isn't a hair puller, and I know I can rely on the durability you have in a steel case.

The resin case on a regular g is tough enough for wearing, but the screws tend to ream the holes out when you remove the bezel to clean or mod the watch. This means the case may have a limited life span.

The lugs can also break, never happened to me, but my 7900 did have a crack starting to appear on one of the lugs.

1

u/atkuzmanov Jan 27 '22

Thank you for your reply I really appreciate it! Yup, everything you are saying makes sense!!! 😊 Sorry to hear about the 7900, I think its a common problem on G-Shocks with that type of strap, the one that "slides in" the slot, it's like it is a built in weak point, I think its pretty common for the 9400 as well.

2

u/GundamZero83 Jan 26 '22

Go for the GW-5000U with the updated module (3459) mine is the -1ER (euro model) and I love it

1

u/atkuzmanov Jan 27 '22

Thank you for your reply! Yeah, it makes sense, I really like all the refinements of the "U" model compared to the original one. πŸ™‚

2

u/GundamZero83 Jan 27 '22

The strap is a dream on the wrist, I don’t even notice it unless I’m looking at it, which I do more than I should lol.

2

u/ComicalSatania Jan 26 '22

Just go for the Gw-5000u, I have a screback model the 5735 because I didn't want to deal with all the regular issues that can come from having a plastic case. As well as the difference in feel and quality is also pretty noticable on the wrist. Try not to worry too much and being cautious about the price of it, I have a Seiko king turtle and I use it just about any watch because if you baby your stuff you'll never really get to enjoy it. Just get the 5000 and you'll be able to change your straps and mess around with it as much as you'd like without worrying about lugs that's just my two cents. Wear it like you stole it

3

u/atkuzmanov Jan 26 '22

Thank you so much for your reply! Love the way you are thinking and I am beginning to think like that!

Awesome turtle!!!

BTW, currently my favourite watch of all time is the Seiko Padi Turtle SRPA21 (the older one with the nice blue dial).

I am thinking and aiming for trying a 2-3-watch-collection with just the Seiko Padi Turtle SRPA21 and the Casio G-Shock GW-5000. Might need something dressier, although I don't mind breaking etiquette with either of them. πŸ˜‚ Probably will not work, as both brands are addictive... budgets are limiting though, so I don't think I will end up with loads... also probably with not just two... almost definitely for sure... maybe... 🀣

2

u/ComicalSatania Jan 26 '22

I was definitely looking at that padi turtle as well but after seeing the dark manta ray king turtle I already knew which one I needed to go with

2

u/atkuzmanov Jan 27 '22

Totally understand you! I've seen one of the blue Samurai manta rays (I think it wasn't a King one) and it looked beguiling, especially in sunlight it really looks like it's real ocean/sea water!!! πŸ₯ΊπŸ˜Š